셰익스피어 『맥베스』의 영상화: 폴란스키의 각색과 변용
Screening of Shakespeare’s Macbeth: Polanski’s Adaptation and Transformation
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper examines how Roman Polanski’s adaptation and transformation of Shakespeare’s Macbeth are carried out and aims to consider the implications of his interpretation transmitted to the audience. In Shakespeare’s play, many violent parts of the text are verbalized and not acted out on stage. But Polanski’s movie version shows scenes of brutality implied in the text with graphic violence. With regard to technical style, some asides and soliloquies are changed into inner monologues for the sake of psychological realism. He also changes the role of Ross, who is a relatively insignificant character in the play, and makes him an amoral, opportunistic person. The most significant difference between the original play and its adaptation by Polanski lies in the ending. The ending of Shakespeare’s tragedy leaves the audience with a positive feeling and indicates the restoration of legitimate order and political stability for Scotland’s future after Macbeth’s tyranny. However, Polanski defies this traditional interpretation of the original play. The conception of his movie is to dramatize at its heart not the reestablishment of order but unending power struggles. For this purpose he inserts the scene of a visit to the witches’ den by Donalbain. Through this epilogue Polanski demonstrates the idea that the role of evil is persistent and will never end. This scene completely undercuts the hopeful words uttered by Macduff that “the time is free.” Polanski’s version suggests that greed and violence may be a vicious, never-ending cycle. Thus, the ending of Polanski’s Macbeth leaves the audience with the sense of continued political unrest in Scotland. In conclusion, Polanski’s modern interpretation of Shakespeare’s Macbeth questions human nature and destiny, showing his pessimistic view of the modern world.
Abstract
This paper examines how Roman Polanski’s adaptation and transformation of Shakespeare’s Macbeth are carried out and aims to consider the implications of his interpretation transmitted to the audience. In Shakespeare’s play, many violent parts of the text are verbalized and not acted out on stage. But Polanski’s movie version shows scenes of brutality implied in the text with graphic violence. With regard to technical style, some asides and soliloquies are changed into inner monologues for the sake of psychological realism. He also changes the role of Ross, who is a relatively insignificant character in the play, and makes him an amoral, opportunistic person. The most significant difference between the original play and its adaptation by Polanski lies in the ending. The ending of Shakespeare’s tragedy leaves the audience with a positive feeling and indicates the restoration of legitimate order and political stability for Scotland’s future after Macbeth’s tyranny. However, Polanski defies this traditional interpretation of the original play. The conception of his movie is to dramatize at its heart not the reestablishment of order but unending power struggles. For this purpose he inserts the scene of a visit to the witches’ den by Donalbain. Through this epilogue Polanski demonstrates the idea that the role of evil is persistent and will never end. This scene completely undercuts the hopeful words uttered by Macduff that “the time is free.” Polanski’s version suggests that greed and violence may be a vicious, never-ending cycle. Thus, the ending of Polanski’s Macbeth leaves the audience with the sense of continued political unrest in Scotland. In conclusion, Polanski’s modern interpretation of Shakespeare’s Macbeth questions human nature and destiny, showing his pessimistic view of the modern world.
참고문헌 (17)
- Berlin, Norman, "Macbeth: Polanski and Shakespeare", Literature, 1973, pp.1(4), 291~298
- Buhler, Stephen M., "Shakespeare in the Cinema: Ocular Proof" (2002), State U of New York P
- Crowl, Samuel, "Shakespeare Observed : Studies in Performance on Stage and Screen" (1992), Ohio UP
- Dubois, Larry, "Playboy Interview: Roman Polanski", Playboy, 18(12), pp.93~118 (1951)
- Harper, Wendy Rogers, "Polanski vs. Wells on Macbeth: Character or Fate?", Literature, 1986, pp.14(4), 203~210
- Hatchuel, Sarah, "Prithee, See There! Behold! Look’ (3.4.69): The Gift or the Denial of Sight in Screen Adaptations of Shakespeare’s Macbeth", Borrowers and Lenders: The Journal of Shakespeare and Appropriation, 1(2), pp.1~26 (2005)
- Hindle, Maurice, "Shakespeare on Film" (2015), Palgrave
- Hutcheon, Linda, "A Theory of Adaptation" (2006), Routledge
- Jorgens, Jack J., "Shakespeare on Film" (1977), Indiana UP
- Kael, Pauline, "Conversations with Pauline Kael" (1996), UP of Mississippi
- Leaming, Barbara, "Polanski, a Biography: The Filmmaker as Voyeur" (1981), Simon and Schuster
- Pearlman, E., "Shakespeare and the Moving Image: the Plays on Film and Television", pp.250~260 (1994), Cambridge UP
- Polanski, Roman, "The Tragedy of Macbeth" (1971), Playboy Productions
- Polanski, Roman, (1984), Heinemann
- Rothwell, Kenneth S., "Roman Polanski’s Macbeth: Gogotha Triumphant", Literature, 1973, pp.1(1), 71~75
- Shakespeare, William, "Macbeth" (1962), Methuen
- Wexman, Virginia Wright, "Roman Polanski" (1985), G. K. Hall
