People Are Special, Animals Are Not: An Early Medieval Confucian’s Views on the Difference between Humans and Beasts
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Early Confucians viewed their world in an anthropocentric way – man was an embodiment of the cosmos and embodied the virtues of benevolence and righteousness. By the early medieval period (220–589), though, Confucian tales of virtuous animals flourished, betraying that Confucian attitudes towards animals had changed: the moral boundaries between animals and humans were fluid and beasts could serve as exemplars for humans. One of the few early medieval Confucian thinkers who spoke at length about animals was He Chengtian 何承天 (370–447), a famed historian, astronomer, classical scholar, musicologist, and numerologist. His view of what separates humans from animals emerges from letters and essays he wrote attacking Buddhism. To refute the idea that humans and animals are both sentient beings, he espoused the old belief that people had a privileged place in the universe because of their moral excellence. Moreover, even though there was a gap between sages and ordinary humans, the latter were still ethically superior to beasts. In addition, for him, meateating was both a natural and sacred activity. Ironically, man’s benevolence and righteousness are most visible in the humane ways that Confucians wanted people to hunt and fish. He Chengtian’s opposition to Buddhism thus seems to have pushed him to a more extreme view of animals than his contemporaries. Nevertheless, his attempt to refute the idea of karmic retribution through an example taken from the animal kingdom betrays that he saw humans and non-human animals on a more equal footing than he cared to admit.
Abstract
Early Confucians viewed their world in an anthropocentric way – man was an embodiment of the cosmos and embodied the virtues of benevolence and righteousness. By the early medieval period (220–589), though, Confucian tales of virtuous animals flourished, betraying that Confucian attitudes towards animals had changed: the moral boundaries between animals and humans were fluid and beasts could serve as exemplars for humans. One of the few early medieval Confucian thinkers who spoke at length about animals was He Chengtian 何承天 (370–447), a famed historian, astronomer, classical scholar, musicologist, and numerologist. His view of what separates humans from animals emerges from letters and essays he wrote attacking Buddhism. To refute the idea that humans and animals are both sentient beings, he espoused the old belief that people had a privileged place in the universe because of their moral excellence. Moreover, even though there was a gap between sages and ordinary humans, the latter were still ethically superior to beasts. In addition, for him, meateating was both a natural and sacred activity. Ironically, man’s benevolence and righteousness are most visible in the humane ways that Confucians wanted people to hunt and fish. He Chengtian’s opposition to Buddhism thus seems to have pushed him to a more extreme view of animals than his contemporaries. Nevertheless, his attempt to refute the idea of karmic retribution through an example taken from the animal kingdom betrays that he saw humans and non-human animals on a more equal footing than he cared to admit.
참고문헌 (42)
- Ames, Roger T, "A Communion of Subjects: Animals in Religion, Science & Ethics", pp.311~324 (2006), Columbia University Press
- Blakeley, Donald N, "Listening to the Animals: The Confucian View of Animal Welfare", Journal of Chinese Philosophy, 30(2), pp.137~157 (2003)
- Chan, Alan K. L, "Philosophy and Religion in Early Medieval China", pp.32~44 (2010), SUNY Press
- Chapple, Christopher Key, "Nonviolence to Animals, Earth, and Self in Asian Traditions" (1993), SUNY Press
- Chen, Huaiyu, "In the Land of Tigers and Snakes: Living with Animals in Medieval Chinese Religions" (2023), Columbia University Press
- Endō, Yusuke, "A Study of the Acceptance of Buddhism during the Six Dynasties Period" (2014), Hakuteisha
- Fan, Ruiping, "How Should We Treat Animals? A Confucian Reflection", Dao, 9, pp.79~96 (2010)
- Fan, Ye, "Book of the Later Han" (1977), Hongye shuju
- Gao, Min, "Research on Essay on Attaining Original Nature and Śrītattvasiddhi", Journal of Xi’an Studies, 2, pp.164~167 (2023)
- Gao, Xinman, "Research on He Chengtian and the He Family" (2013), Shandong renmin chubanshe
- Gao, Xinman, "He Chengtian's Perspective on the Universe and Nature", Association Forum, 18(2), pp.147~149 (2012)
- Goodman, Howard L, "Xun Xu and the Politics of Precision in Third-Century AD China" (2010), Brill
- Harris, Ian, "A Communion of Subjects: Animals in Religion, Science & Ethics", pp.207~217 (2006), Columbia University Press
- Harvard-Yenching Institute Yinde Bianzuanchu, "Index to the Analects" (1972), Chinese Materials and Research Aids Service Center
- Huang, Chun-Chieh, "The Debate and Confluence between Confucianism and Buddhism in East Asia" (2020), V&R Unipress
- Ji, Zhichang, "Southern Dynasties' Pure Conversation: Discourse Culture and Interactions among Three Teachings in the Development of the Southern Dynasties" (2020), Taida chuban zhongxin chuban
- Jiang, Jianyun, "On He Chengtian's Anti-Buddhist Thought", Theoretical Monthly, 7, pp.62~66 (2017)
- Jiang, Xinyan, "Why Was Mengzi Not a Vegetarianist?", Journal of Chinese Philosophy, 32(1), pp.59~73 (2005)
- Kieschnick, John, "Of Tripod and Palate: Food, Politics, and Religion in traditional China", pp.186~212 (2005), Palgrave Macmillan
- Knapp, Keith N, "Animals through Chinese History: Earliest Times to 1911", pp.64~83 (2019), Cambridge University Press
- Knechtges, David R., "Ancient and Early Medieval Chinese Literature: A Reference Guide Part Four" (2014), Brill
- Lavoix, V, "Buddhism and Literature in Medieval China", pp.103~144 (2002), Centre D’Études Chinoises
- Liebenthal, Walter, "The Immortality of the Soul in Chinese Thought", Monumenta nipponica, 8, pp.327~397 (1952)
- Liu, Dianjue, "Rites of Zhou Character Index" (1992), Taiwan Shangwu yinshuguan
- Major, John S, "Animals and Animal Metaphors in the Huainanzi", Asian Major Third Series, 21(1), pp.133~152 (2008)
- Middendorf, Ulrike, "Philosophy and Religion in Early Medieval China", pp.135~171 (2010), SUNY Press
- Nylan, Michael, "Humans as Animals and Things in Pre-Buddhist China", Religions, 10, pp.360~382 (2019)
- Ohnuma, Reiko, "Unfortunate Destiny: Animals in the Indian Buddhist Imagination" (2017), Oxford University Press
- Pu, Chengzhong, "Ethical Treatment of Animals in Early Chinese Buddhism" (2014), Cambridge Scholars Publishing
- Ruan, Yuan, "Thirteen Classics with Commentaries and Annotations" (1965), Yiwen yinshu yinhang
- Schafer, Edward H, "Pacing the Void: T’ang Approaches to the Stars" (1977), University of California Press
- Seng, You, "The Collected Annotations of Hongming" (2013), Shanghai guji chubanshe
- Seng, You, "The Collected Annotations of Hongming" (1991), Shanghai guji chubanshe
- Sterckx, Roel, "The Animal and the Daemon in Early China" (2002), SUNY Press
- Sterckx, Roel, "Wildlife in Asia: Cultural Perspectives", pp.15~35 (2003), RoutledgeCurzon
- Su, Jui-lung, "Dictionary of Literary Biography Volume 358: Classical Chinese Writers of the Pre-Tang Period", pp.273~276 (2011), Gale Cengage Learning
- Sun, Yaoqing, "On He Chengtian’s Anti-Buddhist Thought", Theory Monthly, 7, pp.62~66 (2017)
- Taylor, Rodney, "A Communion of Subjects: Animals in Religion, Science & Ethics", pp.293~310 (2006), Columbia University Press
- Wang, Sanqing, "Encyclopedias from Dunhuang 2 vols" (1993), Liwen wenhua shiye
- Yang, Enyu, "Biography of He Chengtian" (2018), Fenghuang chubanshe
- Yōgaku no Kai, "Annotations on the Accounts of Filial Children" (2003), Kyuko shoin
- Ziegler, Harumi Hirano, "Collection for the Propagation and Clarification of Buddhism" (2015), BDK America