Jonathan Swift’s A Tale of a Tub: Carnivalization and Boundaries of Genre
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The ongoing attempt to classify and categorize Jonathan Swift’s literary work, A Tale of a Tub, as either satire or parody has not only opened issues concerning authorial intent and a present voice but also surfaced questions as to whether Swift identifies with what he is criticizing, thereby becoming the subject he schemes to destroy in his own literary work. In addressing these critical problems, my paper questions the boundaries of genre and analyzes the Tale, not within the conventional terms of literary genre, but by applying Bakhtin’s theory of the carnivalistic impulse to Swift’s Tale. Rather than focus on finding the author or identifying a voice within the text, Bakhtin’s literary vision of carnivalization allows a means of subverting all rules yet holding the work together to present a shocking experience for the reader. Within the Tale, carnivalistic participation includes the reader who at one point is given the detached position of subjective spectator yet eventually decrowns the reader as both a carnivalistic participant and object of the same ridicule and derision once used to judge others. In conclusion, the Tale is revealed as a mocking commentary on the efforts of human beings/participants/writers to ignore the carnival aspects of existence and attempt to elevate themselves to the privileged role of spectator/reader.
Abstract
The ongoing attempt to classify and categorize Jonathan Swift’s literary work, A Tale of a Tub, as either satire or parody has not only opened issues concerning authorial intent and a present voice but also surfaced questions as to whether Swift identifies with what he is criticizing, thereby becoming the subject he schemes to destroy in his own literary work. In addressing these critical problems, my paper questions the boundaries of genre and analyzes the Tale, not within the conventional terms of literary genre, but by applying Bakhtin’s theory of the carnivalistic impulse to Swift’s Tale. Rather than focus on finding the author or identifying a voice within the text, Bakhtin’s literary vision of carnivalization allows a means of subverting all rules yet holding the work together to present a shocking experience for the reader. Within the Tale, carnivalistic participation includes the reader who at one point is given the detached position of subjective spectator yet eventually decrowns the reader as both a carnivalistic participant and object of the same ridicule and derision once used to judge others. In conclusion, the Tale is revealed as a mocking commentary on the efforts of human beings/participants/writers to ignore the carnival aspects of existence and attempt to elevate themselves to the privileged role of spectator/reader.
참고문헌 (18)
- Arion, Ian, "Essays on Literature" (2007), Dionysus Delphinus
- Bakhtin, Mikhail, "Characteristics of Genre and Plot Composition in Dostoevsky’s Works in: Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics: Theory and History of Literature. Vol. 8.", pp.101~180 (1984), U of Minnesota P
- Clark, John R., "Form and Frenzy in Swift’s “Tale of a Tub.”" (1970), Cornell UP
- Devine, Michael. G., "Disputing the ‘Original’ in Swift’s Tale of a Tub", Swift Studies: The Annual of the Ehrenpreis Center, 18, pp.26~33 (2003)
- Forster, Jean-Paul, "Swift and Wotton: The Unintended Mousetrap", Swift Studies: The Annual of the Ehrenpreis Center, 7, pp.23~35 (1992)
- Griffin, Dustin, "tire: A Critical Reintroduction" (1994), UP of Kentucky
- Kelly, Ann Cline, "Swift and the English Language" (1989), U Penn P
- Leavis, F. R., "The Irony of Swift", Scrutiny, II, pp.361~373 (1934)
- Mueller, Judith C., "A Tale of a Tub and early prose in: The Cambridge Companion to Jonathan Swift", pp.202~215 (2003), Cambridge UP
- Phiddian, Robert, "Swift’s Parody: Cambridge Studies in Eighteenth-Century English Literature and Thought" (1995), Cambridge UP
- Said, Edward W., "Swift as Intellectual in: The World, the Text, and the Critic", pp.72~89 (1983), Harvard UP
- Suarez, Michael F., "Swift’s satire and parody in: The Cambridge Companion to Jonathan Swift", pp.112~127 (2003), Cambridge UP
- Swift, Jonathan, "A Tale of a Tub in: The Writings of Jonathan Swift" (1973), Norton
- Traugott, John, "A Tale of a Tub in: The Character of Swift’s Satire: A Revised Focus", pp.83~126 (1983), U of Delaware P
- Walsh, Marcus, "Text, ‘Text,’ and Swift’s A Tale of a Tub in: Modern Language Review 85(1990) in: Jonathan Swift: Longman Critical Readers" (1999), Addison Wesley Longman Inc.
- Wotton, William, "Observations upon the Tale of a Tub in: A Defense of the Reflections upon Ancient and Modern Learning. In Answer to the Objections of Sir W, Temple, and Others. With Observations upon the Tale of a Tub in: The Writings of Jonathan Swift", pp.592~598 (1973), Norton
- Young, Heather, "Satire as a Virus: Generic Inhabitation and Transformation in Swift’s Tale", Swift Studies: The Annual of the Ehrenpreis Center, 12, pp.48~55 (2006)
- Zimmerman, Everett, "Swift’s Narrative Satires: Author and Authority" (1983), Cornell UP