형벌의 사회적 맥락 : 형벌사회학적 접근
Social Contexts of Criminal Punishment: Toward a sociology of punishment
0
조회
0
다운로드
7
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Abstract
This study is designed to introduce perspectives of sociological understanding for criminal punishment. The basic stance of sociology of punishment is that we should consider social contexts under which penal policy and criminal justice activities are constructed and processed. This notion is quite different from the existing penological approach to the enterprise of crime control : it focuses on finding the best way to deter criminals from committing crimes and evaluating the most effective correctional programs and punishment devices. On the contrary, the sociology of punishment seeks to understand punishment within the broader social environments such as economic and political contexts. According to the sociological account of the function of punishment, a main role of punishment is not confined in its instrumental purposes. It also serves as an indicator to represent the society itself. Based on this line of understanding, this article first clarifies the concept and functions of punishment in sociological terms and then introduces explanations for changes in forms of punishment suggested by Durkheim, Marxist penal sociologists and Foucault. Next, it reviews many empirical studies that consider social, economic, political contexts for explaining crime control practices such as imprisonment. In conclusion, this study encourages further research adopting the sociological lenses in exploring criminal justice practices.
참고문헌 (41)
- Adamson, Christopher, "Toward a Marxian penology : Captive criminal population as economic threats and resources", Social Problems, 31(4), pp.435~58 (1984)
- Bailey, Williams C, "Inequality in the legal order : Some further analysis and commentary", Social Problems, 29(1), pp.51~60 (1981)
- Barberet, Rosemary Louise, "Modernization, Criminal Sanctions and Crime in Spain. Unpublished dissertation", Z, pp.1994
- Brake, Michael, "Public Order and Private Lives : The Politics of Law and Order" (1992), London : Routledge
- Bridges, George S, "Crime, social structure and criminal punishment : White and nonwhite rates of imprisonment", Social Problems, 34(4), pp.345~61 (1987)
- Chamlin, Mitchell B, "A macro social analysis of change in police force size, 1972-1982 : Controlling for static and dynamic influences", Sociological Quarterly, 30, pp.615~24 (1989)
- Chiricos, Theodore G, "The media, moral panics and the politics of crime control. in The Criminal Justice System : Politics and Policies", pp.1998, Albany : West
- Chiricos, T, "Labor surplus and punishment : A Review and assessment of theory and evidence", Social Problems, 39, pp.421~46 (1992)
- Cole, George F, "The Criminal Justice System : Politics and Policies", pp.1998, Albany : West
- Currie, Elliott, "Crime and Punishment in America=미국의 범죄와 형벌(2004)" (1998), 서울 : 학지사
- Downes, D, "Contrasts in Tolerance" (1988), Oxford : Polity
- Duff, Anthony, "A reader on Punishment" (1994), Oxford University Press
- Durkheim, Emile, "The Rules of Sociological Method" (1966), New Yokr : Macmillan
- Durkheim, Emile, "The Division of labor in Society with an introduction by Lewis Coser" (1984), New York : Free Press
- Durkheim, Emile, "Two laws of penal evolution", Reprinted in Economy and Society, 2, pp.285~308 (1973)
- Foucault, Michel, "Discipline and Punish : The Birth of Prison=감시와 처벌 : 감옥의 역사(1994)" (1975), London : Allen Lane;서울 : 나남
- Knowledge : Selected interviews and Other Writings, 1972-1977, "Power", pp.1977, Colin Gordon
- Garland, David, "Punishment and Modern Society : A Study in Social Theory" (1990), Chicago : University of Chicago Press
- "Sociological perspective on punishment", Crime and Justice : A Review of Research, 14, pp.115~65 (1991)
- Garland, David, "The Power to Punish" (1983), London : Heinemann
- Hirst, P. Q, "Law, Socialism and Democracy" (1986), London : Routledge
- Jacobs, David, "Inequality and police strength : Conflict theory and coercive control in metropolitan areas", American Sociological Review, 44, pp.913~25 (1979)
- Jacobs, David, "Toward a political model of incarceration : A time-series examination of multiple explanation for prison admission rates", American Journal of Sociology, 102(2), pp.323~57 (1996)
- "Testing coercive explanations for order : The determinants of law enforcement strength over time", Social Forces, 75(4), pp.1361~92 (1997)
- Liska, Allen E, "Social structure and crime control among macro social units", American Journal of Sociology, 90(2), pp.383~95 (1984)
- Liska, Allen E, "Testing the economic production and Conflict models of crime control", Social Forces, 64(1), pp.119~38 (1985)
- Liska, Allen E, "Specifying and testing the threat hypothesis : political use of deadly force. in Social Threat and Social Control", pp.53~68 (1992), Albany : SUNY press
- Marion, Nancy E, "A History of Federal Crime Control Initiatives", pp.1960~1993 (1994), Westport : Praeger
- "A Primer in the Politics of Criminal Justice" (1995), New York : Harrow and Heston
- Melossi, Dario, "Punishment and social action : Changing vocabularies of punitive motive with a political business cycle", Current Perspectives in Social Theory, 6, pp.162~97 (1985)
- "An introduction : Fifty years later, punishment and social structure in comparative analysis", Contemporary Crises, 13, pp.311~26 (1989)
- Myers, Martha A, "Economic inequality and discrimination in sentencing", Social Forces, 65, pp.746~66 (1987)
- Rusche, Georg, "Labor market and penal sanction : Thoughts on the sociology of criminal justice in The Sociology of Punishment : socio-structural perspective" (1998), Dartmouth : Ashgate
- Rusche, Georg, "Punishment and Social Structure, with a new introduction by Dario Melossi" (2003), New Brunswick : Transaction
- Savelsberg, Joachim J, "Knowledge, domination, and criminal punishment", American Journal of Sociology, 99(4), pp.911~43 (1994)
- Sheingold, Stuart A, "Politics, public policy, and street crime(The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Sciences)", pp.155~68 (1995)
- Spitzer, Steven, "Toward a Marxian theory of deviance", Social Problems, 22, pp.638~51 (1975)
- "Punishment and social organization : A study of Durkheim's theory of penal evolution", Law & Society Review, 9, pp.613~37 (1975)
- Williams, Kirk R, "Social structure, crime and criminalization : An empirical examination of the conflict perspective", Sociological Quarterly, 21, pp.563~75 (1980)
- Yoon, Okkyung, "Social contexts of crime control : A time-series analysis of the Korean case", a paper presented at the 57th annual meeting of the American Society of Criminology, Toronto, Canada (2005)
- Zimring Franklin E, "The Scale of Imprisonment" (1991), Chicago : the University of Chicago Press
