중국의 전쟁 결정요인에 관한 연구-중월전쟁을 중심으로 -
A StudyontheChina'sWarDecisionFactors -FocusingontheChina-Vietnam War-
0
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Throughouthistory,wars between emerging powerfulnations and the originaloneshavebroughta changein theinternationalorder.Struggles among European powers such as Espana,Netherlands,England between 16th and18th centuriessupportsitwell.Each countrieshadcompetedfor powerand foughtmany wars.In such perspective,China'srisein power willbethereason forChinatomaintain itsown orderthrough expanding military,whichisthesymbolforpower,andsuch action willfurtheraffect theinternationalorderandEastAsiaregioninnegativeways.Thus,strong power is needed in order to assign China the bigger responsibility and commitment. Moreover, China is expanding its military to prepare for diversifiednew threatsandpossiblewarandtoprofitforitssurvival.Such future China willmore likely to become a majorthreatto its neighbor countriesratherthanacontributiontocommonprosperity. The research has utilized Waltz's three images to analyze China's war decision in caseoftheChina-Vietnam War.In otherwords,threeelements calledindividual,nation,internationalstructureexplainwhyChinadeclared warupon Vietnam atthetime.Therearethreereasonswhich causedthe war:awarenessofChina'sleaderslikeDeungShaoPing in an individual scale, change in China's strategy in a nationalscale, and change in internationalorder First reason is the awareness of China's political leaders. This is differentfrom the Western conceptoffairamong countries.Analyze how china recognized other countries and how this caused China to declare war.ThatistosayChina'spoliticalleaders',includingDeong ShaoPing,historicalawareness ofcolonized Vietnam and geopoliticalawareness of EastAsiagreatlyaffectedChina'sactionforwar. Secondreason isthechangein China'sstrategy.AfterDeon ShaoPing's rein,therewas a change in termsofitsmilitary and economy.China's military,changedfrom Communistswarfarestrategytomodern Communist warfare strategy,stressed more on offense,so the new conceptofwar strategy affected the war execution procedure. And in order to secure assets and skills needed for its economic growth, China realized the importanceofChineseresidentabroad.Vietnam'soppression policy,which wasagainsttheChinesepolicy,convincedChinaforitswar. Third reason isthechangein localinternationalorder.In otherwords,Vietnam'saction in breaking away from China and in allyingwith Soviet Union heightened the tension for war.Vietnam's oppression on Chinese residents and Cambodian's military invasion worsened the relationship between China and Vietnam. As the complications occurred, Vietnam moved toward more Soviet-friendly policy.As a result,China decided to wage war when it understood Vietnam-Soviet relations as a threat in China'ssecurity. In conclusion, analyzing China's decision factors before the China-Vietnam War can be used to understand strategy ofpowerfulcountries around China.IfChina's three factors,as mentioned above,areused to analyzeChina'sfuturerise,whetherChinausesitsmilitarypowerforthe sakeofitssurvivalandsecurity. Once again, through out the research on China's war determination factors,we can prospectthatwhich theory remains in the relation with adjacentnationsamongChinathreattheoryandpeacedevelopmenttheory
Abstract
Throughouthistory,wars between emerging powerfulnations and the originaloneshavebroughta changein theinternationalorder.Struggles among European powers such as Espana,Netherlands,England between 16th and18th centuriessupportsitwell.Each countrieshadcompetedfor powerand foughtmany wars.In such perspective,China'srisein power willbethereason forChinatomaintain itsown orderthrough expanding military,whichisthesymbolforpower,andsuch action willfurtheraffect theinternationalorderandEastAsiaregioninnegativeways.Thus,strong power is needed in order to assign China the bigger responsibility and commitment. Moreover, China is expanding its military to prepare for diversifiednew threatsandpossiblewarandtoprofitforitssurvival.Such future China willmore likely to become a majorthreatto its neighbor countriesratherthanacontributiontocommonprosperity. The research has utilized Waltz's three images to analyze China's war decision in caseoftheChina-Vietnam War.In otherwords,threeelements calledindividual,nation,internationalstructureexplainwhyChinadeclared warupon Vietnam atthetime.Therearethreereasonswhich causedthe war:awarenessofChina'sleaderslikeDeungShaoPing in an individual scale, change in China's strategy in a nationalscale, and change in internationalorder First reason is the awareness of China's political leaders. This is differentfrom the Western conceptoffairamong countries.Analyze how china recognized other countries and how this caused China to declare war.ThatistosayChina'spoliticalleaders',includingDeong ShaoPing,historicalawareness ofcolonized Vietnam and geopoliticalawareness of EastAsiagreatlyaffectedChina'sactionforwar. Secondreason isthechangein China'sstrategy.AfterDeon ShaoPing's rein,therewas a change in termsofitsmilitary and economy.China's military,changedfrom Communistswarfarestrategytomodern Communist warfare strategy,stressed more on offense,so the new conceptofwar strategy affected the war execution procedure. And in order to secure assets and skills needed for its economic growth, China realized the importanceofChineseresidentabroad.Vietnam'soppression policy,which wasagainsttheChinesepolicy,convincedChinaforitswar. Third reason isthechangein localinternationalorder.In otherwords,Vietnam'saction in breaking away from China and in allyingwith Soviet Union heightened the tension for war.Vietnam's oppression on Chinese residents and Cambodian's military invasion worsened the relationship between China and Vietnam. As the complications occurred, Vietnam moved toward more Soviet-friendly policy.As a result,China decided to wage war when it understood Vietnam-Soviet relations as a threat in China'ssecurity. In conclusion, analyzing China's decision factors before the China-Vietnam War can be used to understand strategy ofpowerfulcountries around China.IfChina's three factors,as mentioned above,areused to analyzeChina'sfuturerise,whetherChinausesitsmilitarypowerforthe sakeofitssurvivalandsecurity. Once again, through out the research on China's war determination factors,we can prospectthatwhich theory remains in the relation with adjacentnationsamongChinathreattheoryandpeacedevelopmenttheory
참고문헌 (28)
- Alastair Iain Johbston, "Chinese Militarized Interstate Dispute Behavior 1949~1992: A First Cutat the Data", China Quarterly, (153), pp.14~17 (1998)
- Robert J. Lieber, "Theory and World Politics", pp.93~ (1973), George Allen & Unwin Ltd
- Kenneth N. Waltz, "Man, The Stateand War: A TheoreticalAnalysis", pp.16~ (1959), Columbia University Press
- 양승윤, "동남아-중국관계론", pp.161~ (2003), 한국외국어대학교출판부
- "인민일보", ~
- 정천구, "중월전쟁의 원인과 결과", 한국과 국제정치, 2(2), pp.135~136 (1986)
- 가안전기획부, "베트남 현황", pp.31~32 (1997), 국가안전기획부
- 김명섭, "1979년 중국-베트남 전쟁의 원인에 관한 재고찰", 세계지역연구논총, 26(1), pp.153~ (1989)
- 김영문, "모택동 이후의 중국 외교정책", pp.103~ (1989), 대광문화사
- 벤저민, "덩샤오핑 평전", pp.294~296 (2007), 황금가지
- 김홍규, "중국 국방개혁과 군사력 평가, In 2006변환기 국제정세와 한국외교", pp.298~300 (2007), 외교안보연구원
- 황병무, "신중국 군사론" (1995), 법문사
- Marks Bules, "Patterns in China's use of Force: Evidence from History and Doctrinal Writings", pp.26~29 (2000), RAND
- Nan Li, "The PLA's Evolving Warfighting Doctrine, Strategy and Tacktics, 1985~1995: A Chinese Perspective", The China Quarterly, 146 (1995)
- 김옥준, "중국의 대 베트남 징벌 전쟁의 의의:반소전략의 외교탐색전", 사회과학논총, 3(1), pp.103~ (2010)
- 권기수, "베트남전쟁 유발요인 분석", 한국동북아논총, 7(24), pp.219~234 (2002), 한국동북아학회
- Allan C.Ⅲ, Stam, "Win, lose, ordraw: Domestic politics and the crucible of war" (1996), University of Michigan Press
- Dan Reiter, "Democracy, War initiation and victory", American Political Science Review, 92 (1998)
- John J. Mearsheimer, "Conventional deterrence" (1983), Cornell University Press
- Barru R. Posen, "The Sources of Military Doctrine : France, Britain, and Germany Between the World Wars" (1984), Cornell University Press
- "동아일보", ~
- Wang Gungwu, "External Chinaasa New Policy Area", Foreign Affairs, 58(1), pp.28~43 (1985)
- Hemen Ray, "China's Vietnam War", pp.79~80 (1983), Radiant Publish
- 노영순, "20세기 동남아시아의 역사", pp.470~471 (2005), 심산
- 鄭千九, "中共·베트남戰爭의 原因分析", 박사, pp.1981
- "News Week", ~ (1978)
- 신장성, "자국의 주권 및 영토보전과 관련된 핵심 이익 사안", 연합뉴스, ~ (2010)
- "조선일보", ~ (2011)
