公司反收购中的董事受信义务初探
Primary Research on Fiduciary Duties of Directors in Anti-takeover Circumstances —Take US for example—
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
在公司反收购中,目标公司董事会深陷利益冲突的漩涡,很难保证其掌控下的公司反收购决定始终会有利于股东,尤其是中小股东的最大利益。因此,对目标公司董事会苛以受信义务便成了防止董事侵害股东利益,滥用公司反收购决定权为自己牟利的“紧箍咒”。本文着重探讨了美国模式下,司法判例对于注意义务与勤勉义务的审查标准,即商业判断原则与实质公平标准。然后结合公司反收购案件,讨论了美国司法判例对于商业判断原则的灵活变通:优尼科规则与露华浓规则。最后,结合我国的具体国情,笔者认为应当借鉴美国模式,将公司反收购决定权赋予董事会。同时合理移植美国的商业判断原则及其变通规则作为法院审查目标公司管理层在反收购案件中的适用标准。
Abstract
In the case of anti-takeover transactions, board of directors of the target company is deeply involved in a situation of conflict of interests, which arouses our concern on whether the anti-takeover decisions made by such directors are always favorable to shareholders, especially minority shareholders. Therefore, fiduciary duties work as the recipe to prevent directors from derogating the true interests of shareholders and seeking their own interests instead. This article mainly discusses the judicial review standards of duty of care and duty of loyalty, which are business judgment rule and substantial equality rule respectively. Then in conjunction with anti-takeover cases, this paper discusses the adaptations of business judgment rule in the judicial practices of US, which give birth to another two rules: Unocal rule and Revlon rule. Lastly, in consideration of concrete situation of China, this paper suggests US model should be referred to and entrust the power of deciding the anti-takeover affairs to the board of directors. At the same time, the US business judgment rule and its adaptations should be transplanted into China as the applicable standard of People’s court to examine the decisions of board of directors in anti-takeover issues.
참고문헌 (11)
- 施天涛, "公司法论" (2006), 法律出版社
- 罗伯特, "公司法则" (1999), 工商出版社
- 潘路佳, "目标公司反收购中的董事义务研究", 硕士, pp.2006
- 杨欣, "目标公司反收购行为的法律规制", 硕士, pp.2006
- 黄文, "目标公司反收购中董事信义义务研究", 硕士, pp.2007
- 颜娟, "我国上市公司反收购制度的研判与建构——以目标公司管理层信义义务为中心", 硕士, pp.2006
- 李劲松, "公司反收购与董事受信义务研究", 现代法学, 25(4) (2003)
- 杜枢, "美国对目标公司反收购行为的规制:商业判断规则之运用", 商业研究, (264) (2003)
- 朱圆, "美国反收购法律规制叹息", 华东政法学院学报, (6) (2004)
- 莫初明, "规则与裁判:反收购中董事忠实义务的法律判断", 广西政法管理干部学院学报, 21(1) (2006)
- Fiduciary Duties of Directors in Corporate Takeovers, Mergers, and Acquisitions: Recent Developments, "Fred B. White, III", ~, pp.PLI Order No. B4-7179 (1997)
