우리나라 의학전문직업성 교육과정에서의 ‘전문직 정체성 형성’ 교육 현황
Current Status of ‘Professional Identity Formation’ Education in the Medical Professionalism Curriculum in Korea
1
조회
0
다운로드
7
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study examined the current status of the medical professionalism curriculum in Korea to suggest a plan to move towards the formation of a professional identity. Professionalism education data from 28 Korean medical schools were analyzed, including the number of courses, required or elective status, corresponding credits, major course contents, and teaching and evaluation methods. Considerable variation was found in the number of courses and credits in the professionalism curriculum between medical schools. The course contents were structured to expand learners’ experiences, including the essence and knowledge of professionalism, understanding of oneself, social interaction with others, and the role of doctors in society and the healthcare system. The most common teaching methods were lectures and discussions, while reflective writing, coaching, feedback, and role models were used by fewer than 50% of medical schools. Written tests, assignments and reports, discussions, and presentations were frequently used as evaluation methods, but portfolio and self-evaluation rates were relatively low. White coat ceremonies were conducted in 96.2% of medical schools, and 22.2% had no code of conduct. Based on the above results, the author suggests that professional identity formation should be explicitly included in learning outcomes and educational contents, and that professional identity formation courses need to be added to each year of the program. The author also proposes the need to expand teaching methods such as reflective writing, feedback, dilemma discussion, and positive role models, to incorporate various evaluation methods such as portfolios, self-assessment, and moral reasoning, and to strengthen faculty development.
Abstract
This study examined the current status of the medical professionalism curriculum in Korea to suggest a plan to move towards the formation of a professional identity. Professionalism education data from 28 Korean medical schools were analyzed, including the number of courses, required or elective status, corresponding credits, major course contents, and teaching and evaluation methods. Considerable variation was found in the number of courses and credits in the professionalism curriculum between medical schools. The course contents were structured to expand learners’ experiences, including the essence and knowledge of professionalism, understanding of oneself, social interaction with others, and the role of doctors in society and the healthcare system. The most common teaching methods were lectures and discussions, while reflective writing, coaching, feedback, and role models were used by fewer than 50% of medical schools. Written tests, assignments and reports, discussions, and presentations were frequently used as evaluation methods, but portfolio and self-evaluation rates were relatively low. White coat ceremonies were conducted in 96.2% of medical schools, and 22.2% had no code of conduct. Based on the above results, the author suggests that professional identity formation should be explicitly included in learning outcomes and educational contents, and that professional identity formation courses need to be added to each year of the program. The author also proposes the need to expand teaching methods such as reflective writing, feedback, dilemma discussion, and positive role models, to incorporate various evaluation methods such as portfolios, self-assessment, and moral reasoning, and to strengthen faculty development.
참고문헌 (58)
- Arnold L, "Measuring medical professionalism", pp.15~37 (2006), Oxford University Press
- Cruess RL, "A schematic representation of the professional identity formation and socialization of medical students and residents : a guide for medical educators", Acad Med, 90(6), pp.718~725 (2015)
- Cruess RL, "Reframing medical education to support professional identity formation", Acad Med, 89(11), pp.1446~1451 (2014)
- Cooke M, "Educating physicians: a call for reform of medical school and residency" (2010), Jossey-Bass
- Irby DM, "Parting the clouds : three professionalism frameworks in medical education", Acad Med, 91(12), pp.1606~1611 (2016)
- Bebeau MJ, "Lost virtue: professional character development in medical education", pp.47~87 (2006), Elsevier
- Jarvis-Selinger S, "Competency is not enough : integrating identity formation into the medical education discourse", Acad Med, 87(9), pp.1185~1190 (2012)
- Skorikov VB, "Handbook of identity theory and research", pp.693~714 (2011), Springer
- Burford B, "Group processes in medical education : learning from social identity theory", Med Educ, 46(2), pp.143~152 (2012)
- Bebeau MJ, "Manual for assessing and promoting identity formation", University of Minnesota, Center for the Study of Ethical Development, ~ (2003)
- Hafferty FW, "The role of the hidden curriculum in “on doctoring” courses", AMA J Ethics, 17(2), pp.130~139 (2015)
- Helmich E, "Entering medical practice for the very first time : emotional talk, meaning and identity development", Med Educ, 46(11), pp.1074~1086 (2012)
- Frost HD, "“I am a doctor”: negotiating the discourses of standardization and diversity in professional identity construction", Acad Med, 88(10), pp.1570~1577 (2013)
- Tagawa M, "Scales to evaluate developmental stage and professional identity formation in medical students, residents, and experienced doctors", BMC Med Educ, 20(1), pp.40~ (2020)
- Erikson EH, "The life cycle completed" (1982), Norton
- Hafferty FW, "The increasing complexities of professionalism", Acad Med, 85(2), pp.288~301 (2010)
- Hafferty FW, "Teaching medical professionalism", pp.53~73 (2009), Cambridge University Press
- Monrouxe LV, "Differences in medical students’ explicit discourses of professionalism : acting, representing, becoming", Med Educ, 45(6), pp.585~602 (2011)
- MacLeod A, "Caring, competence and professional identities in medical education", Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 16(3), pp.375~394 (2011)
- Goldie J, "The formation of professional identity in medical students : considerations for educators", Med Teach, 34(9), pp.e641~e648 (2012)
- Kohlberg L, "The psychology of moral development : moral stages and the life cycle" (1984), Harper & Row
- Kegan R, "The evolving self : problems and process in human development" (1982), Harvard University Press
- 허예라, "의과대학생들의 의학 전문직업성에 대한 자기평가", Korean Journal of Medical Education, 20(1), pp.23~35 (2008), 한국의학교육학회
- 허예라, "Are Medical Students Satisfied with Their Medical Professionalism Education?", Korean Journal of Medical Education, 22(1), pp.65~70 (2010), 한국의학교육학회
- 권효진, "Development an instrument assessing residents’ attitude towards professionalism lapsesin training", Korean Journal of Medical Education, 29(2), pp.82~91 (2017), 한국의학교육학회[DOI]
- 이금호, "의학 전문직업성 평가 척도의 탐색적·확인적 요인분석", Korean Journal of Medical Education, 24(4), pp.339~346 (2012), 한국의학교육학회[DOI]
- 방재범, "의학 전문직업성의 기초자질 함양을 위한 교육과정 평가 및 구성", Korean Journal of Medical Education, 20(2), pp.109~121 (2008), 한국의학교육학회
- Learning outcomes of basic medical education : human society-centered, "Korea Association of Medical Colleges", Korea Association of Medical Colleges, ~ (2017)
- Maxwell JA, "The SAGE handbook of qualitative data analysis", pp.21~34 (2014), SAGE
- Huber SJ, "The white coat ceremony : a contemporary medical ritual", J Med Ethics, 29(6), pp.364~366 (2003)
- Wilson I, "Professional identity in medical students : pedagogical challenges to medical education", Teach Learn Med, 25(4), pp.369~373 (2013)
- Mann KV, "Theoretical perspectives in medical education : past experience and future possibilities", Med Educ, 45(1), pp.60~68 (2011)
- Vagan A, "Medical students’ perceptions of identity in communication skills training : a qualitative study", Med Educ, 43(3), pp.254~259 (2009)
- Cohen MJ, "Identity transformation in medical students", Am J Psychoanal, 69(1), pp.43~52 (2009)
- Murphy RJ, "A comparative study of professional student stress", J Dent Educ, 73(3), pp.328~337 (2009)
- Pitkala KH, "Professional socialization revised : medical students’ own conceptions related to adoption of the future physician’s role : a qualitative study", Med Teach, 25(2), pp.155~160 (2003)
- Vignoles VL, "Handbook of identity theory and research", pp.1~30 (2011), Springer
- Wenger E, "Communities of practice: learning, meaning and identity" (1998), Cambridge University Press
- "Constructing physician’s professional identity: exploration of students’ critical experiences in medical education" (2001)[URL]
- Beijaard D, "Reconsidering research on teachers’professional identity", Teach Teach Educ, 20, pp.107~128 (2004)
- Clandinin DJ, "Creating pedagogical spaces for developing doctor professional identity", Med Educ, 42(8), pp.765~770 (2008)
- Sharpless J, "The becoming : students’ reflections on the process of professional identity formation in medical education", Acad Med, 90(6), pp.713~717 (2015)
- Hilton S, "Education and the changing face of medical professionalism:from priest to mountain guide?", Br J Gen Pract, 58(550), pp.353~361 (2008)
- Korica M, "Making sense of professional identities : stories of medical professionals and new technologies", Hum Relat, 63(12), pp.1879~1901 (2010)
- Smith CS, "The roles of experience and reflection in ambulatory care education", Acad Med, 72(1), pp.32~35 (1997)
- Self DJ, "The amount of small-group case-study discussion needed to improve moral reasoning skills of medical students", Acad Med, 73(5), pp.521~523 (1998)
- Miller SZ, "The habit of humanism : a framework for making humanistic care a reflexive clinical skill", Acad Med, 74(7), pp.800~803 (1999)
- Trede F, "Becoming professional in the 21st century", J Emerg Prim Health Care, 7(4), pp.990380~ (2009)
- Goldie J, "Teaching professionalism in the early years of a medical curriculum : a qualitative study", Med Educ, 41(6), pp.610~617 (2007)
- Gleeson C, "Education beyond competencies : a participative approach to professional development", Med Educ, 44(4), pp.404~411 (2010)
- Maudsley G, "Promoting professional knowledge, experiential learning and critical thinking for medical students", Med Educ, 34(7), pp.535~544 (2000)
- Mann K, "Reflection and reflective practice in health professions education : a systematic review", Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 14(4), pp.595~621 (2009)
- Kalet A, "Measuring professional identity formation early in medical school", Med Teach, 39(3), pp.255~261 (2017)
- Haas J, "Becoming doctors: the adoption of a cloak of competence" (1987), JAI Press
- Shuval JT, "From “boy” to “colleague”: processes of role transformation in professional socialization", Soc Sci Med, 9(8-9), pp.413~420 (1975)
- Khalili H, "An interprofessional socialization framework for developing an interprofessional identity among health professions students", J Interprof Care, 27(6), pp.448~453 (2013)
- Bebeau MJ, "Learning trajectories, innovation and identity for professional development", pp.135~162 (2011), Springer
- Steinert Y, "Faculty development as an instrument of change : a case study on teaching professionalism", Acad Med, 82(11), pp.1057~1064 (2007)