본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

한국과 필리핀의 법치주의 실현에 대한 비교법적 연구

Comparative Study for Actualization of Constitutionalism in Philippines and Korea

1

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

초록

This study looks at the Philippines and Korea from the standing point of comparative law to find out ways for actualization of constitutionalism and the problems that arise. Thus, five methods for realization of constitutionalism for both countries are laid out. Firstly, national security system must be strengthened to prevent invasion of foreign powers. To be ready for war and to be ready to defend the country, both countries must put efforts to build up national power and cooperate with its allies to adapt to Korea's peaceful unification plan and contribute to world peace in the long run. Secondly, constitutionalism must be realized. In other words,all national actions must abide by rule of law. Realization of constitutionalism involves politically liberal principles such as ensuring all the basic human rights for all its citizens,distributing government power to three branches of judicial,legislative, and executive and establish system of checks and balances between each to prevent concentration of power, and ensuring freedom of people from abuse of government power. Thus justice must be upheld in all establishment, execution, and judgement of the law. Thirdly, principle of democratic state must be realized. Principle of democratic state is a constitutional principle that democracy is the guiding principle in the state arena. Because the state is composition of government authority to realize public ideals, in no case the state should use its authority arbitrarily. The state cannot be justified for its itself, but exists for the purpose of maintaining the community and realizing the members'freedoms and rights. Because the owner of the community is its members, the existence of the state must be justified by its members. Today, the principle that the members of the community is the owner of the community is established as popular sovereignty and the state is established, maintained, and operated by the principle of democracy. Fourthly, the economy must be revitalized. Above all, an economic order suitable for market economy must be established. Thus the government strictly execute regulations related to economic activities and the corporations and individuals must compete within the borders set by the law. The constitution allows for state intervention in the economy in order to keep the function of the market sound. Such state intervention, as it is executed for the purpose of protecting the people's economic activities, keeping functions of the economy,and ensuring social security, must abide by the consitutional principles of subsidiarity, of trust and protection, and of proportionality, as well as prohibition of retrospective deprivation of private property. Also, all economic actors, in the course of their economic activities, must consider equity as well as efficiency. They also must practice economic ethics and build trust through their role in society. Fifthly measure is revitalization of civil society movements. Civil movements have a large influence today and the assessment of the movement is quite positive. In other words,civil movements receive highly positive assessment because it pursues social publicness through gradual, non-violent, peaceful,and legal actions. The role of civil movement is firstly to monitor and criticize state authority, secondly to suggest,request, and institutionalize policies that represent public Civil society movements must act as control and monitor watchdog for authoritarian nation, centralization, and local autonomy. For that, it is necessary to implement new policies to strengthen the role of medium between the existing system and the informal system. Also, it is necessary to develop policies in current system of policies and regulations. Furthermore, it is needed to expand education for citizens and communication with the civil society using community organizations such as schools and corporations to enhance public interests. Democracy in Philippines and Korea. This study looks at the Philippines and Korea from the standing point of comparative law to find out ways for actualization of constitutionalism and the problems that arise. Thus, five methods for realization of constitutionalism for both countries are laid out. Firstly, national security system must be strengthened to prevent invasion of foreign powers. To be ready for war and to be ready to defend the country, both countries must put efforts to build up national power and cooperate with its allies to adapt to Korea's peaceful unification plan and contribute to world peace in the long run. Secondly, constitutionalism must be realized. In other words,all national actions must abide by rule of law. Realization of constitutionalism involves politically liberal principles such as ensuring all the basic human rights for all its citizens,distributing government power to three branches of judicial,legislative, and executive and establish system of checks and balances between each to prevent concentration of power, and ensuring freedom of people from abuse of government power. Thus justice must be upheld in all establishment, execution, and judgement of the law. Thirdly, principle of democratic state must be realized. Principle of democratic state is a constitutional principle that democracy is the guiding principle in the state arena. Because the state is composition of government authority to realize public ideals, in no case the state should use its authority arbitrarily. The state cannot be justified for its itself, but exists for the purpose of maintaining the community and realizing the members'freedoms and rights. Because the owner of the community is its members, the existence of the state must be justified by its members. Today, the principle that the members of the community is the owner of the community is established as popular sovereignty and the state is established, maintained, and operated by the principle of democracy. Fourthly, the economy must be revitalized. Above all, an economic order suitable for market economy must be established. Thus the government strictly execute regulations related to economic activities and the corporations and individuals must compete within the borders set by the law. The constitution allows for state intervention in the economy in order to keep the function of the market sound. Such state intervention, as it is executed for the purpose of protecting the people's economic activities, keeping functions of the economy,and ensuring social security, must abide by the consitutional principles of subsidiarity, of trust and protection, and of proportionality, as well as prohibition of retrospective deprivation of private property. Also, all economic actors, in the course of their economic activities, must consider equity as well as efficiency. They also must practice economic ethics and build trust through their role in society. Fifthly measure is revitalization of civil society movements. Civil movements have a large influence today and the assessment of the movement is quite positive. In other words,civil movements receive highly positive assessment because it pursues social publicness through gradual, non-violent, peaceful,and legal actions. The role of civil movement is firstly to monitor and criticize state authority, secondly to suggest,request, and institutionalize policies that represent public Civil society movements must act as control and monitor watchdog for authoritarian nation, centralization, and local autonomy. For that, it is necessary to implement new policies to strengthen the role of medium between the existing system and the informal system. Also, it is necessary to develop policies in the public interest and put efforts to solve problems in the current system of policies and regulations. Furthermore, it is needed to expand education for citizens and communication with the civil society using community organizations such as schools and corporations to enhance public interests.

Abstract

This study looks at the Philippines and Korea from the standing point of comparative law to find out ways for actualization of constitutionalism and the problems that arise. Thus, five methods for realization of constitutionalism for both countries are laid out. Firstly, national security system must be strengthened to prevent invasion of foreign powers. To be ready for war and to be ready to defend the country, both countries must put efforts to build up national power and cooperate with its allies to adapt to Korea's peaceful unification plan and contribute to world peace in the long run. Secondly, constitutionalism must be realized. In other words,all national actions must abide by rule of law. Realization of constitutionalism involves politically liberal principles such as ensuring all the basic human rights for all its citizens,distributing government power to three branches of judicial,legislative, and executive and establish system of checks and balances between each to prevent concentration of power, and ensuring freedom of people from abuse of government power. Thus justice must be upheld in all establishment, execution, and judgement of the law. Thirdly, principle of democratic state must be realized. Principle of democratic state is a constitutional principle that democracy is the guiding principle in the state arena. Because the state is composition of government authority to realize public ideals, in no case the state should use its authority arbitrarily. The state cannot be justified for its itself, but exists for the purpose of maintaining the community and realizing the members'freedoms and rights. Because the owner of the community is its members, the existence of the state must be justified by its members. Today, the principle that the members of the community is the owner of the community is established as popular sovereignty and the state is established, maintained, and operated by the principle of democracy. Fourthly, the economy must be revitalized. Above all, an economic order suitable for market economy must be established. Thus the government strictly execute regulations related to economic activities and the corporations and individuals must compete within the borders set by the law. The constitution allows for state intervention in the economy in order to keep the function of the market sound. Such state intervention, as it is executed for the purpose of protecting the people's economic activities, keeping functions of the economy,and ensuring social security, must abide by the consitutional principles of subsidiarity, of trust and protection, and of proportionality, as well as prohibition of retrospective deprivation of private property. Also, all economic actors, in the course of their economic activities, must consider equity as well as efficiency. They also must practice economic ethics and build trust through their role in society. Fifthly measure is revitalization of civil society movements. Civil movements have a large influence today and the assessment of the movement is quite positive. In other words,civil movements receive highly positive assessment because it pursues social publicness through gradual, non-violent, peaceful,and legal actions. The role of civil movement is firstly to monitor and criticize state authority, secondly to suggest,request, and institutionalize policies that represent public Civil society movements must act as control and monitor watchdog for authoritarian nation, centralization, and local autonomy. For that, it is necessary to implement new policies to strengthen the role of medium between the existing system and the informal system. Also, it is necessary to develop policies in current system of policies and regulations. Furthermore, it is needed to expand education for citizens and communication with the civil society using community organizations such as schools and corporations to enhance public interests. Democracy in Philippines and Korea. This study looks at the Philippines and Korea from the standing point of comparative law to find out ways for actualization of constitutionalism and the problems that arise. Thus, five methods for realization of constitutionalism for both countries are laid out. Firstly, national security system must be strengthened to prevent invasion of foreign powers. To be ready for war and to be ready to defend the country, both countries must put efforts to build up national power and cooperate with its allies to adapt to Korea's peaceful unification plan and contribute to world peace in the long run. Secondly, constitutionalism must be realized. In other words,all national actions must abide by rule of law. Realization of constitutionalism involves politically liberal principles such as ensuring all the basic human rights for all its citizens,distributing government power to three branches of judicial,legislative, and executive and establish system of checks and balances between each to prevent concentration of power, and ensuring freedom of people from abuse of government power. Thus justice must be upheld in all establishment, execution, and judgement of the law. Thirdly, principle of democratic state must be realized. Principle of democratic state is a constitutional principle that democracy is the guiding principle in the state arena. Because the state is composition of government authority to realize public ideals, in no case the state should use its authority arbitrarily. The state cannot be justified for its itself, but exists for the purpose of maintaining the community and realizing the members'freedoms and rights. Because the owner of the community is its members, the existence of the state must be justified by its members. Today, the principle that the members of the community is the owner of the community is established as popular sovereignty and the state is established, maintained, and operated by the principle of democracy. Fourthly, the economy must be revitalized. Above all, an economic order suitable for market economy must be established. Thus the government strictly execute regulations related to economic activities and the corporations and individuals must compete within the borders set by the law. The constitution allows for state intervention in the economy in order to keep the function of the market sound. Such state intervention, as it is executed for the purpose of protecting the people's economic activities, keeping functions of the economy,and ensuring social security, must abide by the consitutional principles of subsidiarity, of trust and protection, and of proportionality, as well as prohibition of retrospective deprivation of private property. Also, all economic actors, in the course of their economic activities, must consider equity as well as efficiency. They also must practice economic ethics and build trust through their role in society. Fifthly measure is revitalization of civil society movements. Civil movements have a large influence today and the assessment of the movement is quite positive. In other words,civil movements receive highly positive assessment because it pursues social publicness through gradual, non-violent, peaceful,and legal actions. The role of civil movement is firstly to monitor and criticize state authority, secondly to suggest,request, and institutionalize policies that represent public Civil society movements must act as control and monitor watchdog for authoritarian nation, centralization, and local autonomy. For that, it is necessary to implement new policies to strengthen the role of medium between the existing system and the informal system. Also, it is necessary to develop policies in the public interest and put efforts to solve problems in the current system of policies and regulations. Furthermore, it is needed to expand education for citizens and communication with the civil society using community organizations such as schools and corporations to enhance public interests.

참고문헌 (53)

  1. 권률, "동아시아의 교역 및 투자구조 분석", 19(1) (2005), 인하대 산업경제연구소
  2. 김창록, "한국의 법체계는 어디로 나아가고 있는가", 법학연구 (1997), 부산대학교 법학연구
  3. 변종화, "헌법학개론" (2007), 두오출판미디어
  4. 김호범, "식민지기 필리핀의 토지제도", 경제학논집, 10(2) (2001), 한국국민경제학회
  5. 김호범, "필리핀의 토지제도와 농지개혁", 경제학논집, 8(2) (1998), 한국국민경제학회
  6. 류시조, "법치주의의 전개와 현대적 과제", 비교법학, 11 (2000), 부산외국어대학교 비교법연구소
  7. 박일경, "평화보장체제의 허상과 실상" (1993)
  8. 박희호, "혼합법계로서의 필리핀 법체계에 대한 소고 - 혼합법계의 형성과정 및 그 내용을 중심으로 -", 비교사법, 15(2), pp.51~81 (2008), 한국비교사법학회
  9. 서경교, "필리핀의 민주주의: 민주화 과정을 통한 고찰", 동남아시아연구, 15(1), pp.1~39 (2005), 한국동남아학회
  10. 박승우, "민주적 이행 이후 필리핀 민주주의의 성격과 한계", 동남아시아연구, 19(3), pp.137~186 (2009), 한국동남아학회
  11. 박희호, "혼합법계로서의 필리핀 법체계에 대한 소고 - 혼합법계의 형성과정 및 그 내용을 중심으로", 비교사법, 15(2), pp.51~81 (2008), 한국비교사법학회
  12. 연점숙, "한국과 필리핀의 식민 저항시 비교 연구", 비교한국학, 9 (2001), 국제비교한국학회
  13. 유정현, "법치주의에 관한 연구", 법학연구, 7 (1985), 원광대학교
  14. 육종수, "한국헌법과 필리핀헌법의 비교", 영광문화, 9 (1986), 대구대학교
  15. 고경호, "헌법학원론" (2006), 법영사
  16. 최종고, "아시아법의 법계와 체계", (1) (2004), 아시아법제연구원(한국법제연구원)
  17. 최영규, "한국의 법치주의", 영남법학, 18 (2002)
  18. "헌재 1991. 7. 22, 89헌가 106, 헌재판례집 제3권", ~ (1991)
  19. "5.10선거와 필리핀 민주주의의 현주소"[URL]
  20. "제2부 필리핀 사회운동과 NGO 성공회대 사회복지학과 교수 홈페이지", 이영환[URL]
  21. "국제투명성기구"[URL]
  22. "세계은행. 지니계수"[URL]
  23. "UNU-WIDER. 지니계수"[URL]
  24. "ttp://k.daum.net/qna/view.html?category_id=QQO&qid=3xO3n&q=%B8%B6%C1%A9%B6%F5"[URL]

관련 논문AI추천

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (12건)