본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Stone-Free Rates of mPCNL, PCNL, and RIRS: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis

2

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

주제분류비뇨기과학

초록

Purpose: Retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS) and percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) are performed to treat renal stones, and miniature PCNL (mPCNL) is used as an alternative to conventional PCNL. We conducted a systematic review of published studies regarding RIRS, PCNL, and mPCNL and performed network meta-analysis on successful outcome (stone-free) rates. Materials and Methods: The PubMed and EMBASE databases were searched up to December 2020. Data extraction formats were used to extract data on successful outcome rates, study designs, numbers of subjects and characteristics, and methods used to treat renal stones (i.e., RIRS, PCNL, or mPCNL). Results: Data obtained by 25 studies were used to compare the stone-free rates of RIRS, PCNL, and mPCNL; six comparisons of PCNL and mPCNL, seven of mPCNL and RIRS, and 12 of RIRS and PCNL were analyzed. No difference was found between the stone-free rates of PCNL and mPCNL (odds ratio [OR]: 0.96; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.51-1.9) by network meta-analysis. However, the stone-free rate of RIRS was lower than that of mPCNL (OR: 0.41; 95% CI: 0.021-0.82) and PCNL (OR: 0.43; 95% CI: 0.22-0.82). Ranking analysis ranked mPCNL as No. 1 and PCNL as No. 2. Conclusions: PCNL and mPCNL had better stone-free rates than RIRS for the treatment of renal stones, but the treatment outcomes of PCNL and mPCNL were no different.

Abstract

Purpose: Retrograde intrarenal surgery (RIRS) and percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) are performed to treat renal stones, and miniature PCNL (mPCNL) is used as an alternative to conventional PCNL. We conducted a systematic review of published studies regarding RIRS, PCNL, and mPCNL and performed network meta-analysis on successful outcome (stone-free) rates. Materials and Methods: The PubMed and EMBASE databases were searched up to December 2020. Data extraction formats were used to extract data on successful outcome rates, study designs, numbers of subjects and characteristics, and methods used to treat renal stones (i.e., RIRS, PCNL, or mPCNL). Results: Data obtained by 25 studies were used to compare the stone-free rates of RIRS, PCNL, and mPCNL; six comparisons of PCNL and mPCNL, seven of mPCNL and RIRS, and 12 of RIRS and PCNL were analyzed. No difference was found between the stone-free rates of PCNL and mPCNL (odds ratio [OR]: 0.96; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.51-1.9) by network meta-analysis. However, the stone-free rate of RIRS was lower than that of mPCNL (OR: 0.41; 95% CI: 0.021-0.82) and PCNL (OR: 0.43; 95% CI: 0.22-0.82). Ranking analysis ranked mPCNL as No. 1 and PCNL as No. 2. Conclusions: PCNL and mPCNL had better stone-free rates than RIRS for the treatment of renal stones, but the treatment outcomes of PCNL and mPCNL were no different.

참고문헌 (61)

  1. Hennessey DB, "Mini PCNL for renal calculi: does size matter?", BJU Int, 119(Suppl 5), pp.39~46 (2017)
  2. Helal M, "The Hickman peel-away sheath : alternative for pediatric percutaneous nephrolithotomy", J Endourol, 11, pp.171~172 (1997)
  3. Nariman Gadzhiev, "Evaluation of the effect of Bernoulli maneuver on operative time during mini-percutaneous nephrolithotomy: A prospective randomized study", Investigative and Clinical Urology, 58(3), pp.179~185 (2017), 대한비뇨의학회[DOI]
  4. Sakr A, "Minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy vs standard PCNL for management of renal stones in the flank-free modified supine position : single-center experience", Urolithiasis, 45, pp.585~589 (2017)
  5. Giusti G, "Miniperc? No, thank you!", Eur Urol, 51, pp.810~814 (2007)
  6. Lahme S, "Minimally invasive PCNL in patients with renal pelvic and calyceal stones", Eur Urol, 40, pp.619~624 (2001)
  7. Turk C, "EAU guidelines on interventional treatment for urolithiasis", Eur Urol, 69, pp.475~482 (2016)
  8. Lawler AC, "Extracorporeal shock wave therapy : current perspectives and future directions", Curr Urol Rep, 18, pp.25~ (2017)
  9. 강호원, "Predictive factors and treatment outcomes of Steinstrasse following shock wave lithotripsy for ureteral calculi: A Bayesian regression model analysis", Investigative and Clinical Urology, 59(2), pp.112~118 (2018), 대한비뇨의학회[DOI]
  10. 한덕현, "Stone-breaking and retrieval strategy during retrograde intrarenal surgery", Investigative and Clinical Urology, 57(4), pp.229~230 (2016), 대한비뇨의학회[DOI]
  11. Lee JY, "Intraoperative and postoperative feasibility and safety of total tubeless, tubeless, small-bore tube, and standard percutaneous nephrolithotomy : a systematic review and network meta-analysis of 16 randomized controlled trials", BMC Urol, 17, pp.48~ (2017)
  12. Lu Y, "Randomized prospective trial of tubeless versus conventional minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy", World J Urol, 31, pp.1303~1307 (2013)
  13. Caldwell DM, "Simultaneous comparison of multiple treatments : combining direct and indirect evidence", BMJ, 331, pp.897~900 (2005)
  14. Mills EJ, "Demystifying trial networks and network meta-analysis", BMJ, 346, pp.f2914~ (2013)
  15. Kang DH, "Comparison of high, intermediate, and low frequency shock wave lithotripsy for urinary tract stone disease : systematic review and network meta-analysis", PLoS One, 11, pp.e0158661~ (2016)
  16. Moher D, "Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses : the PRISMA statement", PLoS Med, 6, pp.e1000097~ (2009)
  17. Nomura K, "Effect of smoking on hearing loss : quality assessment and meta-analysis", Prev Med, 40, pp.138~144 (2005)
  18. Macfarlane TV, "Systematic review of population-based epidemiological studies of oro-facial pain", J Dent, 29, pp.451~467 (2001)
  19. Higgins JP, "Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses", BMJ, 327, pp.557~560 (2003)
  20. 이주용, "Meta-Analysis of the Relationship between CXCR4 Expression and Metastasis in Prostate Cancer", The World Journal of Men's Health, 32(3), pp.167~175 (2014), 대한남성과학회
  21. Fleiss JL, "Analysis of data from multiclinic trials", Control Clin Trials, 7, pp.267~275 (1986)
  22. L'Abbe KA, "Meta-analysis in clinical research", Ann Intern Med, 107, pp.224~233 (1987)
  23. Galbraith RF, "A note on graphical presentation of estimated odds ratios from several clinical trials", Stat Med, 7, pp.889~894 (1988)
  24. Cheng F, "Minimally invasive tract in percutaneous nephrolithotomy for renal stones", J Endourol, 24, pp.1579~1582 (2010)
  25. Knoll T, "Do patients benefit from miniaturized tubeless percutaneous nephrolithotomy? A comparative prospective study", J Endourol, 24, pp.1075~1079 (2010)
  26. Li LY, "Does a smaller tract in percutaneous nephrolithotomy contribute to less invasiveness? A prospective comparative study", Urology, 75, pp.56~61 (2010)
  27. Mishra S, "Prospective comparative study of miniperc and standard PNL for treatment of 1 to 2 cm size renal stone", BJU Int, 108, pp.896~899 (2011)
  28. Song L, "The application of a patented system to minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy", J Endourol, 25, pp.1281~1286 (2011)
  29. Zhong W, "Minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy with multiple mini tracts in a single session in treating staghorn calculi", Urol Res, 39, pp.117~122 (2011)
  30. Xu S, "A prospective comparative study of haemodynamic, electrolyte, and metabolic changes during percutaneous nephrolithotomy and minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy", World J Urol, 32, pp.1275~1280 (2014)
  31. Hyams ES, "Percutaneous nephrostolithotomy versus flexible ureteroscopy", holmium laser lithotripsy : cost and outcome analysis, 2009, pp.182, 1012~1017
  32. Akman T, "Comparison of percutaneous nephrolithotomy and retrograde flexible nephrolithotripsy for the management of 2-4 cm stones : a matched-pair analysis", BJU Int, 109, pp.1384~1389 (2012)
  33. Bozkurt OF, "Retrograde intrarenal surgery versus percutaneous nephrolithotomy in the management of lower-pole renal stones with a diameter of 15to 20 mm", J Endourol, 25, pp.1131~1135 (2011)
  34. Aboutaleb H, "Lower pole midsize(1-2 cm)calyceal stones : outcome analysis of 56 cases", Urol Int, 89, pp.348~354 (2012)
  35. Bryniarski P, "A randomized controlled study to analyze the safety and efficacy of percutaneous nephrolithotripsy and retrograde intrarenal surgery in the management of renal stones more than 2 cm in diameter", J Endourol, 26, pp.52~57 (2012)
  36. Ozturk U, "Comparison of percutaneous nephrolithotomy, shock wave lithotripsy, and retrograde intrarenal surgery for lower pole renal calculi 10-20 mm", Urol Int, 91, pp.345~349 (2013)
  37. Resorlu B, "Comparison of retrograde intrarenal surgery, shockwave lithotripsy, and percutaneous nephrolithotomy for treatment of medium-sized radiolucent renal stones", World J Urol, 31, pp.1581~1586 (2013)
  38. Bas O, "Comparison of shock wave lithotripsy, flexible ureterorenoscopy and percutaneous nephrolithotripsy on moderate size renal pelvis stones", Urolithiasis, 42, pp.115~120 (2014)
  39. 정규환, "Comparison of retrograde intrarenal surgery versus a single-session percutaneous nephrolithotomy for lower-pole stones with a diameter of 15 to 30 mm: A propensity score-matching study", Investigative and Clinical Urology, 56(7), pp.525~532 (2015), 대한비뇨의학회[DOI]
  40. Karakoyunlu N, "A comparison of standard PCNL and staged retrograde FURS in pelvis stones over 2 cm in diameter : a prospective randomized study", Urolithiasis, 43, pp.283~287 (2015)
  41. Resorlu B, "Comparison of retrograde intrarenal surgery and mini-percutaneous nephrolithotomy in children with moderate-size kidney stones : results of multi-institutional analysis", Urology, 80, pp.519~523 (2012)
  42. Kirac M, "Comparison of retrograde intrarenal surgery and mini-percutaneous nephrolithotomy in management of lower-pole renal stones with a diameter of smaller than 15 mm", Urolithiasis, 41, pp.241~246 (2013)
  43. Pan J, "RIRS versus mPCNL for single renal stone of 2-3 cm : clinical outcome and cost-effective analysis in Chinese medical setting", Urolithiasis, 41, pp.73~78 (2013)
  44. Sabnis RB, "Treating renal calculi 1-2cm in diameter with minipercutaneous or retrograde intrarenal surgery : a prospective comparative study", BJU Int, 110(8Pt B), pp.E346~E349 (2012)
  45. Kumar A, "A prospective, randomized comparison of shock wave lithotripsy, retrograde intrarenal surgery and miniperc for treatment of 1 to 2 cm radiolucent lower calyceal renal calculi : a single center experience", J Urol, 193, pp.160~164 (2015)
  46. Lee JW, "Mini-percutaneous nephrolithotomy vs retrograde intrarenal surgery for renal stones larger than 10 mm : a prospective randomized controlled trial", Urology, 86, pp.873~877 (2015)
  47. Zeng G, "The comparison of minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy and retrograde intrarenal surgery for stones larger than 2 cm in patients with a solitary kidney : a matched-pair analysis", World J Urol, 33, pp.1159~1164 (2015)
  48. Rucker G, "Ranking treatments in frequentist network meta-analysis works without resampling methods", BMC Med Res Methodol, 15, pp.58~ (2015)
  49. 정재용, "Digital Videoscopic Retrograde Intrarenal Surgeries for Renal Stones: Time-to-Maximal Stone Length Ratio Analysis", Yonsei Medical Journal, 59(2), pp.303~309 (2018), 연세대학교의과대학[DOI]
  50. 정해도, "Real-time simultaneous endoscopic combined intrarenal surgery with intermediate-supine position: Washout mechanism and transport technique", Investigative and Clinical Urology, 59(5), pp.348~354 (2018), 대한비뇨의학회[DOI]
  51. Nagele U, "A newly designed amplatz sheath decreases intrapelvic irrigation pressure during mini-percutaneous nephrolitholapaxy : an in-vitro pressure-measurement and microscopic study", J Endourol, 21, pp.1113~1116 (2007)
  52. Loftus CJ, "Mini versus standard percutaneous nephrolithotomy : the impact of sheath size on intrarenal pelvic pressure and infectious complications in a porcine model", J Endourol, 32, pp.350~353 (2018)
  53. Atalay HA, "Evaluation of stone volume distribution in renal collecting system as a predictor of stone-free rate after percutaneous nephrolithotomy : a retrospective single-center study", Urolithiasis, 46, pp.303~309 (2018)
  54. Jiang H, "Minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy versus retrograde intrarenal surgery for upper urinary stones : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Biomed Res Int, 2017, pp.2035851~ (2017)
  55. Kang SK, "Systematic review and meta-analysis to compare success rates of retrograde intrarenal surgery versus percutaneous nephrolithotomy for renal stones >2 cm: an update", Medicine(Baltimore), 96, pp.e9119~ (2017)
  56. Zheng C, "Retrograde intrarenal surgery versus percutaneous nephrolithotomy for treatment of renal stones >2 cm : a meta-analysis", Urol Int, 93, pp.417~424 (2014)
  57. Zhang W, "Retrograde intrarenal surgery versus percutaneous nephrolithotomy versus extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy for treatment of lower pole renal stones : a meta-analysis and systematic review", J Endourol, 29, pp.745~759 (2015)
  58. Zhu W, "Minimally invasive versus standard percutaneous nephrolithotomy : a meta-analysis", Urolithiasis, 43, pp.563~570 (2015)
  59. Proietti S, "A critical review of miniaturised percutaneous nephrolithotomy: is smaller better?", Eur Urol Focus, 3, pp.56~61 (2017)
  60. Jackman SV, "The "mini-perc" technique: a less invasive alternative to percutaneous nephrolithotomy", World J Urol, 16, pp.371~374 (1998)
  61. Nicklas AP, "The vacuum cleaner effect in minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolitholapaxy", World J Urol, 33, pp.1847~1853 (2015)

관련 논문AI추천

Digital Videoscopic Retrograde Intrarenal Surgeries for Renal Stones: Time-to-Maximal Stone Length Ratio Analysis강동혁, 김종찬, 이주용, 정재용연세대학교의과대학 · Yonsei Medical Journal2018 · 제59권 제2호The First 100 Cases of Endoscopic Combined Intrarenal Surgery in Korea: Matched Cohort Analyses versus Shock-Wave Lithotripsy문영준, 이주용, 정해도, Ahmad J. Almujalhem, Ali Abdullah Alqahtani, Mohammed Ali Alkhureeb연세대학교의과대학 · Yonsei Medical Journal2022 · 제63권 제5호Does Early Retrograde Intrarenal Surgery Improve the Cost-Effectiveness of Renal Stone Management?권순홍, 양소영, 이선희, 이의경, 이주용, 정해도연세대학교의과대학 · Yonsei Medical Journal2020 · 제61권 제6호Effect of Residual Stone Fragments on Patient-Reported Quality of Life after Endoscopic Kidney Stone SurgeryBum Soo Kim, Eun Sang Yoo, Hyun Tae Kim, Jae-Wook Chung, Jun-Koo Kang, Jun Nyung Lee, Sang Hee Lee, Seock Hwan Choi, Tae Gyun Kwon, Tae-Hwan Kim, Yun-Sok Ha대한요로생식기감염학회 · Urogenital Tract Infection2024 · 제19권 제2호Comparison of three different endoscopic approaches in the treatment of bladder calculi고영휘, 송필현, 최재영, Jae Youn Jang영남대학교 의과대학 · Journal of Yeungnam Medical Science2019 · 제36권 제1호Perioperative Risk Factors Related to Systemic Inflammatory Response Syndrome after Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy정호석, Seung Il Jung대한요로생식기감염학회 · Urogenital Tract Infection2019 · 제14권 제1호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (3건)