독일 상법 제89 b조 대리상의 보상청구권에 관한 연구
Compensation Claim of Commercial Agent Under German Commercial Code § 89 b
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The German Commercial Code § 89 b provides commercial agents with rights to claim for compensation under certain conditions. There are several preconditions for this claim under the Code: agency contract should be terminated; principal should preserve considerable future earnings after the termination of contract; compensation should be paid in an appropriate rate based on the principles of equity. The amount of compensation should be calculated based on the commissions paid to the agents over the last 12 months of the agency contract. In addition, the amount of compensation should be decided after deducting commissions that were already paid for the trading with the existing customers and for the management behaviors, and after considering the loss of value from the leaving customers who are newly collected. However, it cannot exceed a year’s commission averaged over the last 5 years of the agency contract. Compensation upon the termination is justified by circumstances attributable to the principal of a commercial agency contract without any critical reasons caused by an agent. In addition, the compensation claim cannot be excluded before the termination of an agency contract and should be executed within one year after the termination of the contract.
Abstract
The German Commercial Code § 89 b provides commercial agents with rights to claim for compensation under certain conditions. There are several preconditions for this claim under the Code: agency contract should be terminated; principal should preserve considerable future earnings after the termination of contract; compensation should be paid in an appropriate rate based on the principles of equity. The amount of compensation should be calculated based on the commissions paid to the agents over the last 12 months of the agency contract. In addition, the amount of compensation should be decided after deducting commissions that were already paid for the trading with the existing customers and for the management behaviors, and after considering the loss of value from the leaving customers who are newly collected. However, it cannot exceed a year’s commission averaged over the last 5 years of the agency contract. Compensation upon the termination is justified by circumstances attributable to the principal of a commercial agency contract without any critical reasons caused by an agent. In addition, the compensation claim cannot be excluded before the termination of an agency contract and should be executed within one year after the termination of the contract.
참고문헌 (24)
- 이기수, (2008)
- 이철송, "상법총칙·상행위" (2012)
- 박준우, "代理想의 補償請求權과 營業秘密遵守義", 상사법연구, 21(1), pp.6~196 (2002), 한국상사법학회
- 오창석, "상법 제92조의2의 대리상의 보상청구권에 관한 연구", 상사판례연구, 19(3), pp.79~113 (2006), 한국상사판례학회
- Baumbach, "Handelsgesetzbuch Kommentar" (2012)
- Eckert, "Die analoge Anwendung des Ausgleichsanspruchs nach § 89 b HGB auf vertragshändler und Franchisenehmer", WM, 1237~ (1991)
- Haas, "Wegfall des Handelsvertreter-Ausgleichsanspruchs gemäß § 89 b Abs. 3 Nr. 1 HGB bei Eigenkündigung ohne besonderen Anlaß verfassungwidrig?", BB, ~
- Horn, "Zum Ausgleichsanspruch des Eigenhändlers: Kundenstamm und werbende Tätigkeit", ZIP, 137~ (1988)
- von Howningen, "Huene in Münchener Kommentar zum Handels- gesetzbuch Band 1" (2010)
- Kiene, "Die Beurteilung des Kundenstamms bei einer Agenturnachfloge", VersR, 1024~ (2006)
- Köhler, "Ausgleichsanspruch des Franchisenehmers: Bestehen, Bemessung, Abwälzung", NJW, 1689~ (1990)
- Kraatz, "Zur Berechnung des Ausgleichsanspruchs des Handelsvertreters nach Vertragsbeendigung", WM, 498~ (1982)
- Küstner, "Berechnung des Ausgleichsanspruchs des Vertragshändlers", BB, 1972~ (1988)
- Matthies, "Der Ausgleichsanspruch des Handelsvertreters bei kurzer Vertragsdauer", DB, 2063~ (1986)
- Moritz, "Zum Wegfall des Ausgleichsanspruchs bei Kündigung durch den Handelsvertreter", DB, 875~ (1987)
- Niebling, "Der Ausgleichsanspruch des Vertragshändlers – Grundlagen und Berechnung", BB, 2388~ (1997)
- Saenger, "Das Recht des Handelsvertreters zur ausgleichswahrenden Eigenkändigung", DB, 129~ (2000)
- Schmitz, "Handelsvertreterausgleichsansprüche bei Asset Deals", ZIP, 59~ (2003)
- Sonnenschein, "in Heymann Handelsgesetzbuch Kommentar Band 1", ~ (1995)
- Thume, "Die Bedeutung des Kundenstammes im Vertriebsrecht", BB, 1026~ (2009)
- Thume, "Neues zum Ausgleichsanspruch des Hansdelsvertreters und des Bertragshändlers", BB, 2358~ (1994)
- Thume, "Der Ausgleichsanspruch des Handelsvertreters", BB, 1969~ (1990)
- Wendel, "Kein Ausgleichsanspruch nach § 89 b HGB bei Insolvenz des Händlers", WRP, 999~ (2005)
- Westpha, "Neues Handelsvertreterrecht" (1991)