The Crisis of British Imperialism in Southeast Asia: The (Mis)Representation of the Indigenous in Clifford and Conrad
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In the late nineteenth century, British colonial activities became aggressive and annexationist in the tropics, including the Southeast Asian Archipelago, which reflected the historical circumstances of both increasing resistance from the indigenous and severe competition among European powers. Interestingly, the change in English colonial policy toward an annexationist or imperialist vision adopted the motto of a civilizing mission, which was founded on the anthropological assumption that the white English were civilized, while the non-white indigenous were savage. The assumption developed into colonial discourse through systematic gathering of anthropological knowledge about the peripheries of the Empire. The knowledge system was flawed, which stressed the differences of the peripheral populations from the English and served as an inverted discourse on the Imperial Self rather than the description of the Other. Furthermore, the natives were heterogeneous, which rendered indistinct the racial and cultural differences between the English and the natives. Still, the aboriginals called Malays, who were comprised of many ethnic subgroups, needed to be deemed savage or inferior by the English in order to justify the English civilizing work or imperial ambition. Put differently,the representation of the English as civilized necessitated the (mis)representation of the natives as savage. In this context, Clifford’s works contribute to systematic misrepresentation of the Malays, on which colonial discourse is founded, though not without self-contradiction. On the other hand, Conrad’s novels that are set in the Malay Archipelago resort to a strategic misrepresentation that reveals the relativity of the discourse. Exploring the dilemma of denationalization to various degrees, Conrad’s Malay texts problematize the (mis)representation of the indigenous as inferior, which is the basis of English claim to superiority.
Abstract
In the late nineteenth century, British colonial activities became aggressive and annexationist in the tropics, including the Southeast Asian Archipelago, which reflected the historical circumstances of both increasing resistance from the indigenous and severe competition among European powers. Interestingly, the change in English colonial policy toward an annexationist or imperialist vision adopted the motto of a civilizing mission, which was founded on the anthropological assumption that the white English were civilized, while the non-white indigenous were savage. The assumption developed into colonial discourse through systematic gathering of anthropological knowledge about the peripheries of the Empire. The knowledge system was flawed, which stressed the differences of the peripheral populations from the English and served as an inverted discourse on the Imperial Self rather than the description of the Other. Furthermore, the natives were heterogeneous, which rendered indistinct the racial and cultural differences between the English and the natives. Still, the aboriginals called Malays, who were comprised of many ethnic subgroups, needed to be deemed savage or inferior by the English in order to justify the English civilizing work or imperial ambition. Put differently,the representation of the English as civilized necessitated the (mis)representation of the natives as savage. In this context, Clifford’s works contribute to systematic misrepresentation of the Malays, on which colonial discourse is founded, though not without self-contradiction. On the other hand, Conrad’s novels that are set in the Malay Archipelago resort to a strategic misrepresentation that reveals the relativity of the discourse. Exploring the dilemma of denationalization to various degrees, Conrad’s Malay texts problematize the (mis)representation of the indigenous as inferior, which is the basis of English claim to superiority.
참고문헌 (27)
- Brantlinger. Patrick, "Rule of Darkness: British Literature and Imperialism,1830-1914" (1988), Cornell UP
- Bridges, Roy, "Exploration and Travel Outside Europe (1720-1914), In The Cambridge Companion to Travel Writing", pp.53~69 (2002), Cambridge UP
- Chamberlain, Joseph, "The True Conception of Empire, In Empire Writing: An Anthology of Colonial Literature 1870-1918", pp.212~215 (1998), Oxford UP
- Clifford, Hugh Charles, "In Court and Kampong" (2010), General Books
- Clifford, Hugh Charles, "Since the Beginning, In A Tale of an Eastern Land" (2009), General Books
- Clifford, Hugh Charles, "Studies in Brown Humanity, Being Scrawls and Smudges in Sepia, White, and Yellow" (1898), G. Richards
- Clifford, Hugh Charles, "Salley, A Study, and Other Tales of the Outskirts" (2010), General Books
- Clifford, Hugh Charles, "Saleh: A Sequel" (1908), Blackwood & Sons
- Clifford, James, "Introduction: Partial Truths, In Writing Culture: the Poetics and Politics of Ethnography", pp.1~27 (1986), U of California P
- Conrad, Joseph, "Almayer’ Folly" (2008), Wilder Publications
- Conrad, Joseph, "Lord Jim" (1968), Norton
- Conrad, Joseph, "An Outcast of the Islands" (1992), Oxford UP
- Conrad, Joseph, "The Rescue : A Romance of the Shallows" (1968), Norton
- Conrad, Joseph, "Youth: A Narrative, In Youth, Heart of Darkness, The End of the Tether", pp.9~43 (1995), Penguin Books
- Crane, Ralph, "Flora Annie Steel in the Punjab, In Writing, Travel and Empire: In the Margins of Anthropology" (2007), I. B. Tauris
- GoGwilt, Christopher, "The Invention of the West: Joseph Conrad and the Double-Mapping of Europe and Empire" (1995), Stanford UP
- Hampson, Robert, "Cross-Cultural Encounters in Joseph Conrad’ Malay Fiction" (2000), Palgrave
- Hampson, Robert, "“Hugh Clifford in Malaya.”Writing, Travel and Empire", 147~166
- Hay, Eloise Knapp, "The Political Novels of Joseph Conrad: A Critical Study" (1963), U of Chicago P
- Colonial Texts: Hugh Clifford & the Discipline of English Literature in the Straits Settlements & Malaya 1895-1907, "Modern Subjects", pp.2000, Holden, Philip
- Kuklick, Henrika, "The Savage Within : The Social History of British Anthropology, 1885-1945" (1991), Cambridge UP
- Pratt, Mary Louis, "Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation" (1992), Routledge
- Ruskin, John, "Conclusion to Inaugural Lecture, in Empire Writing", 16~20 (1870)
- Sherry, Norman, "Conrad’ Eastern World" (1966), Cambridge UP
- Spurr, David, "The Rhetoric of Empire: Colonial Discourse in Journalism, Travel Writing, and Imperial Administration" (1993), Duke UP
- Thomas, Nicholas, "Colonialism’ Culture: Anthropology, Travel and Government" (1994), Polity Press
- "The Perak War, in A History of the Malay Peninsula"[URL]