여러 가지 임상평가방법과 성적과의 상관관계
Correlations of Clinical Assessment Tools with Written Examinations
2
조회
0
다운로드
11
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Purpose: Despite the goal of medical education, which is 'training to be a primary care physician,' only written examinations (WEs) generally have been used to assess medical student ability. We assessed clinical competence using the CPX (clinical performance examination), PA (portfolio assessment), VMA (video-monitoring assessment), CGD (case group discussion), and PCP (primary clinical practice) during students’ clerkships in family medicine and correlated these clinical assessment tools with WEs. Also, we correlated these tools with each other to determine the feasibility of each as a replacement of the other tools. Methods: Thirty-nine fourth year students at University of Ulsan College of Medicine took part in their clerkship in family medicine for 2 weeks during the first session of 2005. They took 1 CPX, 2 VMAs, 6 CGDs, and 2 PCPs and were required to submit their portfolios at the end of the clerkship. We evaluated the correlations of these tools and WEs by the overall scores of each class year and in each subject. Results: The CPX, VMA, and PCP showed no significant correlation,while PA showed strong correlation with 4th year students' overall WEs. The CGD showed strong correlation with all overall scores and with almost all subjects. In addition, the PA correlated significantly with CGD. Conclusion: New clinical assessment tools, such as CPX, PA, and VMA, have no significant correlation with WE, even though these tools closely correspond with real clinical practice. Therefore, these tools should be considered as complementary instruments to better assess clinical competence.
Abstract
Purpose: Despite the goal of medical education, which is 'training to be a primary care physician,' only written examinations (WEs) generally have been used to assess medical student ability. We assessed clinical competence using the CPX (clinical performance examination), PA (portfolio assessment), VMA (video-monitoring assessment), CGD (case group discussion), and PCP (primary clinical practice) during students’ clerkships in family medicine and correlated these clinical assessment tools with WEs. Also, we correlated these tools with each other to determine the feasibility of each as a replacement of the other tools. Methods: Thirty-nine fourth year students at University of Ulsan College of Medicine took part in their clerkship in family medicine for 2 weeks during the first session of 2005. They took 1 CPX, 2 VMAs, 6 CGDs, and 2 PCPs and were required to submit their portfolios at the end of the clerkship. We evaluated the correlations of these tools and WEs by the overall scores of each class year and in each subject. Results: The CPX, VMA, and PCP showed no significant correlation,while PA showed strong correlation with 4th year students' overall WEs. The CGD showed strong correlation with all overall scores and with almost all subjects. In addition, the PA correlated significantly with CGD. Conclusion: New clinical assessment tools, such as CPX, PA, and VMA, have no significant correlation with WE, even though these tools closely correspond with real clinical practice. Therefore, these tools should be considered as complementary instruments to better assess clinical competence.
참고문헌 (23)
- Barrows HS, "The programmed patient: a technique for appraising student performance in clinical neurology", J Med Educ, 39, pp.802~805 (1964)
- Lee HS, "Primary care education in medical schools in USA", J Korean Acad Fam Med, 20, pp.761~770 (1999)
- Harden RM, "Stevenson M, Downie WW, Wilson GM. Assessment of clinical competence using objective structured examination", Br Med J, 1, pp.447~451 (1975)
- 정기훈, "객관구조화진료시험(OSCE)에서 전문 표준화 환자와 비전문 표준화 환자간의 비교연구", 한국의학교육, 17(1), pp.97~105 (2005), 한국의학교육학회
- 박혜숙, "임상실습 전 학생과 임상실습 후 학생에서 시행한 객관구조화진료시험(OSCE) 평가", 한국의학교육, 16(1), pp.63~72 (2004), 한국의학교육학회
- 한재진, "임상 실습 종합 평가로서 시행한 객관구조화진료시험 (OSCE) -이화 의대의 경험-", 한국의학교육, 16(1), pp.33~40 (2004), 한국의학교육학회
- Park H, "The agreement of checklist recordings between faculties and standardized patients in an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE)", Korean J Med Educ, 15, pp.143~152 (2003)
- 박훈기, "객관구조화진료시험(OSCE; Objective Structured Clinical Examination)의 임상적 활용", 한국의학교육, 16(1), pp.13~24 (2004), 한국의학교육학회
- 김수현, "객관적 임상실기시험(Objective Structured Clinical Examination)을 이용한 가정의학과 임상실습학생의 임상수행능력 평가", 가정의학회지, 23(5), pp.4~592 (2002), 대한가정의학회
- Lee YM, "An experience of OSCE for introducing clinical performance assessment to Korean medical licensure examination", Korean J Med Educ, 13, pp.47~57 (2001)
- 권복규, "표준화 환자를 이용한 임상수행능력평가시험 (CPX)에서 교수와 표준화 환자의 평가 결과 비교", 한국의학교육, 17(2), pp.173~184 (2005), 한국의학교육학회
- 신좌섭, "진료수행시험에서 표준화 환자 채점의 정확도", 한국의학교육, 17(2), pp.197~203 (2005), 한국의학교육학회
- 김주자, "일개 의과대학에서 실시한 표준화환자 (SP)를 이용한 임상수행능력평가시험 (CPX) 결과 분석", 한국의학교육, 16(1), pp.51~62 (2004), 한국의학교육학회
- 박완범, "CPX 성적과 기존의 실습성적 및 필기시험 성적과의 상관관계", 한국의학교육, 17(3), pp.297~304 (2005), 한국의학교육학회
- Kim S, "Portfolio assessment and its application in medical education", Korean J Med Educ, 15, pp.73~81 (2003)
- Webb C, "Evaluating portfolio assessment systems: what are the appropriate criteria?", Nurse Educ Today, 23, pp.600~609 (2003)
- Finlay IG, "A randomized controlled study of portfolio learning in undergraduate cancer education", Med Educ, 32, pp.172~176 (1998)
- 최창진, "가정의학 학생실습 실태 조사", 가정의학회지, 25(12), pp.895~900 (2004), 대한가정의학회
- Scherer LA, "Videotape review leads to rapid and sustained learning", Am J Surg, 185, pp.516~520 (2003)
- Chou C, "Improving resident's interviewing skills by group videotape review", Acad Med, 77, pp.744~ (2002)
- Scheidt PC, "Evaluation of system providing feedback to students on videotaped patient encounters", J Med Educ, 61, pp.585~590 (1986)
- Kim BT, "의원파견실습교육", J Korean Acad Fam Med, 25, pp.S394~S398 (2004)
- Lee JK, "Evaluation of community primary care clerkship", J Korean Acad Fam Med, 20, pp.812~821 (1999)