Some Remarks on Ahn and Cho’s (2006) Dual Analysis of Korean RNR
2
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
There have been various approaches entertained in the literature to account for the properties that the so-called right node raising construction (RNR) displays: Across-the-board rightward movement analyses, PF deletion analyses, and multi-dominance analyses, to name a few. Pointing out that no single uniform analysis can account for all the properties displayed by the RNR, Ahn and Cho (2006) propose a heterogeneous analysis approach: There are two types of RNR structures, one being derived by a semantically constrained ellipsis (S-ellipsis), while the other being derived by a phonologically constrained ellipsis (P-ellipsis). This article shows that despite some genius in it, Ahn and Cho’s (2006) dual analysis approach faces some empirical and theoretical problems. It will be first shown that there exist some RNR properties which are hardly accounted for by any version of ellipsis approach, including S-ellipsis or P-ellipsis. It will be also shown that the mechanism of P-ellipsis, if strictly followed, leads to some non-trivial technical and semantic problems. The conclusion drawn is agnostic: The RNR is still in a haze. (Hanyang University)
Abstract
There have been various approaches entertained in the literature to account for the properties that the so-called right node raising construction (RNR) displays: Across-the-board rightward movement analyses, PF deletion analyses, and multi-dominance analyses, to name a few. Pointing out that no single uniform analysis can account for all the properties displayed by the RNR, Ahn and Cho (2006) propose a heterogeneous analysis approach: There are two types of RNR structures, one being derived by a semantically constrained ellipsis (S-ellipsis), while the other being derived by a phonologically constrained ellipsis (P-ellipsis). This article shows that despite some genius in it, Ahn and Cho’s (2006) dual analysis approach faces some empirical and theoretical problems. It will be first shown that there exist some RNR properties which are hardly accounted for by any version of ellipsis approach, including S-ellipsis or P-ellipsis. It will be also shown that the mechanism of P-ellipsis, if strictly followed, leads to some non-trivial technical and semantic problems. The conclusion drawn is agnostic: The RNR is still in a haze. (Hanyang University)
참고문헌 (34)
- Abels,Klaus, "Right Node Raising: Ellipsis or ATB Movement", 34th North East Linguistics Society, pp.44~59 (2004), GLSA Publications
- Ahn, Hee-Don, "A Dual Analysis of Verb-less Coordination in Korean", Language Research, 42(1), pp.47~68 (2006)
- An Duk-Ho, "Right Node Raising as PF Deletion", To appear in Proceedings of the 16th Japanese Korean Linguistics Conference (2006)
- Boskovic,Zeljko, "Two Notes on Right Node Raising", University of Connecticut Working Papers in Linguistics, 12, pp.13~24 (1997), Department of Linguistics. University of Connecticut
- Chung,Daeho, "A Multiple Dominance Analysis of Right Node Raising Constructions", Language Research, 40, pp.791~812 (2004)
- Chung,Daeho, "Interpretation of Verbal Affixes in V-ed and V-less Coordination and Some Theoretical Implications", 8th Korea Generative Grammar Conference (2005)
- Chung, Daeho, "Agree but Not Necessarily at the Same Time", Studies in Generative Grammar, 18(3), pp.509~524 (2008)
- Chung, Daeho, "On the Syntax of Non-final Predicate Construction in Korean", 2008 Winter LSK Conference, pp.14~15 (2008), Chung-Ang University
- Chung, Daeho, "RNR Kwumwun: Pwunsek-kwa Cenmang (Right Node Raising: Analyses and Prospective)", pp.163~209 (2007), Pemenecek Kwanchal
- Ha, Seungwan, "Multiple Dominance CAN’T. but Ellipsis CAN Account for Right Node Raising", To appear in the Proceedings of the Chicago Linguistics Society, 42 (2006)
- Ha, Seungwan, "An Ellipsis Account of Right Node Raising in Korean", To appear in the Proceedings of Workshop on Altaic in Formal Linguistics, 3 (2006)
- Ha,Seungwan, "On Ellipsis Features and Right Node Raising", To appear in Proceedings of ConSOLE XV (2007)
- Ha,Seungwan, "Ellipsis. Right Node Raising. and Across-the-board Constructions", 박사, pp.2008
- Hartmann,Katharina, "Right Node Raising and Gapping: Interface Conditions on Prosodic Deletion" (2000), John Benjamins
- Hartmann,Katharina, "Background Matching in Right Node Raising Constructions. The Interfaces:Deriving and Interpreting Omitted Structures", pp.121~151 (2003), John Benjamins Publishing Company
- Horsntein,Nobert, "Logical form:from GB to Minimalism" (1995), Blackwell
- Kim,Jeong-Seok, "A Minimalist Account of Gapping in Korean", Japanese. Studies in Generative Grammar, 8, pp.105~137 (1998)
- Kim,Jeong-Seok, "Against a Multiple Dominance Analysis of Right Node Sharing Constructions in Korean and Japanese", Studies in Modern Grammar, 46, pp.123~147 (2006)
- Kim,Yong-Ha, "Hankwuke-uy Mwutongsa Cepsokmwun (Verb-less Coordination in Korean)", pp.84~122 (2007), Pemenecek Kwanchal
- McCawley,James D., "Parentheticals and Discontinuous Constituent Structure", Linguistic Inquiry, 13(1) (1982)
- McCloskey,James, "Right Node Raising and Preposition Stranding", Linguistic Inquiry, 17, pp.183~186 (1986)
- Merchant,Jason, "The Syntax of Silence: Sluicing. Islands and the Theory of Ellipsis" (2001), Oxford University Press
- Mukai.Emi, "On Verbless Conjunction in Japanesese. Proceedings of the 33rd North East Linguistic Society", pp.205~224 (2003), GLSA. Umass
- Oehrle,Richard T., "Categorial Frameworks. Coordination and Extraction", WCCFL, 9, pp.411~425 (1991)
- Park,Myung-Kwan, "RNR in Korean as Right-Edge Coordination", Studies in Generative Grammar, 17(1), pp.85~97 (2007)
- Postal,Paul M., "On Raising" (1974), The MIT Press
- Postal,Paul M., "Three Investigations of Extraction" (1998), MIT Press
- Ross,John, "Constraints in Variable in Syntax", 박사, pp.1967
- Sabbagh,Joseph, "Ordering and Linearizing Rightward Movement", 22nd West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, pp.436~449 (2003), Cascadilla Press
- Sabbagh,Joseph, "Ordering and Linearizing Rightward Movement", Natural Language and Linguistic Theory, 25, pp.349~401 (2007)
- Saito,Mamoru, "Three Notes on Synatictic Movement in Japanese Issues in Japanese Linguistics", pp.301~350 (1987), Foris
- Sohn,Keun-Won, "Deletion and Right Node Raising in Korean and English", Studies in Generative Grammar, 11, pp.485~501 (2001)
- De Vos. Mark, "Coordination under Right Node Raising", pp.97~104 (2005), Cascadilla Press
- Wilder,Chris, "Right Node Raising and the LCA", West Coast Conference in Formal Linguistics, pp.586~598 (1999)