The Discord between the Rule of Law and Justice
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Modern legal philosophy is caught in a frame where it is forced to accept the discordbetween the rule of law and justice. The return of justice in legal philosophy is unachievable without reconciliation with the Rule of Law. Keeping ‘legal philosophy of reconciliation’ in mind, this paper provides an overview how we can reduce the tension between the rule of law and justice. Through the introspective reflection on the weak and impoverished state modern legalphilosophy finds itself in, this paper attempts to characterize the tendency of the question of justice being marginalized in the environment of legal positivism which is the product of the combination of scientific rationality and legal knowledge. Firstly, the autonomy of the actor as the subject being replaced by the autonomy of the legal system resulting in a kind of mechanism design, secondly, legal perception of form being contrasted to substance, thirdly, the problem of legal professionalism in which all views from outsiders are discounted, fourthly, by separating legal knowledge from political and social power encroaching upon law’s potential emancipatory ability, fifthly, the clash between the Rule of Law and democracy.
Abstract
Modern legal philosophy is caught in a frame where it is forced to accept the discordbetween the rule of law and justice. The return of justice in legal philosophy is unachievable without reconciliation with the Rule of Law. Keeping ‘legal philosophy of reconciliation’ in mind, this paper provides an overview how we can reduce the tension between the rule of law and justice. Through the introspective reflection on the weak and impoverished state modern legalphilosophy finds itself in, this paper attempts to characterize the tendency of the question of justice being marginalized in the environment of legal positivism which is the product of the combination of scientific rationality and legal knowledge. Firstly, the autonomy of the actor as the subject being replaced by the autonomy of the legal system resulting in a kind of mechanism design, secondly, legal perception of form being contrasted to substance, thirdly, the problem of legal professionalism in which all views from outsiders are discounted, fourthly, by separating legal knowledge from political and social power encroaching upon law’s potential emancipatory ability, fifthly, the clash between the Rule of Law and democracy.
참고문헌 (23)
- Johann Braun, "Rechtsphilosophie im 20. Jahrhundert: Die Rückk ehr der Gerechtigk eit" (2001), C.H. Beck
- Johann Braun, "Einführung in die Rechtsphilosophie" (2011)
- Hans Kelsen, "Reine Rechtslehre" (1960), Franz Deuticke
- Shim Hun-Sup, "Kelsen’'s Life and Work", Presentation at the Legal Philosophy Discussion held by the Korean Association of Legal Philosophy (2009)
- Hans Kelsen, "2 Die Wiener Rechtstheoretische Schule", pp.1445~1453 (1968)
- Pak Un Jong, "May 18th Legal Responsibility and Historical Responsibility" (1995), Ewha Womans University Press
- H.L.A. Hart, "The Concept of Law (Clarendon Law Series)", pp.93~ (1961)
- Nigel Simmonds, "Law as a Moral Idea", pp.135~ (2007), Oxford University Press
- Niklas Luhmann, "A Sociological Theory of Law", pp.22~49 (1985)
- Niklas Luhmann, "Advances in Social Theory and Methodology: Toward as Integration of Micro- and Macro-Sociologies", pp.234~ (1981)
- Joseph Raz, "Natural Law Theory", pp.309~ (1992)
- Pak Un Jong, "Problems of Natural Law", pp.196~ (2007), Sechang Publications
- Martin Loughlin, "An Examination of the Relationship between Law and Politics", pp.233~ (2000), Hart Publishing
- Boaventura de Sousa Santos, "Toward a New Legal Common Sense 5", pp.62~ (2002), Butterworths
- Pak Un Jong, "Why The Rule Of Law", pp.263~274 (2010), Dolbegae
- T.R.S. Allan, "Law, Liberty and Justice: The Legal Foundation of British Constitutionalism", pp.21~22 (1993), Oxford University Press
- Lon L. Fuller, "The Morality of Law", pp.74~ (1969), Yale University Press rev
- Park Byong-Ho, "Historical Lessons for Actualization of the Rule of Law", Legislation Research, 1, pp.27~ (1991)
- Michel Foucault, "Essential Works of Foucault, Vol. 1: Ethics", pp.290~ (1997)
- Ben Golder, "Foucault's Law", pp.71~ (2009), Routledge
- Michel Foucault, "Essential Works of Foucault, Vol. 3:Power 23" (2000)
- Eric Hilgendorf, "Gesellschaft und Gerechtigk eit: Festschrift für Hubert Rottleuthner", pp.45~ (2011), Nomos
- Robert Alexy, "Jurisprudence or Legal Science? A Debate about the Nature of Legal Theory", pp.51~ (2005)