본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

신용평가기능 개선을 위한 과제

Restoring the Role of Credit Rating Agencies as Gatekeepers

조성빈
한국개발연구원 (Korea Development Institute)|2011.06|KDI Journal of Economic Policy|제33권 제2호|pp. 81-110|DOI 10.23895/kdijep.2011.33.2.81

0

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

규제도덕적 해이경쟁RegulationCompetition신용평가Moral HazardReputation평판Credit Rating Agencies
주제분류경제학

초록

서브프라임 모기지 및 구조화 상품 등에 대한 부정확한 신용등급은 최근 금융위기 확산의 주요 요인으로 지적되고 있다. 본 논문은 신용평가노력을 관찰할 수 없는 숨겨진 행동모형(hidden action model)을 통해 신용평가회사의 행태 및 규제에 대한 분석을 시도하여 현재 논의되고 있는 신용평가기능 개선을 위한 논의에 보완적인 기여를 하고자 한다. 분석 결과, 도덕적 해이가 존재하면 신용평가노력이 관찰 가능하지 않음으로 인해 사회적으로 최적인 수준보다 낮은 수준의 신용평가노력을 기울임을 확인하였다. 경쟁 및 평판효과를 고려한 확장된 모형의 경우에도 신용평가회사에 사회적으로 최적의 유인을 제공하는 데는 한계가 존재한다. 그리고 부수업무의 존재는 신용평가회사의 노력수준과 사회적 최적 수준 간의 괴리를 확대함을 확인하였다. 따라서 경쟁과 평판에 의한 규율이 불완전한 경우 신용평가회사에 대한 감독 및 잘못된 정보의 제공에 따른 책임의 부과가 필요하다.

Abstract

Credit rating agencies(CRAs) are accused of failing to provide accurate and fair credit ratings and hence being responsible for the crisis. This paper tries to add on to the literature on credit rating reform through examining the CRAs in a model where rating quality is unobservable. We show that unobservability of rating effort results in the sub-optimal level of quality. Then the paper extends the model to incorporate ancillary services, competition and reputation. We show that ancillary services worsen the conflict of interests of the CRAs and that competition and reputation may not be strong enough to discipline the CRAs. Hence regulatory oversight and imposition of liability may be necessary in order to increase the accuracy of ratings.

참고문헌 (46)

  1. 임경묵, "채권시장에서의 신용평가기능 개선을 위한 정책방향" (2004), 한국개발연구원
  2. Acharya, V. V, "Resotring Financial Stability: How to Repair a Failed System" (2009), John Wiley & Sons
  3. Modelling the Role of Credit Rating Agencies－Do They Spark off a Virtuous Circle, "Bannier, C. E", ~ (2006)
  4. Reputation and Competition: Evidence from the Credit Rating Industry, "Becker, B", Havard Business School, ~ (2009)
  5. How Did Increased Competition Affect Credit Ratings, "Becker, B", Havard Business School, ~ (2010)
  6. Berger, A., "Comparing Market and Supervisory Assessments of Bank Performance: Who Knows What When", Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 32(3), pp.641~667 (2000)
  7. The Role of Ratings in Structured Finance: Issues and Implications, "BIS", ~ (2005)
  8. Ratings in Structured Finance: What Went Wrong and What Can be Done to Address Shortcomings, "BIS", ~ (2008)
  9. Bolton, P., "Conflicts of Interest, Information Provision, and Competition in the Financial Services Industry", Journal of Financial Economics, 85, pp.297~330 (2007)
  10. The Credit Ratings Game, "Bolton, P.", Columbia Business School, ~ (2009)
  11. Boot, A., "Credit Ratings as Coordinating Mechanisms", Review of Financial Studies, 19, pp.81~118 (2006)
  12. Brunnermeier, M. K., "Deciphering the 2007-08 Liquidity and Credit Crunch", Journal of Economic Perspectives, 23(1), pp.77~100 (2008)
  13. Cantor, R., "An Introduction to Recent Research on Credit Ratings", Journal of Banking and Finance, 28, pp.2565~2573 (2004)
  14. Cantor, R, "The Credit Rating Industry", Journal of Fixed Income, 5(3), pp.10~34 (1995)
  15. CCMR(Committee on Capital Markets Regulation), "The Global Financial Crisis: A Plan for Regulatory Reform", ~ (2009)
  16. Coffee Jr., J. C, "Gatekeeper Failure and Reform: The Challenge of Fashioning Relevant Reforms" (2004), Boston University
  17. Testing Conflicts of Interest at Bond Ratings Agencies with Market Anticipation: Evidence that Reputation Incentives Dominate, "Covitz, D. M", Federal Reserve Board, ~ (2003)
  18. Conflicts of Interest in the Financial Services Industry: What Should We Do About Them, "Crockett, A.", ~ (2004)
  19. Macroeconomic Stability and Financial Regulation: Key Issues for the G20, "Dewatripont, M.", CEPR, ~ (2009)
  20. Dichev, I, "The Long-Run Stock Returns Following Bond Ratings Changes", Journal of Finance, 56(1), pp.173~203 (2001)
  21. Dye, R. A., "Auditing Standards, Legal Liability, and Auditor Wealth", Journal of Political Economy, 101(5), pp.887~914 (1993)
  22. Inside the Ratings: What Credit Ratings Mean, "Fitch", ~ (2007)
  23. "The Credit Rating Industry: Incentives, Shooping and Regulation"[URL]
  24. Hörner, J., "Reputation and Competition", American Economic Review, 92(3), pp.644~663 (2002)
  25. The Role of Credit Rating Agencies in Structured Finance Market, "IOSCO", ~ (2008)
  26. Jorion, P, "Information Effects of Bond Rating Changes: The Role of the Rating Prior to the Announcement", Journal of Fixed Income, 16, pp.45~59 (2007)
  27. Kuhner, C., "Financial Rating Agencies: Are They Credible?－Insights into the Reporting Incentives of Rating Agencies in Times of Enhanced Systemic Risk", Schmalenbach Business Review, 5, pp.2~26 (2001)
  28. Lizzeri, A., "Information Revelation and Certification Intermediaries", RAND Journal of Economics, 30(2), pp.214~231 (1999)
  29. Makowski, L, "Perfect Competition and the Creativity of the Market", Journal of Economic Literature, 39(2), pp.48~58 (2001)
  30. Mankiw, N. G, "Free Entry and Social Inefficiency", RAND Journal of Economics, 17(1), pp.479~535 (1986)
  31. Mathis, J., "Rating the Raters: Are Reputation Concerns Powerful Enough to Discipline Rating Agencies", Journal of Monetary Economics, 56, pp.657~674 (2008)
  32. Millon, M. H, "Moral Hazard and Information Sharing: A Model of Financial Information Gathering Agencies", Journal of Finance, 40(5), pp.1403~1422 (1985)
  33. Real Time Solutions for Financial Reform, "NYU Stern Working Group", ~ (2009)
  34. Pagano, M, "Optimal Regulation of Auditing", CESifo Economic Studies, 53, pp.363~388 (2007)
  35. Partnoy, F., "The Siskel and Ebert of Financial Markets?: Two Thumbs Down for the Credit Rating Agencies", Washington University Law Quarterly, 77(3), pp.619~712 (1999)
  36. Partnoy, F., "The Paradox of Credit Ratings in Ratings, Rating Agencies and the Global Financial System" (2001), Kluwer Academic Publishers
  37. Strict Liability for Gatekeepers:A Reply to Professor Coffee, "Partnoy, F.", Boston University, ~ (2004)
  38. How and Why Credit Rating Agencies Are Not Like Other Gatekeepers,” University of San Diego Legal Studies Research Paper Series, "Partnoy, F.", ~, pp.No. 07-46 (2006)
  39. Rethinking Regulation of Credit Rating Agencies: An Institutional Investor Perspective, "Partnoy, F.", ~ (2009)
  40. Credit-Rating Shopping, Selection and the Equilibrium Structure of Ratings, "Sangiorgi, F.", ~ (2009)
  41. Annual Report on Nationally Recognized Statistical Rating Organizations, "SEC", ~ (2008)
  42. Annual Report on Nationally Recognized Statistical Rating Organizations, "SEC", ~ (2009)
  43. Skreta, L, "Ratings Shopping and Asset Complexity: A Theory of Ratings Inflation", Journal of Monetary Economics, 56, pp.678~695 (2009)
  44. Smith, R. C, "Rating agencies: Is There an Agency Issue in Ratings, Rating Agencies and the Global Financial System" (2002), Kluwer Academic Publishers
  45. Stolper, A., "Regulation of Credit Rating Agencies", Journal of Banking & Finance, 33, pp.1266~1273 (2009)
  46. White, L., "The Credit Rating Industry: An Industrial Organization Analysis in Ratings, Rating Agencies and the Global Financial System" (2002), Kluwer Academic Publishers

관련 논문AI추천

신용평가산업의 이해상충과 경쟁 이슈에 대한 고찰한재준한국금융정보학회 · 금융정보연구2016 · 제5권 제2호信用評價의 信賴性 提高를 위한 制度改善 方向－構造化金融 信用評價를 中心으로－이정두, 홍사랑한국증권법학회 · 증권법연구2019 · 제20권 제1호채권시장에서의 신용평가기능 개선을 위한 정책방향임경묵한국개발연구원 · KDI Journal of Economic Policy2006 · 제28권 제1호신용평가 규제법제의 입법론적 과제박임출한국증권법학회 · 증권법연구2009 · 제10권 제2호글로벌 금융위기로 대두된 신용평가회사 이해상충 문제의 해결방안박훤일한국증권법학회 · 증권법연구2011 · 제12권 제1호신용평가업에 대한 규제강화는 기업 신용평가의 질을 향상시켰는가?양철원보험연구원 · 보험금융연구2022 · 제33권 제1호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (4건)

우리나라 경기변동의 안정성 분석: 서비스산업의 역할을 중심으로이재준pp. 1-39은행 임원의 주식기준 보상과 위험추구여은정, 이호준, 윤경수pp. 41-79노동수요 측면의 임금보조정책 연구유한욱pp. 111-143환경정책, 재분배정책, 경제성장에 관한 정치경제학적 분석김재훈pp. 145-175
원문 보기