The Effectiveness of Reading Strategy Instruction: A Meta-Analysis
1
조회
0
다운로드
15
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Many experimental studies have reported the effects of strategy instruction (SI) on reading comprehension in Korea, but the reported results are not conclusive. This meta-analysis study, therefore, aims to provide reliable common effects of SI on Korean learners’ reading comprehension. The study also aims to investigate how context (institution, L2 proficiency, gender) and treatment variables (strategy type, numbers of different strategies used, test types) affect the effectiveness of SI on the reading comprehension ability of Korean L2 learners. Through a comprehensive search, 37 primary studies were selected and 45 samples were coded into CMA software to calculate effect sizes by computing Heges’ g. The results of this meta-analysis showed a moderate effect of SI on reading comprehension (ES=.58). All moderating variables except L2 proficiency and gender had a statistically significant moderating effect with medium to large effect sizes for 7 variables and small effect sizes for 4 variables. Findings and pedagogical and research implications are discussed.
Abstract
Many experimental studies have reported the effects of strategy instruction (SI) on reading comprehension in Korea, but the reported results are not conclusive. This meta-analysis study, therefore, aims to provide reliable common effects of SI on Korean learners’ reading comprehension. The study also aims to investigate how context (institution, L2 proficiency, gender) and treatment variables (strategy type, numbers of different strategies used, test types) affect the effectiveness of SI on the reading comprehension ability of Korean L2 learners. Through a comprehensive search, 37 primary studies were selected and 45 samples were coded into CMA software to calculate effect sizes by computing Heges’ g. The results of this meta-analysis showed a moderate effect of SI on reading comprehension (ES=.58). All moderating variables except L2 proficiency and gender had a statistically significant moderating effect with medium to large effect sizes for 7 variables and small effect sizes for 4 variables. Findings and pedagogical and research implications are discussed.
참고문헌 (76)
- Anderson, N. J., "The role of metacognition in second language teaching and learning", ERIC Digest, April 2002, 3~4 (2002)
- Anderson, N. J., "Handbook of research in second language teaching and learning", pp.757~771 (2005), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
- 배은실, "중학교 학습자들의 모국어 읽기전략, 영어 읽기전략, 영어 읽기능력 사이의 관계 분석", 현대영어교육, 13(4), pp.293~313 (2012), 현대영어교육학회
- Barnett, M. A., "Reading through context : How real and perceived strategy use affects L2 comprehension", The Modern Language Journal, 72, pp.150~162 (1988)
- Bimmel, P. E., "Effects of strategy training on reading comprehension in first and foreign language", European Journal of Psychology of Education, 16, pp.509~529 (2001)
- Borenstein, M., "Introduction to meta-analysis" (2009), Wiley
- 변지현, "교양영어 읽기전략 훈련의 효과분석", 교양교육연구, 6(2), pp.207~241 (2012), 한국교양교육학회[DOI]
- 이은영, "KWL 전략 활용 읽기 지도를 통한 초등학생의 영어 읽기 능력 발달 연구", 초등영어교육, 19(1), pp.241~269 (2013), 한국초등영어교육학회
- Chamot, A. U., "Language learning strategy instruction : Current issues and research", Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 25, pp.112~130 (2005)
- Chamot, A. U., "The CALLA handbook: Implementing the cognitive academic language learning approach" (1994), Addition-Wesley
- Chamot, A. U., "Comments on Janie Rees-Miller’s"A critical appraisal of learner training : Theoretical bases and teaching implication" : Two readers react", TESOL Quarterly, 28, pp.771~776 (1994)
- Cho, E. J., "Effects of the internet-based reading activities on Korean high school students' English reading comprehension", 석사, pp.2003
- Cho, W. H., "A study of English learning strategies for elementary school students", 박사, pp.2003
- Choi, H. Y., "Attitude and preference of English learners to reading strategy instruction", 석사, pp.2010
- Choi, J. H., "Effects of teaching English reading strategies", 석사, pp.2013
- Choi, N. I., "The effect of reading strategy instruction on private elementary school students’ English reading abilities in extensive reading of various genres", 석사, pp.2013
- Cohen, A. D., "Language learner strategies : Thirty years of research and practice" (2007), Oxford University Press
- Cohen, J., "Statistical power analysis for the behavior science" (1988), Academic Press
- Cooper, H., "Research synthesis and meta-analysis: A step-by-step approach" (2010), Sage
- Cummins, J., "The handbook of language teaching", pp.161~181 (2009), Blackwell
- Dryer, C., "Teaching reading strategies and reading comprehension within a technology-enhanced learning environment", System, 31, pp.349~365 (2003)
- Ellis, R., "Principles of instructed language learning", Asian EFL Journal, 7, pp.9~24 (2005)
- Grabe, W., "Research on teaching reading", Annual Review of Applied Linguistics, 24, pp.44~69 (2004)
- Grabe, W., "Reading in a second language: Moving from theory to practice" (2009), Cambridge University Press
- Green, J. M., "A closer look at learning strategies, L2 proficiency, and gender", TESOL Quarterly, 29, pp.261~297 (1995)
- Hardin, V. B., "Transfer and variation in cognitive reading strategies of Latino fourth-grade students in a late-exit bilingual program", Bilingual Research Journal, 25(4), pp.417~439 (2001)
- Haris, V., "Adapting classroom-based strategy instruction to a distance learning context", TESL-EJ, 7, pp.1~13 (2003)
- Im, J. H., "The effects reading strategy training on low-level high school students’English reading comprehension", 석사, pp.2008
- Jang, J. H., "A study on the strategy training in listening and reading classes for middle school students", pp.2004
- Jeon, E. H., "L2 reading comprehension and its correlates : A meta-analysis", Language Learning, 64(1), pp.160~212 (2014)
- Jeon, B. Q., "A study of the effects of metacognitive reading strategies training on English reading comprehension", The Journal of Linguistic Science, 19, pp.217~240 (2001)
- Jung, D. W., "The effect of English instructed cognitive strategies on elementary students’ reading abilities", 석사, pp.2012
- 정미애, "Reading Strategies in L1 and L2: Comparison of Korean EFL Learners’ Reading Strategy Use", 현대문법연구, 68(68), pp.211~240 (2012), 현대문법학회[DOI]
- Yung-SukJung, "Effects of EFL Reading Strategy Instruction Integrating Technology for Korean University Students", 멀티미디어 언어교육, 5(1), pp.32~58 (2002), 한국멀티미디어언어교육학회
- Kim, H. A., "The effects of reading strategy training on high school students’English reading comprehension", 석사, pp.2008
- Kim, H. K., "A Study on the effects of strategy training on middle school students'reading comprehension", The Journal of English Language, 13(2), pp.21~43 (2001)
- 김혜리, "아동문학 텍스트 기반 초등영어 읽기 전략 지도", 초등영어교육, 16(3), pp.85~121 (2010), 한국초등영어교육학회
- 김현숙, "The Effects of Instruction Using Graphic Organizers on Reading Comprehension", 외국어교육연구, 24(1), pp.209~241 (2010), 외국어교육연구소
- 김미래, "외국어 학습 전략 사용과 영어 학업성취도의 관계", 영어교육연구, 19(1), pp.135~6 (2007), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- Kim, Y. M., "The effects of the explicit learning strategy instruction on high school students' listening and reading abilities: The applicability of the CALLA model", 석사, pp.2013
- Koda, K., "Insights into second language reading: A cross-linguistic approach" (2005), Cambridge University Press
- 권수옥, "Explicit Instruction Does Affect the Metacognitive Awareness of Reading Strategies for EFL Readers", Foreign Languages Education, 16(1), pp.1~27 (2009), 한국외국어교육학회
- Lee, D. E., "A study on the effects of prediction strategy training on reading abilities and attitudes of Korean middle school students", 석사, pp.2013
- Lee. E. Y., "Effects of reading strategy instruction on students’ achievement", 석사, pp.2008
- 이화자, "자기주도적 학습을 위한 전략활용 영자신문 읽기지도", Studies in English Education, 12(1), pp.1~24 (2007), 글로벌영어교육학회
- Lee, J. H., "A study of teaching reading comprehension by using reading strategyfinding main idea task", 석사, pp.2007
- 이경랑, "Improving Self-Efficacy and Reading Performance through Individualized Reading Strategy Instruction", 현대영어교육, 11(3), pp.40~54 (2010), 현대영어교육학회
- Lee, S. J., "The effects of reading strategy training classified by its types on Korean high school students' reading comprehension abilities and the attitude toward reading", 석사, pp.2007
- Lim, J. H., "The effects of reading and vocabulary strategy use on advanced middle school students’ reading comprehension", 석사, pp.2008
- Lim, S. E., "The effects of reciprocal teaching in a Korea high school reading classroom", 석사, pp.2010
- 임은화, "Think-aloud기법을 활용한 이해점검 독해전략 훈련이 영어학습자의 독해력 및 독해 메타인지에 미치는 효과", 현대영어영문학, 55(2), pp.203~227 (2011), 한국현대영어영문학회
- 맹은경, "A Comparative Study of Reading Strategies in L1 and L2: Case Study of Five Korean Graduate Students", 어학연구, 41(2), pp.457~486 (2005), 언어교육원
- 맹은경, "Reading Strategy Instruction and Reading Comprehension of Middle School Students", 영어영문학연구, 52(2), pp.95~121 (2010), 한국중앙영어영문학회
- Magogwe, J. M., "The relationship between language learning strategies, proficiency, age and self-efficacy beliefs : A study of language learners in Botswana", System, 35, pp.338~352 (2007)
- Maxim, H., "A study into the feasibility and effects of reading extended authentic discourse in the beginning German language classroom", The Modern Language Journal, 86, pp.20~35 (2002)
- Nunan, D., "Practical English language teaching", pp.2003, MaGraw-Hill
- Oxford, R. L., "Language learning strategies: What every teacher should know" (1990), Newbury House
- Oxford, R., "Effect of the presence and difficulty of task on strategy use : An exploratory study", International Review of Applied Linguistics, 42, pp.1~47 (2004)
- Park, E. J., "study on the improvement of English reading comprehension for middle school students", 석사, pp.2012
- 박효진, "읽기 전략 지도와 읽기 포트폴리오의 활용이 고등학생의 영어 읽기 능력과 태도에 미치는 영향", 영어교육연구, 23(3), pp.127~149 (2011), 팬코리아영어교육학회
- 박용효, "A Relationship Between Reading Comprehension and Reading Strategy Use: Meta-Analysis", 영어교육, 65(3), pp.3~22 (2010), 한국영어교육학회
- Park, J. M., "The effect of using metacognitive reading strategies on English reading motivation and comprehension", 박사, pp.2011
- Plonsky, L., "The effectiveness of second language strategy instruction : A metaanalysis", Language Learning, 61(4), pp.993~1038 (2011)
- Pressley, M., "Handbook of reading research", pp.545~561 (2000), Lawrence Erlbaum
- Raymond, P. M., "The effects of structure strategy training on the recall of expository prose for university students reading French as a second language", The Modern Language Journal, 77, pp.445~458 (1993)
- Reutzel, D. R., "An evaluation of two approaches for teaching reading comprehension strategies in the primary years using science information texts", Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 20, pp.276~305 (2005)
- Sailor, M., "Professional development that supports the teaching of =cognitive reading strategy instruction", The Elementary School Journal, 110(3), pp.301~322 (2010)
- Seo, I. S., "The effects of reading strategy instruction on the high school students’English reading comprehension", 석사, pp.2009
- 석진이, "상보적 교수법을 통한 읽기 전략 지도의 효과와 유지에 관한 연구", 외국어교육연구, 21(1), pp.35~53 (2007), 외국어교육연구소
- Sheorey, R., "Differences in the metacognitive awareness of reading strategies among native and non-native readers", System, 29, pp.431~449 (2001)
- Shim, J. H., "A study of English reading strategy training for middle school students at a lower proficiency level", 석사, pp.2002
- Shim, M. S., "The effect of affective strategies on elementary school students’listening and reading proficiency", 석사, pp.2006
- Yu, M. K., "The effects of reading strategies on elementary students’ English reading ability and affective domain", 석사, pp.2011
- Yun, H. M., "Effects of reading strategy training with textual enhanced text on Korean middle school students’ reading comprehension abilities and reading strategy uses", 석사, pp.2002
- Yoon, W. J., "The effects of metacognitive strategy instruction for reading in EFL", The Journal of English Language Teaching, 13(2), pp.203~221 (2001)
- Wharton, G., "Language learning strategy use of bilingual foreign language learners in Singapore", Language Learning, 50, pp.203~243 (2000)
