본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

물질흐름분석(MFA)의 의의와 정책적 함의

Material Flow Analysis and its Implication for Sustainability Policy

최정수|조영탁
한국환경연구원 (Korea Environment Institute)|2006.06|환경정책연구 (Journal of Environmental Policy)|제5권 제2호|pp. 1-26

1

조회

0

다운로드

7

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

LCA물질흐름분석EW-MFAPIOTNAMEALCI강지속가능성약지속가능성Material Flow Analysisstrong sustainabilityweak sustainability
주제분류정책학

초록

이 글은 물질흐름분석(MFA)이 지속가능성을 둘러싼 추상적인 개념 대립(약지속가능성과 강지속가능성)을 극복하고 지속가능성의 문제를 구체적인 정책 수준에서 논의할 수 있음을 보인다. 이를 위해 물질흐름분석이란 동일한 논리구조가 현실의 국민경제(EW-MFA)에서부터 산업(PIOT/NAMEA) 그리고 제품(LCI)에 이르기까지 구체적이고 일관성 있게 적용될 수 있음을 보이고, 각 유형의 MFA가 지닌 의의와 정책적 함의를 구명한다.

Abstract

This paper reveals Material Flow Analysis(MFA) has the possibility of reconciling the two contending theoretical viewpoints(weak sustainability v.s. strong sustainability) and thereby makes the concept of sustainability useful at operational level. For this purpose, this paper shows that the theoretical logic of MFA can be applied from national level to product level (EW-MFA, PIOT/NAMEA, LCI), and investigates the meanings and policy implications of MFA at each level.

참고문헌 (47)

  1. 김종호, "생태문제의 경제학적 수용에 관한 비판적 세 논문" (2001)
  2. 조영탁, "생태경제학：비전의 모색과 그 음미", 18, pp.85~129 (2002)
  3. "환경거시경제이론의 소개와 그 평가", 19, pp.361~383 (2002)
  4. "생태경제학 산책：방법론, 비전, 지속가능성", pp.13~58 (2003), 프란치스코 교육회관
  5. 최정수, "환경계정과 지속가능지표：한국의 직접물질유입량지표를 중심으로", pp.1~4 (2004), 이화여자대학교
  6. 환경부, "환경경제통합계정 개발 및 녹색GDP 작성" (2003), 환경부
  7. "환경경제통합계정 개발 및 녹색GDP 작성 II" (2004), 환경부
  8. "환경경제통합계정 개발 및 녹색GDP 작성 Ⅲ：최종보고회 자료" (2005), 환경부
  9. Adriaanse, "Resource Flow：The Material Base of Industrial Economies" (1997), World Resource Institute
  10. Ayres, "Aspects of Environmental Economics：A Materials Balance-General Equilibrium Approach" (1970), Johns Hopkins University Press
  11. Bartelmus, P, "Dematerialization and Capital Maintenance：Two Sides of the Sustainability Coin", 46, pp.61~81 (2003)
  12. Bringezu, S, "Regional and National Material Flow Accounting : From Paradigm to Practice of Sustainabilty" (1997)
  13. "Rationale for and Interpretation of Economy-Wide Materials Flow Analysis and Derived Indicators", 7(2), pp.43~64 (2003)
  14. Daly, "“On Economics as a Life Science” Journal of Political Economy 76", pp.392~406 (1968)
  15. Daniels, P, "Approaches for Quantifying the Metabolism of Physical Economies Part I", 5(4), pp.69~ (2002)
  16. "Approaches for Quantifying the Metabolism of Physical Economies Part II: Review of Individual Approaches", 6(1), pp.65~88 (2002)
  17. Duchin, F, "Industrial Ecology, Online Encyclopaedia of Ecological Economics" (2003)
  18. El Serafy, S, "Natural Resource Accounting, The Handbook of Environmental and Resources Economics" (1999), Edward Elgar
  19. EUROSTAT, "Economy-wide Material Flow Account and Derived Indicators : A Methodological Guide. Statistical Office of the European Union" (2001)
  20. Femia, A, "Use of MFA-Related Family of Tools in Environmental Policy-Making: Overview of Possibilities, Limitations and Existing Examples of Application in Practice", pp.1~2004 (2005), European Environment Agency
  21. Fischer-Kowalski, M, "Society's Metabolism：The Intellectual History of Material Flow Analysis, Part I 1860-1970", 2(1), pp.61~78 (1998)
  22. Fischer-Kowalski, M, "Society's Metabolism：The Intellectual History of Material Flow Analysis, Part II 1970-1998", 2(4), pp.107~136 (1999)
  23. Hinterberger, F, "Material Flows v.s. ‘Natural Capital’ : What Makes an Economy Sustainable?", 23, pp.1~14 (1997)
  24. "Material Flows Accounting and Analysis(MFA) : A Valuable Tool for Analysis of Society-Nature Interrelationship, Online Encyclopaedia of Ecological Economics" (2003)
  25. Hoekstra, R, "Economic Growth, Material Flows and Environment" (2005), Edward Elgar
  26. Lange, G-M, "How to Make Progress toward Integrating Biophysical and Economic Assessment", 29, pp.29~32 (1999)
  27. "“Environmental Repercussions and the Economic Structure：An Input-Output Approach” Review of Economics and Statistics 52", pp.262~71 (1970)
  28. Ford, "“Air Pollution and Economic Structure：Empirical Results of Input-Output Computations” In Brody & Cater" (1972)
  29. Martinez-Alier, J, "The Environmentalism of the Poor : A Study of Ecological Conflicts and Valuation" (2002), Edward Elgar
  30. Matthews, "The Weight of Nations：Material Outflows from Industrial Economies" (2000), World Resource Institute
  31. Moll, S, "Aggregated Indicators for Resource Use and Resource Productivity :Their Meaning, Cross-country Comparability, and Potential Driving Factors" (2004)
  32. European Environment Agency, "European Environment Agency IP 2004-Project 3.2.2." (2004)
  33. OECD, "OECD Environmental Strategy for the First Decade of 21st Century" (2001), OECD Environment Ministers
  34. Ree, W, "Monetary Analysis：Turning a Blind Eye on Sustainability", 29, pp.47~52 (1999)
  35. Ritthoff, M, "Calculating MIPS：Resource Productivity of Products and Services, Wuppertal Spezial 27e, Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy", pp.27~ (2002)
  36. Ropke, I, "Price Are Not Much", 29, pp.47~52 (1999)
  37. Spangenberg, J, "Sustainability Indicators：A Compass on the Road towards Sustainability", (81) (1998), Wuppertal Institute
  38. Spangenberg, J, "Material Flow Analysis, TMR and the MIPS-Concept :A Contribution to the Development of Indicators for Measuring Changes in Consumption and Production Patterns", 2(4), pp.491~505 (1999)
  39. Strassert, G, "Physical Input-Output Accounting and Analysis：New Perspectives" (2000)
  40. Suh, S, "System Boundary Selection in Life-Cycle Inventories Using Hybrid Approaches", 38(3), pp.657~64 (2004)
  41. Udo de Haes, H, "Three Strategies to Overcome the Limitations of Life-Cycle Assessment", 8(3), pp.19~32 (2004)
  42. van den Bergh, "The Interface between Economics and Industrial Ecology：A Survey" (2004), MIT Press
  43. WGEIO, "Material Flow and Related Indicators：OECD Approach and Work Plan for 2005-6", pp.~2005 (2005)
  44. "Material Flow and Related Indicators：Inventory of Country Activities", pp.~2005 (2005)
  45. "Material Flow and Resource Productivity Indicators" (2005)
  46. "Material Flow and Resource Productivity Indicators" (2005)
  47. U.N, "Integrated Environmental and Economic Accounting(SEEA)" (2003)

관련 논문AI추천

순환형 자원관리를 위한 방법론으로서의 물질흐름분석김성용, 김유정, 김인숙한국자원공학회 · 한국자원공학회지2006 · 제43권 제2호물질흐름계정(Material Flow Accounts)의 유용성 및 해외 동향 조사 연구김윤경, 김지환한국자원공학회 · 한국자원공학회지2008 · 제45권 제2호한국의 물질흐름계정 산정김유정한국자원공학회 · 한국자원공학회지2011 · 제48권 제6호물질소비지표에 의한 지속가능성분석최기재, 최정수국가데이터연구원 · 통계연구2004 · 제9권 제1호물질균형접근에 기초한 생산단위의 지속가능성 계측강상목한국환경연구원 · 환경정책연구2013 · 제12권 제1호물질흐름지표를 이용한 韓國의 지속가능한 資源管理 평가 硏究김유정한국자원리싸이클링학회 · 자원리싸이클링2011 · 제20권 제6호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (3건)

토양오염실태조사 및 특정토양오염관리대상시설 부지 등에서 토양오염조사의 효율성 제고를 위한 환경정책의 고찰박상열, 박용하, 양재의pp. 27-47선진 외국에서의 먹는물 중 방사성물질 관리동향박선구, 손지환pp. 49-67청정개발체제(CDM) 베이스라인 방법론 적용에 관한 고찰한승호pp. 69-93
원문 보기