본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

베트남공화국 패망의 軍事史的고찰

A StudyontheMilitaryHistoryabouttheRepublicof Vietnam(SouthVietnam)Collapse

0

조회

0

다운로드

3

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류역사학

초록

This study is to analyzeaboutlessons learned from Vietnam'sHistory and collapse of the Republic ofVietnam (South Vietnam). This paper consisted ofthreepartssuch asthehistoryandwaroftheVietnam,the reasonsaboutcollapseoftheSouth Vietnam,and issuesrising from the SocialistRepublicofVietnam.Especially,analysisofthedatawastriedto objectiveanalysisbased on historicalfactsoftheVietnam.Theresultsof thisstudyareasthefollowings. First, history about Vietnam is giving many lessons to the Korean Peninsula. Korea and Vietnam are positioned in the similar geo-politic location.HistoricallessonsaboutVietnam couldbeunderstoodthrough the studyonnationaltitlesofVietnam.Accordingly,itisneededtostudymore deeply on the classification ofdifferences aboutthe South Vietnam,the RepublicofVietnam,theSocialistRepublicofVietnam,Vietminh,and so on,andcontentsrelatednamesofthenationandwars. Second,thereasonsofoccupyingtheSouth Vietnam bythecommunists couldbesummarizedasthefourelementswhich arethecorruption ofher governmentand leaders,theegoism ofherpeoples,theidleand decayof hermilitary forces,and the wrong strategies ofthe United States (US). Thosefourelementsofreasonsmentioned abovesentencewereinteracted and escalated among others.Consequently,the South Vietnam felldown finally even though positive supports from democratic freedom countries suchastheUS,andsoon. Third,theSocialistRepublicofVietnam disregard thePeace Treaty as the wastepaper,occupied South Vietnam,and won in thewars against CambodiaandChina.Nevertheless,militaryvictoryoftheSocialistRepublic ofVietnam hindered hernationaldevelopment,andgavecausesthatthe countryfelldown astheoneofpoorestcountryin theworld.Andso,the Vietnam should havetried changeofhereconomicsystem called DoiMoi policywhichmeansthecapitalsystem. TheColdWarSystem builtaftertheSecondWorldWar,iscloselyrelated with theVietnam War(1955∼1975)and theKorean War(1950∼1953).In thefuture,thewarsintheEastAsiawillbeaffectedmorebythedynamic internationalrelationshipthaninternalproblemsofothertribes. Recently,four superpower countries around the Korean Peninsula are competingamongothersaswellasopposingtheRepublicofKorea(ROK)with North Korea each other.IftheROK leadersand Korean peopleswill begoforward smoothly on thesurging tidesofgeo-politics,theyneed to acceptpreciselythelessonslearnedfrom theVietnam. Especially North Korean leaderswereurged to acceptthemodelofthe Vietnam'sreform andopeningassoonaspossibleafterdeepconsiderations about the lessons learned from the Vietnam which was blocked the nationaldevelopment.

Abstract

This study is to analyzeaboutlessons learned from Vietnam'sHistory and collapse of the Republic ofVietnam (South Vietnam). This paper consisted ofthreepartssuch asthehistoryandwaroftheVietnam,the reasonsaboutcollapseoftheSouth Vietnam,and issuesrising from the SocialistRepublicofVietnam.Especially,analysisofthedatawastriedto objectiveanalysisbased on historicalfactsoftheVietnam.Theresultsof thisstudyareasthefollowings. First, history about Vietnam is giving many lessons to the Korean Peninsula. Korea and Vietnam are positioned in the similar geo-politic location.HistoricallessonsaboutVietnam couldbeunderstoodthrough the studyonnationaltitlesofVietnam.Accordingly,itisneededtostudymore deeply on the classification ofdifferences aboutthe South Vietnam,the RepublicofVietnam,theSocialistRepublicofVietnam,Vietminh,and so on,andcontentsrelatednamesofthenationandwars. Second,thereasonsofoccupyingtheSouth Vietnam bythecommunists couldbesummarizedasthefourelementswhich arethecorruption ofher governmentand leaders,theegoism ofherpeoples,theidleand decayof hermilitary forces,and the wrong strategies ofthe United States (US). Thosefourelementsofreasonsmentioned abovesentencewereinteracted and escalated among others.Consequently,the South Vietnam felldown finally even though positive supports from democratic freedom countries suchastheUS,andsoon. Third,theSocialistRepublicofVietnam disregard thePeace Treaty as the wastepaper,occupied South Vietnam,and won in thewars against CambodiaandChina.Nevertheless,militaryvictoryoftheSocialistRepublic ofVietnam hindered hernationaldevelopment,andgavecausesthatthe countryfelldown astheoneofpoorestcountryin theworld.Andso,the Vietnam should havetried changeofhereconomicsystem called DoiMoi policywhichmeansthecapitalsystem. TheColdWarSystem builtaftertheSecondWorldWar,iscloselyrelated with theVietnam War(1955∼1975)and theKorean War(1950∼1953).In thefuture,thewarsintheEastAsiawillbeaffectedmorebythedynamic internationalrelationshipthaninternalproblemsofothertribes. Recently,four superpower countries around the Korean Peninsula are competingamongothersaswellasopposingtheRepublicofKorea(ROK)with North Korea each other.IftheROK leadersand Korean peopleswill begoforward smoothly on thesurging tidesofgeo-politics,theyneed to acceptpreciselythelessonslearnedfrom theVietnam. Especially North Korean leaderswereurged to acceptthemodelofthe Vietnam'sreform andopeningassoonaspossibleafterdeepconsiderations about the lessons learned from the Vietnam which was blocked the nationaldevelopment.

참고문헌 (17)

  1. 서경석, "월남 패전의 원인과 교훈", 軍史, (43), pp.297~322 (2011)
  2. 이대용, "월남은 이렇게 망했다! : 월남패망(75. 4. 30)29 주년에 즈음하여 패망직전의 월남을 닮은 한국을 생각한다", 한국논단, (174), pp.12~23 (2004)
  3. 김용삼, "월남의 적화과정과 한국 사회의 요즈음 사정", 월간조선, (244), pp.139~147 (2000)
  4. Duiker, William J., "Ho Chi Minh" (2000), Hyperion
  5. 국방부 군사편찬연구소, "6ㆍ25 전쟁사 1; 전쟁의 배경과 원인", pp.547~553 (2004)
  6. 오구라 사다오, "베트남사", pp.158~159 (1999), 일빛
  7. Stoessinger John G., "전쟁의 원인, In 군사참고 5", pp.132~148 (1988), 국방부 전사편찬위원회
  8. Ellsberg, Daniel, "SECRETS : A Memoir Vietnam and the Pentagon Papers", pp.215~225 (2002), Penguin Books
  9. Westmoreland, William C., "A Soldier Report", pp.407~425 (1976), Doubleday & Company, Inc
  10. 최용호, "한 권으로 읽는 베트남전쟁과 한국군" (2004), 국방부 군사편찬연구소
  11. 채명신, "베트남전쟁의 특성과 연합작전" (2002), 국방부 군사편찬연구소
  12. 최용호, "사진으로 본 베트남전쟁과 한국군", pp.224~225 (2010), 도서출판 보라
  13. 박세일, "21세기 한반도 구상", pp.334~335 (2004), 창비
  14. 이대용, "공산화 전 월남과 그 후의 실상", 자유공론, 154(178-179), pp.154~163 (1982), 한국반공연맹
  15. McNamara, Robert S., "In Retrospect: The Tragedy and Lessons of Vietnam", pp.321~323 (1995), Tines Books
  16. 최용호, "물어보세요 베트남전쟁과 한국군" (2004), 국방부 군사편찬연구소

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (9건)