["단기고사" 중간서]의 저자 문제
A study on the unearthing of Shin Chae-ho's works and the establishment of his authentis text-focused on the Preface to Republication of Danggigosa(檀奇古史重刊序)
0
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study is formed as part of a study on the unearthing of Shin Chae-ho's works and the establishment of his authentic text. I tried to make clear in this study who the real author of "Preface to Republication of Danggigosa"(檀奇古史重刊序) was. It was included in Danjae Shin Chae-ho's complete works. So I made a scrutiny in its style, form, and etc. The preface was written in Andong China in 1912. At that time, Shin Chae-ho lived in Vladivostok of Russia and shouldn't go Andong. And its style is different from his. Besides he had not mentioned Danggigosa(檀奇古史) in any his books. When Lee Hwa-sa edited Danggigosa in 1949, he involved the preface in it. In the preface, Danjae told that he wrote it upon his friend, Lee's request when he went to Andong. Lee, editor of Danggigosa knew who the preface wrote. Firstly, 1 elucidated the preface should not be Danjae's by revealing differences between his works and the preface. Secondly, I compared the preface with Lee's book, for exemple Uiyoungshilgi(義勇實記) and Eonhaengnok(言行錄). Lee had probably met Danjae in 1914, owing to an affair of Gwangbokhoi(光復會). He read many Danjae's works and accepted Danjae's thought and style. Eventually he wrote the preface by taking a page from Danjae's books, especially "the relationship between history and patriotism", "Gwangbokhoi's announcement." Therefore, the preface is not Danjae's but Lee's. Now we regard this work as not belonging to Shin Chae-ho's complete works. And we need to reexamine the complete works of Shin Chae-ho more accurately in the future.
Abstract
This study is formed as part of a study on the unearthing of Shin Chae-ho's works and the establishment of his authentic text. I tried to make clear in this study who the real author of "Preface to Republication of Danggigosa"(檀奇古史重刊序) was. It was included in Danjae Shin Chae-ho's complete works. So I made a scrutiny in its style, form, and etc. The preface was written in Andong China in 1912. At that time, Shin Chae-ho lived in Vladivostok of Russia and shouldn't go Andong. And its style is different from his. Besides he had not mentioned Danggigosa(檀奇古史) in any his books. When Lee Hwa-sa edited Danggigosa in 1949, he involved the preface in it. In the preface, Danjae told that he wrote it upon his friend, Lee's request when he went to Andong. Lee, editor of Danggigosa knew who the preface wrote. Firstly, 1 elucidated the preface should not be Danjae's by revealing differences between his works and the preface. Secondly, I compared the preface with Lee's book, for exemple Uiyoungshilgi(義勇實記) and Eonhaengnok(言行錄). Lee had probably met Danjae in 1914, owing to an affair of Gwangbokhoi(光復會). He read many Danjae's works and accepted Danjae's thought and style. Eventually he wrote the preface by taking a page from Danjae's books, especially "the relationship between history and patriotism", "Gwangbokhoi's announcement." Therefore, the preface is not Danjae's but Lee's. Now we regard this work as not belonging to Shin Chae-ho's complete works. And we need to reexamine the complete works of Shin Chae-ho more accurately in the future.
참고문헌 (17)
- 고동영, "단기고사" (1986), 한뿌리
- 국사편찬위원회, "한국독립운동사2" (1968), 정음문화사
- 김병민, "신채호문학유고선집" (1994), 연변대학출판사
- 김해암, "단기고사" (1949), 문화인쇄사
- 단재신채호선생기념사업회, "개정판단재신채호전집 상중하별책" (1977), 형설출판사
- 단재신채호전집편찬위원회, "단재신채호전집 1~4" (2007), 독립기념관 한국독립운동사연구소
- 도산안창호선생전집편찬위원회, "도산안창호전집 2" (2000), 도산안창호선생기념사업회
- 박광용, "대종교 관련문헌 위작 많다 2- 신단실기 , 단기고사 의 성격에 대한 재검토", 역사비평, (18), pp.108~125 (1992)
- 박중훈, "자료소개-의용실기", 국학연구, (6), pp.299~337 (2001)
- 백태열 편, "장덕진전" (1925), 삼일인쇄사
- 변영만 역, "世界三怪物" (1908), 광학서포
- 신용하, "신채호의 광복회 통고문과 고시문", 학국학보, (32), pp.225~232, 일지사
- 이만열, "단재신채호의 역사학연구" (1990), 문학과지성사
- 이충구김병헌 편역, "화사 이관구 자료집(1)-언행록" (2003), 국학자료원
- 임상석, "신채호 연구의 잃어버린 한 고리 - 대동제국사서언언의 발견", 민족문화연구, 통권 : 38, pp.1~17, 고려대 민족문화연구소
- 조인성, "한말 단국관계사서의 재검토― 신단실기 단기고사 환단고기를 중심으로", 국사관논총, (3), pp.237~256 (1989), 국사편찬위원회
- 한영우, "1910년대의 민족주의적 역사서술", 한국문화, (1), pp.91~136 (1980), 서울대 규장각 한국학연구원
