호감도 함수 기반 다특성 강건설계 최적화 기법
A Desirability Function-Based Multi-Characteristic Robust Design Optimization Technique
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Taguchi method is one of the most popular approaches for design optimization such that performance characteristics become robust to uncontrollable noise variables. However, most previous Taguchi method applications have addressed a single-characteristic problem. Problems with multiple characteristics are more common in practice. The multi-criteria decision making(MCDM) problem is to select the optimal one among multiple alternatives by integrating a number of criteria that may conflict with each other. Representative MCDM methods include TOPSIS(Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution), GRA(Grey Relational Analysis), PCA(Principal Component Analysis), fuzzy logic system, and so on. Therefore, numerous approaches have been conducted to deal with the multi-characteristic design problem by combining original Taguchi method and MCDM methods. In the MCDM problem, multiple criteria generally have different measurement units, which means that there may be a large difference in the physical value of the criteria and ultimately makes it difficult to integrate the measurements for the criteria. Therefore, the normalization technique is usually utilized to convert different units of criteria into one identical unit. There are four normalization techniques commonly used in MCDM problems, including vector normalization, linear scale trans- formation(max-min, max, or sum). However, the normalization techniques have several shortcomings and do not adequately in- corporate the practical matters. For example, if certain alternative has maximum value of data for certain criterion, this alternative is considered as the solution in original process. However, if the maximum value of data does not satisfy the required degree of fulfillment of designer or customer, the alternative may not be considered as the solution. To solve this problem, this paper employs the desirability function that has been proposed in our previous research. The desirability function uses upper limit and lower limit in normalization process. The threshold points for establishing upper or lower limits let us know what degree of fulfillment of designer or customer is. This paper proposes a new design optimization technique for multi-characteristic design problem by integrating the Taguchi method and our desirability functions. Finally, the proposed technique is able to obtain the optimal solution that is robust to multi-characteristic performances.
Abstract
Taguchi method is one of the most popular approaches for design optimization such that performance characteristics become robust to uncontrollable noise variables. However, most previous Taguchi method applications have addressed a single-characteristic problem. Problems with multiple characteristics are more common in practice. The multi-criteria decision making(MCDM) problem is to select the optimal one among multiple alternatives by integrating a number of criteria that may conflict with each other. Representative MCDM methods include TOPSIS(Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution), GRA(Grey Relational Analysis), PCA(Principal Component Analysis), fuzzy logic system, and so on. Therefore, numerous approaches have been conducted to deal with the multi-characteristic design problem by combining original Taguchi method and MCDM methods. In the MCDM problem, multiple criteria generally have different measurement units, which means that there may be a large difference in the physical value of the criteria and ultimately makes it difficult to integrate the measurements for the criteria. Therefore, the normalization technique is usually utilized to convert different units of criteria into one identical unit. There are four normalization techniques commonly used in MCDM problems, including vector normalization, linear scale trans- formation(max-min, max, or sum). However, the normalization techniques have several shortcomings and do not adequately in- corporate the practical matters. For example, if certain alternative has maximum value of data for certain criterion, this alternative is considered as the solution in original process. However, if the maximum value of data does not satisfy the required degree of fulfillment of designer or customer, the alternative may not be considered as the solution. To solve this problem, this paper employs the desirability function that has been proposed in our previous research. The desirability function uses upper limit and lower limit in normalization process. The threshold points for establishing upper or lower limits let us know what degree of fulfillment of designer or customer is. This paper proposes a new design optimization technique for multi-characteristic design problem by integrating the Taguchi method and our desirability functions. Finally, the proposed technique is able to obtain the optimal solution that is robust to multi-characteristic performances.
참고문헌 (28)
- Abdi, H., "Principal component analy-sis, Computational Statistics", Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews, 2, pp.433~459 (2010)
- Chakraborty, S., "A simulation based com-parative study of normalization procedures in multi-attribute decision making", Proceedings of Conference on Artificial Intelligence, Knowledge Engineering and Data Bases (2007)
- Chakraborty, S., "A simulation comparison of normalization procedures for TOPSIS", Proceedings of International Conference on Computers & Industrial Engineering (2009)
- Cristiano, J. J., "Key factors in the successful application of quality function deploy-ment(QFD)", IEEE Transactions on Engineering Manage-ment, 48(1), pp.81~95 (2001)
- Derringer, G., "Simultaneous optimization of several response variables", Journal of Quality Technology, 12, pp.214~219 (1980)
- Fung, C. P., "Multi-response optimization in friction properties of PBT composites using Taguchi method and principle component analysis", Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 170, pp.602~610 (2005)
- Ho, L. H., "A new methodology for customer satisfaction analysis : Taguchi’s sig-nal-to-noise ratio approach", Journal of Service Science and Management, 7, pp.235~244 (2014)
- 정호인, "다구찌 기법을 이용한 CFRP의 최적 드릴링 조건 선정에 관한 연구", 대한기계학회논문집 A, 45(12), pp.1077~1083 (2021), 대한기계학회
- 조재훈, "호감도 함수와 다구찌 법을 이용한 고객지향설계에 관한 연구", 한국산업경영시스템학회지, 45(4), pp.99~108 (2022), 한국산업경영시스템학회
- Kano, N., "Attractive quality and must-be quality", Journal of the Japanese Society for Quality Control(Hinshitsu), 14(2), pp.39~48 (1984)
- Kaushik, N., "Hybrid combination of Taguchi-GRA-PCA for optimization of wear behavior in AA6063", SiCp matrix composite, 2018, pp.6(1), 171~189
- Kim, J. W., "Engineering Design : Creative New Product Development Methodology" (2013), Munundang
- Kuo, Y., "The use of grey relational analysis in solving multiple attribute deci-sion-making problems", Computers & Industrial Engin-eering, 55, pp.80~93 (2008)
- 권용만, "Robust Design Using Desirability Function in Product-Array", 통합자연과학논문집, 11(2), pp.76~81 (2018), 기초과학연구원[DOI]
- Lai, Y. J., "TOPSIS for MODM", European Journal of Operational Research, 76(11), pp.486~500 (1994)
- Lakshmi, T. M., "A comparison of Various Normalization in Techniques for Order Perfor-mance by Similarity to Ideal Solution(TOPSIS)", International Journal of Computing Algorithm, 3(3), pp.255~259 (2014)
- Nahm, Y. E., "Set-based multi-objective design opti-mization at the early phase of design(the third report) : Application to environment-conscious automotive side-door assembly", Journal of Korean Society of Industrial and Systems Engineering, 34(4), pp.139~145 (2011)
- 남윤의, "A novel approach to prioritize customer requirements in QFD based on customer satisfaction function for customer-oriented product design", Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology, 27(12), pp.3765~3777 (2013), 대한기계학회[DOI]
- Najm, O., "Optimization of alkali-activated ladle slag composites mix design using Taguchi-based TOPSIS method", Construction and Building Materials, 327, pp.126946~ (2022)
- Niu, B., "Multi-objective optimization of supply air jet enhanc-ing airflow uniformity in data center with Taguchi-based grey relational analysis", Building and Environment, 208, pp.108606~ (2022)
- Sharma, A., "Experimental investigation and opti-mization of potential parameters of discrete V down baffled solar thermal collector using hybrid Taguchi-TOPSIS method", Applied Thermal Engineering, 209, pp.118250~ (2022)
- Singarvel, B., "Multi ob-jective optimization in turning of EN25 steel using Taguchi Based utility concept coupled with principal component analysis", Procedia Engineering, 97, pp.158~165 (2014)
- Subrahmanyam, A. P. S. V. R., "Taguchi based desirability function analysis for the opti-mization of multiple performance characteristics", Inter-national Journal of Modern Trends in Engineering &Research, 5(5), pp.168~175 (2018)
- van de Poel I. R., "Methodological problems in QFD and directions for future development", Research in Engineer-ing Design, 18, pp.21~36 (2007)
- Viswanathan, R., "Measurement and multi-response optimization of turning parameters for magnesium alloy using hybrid combination of Taguchi-GRA-PCA technique", Measure-ment, 159, pp.107800~ (2020)
- Wu, L., "Evaluation of tar from the microwave co-pyrolysis of low-rank coal and corncob using orthogo-nal-test-based grey relational analysis(GRA)", Journal of Cleaner Production, 337, pp.130362~ (2022)
- 염봉진, "다구치 강건설계 방법 : 현황과 과제", 대한산업공학회지, 39(5), pp.325~341 (2013), 대한산업공학회[DOI]
- 이부윤, "다구찌 기법을 이요한 자동차 폐달 암의 형상 최적설계", 한국정밀공학회지, 24(3), pp.76~83 (2007), 한국정밀공학회