본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

전문직 정체성 형성 및 촉진을 위한 의학교육 현황과 고려점

Current Status and Directions of Professional Identity Formation in Medical Education

서보영|한희영
연세대학교 의과대학 (Yonsei University College of Medicine)|2021.06|의학교육논단 (Korean Medical Education Review)|제23권 제2호|pp. 80-89

2

조회

0

다운로드

7

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

Self-reflectionProfessional developmentHidden curriculumEducational activitiesPhysician identity

초록

Professional identity formation (PIF) is an essential concept in professional education. Many scholars have explored conceptual frameworks of PIF and conducted empirical studies to advance an understanding of the construct in medical education. Despite its importance, it is unclear what educational approaches and assessment practices are actually implemented in medical education settings. Therefore, we conducted a literature review of empirical studies reporting educational practices for medical learners’ PIF. We searched the Web of Science database using keywords and chose 37 papers for analysis based on inclusion and exclusion criteria. Thematic analysis was conducted. Most empirical papers (92%) were from North America and Western Europe and used qualitative research methods, including mixed methods (99%). The papers reported the use of reflection activities and elective courses for specific purposes, such as art as an educational activity. Patient and healthcare experiences were also found to be a central theme in medical learners’ PIF. Through an iterative analysis of the key themes that emerged from the PIF studies, we derived the following key concepts and implications: (1) the importance of creating informal and incidental learning environments, (2) ordinary yet authentic patient experiences, (3) a climate of psychosocial safety in a learning environment embracing individual learners’ background and emotional development, and (4) the reconceptualization of PIF education and assessment. In conclusion, research on PIF should be diversified to include various cultural and social contexts. Theoretical frameworks should also be diversified and developed beyond Kegan’s developmental framework to accommodate the nonlinear and dynamic nature of PIF.

Abstract

Professional identity formation (PIF) is an essential concept in professional education. Many scholars have explored conceptual frameworks of PIF and conducted empirical studies to advance an understanding of the construct in medical education. Despite its importance, it is unclear what educational approaches and assessment practices are actually implemented in medical education settings. Therefore, we conducted a literature review of empirical studies reporting educational practices for medical learners’ PIF. We searched the Web of Science database using keywords and chose 37 papers for analysis based on inclusion and exclusion criteria. Thematic analysis was conducted. Most empirical papers (92%) were from North America and Western Europe and used qualitative research methods, including mixed methods (99%). The papers reported the use of reflection activities and elective courses for specific purposes, such as art as an educational activity. Patient and healthcare experiences were also found to be a central theme in medical learners’ PIF. Through an iterative analysis of the key themes that emerged from the PIF studies, we derived the following key concepts and implications: (1) the importance of creating informal and incidental learning environments, (2) ordinary yet authentic patient experiences, (3) a climate of psychosocial safety in a learning environment embracing individual learners’ background and emotional development, and (4) the reconceptualization of PIF education and assessment. In conclusion, research on PIF should be diversified to include various cultural and social contexts. Theoretical frameworks should also be diversified and developed beyond Kegan’s developmental framework to accommodate the nonlinear and dynamic nature of PIF.

참고문헌 (50)

  1. Cruess RL, "Reframing medical education to support professional identity formation", Acad Med, 89(11), pp.1446~1451 (2014)
  2. Jarvis-Selinger S, "Competency is not enough : integrating identity formation into the medical education discourse", Acad Med, 87(9), pp.1185~1190 (2012)
  3. Niemi PM, "Medical students’ professional identity : self-reflection during the preclinical years", Med Educ, 31(6), pp.408~415 (1997)
  4. Holden MD, "Professional identity formation : creating a longitudinal framework through TIME(Transformation in Medical Education)", Acad Med, 90(6), pp.761~767 (2015)
  5. Cruess RL, "A schematic representation of the professional identity formation and socialization of medical students and residents : a guide for medical educators", Acad Med, 90(6), pp.718~725 (2015)
  6. Goldie J, "The formation of professional identity in medical students : considerations for educators", Med Teach, 34(9), pp.e41~e648 (2012)
  7. Kegan R, "The evolving self: problem and process in human development" (1982), Harvard University Press
  8. Lewin LO, "Minding the form that transforms : using Kegan’s model of adult development to understand personal and professional identity formation in medicine", Acad Med, 94(9), pp.1299~1304 (2019)
  9. Volpe RL, "Is research on professional identity formation biased? : early insights from a scoping review and metasynthesis", Med Educ, 53(2), pp.119~132 (2019)
  10. Wald HS, "Professional identity(trans)formation in medical education : reflection, relationship, resilience", Acad Med, 90(6), pp.701~706 (2015)
  11. Wyatt TR, "‘Whispers and shadows’ : a critical review of the professional identity literature with respect to minority physicians", Med Educ, 55(2), pp.148~158 (2021)
  12. Bearman M, "Qualitative synthesis and systematic review in health professions education", Med Educ, 47(3), pp.252~260 (2013)
  13. Matthew P. Abrams, "Reflective Writing on the Cadaveric Dissection Experience: An Effective Tool to Assess the Impact of Dissection on Learning of Anatomy, Humanism, Empathy, Well‐Being, and Professional Identity Formation in Medical Students", Anatomical Sciences Education, 14(5), pp.658~665 (2021), Wiley[DOI]
  14. Adema M, "Social interactions of clerks : the role of engagement, imagination, and alignment as sources for professional identity formation", Acad Med, 94(10), pp.1567~1573 (2019)
  15. Cunningham H, "Looking back to move forward : first-year medical students’meta-reflections on their narrative portfolio writings", Acad Med, 93(6), pp.888~894 (2018)
  16. Sawatsky AP, "Transformative learning and professional identity formation during international health electives : a qualitative study using grounded theory", Acad Med, 93(9), pp.1381~1390 (2018)
  17. Shiozawa T, "An insight into professional identity formation : qualitative analyses of two reflection interventions during the dissection course", Anat Sci Educ, 13(3), pp.320~332 (2020)
  18. Sorrell S, "First year medical students’ perceptions of the impact of wearing scrubs on professional identity : a narrative analysis in the United Arab Emirates", BMJ Open, 10(11), pp.e039357~ (2020)
  19. Stuart E, "‘Challenges in experiential learning during transition to clinical practice : a comparative analysis of reflective writing assignments during general practice, paediatrics and psychiatry clerkships’", Med Teach, 42(11), pp.1275~1282 (2020)
  20. Wald HS, "Grappling with complexity : medical students’ reflective writings about challenging patient encounters as a window into professional identity formation", Med Teach, 41(2), pp.152~160 (2019)
  21. Wong A, "Reflections : an inquiry into medical students’ professional identity formation", Med Educ, 48(5), pp.489~501 (2014)
  22. Chen LYC, "Exploring the role of classroom-based learning in professional identity formation of family practice residents using the experiences, trajectories, and reifications framework", Med Teach, 39(8), pp.876~882 (2017)
  23. Hatem DS, "Becoming doctors: examining student narratives to understand the process of professional identity formation within a learning community", J Med Educ Curric Dev, 6, pp.2382120519834546~ (2019)
  24. Konkin J, "Creating stories to live by : caring and professional identity formation in a longitudinal integrated clerkship", Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 17(4), pp.585~596 (2012)
  25. Nothnagle M, "Fostering professional formation in residency: development and evaluation of the “forum” seminar series", Teach Learn Med, 26(3), pp.230~238 (2014)
  26. De Lasson L, "Professional identity formation in the transition from medical school to working life: a qualitative study of group-coaching courses for junior doctors", BMC Med Educ, 16, pp.165~ (2016)
  27. Kline CC, "Professional identity formation : a role for patients as mentors", Acad Med, 95(10), pp.1578~1586 (2020)
  28. Parsons AS, "You can have both : coaching to promote clinical competency and professional identity formation", Perspect Med Educ, 10(1), pp.57~63 (2021)
  29. Reis SP, "Contemplating medicine during the Third Reich : scaffolding professional identity formation for medical students", Acad Med, 90(6), pp.770~773 (2015)
  30. Schei E, "Stretching the comfort zone : using early clinical contact to influence professional identity formation in medical students", J Med Educ Curric Dev, 6, pp.2382120519843875~ (2019)
  31. Tien L, "Simulation as a tool to promote professional identity formation and patient ownership in medical students", Simul Gaming, 50(6), pp.711~724 (2019)
  32. Green MJ, "Comics and medicine : peering into the process of professional identity formation", Acad Med, 90(6), pp.774~779 (2015)
  33. Joseph K, "Unmasking identity dissonance : exploring medical students’ professional identity formation through mask making", Perspect Med Educ, 6(2), pp.99~107 (2017)
  34. Rabow MW, "Professional formation and deformation : repression of personal values and qualities in medical education", Fam Med, 45(1), pp.13~18 (2013)
  35. Stephens MB, "Behind the mask : identity formation and team building", Ann Fam Med, 17(6), pp.561~ (2019)
  36. Hawking M, ""Can virtue be taught?" : a content analysis of medical students’ opinions of the professional and ethical challenges to their professional identity formation", BMC Med Educ, 20(1), pp.380~ (2020)
  37. Helmich E, "Becoming a doctor in different cultures: toward a cross-cultural approach to supporting professional identity formation in medicine", Acad Med, 92(1), pp.58~62 (2017)
  38. Matthews R, "From physiotherapy to the army : negotiating previously developed professional identities in mature medical students", Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 25(3), pp.607~627 (2020)
  39. Van den Broek S, "Social identification with the medical profession in the transition from student to practitioner", Teach Learn Med, 32(3), pp.271~281 (2020)
  40. Adams J, "Reflective writing as a window on medical students’ professional identity development in a longitudinal integrated clerkship", Teach Learn Med, 32(2), pp.117~125 (2020)
  41. Sawatsky AP, "Coaching versus competency to facilitate professional identity formation", Acad Med, 95(10), pp.1511~1514 (2020)
  42. Yardley S, "‘What do we do, doctor?’: transitions of identity and responsibility: a narrative analysis", Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract, 25(4), pp.825~843 (2020)
  43. Jarvis-Selinger S, "Understanding professional identity formation in early clerkship : a novel framework", Acad Med, 94(10), pp.1574~1580 (2019)
  44. Pratt MG, "Constructing professional identity : the role of work and identity learning cycles in the customization of identity among medical residents", Acad Manag J, 49(2), pp.235~262 (2006)
  45. Helmich E, "Emotional learning and identity development in medicine : a cross-cultural qualitative study comparing Taiwanese and Dutch medical undergraduates", Acad Med, 92(6), pp.853~859 (2017)
  46. Sawatsky AP, "Autonomy and professional identity formation in residency training : a qualitative study", Med Educ, 54(7), pp.616~627 (2020)
  47. Kay D, "What experiences in medical school trigger professional identity development?", Teach Learn Med, 31(1), pp.17~25 (2019)
  48. Conway-Hicks S, "Living in two worlds: becoming and being a doctor among those who identify with “not from an advantaged background”", Curr Probl Pediatr Adolesc Health Care, 49(4), pp.92~101 (2019)
  49. Wyatt TR, "What does context have to do with anything? : a study of professional identity formation in physician-trainees considered underrepresented in medicine", Acad Med, 95(10), pp.1587~1593 (2020)
  50. 한희영, "전문직 간 교육의 의미와 방향: 담을 허물고 환자가 속한 현장으로 나가는 교육", 의학교육논단, 19(1), pp.1~9 (2017), 연세대학교 의과대학

관련 논문AI추천

전문직 정체성 형성을 위한 의학교육 현장의 과제김선연세대학교 의과대학 · 의학교육논단2021 · 제23권 제2호우리나라 의학전문직업성 교육과정에서의 ‘전문직 정체성 형성’ 교육 현황이영희연세대학교 의과대학 · 의학교육논단2021 · 제23권 제2호의학전문직업성과 의학교육에서의 자기성찰유상호, 전민영, 차경희연세대학교 의과대학 · 의학교육논단2018 · 제20권 제2호일개 의과대학 본과 4학년의 롤 모델링 경험과 성찰수준 분석: 임상실습을 중심으로박경혜, 박연철, 예병일, 이상미연세대학교 의과대학 · 의학교육논단2022 · 제24권 제1호‘의료윤리’보다는 ‘전문직 정체성 형성’을 위한 교육으로 전환어은경한국의료윤리학회 · 한국의료윤리학회지2025 · 제28권 제3호한국에서의 ‘의학전문직업성’ 교육: 과제와 전망맹광호한국의학교육학회 · Korean Journal of Medical Education2008 · 제20권 제1호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)

‘전문직업성’을 넘어 ‘전문직 정체성 형성’으로이영환pp. 73-74한국 의사의 역사적 정체성 형성여인석pp. 75-79우리나라 의학전문직업성 교육과정에서의 ‘전문직 정체성 형성’ 교육 현황이영희pp. 90-103전문직 정체성 형성을 위한 의학교육 현장의 과제김선pp. 104-107의과대학생이 생각하는 좋은 일자리 유형에 관한 Q방법론 연구이재무, 박경혜pp. 108-117
원문 보기