Revisiting Greenberg’s “Generalizations about Numeral Systems” (1978)
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This article examines seven of the 54 generalizations on numeral systems presented by Greenberg in 1978 either as absolute universals or as universal tendencies. Five of the generalizations deal with details of the arithmetic structure of numeral systems, with particular reference to the order of elements in the numeral expression and to the use of subtraction and related phenomena in numeral expressions. It is shown that the details of these generalizations need to be revised in light of new data, and argued that even the formulation of universal tendencies is problematic given the rarity of some of the phenomena at issue and the resulting difficulty of establishing statistically valid inferences. Two of the generalizations discuss fundamental properties of natural language numeral systems, namely whether they are necessarily finite, and whether they allow gaps. It is argued, contra Greenberg, that there are both natural number series that are infinite and those with gaps. Throughout, it is emphasized that only the careful formulation of the original generalizations by Greenberg has enabled us to progress in our understanding of these aspects of numeral systems in natural languages.
Abstract
This article examines seven of the 54 generalizations on numeral systems presented by Greenberg in 1978 either as absolute universals or as universal tendencies. Five of the generalizations deal with details of the arithmetic structure of numeral systems, with particular reference to the order of elements in the numeral expression and to the use of subtraction and related phenomena in numeral expressions. It is shown that the details of these generalizations need to be revised in light of new data, and argued that even the formulation of universal tendencies is problematic given the rarity of some of the phenomena at issue and the resulting difficulty of establishing statistically valid inferences. Two of the generalizations discuss fundamental properties of natural language numeral systems, namely whether they are necessarily finite, and whether they allow gaps. It is argued, contra Greenberg, that there are both natural number series that are infinite and those with gaps. Throughout, it is emphasized that only the careful formulation of the original generalizations by Greenberg has enabled us to progress in our understanding of these aspects of numeral systems in natural languages.
참고문헌 (26)
- Ali, J., "Using Numbers in Arabic" (2013), Georgetown University Press
- Mary Chimaobi Amaechi, "The Syntax of Po Tangle Numerals", Journal of Universal Language, 15(2), pp.35~54 (2014), 언어연구소
- Bárcena, A., "Arte y Vocabulario de la Lengua Toba", Revista del Museo de La Plata, 7, pp.189~227 (1896)
- Bowen, J., "Teach Yourself Welsh" (1960), English Universities Press
- Calder, G., "A Gaelic Grammar, Including a Chapter on Personal and Place Names" (1923), Gairm Publications
- "Numeral Systems of the World’s Languages" (2020)[URL]
- Comrie, B., "Bedrohte Vielfalt: Aspekte des Sprach(en)tods", pp.203~230 (2005), Weißensee Verlag
- Comrie, B., "Trumai and the Internal Syntax of Numeral Expressions", Paper presented at the Conference Syntax of the World’s Languages (SWL 1) (2004)
- Conant, L., "The Number Concept: Its Origin and Development" (1931), Macmillan
- Córdova, J., "Arte del Idioma Zapoteca" (1886), Imprenta del Gobierno
- Dahl, O., "Contes Malgaches en Dialecte Sakalava: Textes, Traduction, Grammaire et Lexique" (1968), Universitetsforlaget
- Georg, S., "A Descriptive Grammar of Ket, Part I: Introduction, Phonology and Morphology" (2007), Global Oriental
- Greenberg, J., "On Language: Selected Writings of Joseph H. Greenberg", pp.271~309 (1990), Stanford University Press
- Guirardello, R., "A Reference Grammar of Trumai", Ph.D, pp.1999
- Hurford, J., "The Linguistic Theory of Numerals" (1975), CUP
- "Chipewyan (Dëne Sų́łıne)" (2014)[URL]
- Kewley Draskau, J., "Practical Manx" (2008), Liverpool University Press
- Merlan, F., "Mangarayi" (1982), North-Holland
- Oftedal, M., "The Gaelic of Leurbost, Isle of Lewis" (1956), Aschehoug
- "Arikara" (2009)[URL]
- Petitot, E., "Dictionnaire de la langue Dènè-Dindjié; dialectes Montagnais ou Chippewayan, Peaux de Lièvre et Loucheux renfermant en outre un grand nombre de termes propres à sept autres dialectes de la même langue; précédé d'une monographie des Dènè-Dindjié, d'une grammaire et de tableaux synoptiques des conjugaisons" (1876), Ernest Leroux
- Rajaonarimanana, N., "Grammaire moderne de la langue malgache" (2001), L’Asiathèque
- Issa O. Sanusi, "The Mathematical Operations in Bàtɔ̀nū Numeral System", Journal of Universal Language, 19(1), pp.57~84 (2018), 언어연구소[DOI]
- Sonnenschein, A., "Four Zapotec Numeral Systems", ~
- Steinen, K., "Unter den Naturvölkern Zentral-Brasiliens. Reiseschilderung und Ergebnisse der zweiten Schingú-Expedition, 1887-1888" (1894), Dietrich Reimer
- Wied, M., "Reise in das innere Nord-America in den Jahren 1832 bis 1834 Ⅱ" (1841), J. Hölscher