본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

국가정체성과 라이벌리: 아부다비와 카타르를 중심으로

National Identity and Rivalry: Focusing on Abu Dhabi and Qatar

박인보|이화준
중동연구소 (Institute of Middle East Studies, Center for International Area Studies, Hankuk University of Forei)|2019.02|중동연구|제37권 제3호|pp. 107-136

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

문화정책국가정체성National IdentityUAE카타르Qatar아부다비Cultural Policy라이벌리Middle Abu DhabiRivaly

초록

This paper tries to argue that two geographically neighboring nations, Qatar and Abu Dhabi, pursued similar cultural policies in pursuit of a similar national identity, leading to political conflicts between the two states. We examine the context of cultural policies and political conflicts in these two nations and analyze the background of the rivalry between the two nations. The background of the rivalry between the two nations was largely due to the conflicts between the cultural policies of the two nations. Here, the similarity of the national identities that they tried to construct through cultural policies was meaningful. The national identities of both nations is not traditionally tracing back. The similarity of national identities poses a challenge of mutual ideology in that it suggests questions at the dimension of national idea. The operation of cultural policies in the process of rivalry between Qatar and Abu Dhabi has the following implications. The first is that a similar or common national identities can lead to political disputes among nations. Second, it is necessary to examine domestic policies context in terms of political disputes rather than military conflicts. These movements by two nations occurred after the political conflicts between the two nations had developed. Therefore, the context of political conflicts should be dealt with in order to analyze the rivalry between the two sides.

Abstract

This paper tries to argue that two geographically neighboring nations, Qatar and Abu Dhabi, pursued similar cultural policies in pursuit of a similar national identity, leading to political conflicts between the two states. We examine the context of cultural policies and political conflicts in these two nations and analyze the background of the rivalry between the two nations. The background of the rivalry between the two nations was largely due to the conflicts between the cultural policies of the two nations. Here, the similarity of the national identities that they tried to construct through cultural policies was meaningful. The national identities of both nations is not traditionally tracing back. The similarity of national identities poses a challenge of mutual ideology in that it suggests questions at the dimension of national idea. The operation of cultural policies in the process of rivalry between Qatar and Abu Dhabi has the following implications. The first is that a similar or common national identities can lead to political disputes among nations. Second, it is necessary to examine domestic policies context in terms of political disputes rather than military conflicts. These movements by two nations occurred after the political conflicts between the two nations had developed. Therefore, the context of political conflicts should be dealt with in order to analyze the rivalry between the two sides.

참고문헌 (68)

  1. "중동의 앙숙, UAE-카타르 갈등ㆍ군사 충돌로 비화 조짐" (2018), 강윤주[URL]
  2. "중동 항공사 ’하늘의 반란’… 가격은 저가, 서비스는 고급" (2018), 곽래건[URL]
  3. 김강석, "걸프 지역 영토주권의 한계와 갈등 양상 연구 - 사우디아라비아, 아랍에미리트, 이란을 중심으로 -", 중동문제연구, 16(2), pp.1~26 (2017), 중동문제연구소
  4. "카타르항공 등 중동 항공사 ‘공격적 투자.’" (2015), 김형규[URL]
  5. "중동 뒤흔든 카타르 단교사태 막전막후…카타르와 사우디 왕가의 ‘원한’ : 중동·아프리카 : 국제 : 뉴스 : 한겨레" (2017), 박민희[URL]
  6. "카타르, 단교 맞서 국방력 강화…英전투기 24대 구입" (2017), 박승희[URL]
  7. "경매 사상 최고가 ‘살바토르 문디’, 루브르 아부다비에 전시된다" (2017), 박용필[URL]
  8. "‘중동의 CNN’ 알 자지라가 중동에서 퇴출되는 까닭은" (2017), 백민정[URL]
  9. 서혜린, "An Analysis on the Authority of the GCC Based on the Network Theory", 중동연구, 34(1), pp.23~54 (2015), 중동연구소
  10. 송기형, "아부다비루브르Louvre Abu Dhabi박물관을 둘러싼 논쟁(I)", 프랑스학연구, (44), pp.215~240 (2008), 프랑스학회
  11. "세잔 ‘카드놀이…’ 미술품 판매 최고가 2800억원에 팔려" (2012), 윤민용[URL]
  12. "아트페어 들었다 놨다 하는 ‘큰손’ 카타르 공주" (2017), 이규현[URL]
  13. "고갱 명화 ’언제 결혼하니?’세계에서 가장 비싼 그림 등극" (2015), 이동휘[URL]
  14. 장세원, "아랍에미리트의 군사엘리트와 부족주의 관계 연구", 중동연구, 28(2), pp.65~81 (2009), 중동연구소
  15. 세계 무기수입 3 위 UAE, 중동의 방산수출 교두보로 급부상, "장원준", 산업연구원, ~ (2018)
  16. "‘카타르 단교 사태" (2017), 조상진[URL]
  17. "떠오르는 미술시장 ④ 두바이·아부다비" (2008), 중앙일보[URL]
  18. 최영일, "대UAE 경제협력의 특수성: 왕족의중요성", 중동연구, 32(3), pp.81~102 (2014), 중동연구소
  19. 최영일, "중견국 군사외교 수단의 효과성 검증 - UAE진출 국가를 중심으로 -", 중동문제연구, 16(1), pp.43~71 (2017), 중동문제연구소
  20. 홍미정, "사우디와 카타르의 역내 리더십 경쟁과 협력", 중동문제연구, 13(2), pp.31~77 (2014), 중동문제연구소
  21. Adler, Emanuel, "The Emergence of Cooperation : National Epis temic Communities and the International Evolution of the Idea of Nuclear Arms Control", International Organization, 46(1), pp.101~145 (1992)
  22. Anderson, Benedict., "Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism" (2006), Verso Books
  23. Anguelov, Nikolay., "Economic Sanctions vs. Soft Power" (2015), Palgrave Macmillan US
  24. "Qatar’s Ties with the Muslim Brotherhood Affe ct Entire Region" (2012)[URL]
  25. Bennett, D. Scott, "Security, Bargaining, and the End of Interst ate Rivalry", International Studies Quarterly, 40(2), pp.157~183 (1996)
  26. Bourdieu, Pierre, "구별짓기 : 문화와 취향의 사회학 上" (2005), 새물결
  27. Bowie, Robert R, "Basic Requirements of Arms Control", Daeda lus, 89(4), pp.708~722 (1960)
  28. Breuilly, John., "Nationalism and the State" (1993), Manchester Universit y Press
  29. Bunse, Simone., "Small States and EU Governance : Leadership t hrough the Council Presidency" (2009), Palgrave Macmillan
  30. Butler, Petra, "Integration and Int ernational Dispute Resolution in Small States" (2018), Springer International Publishing
  31. Buzan, Barry., "People, States and Fear : The National Security Problem in International Relations" (1983), Wheatsbeaf Books
  32. Cederman, Lars-Erik, "Endogenizing Co rporate Identities : The next Step in Constructivist IR Theory", European Journal of International Relations, 9(1), pp.5~35 (2003)
  33. Cooke, Miriam., "Tribal Modern : Branding New Nations in the Ar ab Gulf" (2014), University of Califonia Press
  34. Cooper, Andrew F., "The Diplomacies of Small States : Between Vulnerability and Resilience" (2009), Palgrave Macmillan
  35. Diehl, Paul, "War and Peace in International Ri valry" (2000), The University of Michigan Press
  36. Elman, Miriam Fendius, "The Foreign Policies of Small States : Challenging Neorealism in Its Own Backyard", British Journal o f Political Science, 25(2), pp.171~217 (1995)
  37. "UAE Says Qatar Fighter Jets Intercept Flights, Doha Denies" (2018)[URL]
  38. Gellner, Ernest., "Nations and Nationalism" (2008), Cornell U niversity Press
  39. "Qatar, UAE Sign Pacts to Boost Bilateral Ties" (2016)[URL]
  40. Hannerz, Ulf, "Small Countries : Structures and Sensibilities" (2017), University of Pennsylvania Press
  41. Hopf, Ted, "Common-Sense Constructivism and Hegemony in World Politics", International Organization, 67(2), pp.317~354 (2013)
  42. "Qatar Says It Will Leave OP EC and Focus on Natural Gas" (2018)[URL]
  43. Jesse, Neal G., "Small States in the Interna tional System: At Peace and At War. Animal Genetics" (2008), Lexington Books
  44. Kaufmann, Mareile, "Exercising Emergencies : Resilience, Affec t and Acting out Security", Security Dialogue, 47(2), pp.99~116 (2016)
  45. "3 Gulf Countries Pull Ambassadors From Qatar Over Its Support of Islamists" (2014)[URL]
  46. Klein, James P, "The New Rival ry Dataset : Procedures and Patterns", Journal of Peace Research, 43(3), pp.331~348 (2006)
  47. Larsen, Henrik., "Analysing the Foreign Policy of Small States in the EU : The Case of Denmark" (2005), Palgrave Macmillan
  48. "Qatar’s Support for Islamists Muddles Its Reput ation as Neutral Broker in Mideast" (2012)[URL]
  49. Maass, Matthias, "Small States : Survival and Proliferation", Int ernational Politics, 51(6), pp.709~728 (2014)
  50. Mearsheimer, John J., "The Tragedy of Great Power Politics" (2001), WW Norton & Company
  51. Noreen, Erik, "Why Small States Join Big Wars : The Case of Sweden in Afghanistan 200 2–2014", International Relations, 31(2), pp.145~168 (2017)
  52. Nye, Joseph S, "소프트 파워" (2004), 세종연구원
  53. Onuf, Nicholas., "Making Sense, Making Worlds: Constructivism i n Social Theory and International Relations" (2013), Routledge
  54. Porter, Michael E., "Competitive Advantage : Creating and Susta ining Superior Performance" (1990), Free Press
  55. Porter, Michael E., "The Competitive Advantage of Nations" (1990), Free Press
  56. Reiter, E, "Small States and Alliances" (2001), Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg GmbH
  57. Roberts, David B, "Qatar and the Muslim Brotherhood: Pragmati sm or Preference?", Middle East Policy, 21(3), pp.84~94 (2014)
  58. Roberts, David B, "Qatar and the UAE : To the Arab Spring", The Middle East Journal, 71(4), pp.544~562 (2017)
  59. Smith, Anthony D., "National Identity" (1991), Penguin Press
  60. Smith, Anthony D., "Ethno-Symbolism and Nationalism: A Cultural Approach" (2009), Routledge
  61. Smith, Anthony D., "Nations and Nationalism in a Global Era" (2013), John Wiley & Sons
  62. Stokke, Kristian., "Peace-Building as Small State Foreign Polic y", International Studies, 49(3–4), pp.207~231 (2012)
  63. Sulayman Khalaf, Abu., "Small Countries : Structures and Se nsibilities", pp.267~282 (2017), University of Pennsylvania Press
  64. Thies, Cameron G, "State Building, Interstate and Intrastate Ri valry : A Study of Post-Colonial Developing Country Extracti ve, 1975-2000", International Studies Quarterly, 48(1), pp.53~72 (2004)
  65. Thompson, William R, "Identifying Rivals and Rivalries in Worl d Politics", International Studies Quarterly, 45(4), pp.557~586 (2001)
  66. "Dubai Receives a $10bn Bailout from Abu Dhabi" (2009)[URL]
  67. "We Do Not Trust Them’: UAE Calls for W estern Monitoring of Qatar" (2017)[URL]
  68. "UAE Ambassador Threatens Further Sanctions against Qatar" (2017)[URL]

관련 논문AI추천

카타르의 국가정체성의 형성과 소프트 파워 전략강원구한국중동학회 · 한국중동학회논총2025 · 제46권 제1호카타르 단교 사태와 국민국가 정체성 강화에 관한 연구백승훈, 황의현중동연구소 · 중동연구2022 · 제40권 제3호걸프국가 소프트파워 구축전략과 한계 연구 - 사우디아라비아, 아랍에미리트, 카타르 문화산업을 중심으로 -엄익란한국중동학회 · 한국중동학회논총2020 · 제41권 제1호사우디와 카타르의 역내 리더십 경쟁과 협력홍미정중동문제연구소 · 중동문제연구2014 · 제13권 제2호한국의 대중동 공공외교에 대한 고찰김강석, 이주성한국중동학회 · 한국중동학회논총2023 · 제44권 제1호Nationalism and Cultural Identity: Unravelling Disputes over Culture Ownership between China and South KoreaXIE YING아시아연구소 · 아시아리뷰2023 · 제13권 제3호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (6건)

예멘의 대내외적 핵심 행위자들의 전략적 동맹과 그 변화요인 분석남옥정pp. 1-26Culture and Economic Development: A Comparative Study of Iran and South Korea유달승pp. 27-46글로벌 지하디즘의 맥락 분석: 지하드 개념의 왜곡과 편견을 중심으로이주성pp. 47-68모로코 라바트(Rabat) 외곽의 시민사회단체와 그 사회적 함의: 야쿱 엘 만수르(Ya’coub El Mançour)사례이한규pp. 69-106Economic Boycott: A New Form of Protests in Post Arab Spring Morocco?EL BOUCHIKHI MOHAMEDpp. 137-164
원문 보기