두통에 대한 이혈 방혈요법의 유효성 분석: 체계적 문헌고찰 및 메타분석
Effectiveness of Auricular Blood-letting Therapy for Headaches: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
2
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Objectives: The purpose of this study was to provide clinical evidence to support the use of auricular blood-letting therapy (ABT) for headaches. Methods: Studies were identified by a comprehensive search of five databases. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that investigated the effects of the ABT for headaches were included. Two authors independently extracted the data and assessed the methodological quality of the included studies using Cochrane’s risk-of-bias tool. If two or more studies reported the same outcome, a meta-analysis was performed. Meta-analysis results for dichotomous variables are expressed as risk ratios (RRs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs). Results: A total of eight RCTs were included in this review. The total effective rate (TER) was the most commonly used outcome measurement. Among the eight RCTs, five were included in the metaanalysis. The TER was not statistically significantly different in the ABT group compared to the medication group (two studies, n=55, RR=1.24, 95% CI: 0.78 to 1.96, p=0.36, I2=86%). However, the TER of the combined ABT and medication group was significantly different compared to the medication alone group (four studies, n=159, RR=1.23, 95% CI: 1.12 to 1.35, p<0.0001, I2= 0%). Pain and mental health-related outcomes in the combined ABT and medication group were significantly different from the control groups. The methodological quality of the included RCTs was generally low. Conclusions: ABT combined with medication may be effective for treating headaches. However, the number of studies included was small, so the results were insufficient, and statistically significant effects were not confirmed for a single implementation of ABT. Thus, well-designed further studies based on the findings of this study are recommended.
Abstract
Objectives: The purpose of this study was to provide clinical evidence to support the use of auricular blood-letting therapy (ABT) for headaches. Methods: Studies were identified by a comprehensive search of five databases. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that investigated the effects of the ABT for headaches were included. Two authors independently extracted the data and assessed the methodological quality of the included studies using Cochrane’s risk-of-bias tool. If two or more studies reported the same outcome, a meta-analysis was performed. Meta-analysis results for dichotomous variables are expressed as risk ratios (RRs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs). Results: A total of eight RCTs were included in this review. The total effective rate (TER) was the most commonly used outcome measurement. Among the eight RCTs, five were included in the metaanalysis. The TER was not statistically significantly different in the ABT group compared to the medication group (two studies, n=55, RR=1.24, 95% CI: 0.78 to 1.96, p=0.36, I2=86%). However, the TER of the combined ABT and medication group was significantly different compared to the medication alone group (four studies, n=159, RR=1.23, 95% CI: 1.12 to 1.35, p<0.0001, I2= 0%). Pain and mental health-related outcomes in the combined ABT and medication group were significantly different from the control groups. The methodological quality of the included RCTs was generally low. Conclusions: ABT combined with medication may be effective for treating headaches. However, the number of studies included was small, so the results were insufficient, and statistically significant effects were not confirmed for a single implementation of ABT. Thus, well-designed further studies based on the findings of this study are recommended.
참고문헌 (46)
- Saylor D, "The global burden of headache", Semin Neurol, 38, pp.182~190 (2018)
- "Classification and diagnostic criteria for headache disorders, cranial neuralgias and facial pain. Headache Classification Committee of the International Headache Society", Cephalalgia, 8(Suppl 7), pp.1~96 (1988)
- "The International Classification of Headache Disorders:2nd edition", Cephalalgia, 24(Suppl 1), pp.9~160 (2004)
- "The International Classification of Headache Disorders, 3rd edition (beta version)", Cephalalgia, 33, pp.629~808 (2013)
- Becker WJ, "Guideline for primary care management of headache in adults", Can Fam Physician, 61, pp.670~679 (2015)
- Kristoffersen ES, "Medication-overuse headache : epidemiology, diagnosis and treatment", Ther Adv Drug Saf, 5, pp.87~99 (2014)
- Cheema S, "Cluster headache: what’s new?", Neurol India, 69, pp.S124~s34 (2021)
- 손종희, "군발두통 치료의 최신지견", 대한신경과학회지, 39(3), pp.113~120 (2021), 대한신경과학회
- The Textbook Compilation Committee of Neuropsychiatry of Oriental Medical Schools in Nation, "The Neuropsychiatry of Oriental medicine" (2016), Jipmoondang
- 황정현, "『東醫寶鑑』 十種頭痛을 중심으로 한 두통 처방의轉寫에 대한 연구", 동의신경정신과학회지, 23(2), pp.129~146 (2012), 대한한방신경정신과학회[DOI]
- Acupuncture Medicine, "Hanmibook: The Korean Acupuncture & Moxibstion Medicine Society" (2020), The Textbook Compilation Committee
- Jing N, "Effectiveness and safety of auricular acupoint bloodletting in treatment of insomnia : an assessor-blinded pilot randomized controlled trial", Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 38, pp.763~768 (2018)
- Kwon C-Y, "Efficacy and safety of bloodletting on ear apex for primary hypertension : A systematic review and meta-analysis", European Journal of Integrative Medicine, 23, pp.90~100 (2018)
- Liberati A, "The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration", Bmj, 339, pp.b2700~ (2009)
- Higgins JP, "Assessing risk of bias in included studies. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions:Cochrane book series", pp.187~241 (2008)
- Liu K, "Observation on curative effect of ear tip bloodletting combined with Songling Xuemaikang capsule in treating head wind with hyperactivity of liver yang", 2013 Zhejiang Acupuncture Society Annual Meeting and Academic Exchange Meeting (2013)
- Guo Y, "Clinical observation on the curative effect of acupuncture and relief on migraine of blood stasis blocking brain collateral type", Master's, pp.2019
- Fang Z, "Clinical study on ear tip bloodletting combined with acupuncture in treating migraine with hyperactivity of liver yang", Master’s, pp.2011
- Wang Z, "Immediate and long-term curative effect observation on ear tip bloodletting combined with electroacupuncture in treating migraine", Master’s, pp.2014
- Liu Y, "Study on the immediate analgesic effect and mechanism of ear dorsal vein bloodletting in the treatment of migraine without aura", Master’s, pp.2011
- Zhang L, "Clinical study on ear tip bloodletting combined with acupuncture in the treatment of migraine of stasis blocking collateral type", Master’s, pp.2019
- Zhang Y, "Clinical study on migraine of hyperactivity of liver-yang type treated by pricking collaterals and bloodletting combined with Tianma Gouteng Decoction", Master’s, pp.2015
- Yang F, "Clinical observation on antihypertensive effect of ear tip bloodletting and acupuncture on the antihypertensive effect of primary hypertension with hyperactivity of liver fire", Master’s, pp.2010
- Zhang X, "Etiology, pathogenesis and syndrome differentiation treatment of vascular headache", Practical Clinical Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine, (03), pp.74~76 (2004)
- Li P, "Clinical observation on 28 cases of intractable headache treated by pricking and bloodletting at the back of the ear", Journal of Clinical Acupuncture and Moxibustion, (07), pp.45~ (2006)
- Sun X, "120Cases of angioneurotic headache treated by bloodletting from dorsal ear vein", Shanghai Journal of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, (01), pp.17~23 (1988)
- Wang H, "Effect of auricular point pricking combined with mugwort moxibustion on clinical symptoms and quality of life in patients with chronic tension-type headache", Modern Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine, 30, pp.1002~1005 (2021)
- Wang J, "Optimized schemes for acupuncture treatment of migraine during attack", Acupuncture Research, 38, pp.234~240 (2013)
- Wang Q, "Study on the best solution of immediate analgesia of acupuncture for migraine", Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion, 30, pp.798~801 (2010)
- Gao G, "Observation on clinical curative effect of auricular point pricking method in treating vascular headache", Inner Mongol Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 36, pp.60~61 (2017)
- Huang Y, "Observation on curative effect of ear tip bloodletting combined with Songling Xuemaikang capsule in treating headache with hyperactivity of liver-yang", Chinese Journal of Traditional Medical Science and Technology, 21, pp.199~200 (2014)
- Li B, "Clinical study on the treatment of migraine by ear point pricking and bloodletting combined with massage", Chinese Manipulation & Rehabilitation Medicine, 7, pp.19~20 (2016)
- Lyu J, "65 Cases of migrainous headache due to hyperhepatic Yang treated with bloodletting on top of ears", Henan Traditional Chinese Medicine, 35, pp.162~163 (2015)
- Pei F, "Efficacy observation of collateral pricking at auricular points combined with moxibustion for chronic tension-type headache and its effects on mental symptoms", Shanghai J Acu-mox, 40, pp.1075~1080 (2021)
- Yu Q, "Observation on the effect of ear bloodletting therapy in patients with head traumatic headache", Nursing and Rehabilitation Journal, 15, pp.597~599 (2016)
- Zhu P, "Curative effect observation on 30 cases of traumatic headache treated by auricular point bloodletting", Zhejiang JITCWM, 26, pp.749~750 (2016)
- Zhu Z, "Efficacy of auricular bloodletting combined with Chuanxiong Qingnao granules in the treatment of primary headache", Journal of Mathematical Medicine, 34, pp.111~112 (2021)
- Dai Y, "Comparison of Chinese and international psychiatrists’views on classification of mental disorders", Asia Pac Psychiatry, 6, pp.267~273 (2014)
- 이정소, "ICHD 분류에 따른 원발 두통의 한의학적 변증 연구", 동의생리병리학회지, 31(4), pp.201~212 (2017), 한의병리학회[DOI]
- Li J, "Simple analysis on collateral therapy in Huangdi’s Internal Classic", Zhongguo Zhen Jiu, 25, pp.889~892 (2005)
- 차지윤, "FCST(기능적 뇌척주요법)를 병행한 한의 치료로 만성편두통 환자의 두통과 오심을 치료한 증례 보고 1례", 대한한방내과학회지, 39(4), pp.784~793 (2018), 대한한방내과학회
- "P. W. Skills of traditional Chinese medicine: ear-acupoint pressing", pp.13~ (1999), Tianjin Medicine Science and Technology Press
- 최선엽, "이혈요법이 근골격계 통증에 미치는 효과: 체계적 문헌 고찰 및 메타분석", Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing, 52(1), pp.4~23 (2022), 한국간호과학회
- Oleson T, "Auriculotherapy manual: Chinese and Western systems of ear acupuncture", 1~464 (2013)
- 김난영, "귀반사요법이 여자대학생들의 월경통, 일상생활 장애, 부정적인 정서 및 자율신경계 반응에 미치는 효과", Journal of Korean Biological Nursing Science, 17(2), pp.159~168 (2015), 한국기초간호학회
- Tabatabaei F, "Effectiveness of wet cupping on patients with facial acne vulgaris : a 12-week, randomized, single-blind, interventionsham-controlled trial", Complement Med Res, 28, pp.508~515 (2021)