Replacing Liberal Confucianism with Progressive Confucianism
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The core thesis of this essay is that “progressive Confucianism” is a clear and viable category, a label for many though not all contemporary Confucians, which succeeds in capturing what is useful about so-called “liberal” Confucianism without suffering from various problems to which I show “liberal Confucianism” falls prey. The essay begins with examples of progressive Confucians being labeled as “liberal” in ways that are misleading. I next turn to the use of “liberal” by influential twentieth-century New Confucians and then look at some contemporary theorists who are often labeled “liberal Confucians.” Overall, for reasons having to do both with content and with rhetoric, I argue that even some Confucians who have been content to be called “liberal Confucians” should resist this label and identify as progressive Confucians instead, although others with “dualcommitments” may still prefer “liberal Confucian” or even “Confucian liberal.” The essay concludes with some further clarification of the senses in which progressive Confucians use the idea of “progress.”
Abstract
The core thesis of this essay is that “progressive Confucianism” is a clear and viable category, a label for many though not all contemporary Confucians, which succeeds in capturing what is useful about so-called “liberal” Confucianism without suffering from various problems to which I show “liberal Confucianism” falls prey. The essay begins with examples of progressive Confucians being labeled as “liberal” in ways that are misleading. I next turn to the use of “liberal” by influential twentieth-century New Confucians and then look at some contemporary theorists who are often labeled “liberal Confucians.” Overall, for reasons having to do both with content and with rhetoric, I argue that even some Confucians who have been content to be called “liberal Confucians” should resist this label and identify as progressive Confucians instead, although others with “dualcommitments” may still prefer “liberal Confucian” or even “Confucian liberal.” The essay concludes with some further clarification of the senses in which progressive Confucians use the idea of “progress.”
참고문헌 (35)
- Angle, Stephen C. 安靖如., "Contemporary Confucian Political Philosophy : Toward Progressive Confucianism" (2012), Polity Press
- Angle, Stephen C. 安靖如, "Kongxuetang 孔學堂 (Confucian Academy) 2" (2018), Bilingual publication
- Angle, Stephen C. 安靖如, "The Adolescence of Mainland New Confucianism", Contemporary Chinese Thought, 49(2) (2018)
- Bao, Wenxin 鲍文欣., "Jinbu shiguan yu chuantong jingshen shenghuo: xinlixue de neizai wenti 進步史觀與傳統精神生活: 新理學的內在問題 (The Progressive View of History and Traditional Spiritual Life: An Inherent Problem in New Rationalism)", Huadong shifandaxue xuebao 華東師範大學 學報 (East China University Journal), 6 (2013)
- Bao, Wenxin 鲍文欣., "Zhang Taiyan: Beiguanzhuyi yu ‘jinbu’ guannian 章太炎: 悲觀 主義與“進步”觀念 (Zhang Taiyan: Pessimism and the Idea of “Progress”)", Nanjingdaxue xuebao 南京大學學報 (Journal of Nanjing University), 2, pp.82~91 (2015)
- Bao, Wenxin 鲍文欣., "‘Jinbu ruxue’: Hanyi mohu de biaoqian? 進步儒學: 含義模糊的 标签? (“Progressive Confucianism”: A Label with a Vague Meaning?)", Pengpaixinwen 彭派新聞 (The Paper). June 6, ~ (2017)
- De Bary, William Theodore., "The Liberal Tradition in China" (1983), Columbia University Press
- Du, Yang 杜阳, "Lun Xu Fuguan de ‘rujia ziyou zhuyi’ sixiang de dangdai qishi 論徐復觀的“儒家自由主義”思想的當代啓示 (On the Contemporary Stimulus of Xu Fuguan’s “Confucian Liberalism”)", Jining xueyuan xuebao 濟寧 學院學報 (Journal of Jining University), 37(4), pp.41~45 (2016)
- Gao, Ruiquan 高瑞泉., "Zhongguo xiandai jingshen chuantong 中國現代精神 傳統 (China’s Modern Spiritual Tradition)" (1999), Dongfang chuban zhongxin 東方出版中心
- Hall, David L., "Thinking through Confucius" (1987), State University of New York Press
- Ho, Hsin-chuan 何信全., "Ruxue yu xiandai minzhu: Dangdai xinrujia zhengzhi zhexue yanjiu 儒學與現代民主: 當代新儒家政治哲學硏究 (Confucianism and Modern Democracy: Research on Contemporary New Confucian Political Philosophy)" (2001), Zhongguo shehui kexue chubanshe 中國 社會科學出版社
- "Rujia ziyouzhuyi’ ruhe keneng? "儒家自由主義”如何可能? (How Is “Confucian Liberalism” Possible?)" (2014)[URL]
- Huang, Yushun 黃玉順., "Zhongguo zhengyilun gangyao 中國正義論綱要 (An Outline of a Chinese Theory of Justice)", Sichuandaxue xuebao (zhexue shehui kexue ban) 四川大學學報(哲學社會科學版) (Journal of Sichuan University, Social Science Edition), 164, pp.32~42 (2009)
- Huang, Yushun 黃玉順., "Voice from the East: The Chinese Theory of Justice" (2016), Paths International
- Huang, Yushun 黃玉順, "Ziyou zhuyi rujia heyi keneng? 自由主義儒家何以可能? (How Is Liberal Confucianism Possible?)", Dangdai ruxue 當代儒學 (Contemporary Confucianism), 10, pp.1~18 (2016)
- Huang, Yushun 黄玉順, "Quanqiu shiyexia ruxuede zhuanjin ji qi lujing: Zhongmei ruxuezhe duihua, yishang 全球 視野下儒學的轉進及其路徑: 中美儒學者對話, 一上 (Paths Forward for Confucianism as Seen in Global Perspective: Dialogue Between Eastern and Western Confucians, Part 1A)", Qilu xuekan 齊魯學刊 (Qilu Academic Journal), 4 (2017)
- Huang, Yushun 黄玉順, "Quanqiu shiyexia ruxue de zhuanjin ji qi lujing: Zhong mei ruxuezhe duihua, yi xia 全球視野下儒學的轉進及其路徑: 中美儒學者對話, 一下 (Paths Forward for Confucianism as Seen in Global Perspective: Dialogue Between Eastern and Western Confucians, Part 1B)", Qilu xuekan 齊魯學刊 (Qilu Academic Journal), pp.4~ (2017)
- Jiang, Qing 蔣慶., "A Confucian Constitutional Order: How China’s Ancient Past Can Shape Its Political Future" (2013), Princeton University Press
- ""Guojia bixu queli zhengquanxing yu zhudaoxing de zhipeijiazhi—‘ zhengzhi ruxue’ dui ziyouzhuyi xueli de huiying zhiyi: Yi Chenzuwei jiaoshou weili” 國家必順确立整全性與主導性的支配價値—“政治儒學” 對自由主義 學理的回應之一: 以陳祖爲敎授爲例 (The State Must Establish the Dominant Overall, Guiding Values—One Reply of “Political Confucianism” to the Theories of Liberalism Taking Professor Chen Zu as an Example)" (2016)[URL]
- Liu, Junning 劉軍寧., "Gonghe・minzhu・xianzheng— Ziyouzhuyi sixiang yanjiu 共和·民主·憲政—自由主義思想硏究 (Republic, Democracy, Constitution: Research on Liberal Thought)" (1998), Sanlian shudian 三聯書店
- MacIntyre, Alasdair C., "Whose Justice? Which Rationality?" (1988), University of Notre Dame Press
- Mou, Zongsan 牟宗三., "Zhengdao yu zhidao 政道與治道 (Authority and Governance)" (1991), Xuesheng shuju 學生書局
- Mou, Zongsan 牟宗三., "“Shidai yu ganshou” 時代與感受 (Time and Experience). In Mou zongsan xiansheng quanji 牟宗三先生全集 (Complete Works of Mou Zongsan), Vol. 23" (2003), Lianjing chubanshe 連靖出版社
- Mou, Zongsan 牟宗三., "“Shidai yu ganshou xubian” 時代與感受續編 (Sequel to Time and Experience). In Mou zongsan xiansheng quanji 牟宗三先生全集, Vol. 24" (2003), Lianjing chubanshe 連靖出版社
- Neville, Robert Cummings., "The Good Is One, Its Manifestations Many: Confucian Essays on Metaphysics, Morals, Rituals, Institutions, and Genders", pp.199~211 (2016), State University of New York Press
- Peng, Guoxiang 彭國翔., "Zhizhe de xianshi guanhuai: Mou Zongsan de zhengzhi yu shehui sixiang 智者的現世關懷: 牟宗三的政治與社會思想 (The Worldly Concerns of a Wise One: The Political and Social Thought of Mou Zongsan)" (2016), Lianjing chubanshe 連靖出版社
- Qiu, Feng 秋風., "Rujiashi xiandai zhixu 儒家式現代秩序 (A Modern Confucian Order)", pp.3~29 (2013), Guangxi Shifandaxue chubanshe 廣西師範大學出版社
- Qiu, Feng 秋風., "Rujiashi xiandai zhixu 儒家式現代秩序 (A Modern Confucian Order)", pp.133~156 (2013), Guangxi Shifandaxue chubanshe 廣西師範大學出版社
- Tang, Wenming 唐文明., "Yinmi de dianfu: Mou Zongsan, Kangde yu yuanshi rujia 隱秘的顚覆: 牟宗三, 康德與原始儒家 (Secret Subversion: Mou Zongsan, Kant, and Original Confucianism)" (2012), Sanlian shudian 三聯書店
- Wang, Huaiyu 王懷聿, "Between Hierarchy of Oppression and Style of Nourishment : Defending the Confucian Way of Civil Order", Philosophy East and West, 66(2), pp.559~596 (2016)
- Wang, Yangming 王陽明., "Wang Yangming quanji 王陽明全集 (Complete Works of Wang Yangming)" (1992), Shanghai guji chubanshe 上海 古籍出版社
- Xu, Fuguan 徐復觀., "Xueshu yu zhengzhi zhijian 學術與政治之間 (Between Scholarship and Politics)", pp.331~395 (1980), Xuesheng shuju 學生書居
- Xu, Fuguan 徐復觀., "Xueshu yu zhengzhi zhijian 學術與政治之間 (Between Scholarship and Politics)", pp.457~467 (1980), Xuesheng shuju 學生書居
- Yao, Zhongqiu 姚中秋., "“Rujia fuxing yu Zhongguo sixiang, zhengzhi zhi zouxiang: Yige ziyouzhuyizhe de lichang” 儒家復興與中國思想・政治之走向: 一個 自由主義者的立場 (The Confucian Revival and the Direction of Chinese Thought and Politics: The Standpoint of a Liberal)", Sixiang 思想 (Thought), 20 (2012)
- Zhu Xi 朱熹, "Zhuzi yulei 朱子語類 (The Collected Writings of Master Zhu Xi, Arranged Topically), 3 vols" (1986), Zhonghua shuju 中華書局