본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

The Categorial Status of Control Infinitives and the Distribution of PRO

김랑혜윤
한국생성문법학회|2004.06|생성문법연구 (Studies in Generative Grammar)|제14권 제2호|pp. 167-186

1

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

주제분류언어학

초록

Abstract

This paper investigates the relation between the categorial status of control infinitivals and the distribution of PRO. There are three different types of approaches to the distribution of PRO; the binding-theoretic approach, the Case theoretic approach, and the movement approach. The binding-theoretic approach appeals to the CP/IP distinction to account for the distribution of PRO, the Case theoretic approach is compatible with and argues for the IP analysis of controls, and the movement approach takes the CP analysis of controls. I suggest a general constraint on passivization as an alternative of the CP analysis of Hornstein to account for the cases of control over a passive verb, since the CP analysis faces problems in dealing with Boškovi's (1997) examples. Still, I suspect that the two different views on the categorial status of controls, i.e., IP analysis vs. CP analysis, in fact reflect the fact that controls in itself bears a dual property. It behaves as if it is IP or a weak phase as long as Boškovi's (1997) examples are concerned but it behaves as if it is CP or a strong phase as long as the relatively free distribution are concerned. I propose that the CP deletion hypothesis in Chomsky (1981), rephrased here in terms of the C deletion in consideration of economy, is a way to deal with the dual categorial property of controls.

참고문헌 (57)

  1. "Floating Quantifiers, PRO, and Predication", 26, pp.199~248 (1995)
  2. "The Null Content of Null Case" (2002), New York
  3. "A Minimalist View on the Passive", 2 (1998), University of Connecticut, Storrs
  4. "Mechanisms of chain formation" (2001)
  5. "Reply to 'Control is not movement", 34, pp.269~280 (2003)
  6. "The syntax of nonfinite complementation" (1997), Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press
  7. "On the distribution of null complementizers", 34, pp.527~546 (2003)
  8. "On the content of empty categories" (1984), Foris
  9. "The Syntax of Predication", 24, pp.591~656 (1993)
  10. "A challenge to Null Case theory", 35, pp.141~149 (2004)
  11. "Groningen-Amsterdam Studies in Semantics", me 11 (1989), Semantics and Contextual Expression
  12. "Lectures on government and binding" (1981), Foris
  13. "Knowledge of language" (1986), Praeger
  14. "The minimalist program" (1995), MIT Press
  15. "Minimalist Inquiries-The Framework : Step by Step-Essays on Minimalist Syntax in Honor of Howard Lasnik" (2000), Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press
  16. "Filters and Control", 8, pp.425~504 (1977)
  17. "The theory of principles and parameters" (1995)
  18. "Control is not movement", 32, pp.493~512 (2001)
  19. "On Case and the passive morpheme", 11, pp.31~44 (1993)
  20. "PRO the EPP and the Nominative Case: Evidence from Irish Infinitivals", 4(3), pp.71~86 (1997)
  21. "Movement and chains", 1, pp.99~127 (1998)
  22. "Movement and control", 30, pp.69~96 (1999)
  23. "On A-chains: A reply to Brody", 3, pp.129~143 (2000)
  24. "Move! A minimalist theory of construal" (2000), Malden, Mass.:Blackwell
  25. "On Control" (2001), University of Maryland, College Park
  26. "Remarks on to contraction", 11, pp.239~245 (1980)
  27. "Pronouns and their antecedents" (2001), New York University
  28. "On binding and control", 15, pp.417~459 (1984)
  29. Landau, Idan, "Movement out of control", 34, pp.471~498 (2003)
  30. "Restricting the theory of transformations Explanation in linguistics the logical problem of language acquisition" (1981)
  31. "Lectures on Minimalist Syntax UCONN Occasional Papers in Linguistics 1 University of Connecticut" (1993)
  32. "Effects of head movement on theories of subjacency and proper government" (1991)
  33. "Attitudes De Se and Anaphora: A Presuppositional Account", 3(2), pp.51~66 (1999)
  34. "Locality and anaphoric binding", 4, pp.343~363 (1985)
  35. "Trace Theory and twice-moved NPs", 7, pp.559~582 (1976)
  36. Manzini, M. R, "A minimalist theory of movement and control" (1997), Firenze[DOI]
  37. "On the distribution and Case features of PRO University of Connecticut" (1992)
  38. "A minimalist theory of PRO and control" (1996)
  39. "Null Case and the distribution of PRO", 32, pp.141~166 (2001)
  40. "The copy theory of movement and linearization of chains in the minimalist program" (1995), University of Maryland
  41. "Cyclicity and extraction domains", 3, pp.20~43 (2000)
  42. "Out of Control", 25, pp.361~371 (1995), University of Massachusetts
  43. "Means of Control: Deriving the properties of PRO in the Minimalist Program" (1995), Harvard University
  44. "On coreferential complement subject deletion", 1, pp.439~500 (1970)
  45. "The nature of children's initial clauses" (1994), Essex University
  46. "Syntactic Theory and the Structure of English; A Minimalist Approach" (1997), Cambridge University Press, New York, U.S.A
  47. "Indefinite SE", 14, pp.749~810 (1996)
  48. "Governing -ing", 14, pp.101~136 (1983)
  49. "The grammar of English predicate complement constructions" (1967), MIT Press
  50. "A Principle governing deletion in English sentential complementation Readings in English Transformational Grammar" (1970)
  51. "Null arguments in a theory of economy of projection University of Massachusetts Occasional Papers 17 University of Massachusetts" (1994)
  52. "Cyclic domains in syntactic theory" (2001)
  53. "The tense of infinitives", 13, pp.561~570 (1982)
  54. Takahashi, "Minimality of Movement University of Connecticut" (1994)
  55. "On the subject of gerunds Foundations of Language 8", pp.44~61 (1972)
  56. "Predication", 11, pp.208~238 (1980)
  57. "Syntactic vs. Semantic Control" (2000)

관련 논문AI추천

Some Consideration of Non-controlled PRO in French김신호한국언어과학회 · 언어과학2005 · 제12권 제3호Infinitival Subjects and Phase-based Feature-checking예선희한국생성문법학회 · 생성문법연구2003 · 제13권 제4호A Minimalist Approach to Quantifier Raising문귀선한국생성문법학회 · 생성문법연구2004 · 제14권 제2호Control and the Linking Theory강남길, 김경열대한영어영문학회 · 영어영문학연구2012 · 제54권 제4호Verb Gapping and Pseudogapping in English:A Categorial Grammar Approach이용훈대한영어영문학회 · 영어영문학연구2006 · 제32권 제1호The Configuration of Non-verbal, Non-nominal Small Clause Structures in English조성은한국언어학회 · 언어2006 · 제31권 제4호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (8건)

The Structure of Constituent Negation in English최기용pp. 2-2Intervention Effects in Experiencer Constructions and Their Implications for the Theory of Move and AgreeJong-Un Park, 박명관pp. 3-3Possessor-Raising in Existential Constructions이두원pp. 4-4A Minimalist Approach to Quantifier Raising문귀선pp. 6-6Remarks on the PF-Merger Analysis of the Null Complementizer in English김선웅pp. 7-7
원문 보기