공공정책의 정치적 채택에 영향을 미치는 요인에 관한 연구- 세종시 수정안을 중심으로 -
A Study on the Political Adoptability of Public Policy -The Case of the Amended Sejong City Act-
0
조회
0
다운로드
7
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The Purpose of this study is to examine some factors that influence on the political adoption of the Amended Sejong City Act(ASCA). This study is based on the analytic framework composed of several theories, veto player model, theory of political rationality, and theory of voting behavior in the legislature. The analysis of this study, first of all, shows that the political adoption of controversial policy like the ASCA was affected by the number of veto players. The ASCA couldn't be adopted in political area, because two veto players, the President and the National Assembly, were in conflict with each other over political position and policy value. Second, The ASCA was lack of the political rationality in both the procedural and the substantial aspects. The government paid no attention to serious meeting with the ruling party, to mutual communication to the nation ahead of policy-making. Also, the government put an excessive emphasis on the efficiency and the crisis management instead of balanced development and trust building. Finally, the ASCA failed to get the public acceptance. Many member of the National Assembly couldn't vote for the ASCA which the electorate had opposed strongly.
Abstract
The Purpose of this study is to examine some factors that influence on the political adoption of the Amended Sejong City Act(ASCA). This study is based on the analytic framework composed of several theories, veto player model, theory of political rationality, and theory of voting behavior in the legislature. The analysis of this study, first of all, shows that the political adoption of controversial policy like the ASCA was affected by the number of veto players. The ASCA couldn't be adopted in political area, because two veto players, the President and the National Assembly, were in conflict with each other over political position and policy value. Second, The ASCA was lack of the political rationality in both the procedural and the substantial aspects. The government paid no attention to serious meeting with the ruling party, to mutual communication to the nation ahead of policy-making. Also, the government put an excessive emphasis on the efficiency and the crisis management instead of balanced development and trust building. Finally, the ASCA failed to get the public acceptance. Many member of the National Assembly couldn't vote for the ASCA which the electorate had opposed strongly.
참고문헌 (53)
- 김렬, "환경정책결정과정에서의 정치적 합리성: 주민참여행태와 정부 대응방식을 중심으로", 한국행정학보, 30(4), pp.4091~4104 (1996)
- 김동욱, "정부분할과 지역균형발전", 한국정책학회 특별기획세미나 자료집 (2010)
- 김항규, "정책결정과정에서의 정치적 합리성 확보방안 연구", 한국행정학보, 29(3), pp.681~698 (1995)
- 류동길, "행정도시 어떻게 할 것인가", 한국선진화포럼 토론회 자료집 (2009)
- 박명호, "세종시(市) 수정 논란의 진행 과정에서 나타난 대통령제의 특성에 관한 시론(試論)", 사회과학연구, 17(2), pp.95~111 (2010), 사회과학연구원
- 박치형, "미국 메트로폴리탄 도시의 주택특성이 개발영향부담금 정책채택에 미치는 영향", 지방행정연구, 22(4), pp.133~163 (2008), 한국지방행정연구원
- 박현숙, "의회와 외교정책: 국회의원의 정치적 이념구조와 표결행태 분석", 시민정치학회보, 6, pp.167~183 (2003)
- 신황용, "세종시 건설을 둘러싼 정책과 논쟁의 평가에 관한 연구", 정책분석평가학회보, 21(1), pp.101~130 (2011), 한국정책분석평가학회
- 안병철, "조직개편의 정치적 합리성과 어그러짐", 한국정책과학학회보, 7(1), pp.105~123 (2003), 한국정책과학학회
- 이달곤, "협상론 -협상의 과정, 구조, 그리고 전략" (1996), 서울: 법문사
- 이상봉, "정책의 경제적 합리성과 정체적 합리성-개정(1998.12.31)국민연금 사례를 중심으로", 정부학연구, 10(2), pp.213~253 (2004), 정부학연구소
- 전영평, "국정운영 측면에서 본 세종시 ‘정부 분할 이전’의 문제점", 한국행정학회 기획세미나 발표논문 (2009)
- 전진영, "국회의원의 갈등적 투표행태 분석: 제16대 국회 전자표결을 중심으로", 한국정치학회보, 40(1), pp.47~70 (2006), 한국정치학회
- 정정길, "정책학원론" (1989), 서울: 대명출판사
- 정주철, "신제도주의 모델을 이용한 재난완화 정책 채택의 요인에 대한 분석", 지역연구, 22(2), pp.199~224 (2006), 한국지역학회
- 최준영, "미 하원의원들의 투표행태에 관한 연구: 정치적 개인성(Political Individuality)을 중심으로", 한국정치학회보, 38(2), pp.515~536 (2004), 한국정치학회
- 하혜수, "세종시 수정안의 성립불가성: 논거와 해법", 한국정책학회 기획세미나 발표논문 (2010)
- 하혜수, "지방정부간 분쟁조정과정에 관한 협상론적 분석", 한국행정학보, 37(1), pp.205~224 (2003), 한국행정학회
- 한국행정연구원, "중앙행정기관 분산이전에 따른 행정효율성 분석", 한국행정연구원․한국행정학회 공동기획세미나 발표자료집 (2009)
- 경향신문, "“세종시, 원안 34% vs. 수정안 34% … 여론도 팽팽,” 3.2", 경향신문, ~ (2010)
- 경향신문, "‘수정안 찬성’ 다소 우세 … 충청 ‘원안 찬성’ 압도적", ~ (2010)
- 뉴스웨이, "“당정, 세종시법 제출시기 ‘고심’", ~ (2010)
- 동아일보, "얽히고설킨 ‘세종시 민심", ~ (2010)
- 연합뉴스, "정부, 세종시 대안은 다기능 자족도시", ~ (2009)
- 연합뉴스, "한 ‘세종시TF’ 구성..당정협의 착수", ~ (2009)
- 연합뉴스, "정총리 취임에서 사퇴까지 10개월", 연합뉴스, ~ (2010)
- 조선일보, "여, 세종시 재추진으로 충청 민심 달래기 나서", 조선일보, ~ (2009)
- 조선일보, "수정안, 국회통과 안되면 세종시, 결국 다시 원안으로", 조선일보, A3~ (2010)
- 중앙일보, "105 : 164 : 6 … 세종시 수정안 본회의 부결", 중앙일보, ~ (2010)
- 폴리뉴스, "세종시 ‘원안 35.1%>수정안 32.1%’ 역전", 폴리뉴스, ~ (2010)
- 한겨레, "'교통혼잡․환경개선비용 연 28조’ 수도권 과밀화, 경쟁력 약화 주범", 한겨레, ~ (2009)
- , 2005
- Anderson, James E, "Public Policy Making(5 Edition)" (2010), Boston: Wadsworth
- Beeson, Mark, "Neoliberalism as a Political Rationality: Australian Public Policy Since the 1980s", Journal of Sociology, 34(3), pp.215~231 (1998)
- Bütler, Monika, "The Political Feasibility of Increasing the Retirement Age", International Tax and Public Finance, 9(4), pp.349~365 (2002)
- Diesing, Paul, "Reason in Society: Five Types of Decision and Their Social Conditions" (1962), University of Illinois Press
- Felder, Stetan, "Environment Tax Reform: Efficiency and Political Feasibility", Ecological Economics, 42(1), pp.107~116 (2002)
- Ganghof, Stefen, "Promises and Pitfalls of Veto Player Analysis", Swiss Political Science Review, 9(2), pp.1~25 (2003)
- Gärling, Tommy, "Travel Demand Management Targeting Reduced Private Car Use: Effectireness, Public Acceptability and Political Feasibility", Journal of Social Issues, 63(1), pp.139~153 (2007)
- Hager, Gregory L, "Look for the Party Label: Party Influences on Voting in the U.S. House", Legislative Studies Quarterly, 25, pp.75~99 (2000)
- Janvry, Alain de, "The Political Feasibility of Rural Poverty Reduction", Journal of Development Economics, 37(1), pp.351~367 (1991)
- Majone, G, "On the Notion of Political Feasibility", European Journal of Political Research, 3, pp.259~274 (1975)
- Institutions and Reform Policy: Three Case Studies on the Veto Players Theory, "Merker, Wolfgang", Estudio, 2003
- Miller, P, "Governing Economic Life", Economy and Society, 19(1), pp.1~31 (1990)
- Nye Jr., "Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics" (2005), New York: Public Affairs
- Nye, Mary Alice, "Conservative Coalition Support in the House of Representatives, 1963-1988", Legislative Studies Quarterly, 18, pp.255~270 (1993)
- Roller, Edeltraud, "Conceptualizing and Measuring Institutions of Democratic Governance", Prepared for Presentation at the ECPR Joint Sessions of Workshops (2003)
- Schneider, Jerome, "Ideological Coalition in Congress" (1979), Westpot, CT: Greenwood Press
- Snyder, James M., Jr, "Estimating Party Influences in Congressional Roll Call Votes", American Journal of Political Science, 44, pp.193~211 (2000)
- Eric C.C. Chang, "Veto players and the structure of budgets in advanced industrialized countries", European Journal of Political Research, 43(3), pp.449~476, Blackwell Publishing Inc.
- Tsebelis, George, "Veto Players and Law Production in Parliamentary Democracies", American Political Science Review, pp.84~111 (1999)
- Uebelmesser, Silke, "Political Feasibility of Pension Reforms", Topics in Economic Analysis & Policy, 4(1), pp.20~ (2004)
- Wildavsky, A, "Budgeting: A Comparative Theory of Budgetary Processes" (1975), Boston: Little, Brown & Company