프랑스의 무슬림 이민자와 민족정체성 문제 - 사르코지 시기의 ‘민족정체성 문제’를 중심으로 -
Muslim Immigrants and the Question of National Identity in France
0
조회
0
다운로드
6
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
With respect to the discourses on national identity that flourished in France before and after the presidential election of 2007, this paper examines the policies employed by President Niclolas Sarkozy regarding the issue of national identity. Starting with the 68 Revolution, the full-fledged French debates on national identity rapidly expanded to the political sphere around the time when the Socialist Party, led by François Mitterand, seized power in 1981. This phenomenon was closely related to Muslim immigration in France and the political growth of the National Front, an ultra-rightist party in France. Why did Mr. Sarkozy raise this question again in the 2007 presidential election? When the National Front reached the second-round final ballot in the 2002 presidential election, the leaders of the UMP (Union pour un Mouvement Populaire), the administrative party at the time, were shocked by the rapid progress of such an extremely rightist party. In this situation, it was unclear to the UMP leaders whether they would be able to win the 2007 presidential election or not. To them, the social disturbances caused by Muslim immigrants in 2005 made the situation worse. This unfavorable situation urged Mr. Sarkozy, the candidate on the UMP ticket, to place the issue of national identity against Muslim immigrants higher than the traditional social issues on the crowded list of priorities in the 2007 campaign. This election strategy paid off. His campaign against immigrants garnered wide support from the populace, who were then very sensitive to the social issues such as illegal immigration and French national identity, with the result that the UMP won the election in a landslide victory. Since then, Mr. Sarkozy has been fulfilling his campaign pledges by signing a series of bills for the establishment of the Department of Immigration, designed to tighten regulations on immigration to France, and for the prohibition of wearing the Burqa. Mr. Sarkozy and the UMP will map out new campaign strategies regarding the issue of national identity for the 2012 presidential election vis-à-vis Marine Le Pen on the National Front ticket, whose approval ratings for the presidency has steadily increased according to recent opinion polls. These days, however, the issue of national identity is not confined in France. As seen in the recent tragedy in Oslo, Norway, the Scandinavian countries, which have been believed as a region of acceptance in terms of racial and cultural diversity, are now fully exposed to the same issue. This situational trend in contemporary Europe will go on for the time being towards a rejection of cultural diversity and the emphasis of a less heterogeneous national identity.
Abstract
With respect to the discourses on national identity that flourished in France before and after the presidential election of 2007, this paper examines the policies employed by President Niclolas Sarkozy regarding the issue of national identity. Starting with the 68 Revolution, the full-fledged French debates on national identity rapidly expanded to the political sphere around the time when the Socialist Party, led by François Mitterand, seized power in 1981. This phenomenon was closely related to Muslim immigration in France and the political growth of the National Front, an ultra-rightist party in France. Why did Mr. Sarkozy raise this question again in the 2007 presidential election? When the National Front reached the second-round final ballot in the 2002 presidential election, the leaders of the UMP (Union pour un Mouvement Populaire), the administrative party at the time, were shocked by the rapid progress of such an extremely rightist party. In this situation, it was unclear to the UMP leaders whether they would be able to win the 2007 presidential election or not. To them, the social disturbances caused by Muslim immigrants in 2005 made the situation worse. This unfavorable situation urged Mr. Sarkozy, the candidate on the UMP ticket, to place the issue of national identity against Muslim immigrants higher than the traditional social issues on the crowded list of priorities in the 2007 campaign. This election strategy paid off. His campaign against immigrants garnered wide support from the populace, who were then very sensitive to the social issues such as illegal immigration and French national identity, with the result that the UMP won the election in a landslide victory. Since then, Mr. Sarkozy has been fulfilling his campaign pledges by signing a series of bills for the establishment of the Department of Immigration, designed to tighten regulations on immigration to France, and for the prohibition of wearing the Burqa. Mr. Sarkozy and the UMP will map out new campaign strategies regarding the issue of national identity for the 2012 presidential election vis-à-vis Marine Le Pen on the National Front ticket, whose approval ratings for the presidency has steadily increased according to recent opinion polls. These days, however, the issue of national identity is not confined in France. As seen in the recent tragedy in Oslo, Norway, the Scandinavian countries, which have been believed as a region of acceptance in terms of racial and cultural diversity, are now fully exposed to the same issue. This situational trend in contemporary Europe will go on for the time being towards a rejection of cultural diversity and the emphasis of a less heterogeneous national identity.
참고문헌 (51)
- "Défilé du 14 juillet : Eva Joy crée la polémique, Fillon tacle"[URL]
- "Les socialistes cherchent à faire émerger leur propre vision de l'identité nationale", Le Monde du 3 novembre 2009, ~ (2009)
- 현대 프랑스 사회의 인종주의, "현대 프랑스 사회의 인종주의", 서양사론, (70) (2001)
- Agnès Maillot, "Identité Nationale et Immigration" (2008), Les Carnets de l'Info
- Alternatives Economiques, "Pourquoi Marine Le Pen monte" (2011)
- Annie Kriegel, "L'immigration, un problème clé pour la société française”, Le Figaro du 12 juin 1985 ; “L'identité française menacée”, Le Figaro des 22-23 juin 1985", ~ (1985)
- "Faut-il en finir avec l'identité?"[URL]
- Daniel Lefeuvre, "Faut-il Avoir Honte de l'Identité Nationale?" (2008), Larousse
- Débat Benjamin Stora-Max Gallo, "L'identité nationale, c'est quoi?", L'Express, 18 Sept. 2007, ~ (2007)
- Dominique Schnapper, "La notion d'identité nationale : quelles significations?", Cahiers français, 342 (2008)
- Gérard Noiriel, "A quoi sert l'identité nationale" (2007), Agone
- Jonathan Marcus, "The National Front and French Politics", pp.78~ (1995), Macmillan
- "Journal du dimanche du 13 mars 2007", ~ (2007)
- "Le Monde du 30 avril 2006", ~ (2006)
- "Le Monde du 8 février 2010", ~ (2010)
- Le Monde, "Le vote FN n’est plus un vote sanction", du 21 avril 2011, ~ (2011)
- "Le Nouvel Observateur du 15 mars 2007", ~ (2007)
- Michèle Tribalat, "Immigration et identité nationale", Cahiers français, 342 (2008)
- Patrick Weil, "Liberté, Egalité, Discriminations : L'identité nationale au regard de l'histoire" (2008), Grasset
- Régis Meyran, "Le mythe de l'identité nationale" (2009), Berg International Editeurs
- Séverine Dessajan, "Immigration et identité nationale" (2009), L'Harmattan
- Yvan Gasteau, "Immigration et l'opinion en France sous la Ve République" (2000), Edition du Seuil
- 김용우, "호모파시스투스: 프랑스 파시즘과 반혁명의 문화혁명"
- 김인중, "민족주의의 개념", 프랑스사 연구, (22), pp.295~322 (2010), 한국프랑스사학회
- 김인중, "19세기 프랑스의 국민통합 - 공화국과 '공민'사회의 형성-", 프랑스사 연구, (5), pp.3~3 (2001), 한국프랑스사학회
- 김정인, "프랑스 제3공화정의 세속화와 국민형성", 서양사연구, 18 (1995), 한국서양사연구회
- 마은지, "프랑스 민족주의", 숭실사학, 20 (2007)
- 박단, "2005년 프랑스 ‘소요 사태’와 무슬림 이민자 통합문제", 프랑스사 연구, (14), pp.225~261 (2006), 한국프랑스사학회
- 박단, "프랑스 공화국과 이민 ―“새로운 공화국”을 향하여?―", 프랑스사 연구, (21), pp.151~172 (2009), 한국프랑스사학회
- 박단, "호모파시스투스: 프랑스 파시즘과 반혁명의 문화혁명" (2005), 책세상
- 박단, "프랑스 문화전쟁" (2005), 책세상
- 박선희, "프랑스 이민정책과 사르코지(2002-2008년)", 국제정치논총, 50(2), pp.193~211 (2010), 한국국제정치학회
- 브라이언 젠킨스, "프랑스 민족주의 : 1789년 이후의 계급과 민족", pp.11~12 (2011), 나남
- 에르네스트 르낭, "민족이란 무엇인가?" (2002), 책세상 문고
- "일반인은 55%", Le Figaro du 21 avril 2007, ~ (2007)
- 전수연, "19세기말 프랑스 초등학교 교과서에 나타난 프랑스의 역사", 역사교육, 59 (1996), 역사교육연구회
- 조홍식, "프랑스 극우 민족주의 정치세력과 유럽통합: 민족전선의 사례", 프랑스학연구, (54), pp.317~340 (2010), 프랑스학회
- "티에리 마리아니(Thierry Mariani)의원의 2007년 9월 18일자 법안"[URL]
- 한명숙, "프랑스 국적법 개정과 북아프리카 이민자 문제, 1986-1993", 프랑스사 연구, (20), pp.153~184 (2009), 한국프랑스사학회
- 김인중, "기억의 장소1" (2010), 나남