본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Why Have Policies to Support Small and Medium Sized Retailers not Been Successful in South Korea?

이종현
한국유통과학회 (Korea Distribution Science Association)|2023.12|유통과학연구 (Journal of Distribution Science)|제21권 제12호|pp. 113-125|DOI 10.15722/jds.21.12.202312.113

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

South KoreaTraditional MarketLarge Discount StoreRetail PolicySmall and Medium Sized Retailer

초록

Purpose: Support policies for small and medium-sized retailers (SMSRs) have been promoted in various ways over the past 20 years, but they are generally regarded as unsuccessful. The purpose of this study is to analyze the process and impact of policy changes, identify the reasons for the lack of success, and explore policy alternatives. Research design, data and methodology: This study explored major policies in various categories such as the retail industry, traditional markets, and Micro-Enterprises from the mid-1990s to the present. It also analyzed the short- and long-term impacts of major policies at the retail format level like SMSRs, using data from Statistics Korea's service industry survey. Results: This research found that sudden shifts in policy philosophy conflicted with the existing market structure and reduced the effectiveness of policies. It also found that policies aimed at improving competitiveness at the SMSRs-level had some effect, while polices aimed at supporting expenses at the individual store-level were difficult to achieve their intended purpose. Conclusions: The failure of the policy to support SMSRs is fundamentally due to the late response and conflicts between policies. It was also not successful due to the policy's focus on individual store-level expenses and maintaining employment rather than structural improvements of SMSRs format. 􀀃

Abstract

Purpose: Support policies for small and medium-sized retailers (SMSRs) have been promoted in various ways over the past 20 years, but they are generally regarded as unsuccessful. The purpose of this study is to analyze the process and impact of policy changes, identify the reasons for the lack of success, and explore policy alternatives. Research design, data and methodology: This study explored major policies in various categories such as the retail industry, traditional markets, and Micro-Enterprises from the mid-1990s to the present. It also analyzed the short- and long-term impacts of major policies at the retail format level like SMSRs, using data from Statistics Korea's service industry survey. Results: This research found that sudden shifts in policy philosophy conflicted with the existing market structure and reduced the effectiveness of policies. It also found that policies aimed at improving competitiveness at the SMSRs-level had some effect, while polices aimed at supporting expenses at the individual store-level were difficult to achieve their intended purpose. Conclusions: The failure of the policy to support SMSRs is fundamentally due to the late response and conflicts between policies. It was also not successful due to the policy's focus on individual store-level expenses and maintaining employment rather than structural improvements of SMSRs format. 􀀃

참고문헌 (62)

  1. Ailawadi, K. L., "When WalMart enters : How incumbent retailers react and how this affects their sales outcomes", Journal of Marketing Research, 47(4), pp.577~593 (2010)
  2. Amsden, A., "Asia’s Next Giant : South Korea and Late Industrialization" (1989), Oxford University Press
  3. 안지영, "Machine Learning Approach to the Effects of the Superstore Mandatory Closing Regulation", 유통과학연구, 18(2), pp.69~77 (2020), 한국유통과학회[DOI]
  4. The Study of Effect and Cooperation in Operational Between Onnuri Gift Voucher and Local Gift Voucher, "Back, H.", Korea Small Business Institute(KOSI), ~, pp.Policy Research 19-12 (2019)
  5. Regulatory Reform in Retail Distribution, "Boylaud, O.", OECD, ~ (2001)
  6. Capps, O., "Effect of a Mass Merchandiser on Traditional Food Retailers", Journal of Food Distribution, 29(1), pp.1~7 (1998)
  7. 추명조, "전통시장의 서비스품질요인이 고객가치 관계품질 행동의도에 미치는 영향", 유통과학연구, 13(11), pp.79~92 (2015), 한국유통과학회[DOI]
  8. Evans, P., "Embedded Autonomy : States and Industrial Transformation" (1995), Princeton University Press
  9. Foster, L., "Market Selection, Reallocation, and Restructuring in the U. S. Retail Trade Sector in the 1990s", The Review of Economics and Statistics, 88(4), pp.748~758 (2006)
  10. Griffith, R., "Supermarkets competition in England and planning regulation. The International Review of Retail", Distribution and Consumer Research, 22(1), pp.1~25 (2012)
  11. Hausman, J., "Consumer Benefits from Increased Consumption in Shopping Outlet : Measuring the Effect of Wal-Mart", Journal of Applied Econometrics, 22(7), pp.1157~1177 (2007)
  12. Hicks, M. J., "The Regional Impact of WalMart Entrance : A Panel Study of the Retail Trade Sector in West Virginia", The Review of Regional Studies, 31(3), pp.305~313 (2001)
  13. Inderst, R., "Shopping hours and Price Competition", Economic Review, 49(5), pp.1105~1124 (2005)
  14. Jeong, J. C., "A Case Study on the Competitiveness Reinforcement of Joint Distribution Center of Small and Medium-Sized Business", Korean Business Education Review, 30(1), pp.93~119 (2015)
  15. Jia, P., "What happens when WalMart comes to town : An empirical analysis of the discount retail industry", Econometrica, 76(6), pp.1263~1316 (2008)
  16. A Study on the Development Strategy of Nadle Store, "Jung, S.", Korea SMEs &Startups Institute, ~ (2015)
  17. 김충환, "전통시장의 사회적 가치 요인이 만족도, 충성도 및 지역애착에 미치는 영향", 유통과학연구, 15(2), pp.59~68 (2017), 한국유통과학회[DOI]
  18. 김대윤, "국내 유통진흥정책과 유통조정정책에 대한 고찰", 유통과학연구, 11(4), pp.89~97 (2013), 한국유통과학회[DOI]
  19. 김판진, "소비자의 전통시장에 대한 인식수준이 재 방문의도에 미치는 영향 연구: 목포지역 소비자를 중심으로", 산경연구논집, 8(5), pp.77~85 (2017), 한국유통과학회
  20. 김승희, "시장정비사업의 효율적 실시를 위한 제도개선방안 연구", 유통과학연구, 11(4), pp.23~35 (2013), 한국유통과학회[DOI]
  21. Kwon, T., "Effects of Large Discount Firms on the Number of Small Retail Stores : An Empirical Analysis", Economic Research Institute, 20(2), pp.56~91 (2014)
  22. 권영훈, "대형마트 영업규제에 따른 효율성 비교분석", 경영컨설팅연구, 13(1), pp.115~139 (2013), 한국경영컨설팅학회
  23. 이철성, "전통시장 지원사업과 경쟁 강도가 점포매출액과 방문고객 수에 미치는 영향", 유통과학연구, 17(3), pp.97~105 (2019), 한국유통과학회[DOI]
  24. 이철성, "온누리 상품권과 신용카드가 전통시장내 소상인들의 성과에미치는 영향", 유통경영학회지, 21(2), pp.77~86 (2018), 한국유통경영학회[DOI]
  25. 이규현, "정부의 전통시장 지원 정책 효과에 대한 실증연구", 유통과학연구, 13(11), pp.101~109 (2015), 한국유통과학회[DOI]
  26. 이태정, "대형할인점의 매출과 입지요인분석- 상위 3개 업체의 전국매장현황을 중심으로 -", 응용경제, 9(1), pp.103~134 (2007), 한국응용경제학회
  27. Matsa, D. A., "Competition and Product Quality in the Supermarket Industry", The Quaπ : erly Journal of Economics, 126(3), pp.1539~1591 (2011)
  28. Neumark, D., "The effects of WalMart on local labor markets", Journal of Urban Economics, 63, pp.405~430 (2008)
  29. Jung-Sub Park, "나들가게 활성화를 위한 코사마트 재편에 관한 연구", 유통과학연구, 14(10), pp.153~164 (2016), 한국유통과학회[DOI]
  30. 박성용, "대형할인점의 중소도시 진입에 따른 소매점 유통경쟁구조 분석", 유통연구, 7(2), pp.21~44 (2003), 한국유통학회
  31. 류주현, "대형할인점이 소매업 구조에 미치는 영향", 한국지역개발학회지, 16(3), pp.163~182 (2004), 한국지역개발학회
  32. Schivardi, F., "Entry Barriers in Retail Trade", The Economic Journal, 121(551), pp.145~170 (2010)
  33. 서민교, "컨버전 프랜차이징 전략에 관한 연구-나들가게 사례를 중심으로", 한국프랜차이즈경영연구, 2(1), pp.74~99 (2011), 한국프랜차이즈경영학회
  34. 신우진, "영업시간 제한 및 휴무일 지정에 따른 대형마트와 기업형슈퍼마켓(SSM)의 매출액 감소 효과에 관한 연구 - 대구광역시를 중심으로 -", 대한부동산학회지, 30(2), pp.81~99 (2012), 대한부동산학회
  35. Singh, V. P., "Market entry and consumer behavior : An investigation of a Wal-Mart Supercenter", Marketing Science, 25(5), pp.457~476 (2006)
  36. Sobel, R. S., "Has WalMart buried mom and pop? The impact of WalMart on self-employment and small establishments in the United States", Economic Inquiry, 46(4), pp.676~695 (2008)
  37. 서근하, "Government Support for Entrepreneurship Damage to Small Retail Traders from Large Wholesalers’ Online Business Expansion", 유통과학연구, 13(12), pp.13~21 (2015), 한국유통과학회[DOI]
  38. 서용구, "대형마트 출점이 주변 상권에 미치는 영향: 공간계량경제모형을 이용한 서울시 상권분석", 유통연구, 20(2), pp.47~64 (2015), 한국유통학회
  39. 서용구, "대형마트, SSM 규제 정책의 효과분석", 유통연구, 24(3), pp.133~148 (2019), 한국유통학회
  40. Tanguay G., "Shopping Hours and Price Levels in the Retailing Industry : A Theoretical and Empirical analysis", Economic Inquiry, 33(3), pp.516~524 (1995)
  41. Wade, R., "Governing the Market; Economic Theory and Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization" (1990), Princeton University Press
  42. "The Economic Costs and Benefits of Easing Sunday Shopping Restrictions on Large Stores in England and Wales" (2006)[URL]
  43. Yi, J. H., "History of Korean Modern Retailing : Repressed Consumption and Retail Industry, Perceived Equaity and Economic Growth" (2016), Brill
  44. 이종현, "코로나19의 충격과 소상공인 정책", 동향과 전망, (115), pp.137~171 (2022), 한국사회과학연구회
  45. "Employment Security for seniors and Measures for the Self-Employed" (2014)[URL]
  46. "The Distribution Industry Development Act, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 5327" (1997)[URL]
  47. "The Distribution Industry Development Act, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 5833" (1999)[URL]
  48. "The Special Act for the Development of Traditional Markets, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 7235" (2005)[URL]
  49. "The Special Act for the Development of Traditional Markets and Shopping Streets, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 7945" (2006)[URL]
  50. "The Distribution Industry Development Act, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 7756" (2006)[URL]
  51. "The Special Act for the Development of Traditional Markets and Shopping Streets, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 9887" (2010)[URL]
  52. "The Distribution Industry Development Act, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 10398" (2010)[URL]
  53. "The Distribution Industry Development Act, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 11175" (2012)[URL]
  55. "The Distribution Industry Development Act, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 11626" (2013)[URL]
  56. "The Special Act for Supporting MicroEnterprises, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 11846" (2013)[URL]
  57. "The Distribution Industry Development Act, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 12443" (2014)[URL]
  58. "The Distribution Industry Development Act, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 13739" (2016)[URL]
  59. "The Distribution Industry Development Act, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 17534" (2020)[URL]
  60. "The Micro-Enterprise Act, Reasons for enactment and amendment, Act No. 16954" (2020)[URL]
  61. "Plan for Innovation of Distribution System for SMSRs" (2009)[URL]
  62. Statics Korea, "Wholesale and Retail Survey, each year Statics Korea, Sales Index by Retail Business Type (2015=100) Statistics Korea", Korean Standard Industrial Classification, ~ (2000)

관련 논문AI추천

Why Do Government Policies Fail in Boosting Independent Retailers?조영상한국유통과학회 · 산경연구논집2024 · 제15권 제1호국내 유통진흥정책과 유통조정정책에 대한 고찰권승구, 김대윤한국유통과학회 · 유통과학연구2013 · 제11권 제4호Retailing and Public Policy: A Comparative Study of South Korea and Foreign Countries조영상한국유통과학회 · 유통과학연구2014 · 제12권 제7호Do Retail Regulations Protect Traditional Markets as Well as Independent Stores in Korea?박종호, 정락채, 조영상한국유통과학회 · 유통과학연구2014 · 제12권 제9호A Comparative Study on the Distribution Regulation Policy in Korea and Foreign Countries김대윤, 박철주한국유통과학회 · 유통과학연구2013 · 제11권 제09호A Study on the Collaboration Development between the SSM and Traditional Markets in Korean Government Policies박승제, 서근하, 서창수한국유통과학회 · 유통과학연구2012 · 제10권 제11호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (11건)

The Impact of ICT Costs on Innovation Activity of Digital Hubs in Regions of Kazakhstan: Universities, SMEs and R&DSEITKAN Galiya G., NURLANOVA Nailya K., KREDINA Anna A., KIREYEVA Anel A.pp. 1-13The Effect of Teacher's Business Knowledge Distributions on School's Academic AchievementBASRI Azizul Qayyum, MD YASIR5 Ahmad Shah Hizam, RETNAM R Kalai Vilanggum Kanimoli, KOLANDAN Subramaniam, PALTHAMBURAJ Kingstonpp. 15-22Gen Z's Intention to Repurchase Food Online in The Context of a Crisis: A Case Study in Vietnam Under COVID-19Tran Thuc Ducpp. 23-34Civil Servant Commitment on Giving Cash Waqf: Does Trust Matter?HUSAIN Sri Apriyanti, KADIR Rifadli D, BAROROH Hilmy, AJUNA Luqmanul Hakiem, KONI Wiwin, RAHMAN Supandipp. 35-45How Did I Get My Order? Unveiling The Distribution Process of E-Retail in IndonesiaFATMAWATI Indah, FAJRIANA Salsabila Shafapp. 47-58
원문 보기