The Dramatization of Habitus: A Bourdieun Reading of Pygmalion
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Based on the Greek myth of Pygmalion and the fairy tale of Cinderella, Shaw’s Pygmalion demonstrates a masterful coalescence of these two narrative motifs into a coherent plot scheme. Even more significant is his keen insight into the conflicts created at the tripartite intersection of human activity concerning language/class/culture, which, as the leitmotif, revolves around lessons in language learning. This play basically deals with human transformation and by its very nature, Higgins’s experimentation with transforming Eliza cannot stop at language alone. Her cultural transformation ripples over into the realms of gesture and even a unique way of living (modus vivendi) intimately associated with taste and manners, which Bourdieu terms as habitus. By acquiring a new fashion and language, Eliza is reborn as a new lady aspiring to be filled with a newly acquired habitus. While separating her from her old Cockney style, Higgins inculcates Queen’s English in Eliza, in which process her changed speech styles gradually transforms and restructures her deportment and manners, finally generating new practices, perceptions and attitudes. The gist of Pygmalion is however less Eliza’s ascent into the middle class than her battle for symbolic capital waged at the level of language. By problematizing his contemporary practice of habitus conventionalized and warped by class distinctions based on economic, social and cultural capitals, Shaw creates a new humanist model of man founded on spiritual and rational virtues. In conclusion, Eliza is not a frigid Galatea but a dynamic character that goes through a brilliant transformation of three stages: 1) linguistic; 2) cultural, and 3) humanist. Finally she is built into a “consort battleship” on an equal standing with her sculptor. The process of her character- building cannot be illuminated without resorting to the dynamic notion of habitus, which highlights the process of inculcation, structuring, generation and transposing. Given the overwhelming weight of the heroine’s role and the dynamic process of her transformation as the major plot scheme, this play should be christened Galatea in lieu of Pygmalion.
Abstract
Based on the Greek myth of Pygmalion and the fairy tale of Cinderella, Shaw’s Pygmalion demonstrates a masterful coalescence of these two narrative motifs into a coherent plot scheme. Even more significant is his keen insight into the conflicts created at the tripartite intersection of human activity concerning language/class/culture, which, as the leitmotif, revolves around lessons in language learning. This play basically deals with human transformation and by its very nature, Higgins’s experimentation with transforming Eliza cannot stop at language alone. Her cultural transformation ripples over into the realms of gesture and even a unique way of living (modus vivendi) intimately associated with taste and manners, which Bourdieu terms as habitus. By acquiring a new fashion and language, Eliza is reborn as a new lady aspiring to be filled with a newly acquired habitus. While separating her from her old Cockney style, Higgins inculcates Queen’s English in Eliza, in which process her changed speech styles gradually transforms and restructures her deportment and manners, finally generating new practices, perceptions and attitudes. The gist of Pygmalion is however less Eliza’s ascent into the middle class than her battle for symbolic capital waged at the level of language. By problematizing his contemporary practice of habitus conventionalized and warped by class distinctions based on economic, social and cultural capitals, Shaw creates a new humanist model of man founded on spiritual and rational virtues. In conclusion, Eliza is not a frigid Galatea but a dynamic character that goes through a brilliant transformation of three stages: 1) linguistic; 2) cultural, and 3) humanist. Finally she is built into a “consort battleship” on an equal standing with her sculptor. The process of her character- building cannot be illuminated without resorting to the dynamic notion of habitus, which highlights the process of inculcation, structuring, generation and transposing. Given the overwhelming weight of the heroine’s role and the dynamic process of her transformation as the major plot scheme, this play should be christened Galatea in lieu of Pygmalion.
참고문헌 (23)
- Aubrey, James R., "Race and the spectacle of the monstrous in ‘Othello", CLIO, 22, pp.221~223 (1993)
- Bailey, Amanda, "“Monstrous manner”: style and the early modern theater", Criticism, 43, pp.249~284 (2001)
- Berst, Charles A., "Pygmalion; Shaw’s Spin on Myth & Cinderella" (1995), Twayne Pubs
- Bourdieu, Pierre, "Distinctions: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste" (1984), Harvard UP
- Bourdieu, Pierre, "The Forms of capital in: Handbook of Theory and Research for the Sociology of Education" (1986), Greenwood Press
- Bourdieu, Pierre, "The Logic of Practice" (1990), Polity Press,
- Bourdieu, Pierre, "Language and Symbolic Power" (1991), Harvard UP
- Dukore, Bernard F., "The Director as Interpreter: Shaw’s Pygmalion in: Shaw’s Plays in Performance" (1983), Penn State UP
- Grene, Nicholas, "Bernard Shaw: A Critical View" (1984), St. Martin’s Press
- Harvey, Charles, "Morris - art and idealism (Victorian Values)", History Today, 46, pp.15~21 (1996)
- Harvey, Robert C., "How Shavian is the ‘Pygmalion’ We Teach", The English Journal, 59, pp.1234~1238 (1970)
- Hedrick, ‘Donald’, "The Bard of Enron: from Shakespeare to noir humanism", College Literature, 31, pp.19~43 (2004)
- Hornby, Richard, "Beyond the Verbal in Pygmalion in: Shaw’s Plays in Performance", pp.121~127 (1983), Penn State UP
- Kent, Assunta Bartolomucci, "Maria Irene Fornes and Her Critics" (1996), Greenwood Press
- Levine, Susan S., "On the Mirror Stage with Henry or Play-ing with Pygmalion in Five Acts", Journal of Applied Psychoanalytic Studies, 3, pp.103~125 (2001)
- McAllister, Patrick, "Domestic Space, Habitus, and Xhosa Ritual Beer-Drinking (1)", Ethnology, 43, pp.117~136 (2004)
- MacArthur, Tom, "COCKNEY in: Concise Oxford Companion to the English Language" (1992), Oxford UP
- Mugglestone, Lynda, "Shaw, Subjective Inequality, and the Social Meanings of Language in Pygmalion", Review of English Studies, 44, pp.371~385 (1993)
- Reynolds, Jean, "Pygmalion’s Wordplay; The Postmodern Shaw" (1999), U of Florida P
- Rubidge, Bradley, "The Code of Reciprocation in Corneille’s Heroic Drama", The Romantic Review, 89, pp.55~76 (1998)
- Schwartz. David, "Culture & Power: The Sociology of Pierre Bourdieu" (1997), Chicago UP
- Shaw, G. Bernard, "Shaw and Ibsen: Bernard Shaw’s The Quintessence of Ibsenism, and Related Writings" (1979), U of Toronto P
- Solomon, Stanley J., "The Ending of ‘Pygmalion’: A Structural View", Educational Theatre Journal, 16, pp.59~63 (1963)