Influence of a Co-op Program on Participants’ Academic Performance, Employment and Job Performance: Focusing on the Case of KOREATECH
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
KOREATECH has operated a Co-op program called ‘Industry Professional Practice (IPP)’ that allows students to work full-timein relevant industries for at least four months since 2012, and also developed a systematic performance evaluation model on thebasis of Kirkpatrick’s four-stage assessment model. This study aims to share KOREATECH’s Levels 3 and 4 evaluation resultswhich are clearly what practitioners and academic investigators of cooperative education want to know the most. For this purpose,a questionnaire survey was conducted for KOREATECH graduates and their superiors to examine influence of IPP experienceson employment and job performance. A total of 730 alumni who graduated within last 5 years participated in the survey, with 213(29.2%) having IPP experiences, and 162 superiors rated their subordinates on seven performance criteria. The analysis results weremixed. On the one hand, employment rate of IPP participants was 89.7%, compared to 86.8% of alumni without field experiences. Participants of the IPP program were more satisfied with their salary and felt less unfair about their career and promotion opportunitiesthan alumni without field experiences. On the other, superiors rated their subordinates without IPP experiences slightly morepositively than IPP participants in terms of job performance. These contrasting results are judged to show strengths and weaknessesof the IPP program at the same time. The limitations of the study and future research directions are discussed at the last part.
Abstract
KOREATECH has operated a Co-op program called ‘Industry Professional Practice (IPP)’ that allows students to work full-timein relevant industries for at least four months since 2012, and also developed a systematic performance evaluation model on thebasis of Kirkpatrick’s four-stage assessment model. This study aims to share KOREATECH’s Levels 3 and 4 evaluation resultswhich are clearly what practitioners and academic investigators of cooperative education want to know the most. For this purpose,a questionnaire survey was conducted for KOREATECH graduates and their superiors to examine influence of IPP experienceson employment and job performance. A total of 730 alumni who graduated within last 5 years participated in the survey, with 213(29.2%) having IPP experiences, and 162 superiors rated their subordinates on seven performance criteria. The analysis results weremixed. On the one hand, employment rate of IPP participants was 89.7%, compared to 86.8% of alumni without field experiences. Participants of the IPP program were more satisfied with their salary and felt less unfair about their career and promotion opportunitiesthan alumni without field experiences. On the other, superiors rated their subordinates without IPP experiences slightly morepositively than IPP participants in terms of job performance. These contrasting results are judged to show strengths and weaknessesof the IPP program at the same time. The limitations of the study and future research directions are discussed at the last part.
참고문헌 (5)
- C. K. Parsons, "Cooperative education work assignments : The role of organizational and individual factors in enhancing ABET competencies and Co-op workplace well-being", Journal of Engineering Education, 94(3), pp.309~318 (2005)
- M. K. Schuurman, "Assessing the impact of engineering undergraduate work experience : Factoring in pre-work academic perforperspectivemance", Journal of Engineering Education, 97(2), pp.207~212 (2008)
- B. F. Blair, "The impact of cooperative education on academic performance and compensation of engineering majors", Journal of Engineering Education, 93(4), pp.333~338 (2004)
- A. A. Rezin, "A Comparison of Industry Success of Associate Degree Graduates Who Participated in Cooperative Apprenticeship Programs versus their Counterparts in Traditionally Delivered Programs", Doctor, pp.1998
- Evaluating the Effectiveness of Career-oriented Education at Work: An Analysis based on Questionnaires to Alumni, "Y. Tanaka", Center of Research and Development for Cooperative Education, Kyoto Sangyo University, ~ (2012)
