A Comparative Study on Failure Pprediction Models for Small and Medium Manufacturing Company
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study has analyzed predication capabilities leveraging multi-variate model, logistic regression model, and artificial neural network model based on financial information of medium-small sized companies list in KOSDAQ. 83 delisted companies from 2009 to 2012 and 83 normal companies, i.e. 166 firms in total were sampled for the analysis. Modelling with training data was mobilized for 100 companies inlcuding 50 delisted ones and 50 normal ones at random out of the 166 companies. The rest of samples, 66 companies, were used to verify accuracies of the models. Each model was designed by carrying out T-test with 79 financial ratios for the last 5 years and identifying 9 significant variables. T-test has shown that financial profitability variables were major variables to predict a financial risk at an early stage, and financial stability variables and financial cashflow variables were identified as additional significant variables at a later stage of insolvency. When predication capabilities of the models were compared, for training data, a logistic regression model exhibited the highest accuracy while for test data, the artificial neural networks model provided the most accurate results. There are differences between the previous researches and this study as follows. Firstly, this study considered a time-series aspect in light of the fact that failure proceeds gradually. Secondly, while previous studies constructed a multivariate discriminant model ignoring normality, this study has reviewed the regularity of the independent variables, and performed comparisons with the other models. Policy implications of this study is that the reliability for the disclosure documents is important because the simptoms of firm’s fail woule be shown on financial statements according to this paper. Therefore institutional arragements for restraing moral laxity from accounting firms or its workers should be strengthened.
Abstract
This study has analyzed predication capabilities leveraging multi-variate model, logistic regression model, and artificial neural network model based on financial information of medium-small sized companies list in KOSDAQ. 83 delisted companies from 2009 to 2012 and 83 normal companies, i.e. 166 firms in total were sampled for the analysis. Modelling with training data was mobilized for 100 companies inlcuding 50 delisted ones and 50 normal ones at random out of the 166 companies. The rest of samples, 66 companies, were used to verify accuracies of the models. Each model was designed by carrying out T-test with 79 financial ratios for the last 5 years and identifying 9 significant variables. T-test has shown that financial profitability variables were major variables to predict a financial risk at an early stage, and financial stability variables and financial cashflow variables were identified as additional significant variables at a later stage of insolvency. When predication capabilities of the models were compared, for training data, a logistic regression model exhibited the highest accuracy while for test data, the artificial neural networks model provided the most accurate results. There are differences between the previous researches and this study as follows. Firstly, this study considered a time-series aspect in light of the fact that failure proceeds gradually. Secondly, while previous studies constructed a multivariate discriminant model ignoring normality, this study has reviewed the regularity of the independent variables, and performed comparisons with the other models. Policy implications of this study is that the reliability for the disclosure documents is important because the simptoms of firm’s fail woule be shown on financial statements according to this paper. Therefore institutional arragements for restraing moral laxity from accounting firms or its workers should be strengthened.
참고문헌 (41)
- Altman, E. I., "Financial Ratios, Discriminant Analysis and Prediction of Corporate Bankruptcy", Journal of Finance, 23(4), pp.589~609 (1968)
- Distress Classification of Korean Firms, "Altman, E. I.", New York University, ~, pp.New York University, working paper series, FD-94-2, 1-38 (1994)
- Altman, E. I, "Analyze and Invest in Distressed Debt", pp.3~6 (2005), Joniley & Sons Inc
- Altman, E. I, "Evaluation of a Company as a Going Concern", Journal of Accounting, 138(6), pp.50~57 (1974)
- Back, B., "Neural Networks and Genetic Algorithms For Bankruptcy Predictions", Expert Systems With Applications, 11(4), pp.407~413 (1996)
- 배기수, "상장폐지기업 예측모형에 관한 실증연구", 세무회계연구, (30), pp.125~140 (2011), 한국세무회계학회
- Beaver, W. H., "Financial Ratios as Predictors of Failure", Journal of Accounting Research, 4(3), pp.71~111 (1966)
- Bhandari, S. B, "Predicting Business Failure Using Cash Flow Statement Based Measures", Managerial Finance, 39(7), pp.667~676 (2013)
- Chae, S. I., "Social Science Search Methodology" (2008), B&M Books press
- 최태성, "부실기업예측모형의 판별력 비교", 한국경영과학회지, 27(2), pp.1~13 (2002), 한국경영과학회
- "2013 Global Manufacturing Competitiveness Index" (2013)[URL]
- Deakin, E. B., "A Discriminant Analysis of Predictors of Business Failure", Journal of Accounting Research, 10(1), pp.167~179 (1972)
- Han, H. N., "A Comparative Study on the Predictability of Bankruptcy Model : Artificial Neural Networks Model and Logistics Regression Model", Management includes, Management Research Center of Inha University, 11(1), pp.215~236 (2006)
- Heo, M. H, "Data Mining Modeling and Case" (2008), Hannare Press
- Hwang, S. H., "A Study on Corporate Failure Prediction", Korean Accounting Review, 12(7), pp.57~78 (1991)
- Issah, M., "Predicting Corporate Failure of UK's Listed Companies Comparing Multiple Discriminant Ananlysis and Logistic Regression", pp.32~68 (2012), Lap LaMBERT Academic Publishing
- Jang, Y. K., "Business Analysis" (2012), Trading Management Sa Press
- Jeong, Y. S., "A Neural Network Model for Bankruptcy Prediction", Doctor, pp.2003
- Jeon, S. B, "Reality and Theory on Business Failure" (2000), Dasan Publishing Company
- Jo, Q. G., "A study on the prediction models of corporate failure", Master, pp.2005
- Jo, Y. J., "Data Mining Neural Network Analysis" (1999), SPAA academy Press
- 전현우, "상장폐지기업의 부실예측모형에 관한 연구 -거래소시장을 중심으로-", 국제회계연구, (38), pp.331~362 (2011), 한국국제회계학회
- 정경원, "신용보증지원 이후 중소기업의 부실예측모형에 대한 실증연구", 석사, 경영컨설팅학과, pp.2014
- Kang, H. C., "Introduction to SPSS Data Analysis" (2010), Jayou Academy
- Kim, C. K, "The Business Failure Prediction Model of Small and Medium-sized Firms", Journal of Social Science Research, 17, pp.111~132 (1998)
- Kim, G. C., "A study on corporate failure predictions by using audit opinions and accounting firm's characteristics", Doctor, pp.2011
- 김명종, "부스팅 인공신경망 학습의 기업부실예측 성과비교", 한국정보통신학회논문지, 14(1), pp.63~69 (2010), 한국정보통신학회
- 김수영, "다변량 판별분석과 로지스틱 회귀분석, 인공신경망 분석을 이용한 호텔 도산 예측", 관광학연구, 30(2), pp.53~75 (2006), 한국관광학회
- Kim, W. K, "A Study on Muti-variate Firm's Fail Prediction Model: Focus on MDA, Logit and Non-parametric Model", Journal of Management Research, 1, pp.5~36 (1990)
- Kueon, S. I., "Corporate Credit Analysis" (2012), Korea banking Institute press
- 권경섭, "국가연구개발기관 기술사업화 종합지원사업 성공요인에 관한 탐색적 연구 -세라믹히든챔피언사업을 중심으로-", 벤처창업연구, 7(1), pp.225~232 (2012), 한국벤처창업학회
- Lee, K, C., "A Comparative Study on the Bankruptcy Prediction Power of Statistical Model and AI Models : MDA, Inductive Learning, Neural Network", Journal of the Korean OR and MS Society, 18(2), pp.57~81 (1993)
- 문종건, "횡령ㆍ배임 및 최대주주변경을 고려한 부실기업예측모형 연구", 벤처창업연구, 9(1), pp.119~132 (2014), 한국벤처창업학회
- Nam, J. H., "The Cause of Business's Failure and the Analysis of the Bankruptcy Prediction Model", Journal of Money & Finance, 12(2), pp.77~107 (1998)
- Odom, M, "A neural networks model for bankruptcy prediction", Proceedings of the IEEE internation Conference on Neural Networks, 2, pp.163~168 (1990)
- 오희장, "도산예측에서 신용등급정보의 유용성", 경제연구, 23(2), pp.173~208 (2005), 한국경제통상학회
- Ohlson. J. A., "Financial Ratios and the Probabilistic Prediction of Bankruptcy", Journal of Accounting Research, 18(1), pp.109~131 (1980)
- Park, H. J., "An empirical study on the failure prediction model of the firms listed on the kosdaq", Doctor, pp.2008
- Park, S. E., "Multi-variate Discriminant Analysis and Logistic Regression Analysis" (2002), Minyoung Sa Press
- Razali, N. M, "Power comparisons of Shapiro-Wilk, Kolmogorov-Smirnov, Lilliefors and Anderson-Darling tests", Journal of Statistical Modeling and Analytics, 2(1), pp.21~33 (2011)
- Sarah, A, "Compare failure prediction nodels based on feature selection technique: Empirical case from Iran", Procedia Computer Science, 3, pp.568~573 (2011)