『잘자 데스데모나(잘잤니 줄리엣)』: 여교수 콘스탄스의 자아, 저자 및 어릿광대 찾기에 대한 비판적 고찰
Goodnight Desdemona(Good Morning Juliet): A Critical Study on Constance's Search for the Self, the Author, and the Fool through the Journey of the Unconscious
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This paper probes into some significant problems inherent in the protagonist’s search for the Self, the Author, and the Fool in Ann-Marie MacDonald’s Goodnight Desdemona(Good Morning Juliet). Most critics don’t object that Constance Ledbelly is successful in her self-discovery. This paper will try to prove that there are some problems regarding the accomplishment of Constance’s three missions and that these problems make MacDonald’s objective to criticize scathingly the patriarchal Canadian academia less effective. As for the search for the Self, Constance succeeds in correcting and accepting belligerent Desdemona and lustful Juliet who represent her two repressed archetypes in the unconscious. However, she fails to overcome the tragic affair with Professor Claude Night and to realize clearly her own sexual identity. As for the search for the Author, Constance realizes that she is the Author of the inner play－in fact, MacDonald’s comic adaptation of Shakespearean tragedies, Othello and Romeo and Juliet. But the coexistence of the comical characters and the dangerous ones in the inner play makes her search for the Author problematic because it is contradictory to her conviction that the sources of the two Shakespearean tragedies are comedies. As for the search for the Fool, she grows conscious that she is the Fool of the inner play by preventing the catastrophes and making serious situations comical. However, the comical atmosphere made by Constance can be at any time transformed into the tragic one because of villainous Iago and hot-tempered Tybalt. In conclusion, Ann-Marie MacDonald succeeds in twisting the two Shakespearean tragedies comically, but fails to criticize severely the authoritative male-centered Canadian academia by making the protagonist's three missions problematic.
Abstract
This paper probes into some significant problems inherent in the protagonist’s search for the Self, the Author, and the Fool in Ann-Marie MacDonald’s Goodnight Desdemona(Good Morning Juliet). Most critics don’t object that Constance Ledbelly is successful in her self-discovery. This paper will try to prove that there are some problems regarding the accomplishment of Constance’s three missions and that these problems make MacDonald’s objective to criticize scathingly the patriarchal Canadian academia less effective. As for the search for the Self, Constance succeeds in correcting and accepting belligerent Desdemona and lustful Juliet who represent her two repressed archetypes in the unconscious. However, she fails to overcome the tragic affair with Professor Claude Night and to realize clearly her own sexual identity. As for the search for the Author, Constance realizes that she is the Author of the inner play－in fact, MacDonald’s comic adaptation of Shakespearean tragedies, Othello and Romeo and Juliet. But the coexistence of the comical characters and the dangerous ones in the inner play makes her search for the Author problematic because it is contradictory to her conviction that the sources of the two Shakespearean tragedies are comedies. As for the search for the Fool, she grows conscious that she is the Fool of the inner play by preventing the catastrophes and making serious situations comical. However, the comical atmosphere made by Constance can be at any time transformed into the tragic one because of villainous Iago and hot-tempered Tybalt. In conclusion, Ann-Marie MacDonald succeeds in twisting the two Shakespearean tragedies comically, but fails to criticize severely the authoritative male-centered Canadian academia by making the protagonist's three missions problematic.
참고문헌 (15)
- Bramwell, Murray, "From Bard to Worse in: Drama for Students", pp.153~154 (2006), Thomson Gale
- Curran, Beverley, "Mingling and Unmingling Opposites: Bending Genre and Gender in Ann-Marie MacDonald’s Goodnight Desdemona- (Good Morning Juliet) in: He Said, She Says: An RSVP to the Male Text", pp.211~220 (2001), Fairleigh Dickinson UP
- Djordjevic, Igor, "Goodnight Desdemona(Good Morning Juliet): From Shakespearean Tragedy to Postmodern Satyr Play", Comparative Drama, 37(1), pp.89~115 (2003)
- Friedman, Sharon, "The Feminist Playwright as Critic: Paula Vogel, Ann-Marie MacDonald, and Djanet Sears Interpret Othello in: Feminist Theatrical Revisions of Classic Works: Critical Essays. Ed. Sharon Friedman", pp.113~134 (2009), McFarland & Company
- Harrington, Louise, "Excuse Me While I Turn This Upside-Down’: Three Canadian Adaptations of Shakespeare", British Journal of Canadian Studies, 20(1), pp.123~142 (2007)
- Lockhart, Melanie Lee, "Taking Them to the Moon in a Station Wagon’: An Interview with Ann-Marie MacDonald", Canadian Review of American Studies, 35(2), pp.139~157 (2005)
- MacDonald, Ann-Marie, "Goodnight Desdemona(Good Morning Juliet)" (1998), Grove P
- MacKay, Ellen, "The Spectre of Straight Shakespeare: New Ways of Looking at Old Texts in Goodnight Desdemona and Mad Boy Chronicle", Canadian Theatre Review, 111(2), pp.10~14 (2002)
- Much, Rita, "Ann-Marie MacDonald Interview in: Fair Play: 12 Women Speak", pp.127~143 (1990), Simon & Pierre
- or Ourselves: Plays by Ann-Marie MacDonald and Paula Vogel in: Transforming Shakespeare: Contemporary Women’s Re-Visions in Literature and Performance, "Saving Desdemona and", pp.1999, Novy, Marianne
- Porter, Laurin R., "Shakespeare's ‘Sisters’: Desdemona, Juliet, and Constance Ledbelly in Goodnight Desdemona(Good Morning Juliet)", Modern Drama, 38(3), pp.362~377 (1995)
- Schaffeld, Norbert, "Shakespeare’s Canadian Sister: The Emergence of a Female Playwright in Ann-Marie MacDonald’s Comedy Goodnight Desdemona (Good Morning Juliet)", Literatur-wissenschaftliches Jahrbuch im Auftrage der Gorres-Gesellschaft, 42, pp.287~301 (2001)
- Stevenson, Melanie A., "Othello, Darwin, and the Evolution of Race in Ann-Marie MacDonald’s Work", Canadian Literature, 168(1), pp.34~54 (2001)
- Trudell, Scott, "Critical Essay on Goodnight Desdemona(Good Morning Juliet)", pp.150~153 (2006), Thomson Gale
- Yachnin, Paul, "‘To Kill a King’: The Modern Politics of Bardicide in: Shakespeare and Modern Theatre: The Performance of Modernity", pp.36~54 (2001), Routledge