의학전문대학원생의 임상추론 능력 파악을 위한 수정간이구조화관찰법의 효과
The Modified Brief-Structured Observation is Helpful to Understand Students’ Clinical Reasoning Process
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Purpose: The brief-structured observation (BSO) is the teaching method during clerkship. To assess the usefulness of BSO in clerkship, the survey of faculties for reflecting medical students’ reasoning process was assessed. Methods: The modified BSO was introduced to clinical curriculum at Department of Pediatrics, Gyeongsang National University Medical School since 2011. A total of 71 third-year students were divided into 8 groups and conducted for 5 weeks each for a total of 40 weeks (64 BSOs in a year). The questionnaire was admitted to all faculties to assess their view on, satisfaction, and self-conception comparing with other educational methods. And the correlation of scores of BSO, bedside oral test, clinical performance examination and final exams were analyzed. Results: In all, 4 faculties agreed that the modified BSO is more helpful to assess the students’ clinical reasoning compared to other bed-side teaching, 5 faculties agreed that it is useful to evaluate the communication skills, and 6 faculties agreed that it is useful tool for feedback to peers. The question about comparing with the real patient, 5 faculties agreed that it was not bad using student as a standardized patient. There were present mild to moderate correlation between BSO score and Bed side oral test (R=0.268, P=0.02), BSO and clinical performance examination (R=0.525, P<0.001). All faculties thought that BSO is feedback method despite it has several disadvantages. Conclusion: The modified BSO might be a useful tool to assess the students’ clinical communication skills and clinical reasoning and helpful feedback tool for peers.
Abstract
Purpose: The brief-structured observation (BSO) is the teaching method during clerkship. To assess the usefulness of BSO in clerkship, the survey of faculties for reflecting medical students’ reasoning process was assessed. Methods: The modified BSO was introduced to clinical curriculum at Department of Pediatrics, Gyeongsang National University Medical School since 2011. A total of 71 third-year students were divided into 8 groups and conducted for 5 weeks each for a total of 40 weeks (64 BSOs in a year). The questionnaire was admitted to all faculties to assess their view on, satisfaction, and self-conception comparing with other educational methods. And the correlation of scores of BSO, bedside oral test, clinical performance examination and final exams were analyzed. Results: In all, 4 faculties agreed that the modified BSO is more helpful to assess the students’ clinical reasoning compared to other bed-side teaching, 5 faculties agreed that it is useful to evaluate the communication skills, and 6 faculties agreed that it is useful tool for feedback to peers. The question about comparing with the real patient, 5 faculties agreed that it was not bad using student as a standardized patient. There were present mild to moderate correlation between BSO score and Bed side oral test (R=0.268, P=0.02), BSO and clinical performance examination (R=0.525, P<0.001). All faculties thought that BSO is feedback method despite it has several disadvantages. Conclusion: The modified BSO might be a useful tool to assess the students’ clinical communication skills and clinical reasoning and helpful feedback tool for peers.
참고문헌 (11)
- 허선, "의과대학생의 대인관계와 의사소통술을 어떻게 향상시킬 수 있을까?", Korean Journal of Medical Education, 25(4), pp.261~263 (2013), 한국의학교육학회
- No YG, "The current situation of medical communication skills’ education", Paper presented at:Korean Academy on Communication in Healthcare, Spring Conference (2009)
- 이영미, "의대생을 위한 환자-의사 커뮤니케이션 모델 개발", Korean Journal of Medical Education, 22(3), pp.185~195 (2010), 한국의학교육학회
- Pituch K, "The brief structured observation – a tool for focused feedback", Academic Medicine, 74, pp.599~ (1999)
- Jennings ML, "Medical student burnout: interdisciplinary exploration and analysis", J Med Humanit, 30, pp.253~269 (2009)
- Rush P, "Brief structured observation of medical student hospital visits", Education for health, 26(3), pp.188~191 (2015)
- 임호섭, "역할극 강화를 통한 의학과 학생들의 의사소통 교육효과", 고신대학교 의과대학 학술지, 27(2), pp.151~159 (2012), 고신대학교 의과대학 학술지[DOI]
- Lee JY, "The interview skills observed in medical interview of third-year medical students", J Korean Acad Fam Med, 21, pp.471~478 (2000)
- Kolb DA, "Theories of Group Process" (1975), John Wiley & Fry
- Gordon K, "The one minute preceptor: fiver microskills for clinical teaching", ~
- Onishi H, "The role of case presentation for teaching and learning activities", Kaohsiung J Med Sci, 24, pp.356~360 (2008)
