농업환경보전 프로그램 사업대상지 선정기준의 상대적 중요도 분석
An Analysis of The Relative Importance for Target Selecting Criteria in Agricultural Environment Conservation Program
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Agricultural environmental policies to reduce negative externalities and expand positive externalities became common around the world. However, literature regarding the efficient and effective implementation of agricultural environmental policies, such as optional direct payment, is limited. This study, thus, analyzes the relative importance for target selecting-criteria in order to enhance the cost-effectiveness of the Agricultural Environment Conservation Program in Korea. In this context, we conducted survey to 15 experts who are related in agricultural environment policies and analyzed survey results based on ANP method which can consider correlation between selecting criteria. The results show that, in the case field, “soil”, “water”, and “ecology” field have relative high importance than the other fields. Also, the relative importance for ‘improving rural landscape’, ‘giving nutrient input moderately’, and ‘conserving agricultural heritage’ activities is higher than the other activities. Furthermore, the relative importance among fields and activities of ANP is different from those of AHP. This result implies that it is necessary to consider the correlation between selecting criteria in order to design effectively. Finally, we suggest that in order to enhance the effectiveness of the program, it would be appropriate to assign differential points according to the importance of each activity when identifying appropriate farms.
Abstract
Agricultural environmental policies to reduce negative externalities and expand positive externalities became common around the world. However, literature regarding the efficient and effective implementation of agricultural environmental policies, such as optional direct payment, is limited. This study, thus, analyzes the relative importance for target selecting-criteria in order to enhance the cost-effectiveness of the Agricultural Environment Conservation Program in Korea. In this context, we conducted survey to 15 experts who are related in agricultural environment policies and analyzed survey results based on ANP method which can consider correlation between selecting criteria. The results show that, in the case field, “soil”, “water”, and “ecology” field have relative high importance than the other fields. Also, the relative importance for ‘improving rural landscape’, ‘giving nutrient input moderately’, and ‘conserving agricultural heritage’ activities is higher than the other activities. Furthermore, the relative importance among fields and activities of ANP is different from those of AHP. This result implies that it is necessary to consider the correlation between selecting criteria in order to design effectively. Finally, we suggest that in order to enhance the effectiveness of the program, it would be appropriate to assign differential points according to the importance of each activity when identifying appropriate farms.
참고문헌 (9)
- 채홍기, "선택형 공익직접지불제도의 추진체계 분석", 한국산학기술학회논문지, 22(3), pp.390~397 (2021), 한국산학기술학회[DOI]
- Reforming Direction of Optional Direct Payments for Enhancing Public Benefits of Agriculture and Rural Community, "Kim, T. H.", Korea Rural Economic Institution, 5~8 (2021)
- Lankoski, J., "Guidelines for Cost-effective Agri-Environmental Policy Measures" (2010), OECD
- 김광모, "AHP와 ANP를 이용한 부문별 온실가스 감축 이행 방안 중요도 비교 분석", 환경정책연구, 14(1), pp.33~52 (2015), 한국환경연구원[DOI]
- Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, "2022 Agricultural Environment Conservation Program Implementation Guideline", ~ (2022)
- 오성령, "무기체계의 기능 선정을 위한 ANP 기반의 의사결정 지원시스템 설계", 한국시뮬레이션학회 논문지, 25(3), pp.85~95 (2016), 한국시뮬레이션학회
- Park, Y. S., "Dicision Making Theory and Practice of AHP", pp.267~284 (2009), Kyowoosa
- Saaty, T. L., "Decision making with dependence and feedback: The analytic network process" (1996), RWS publications
- Saaty, T. L., "Decision making with the analytic network process", pp.1~40 (2013), Springer