본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

경제적 합리성 개념에 대한 철학적 반성

Philosophical Reflection on the Concept of Economic Rationality

이남인
인문학연구원 (Institute of Humanities, Seoul National University)|2005.06|인문논총 (Journal of Humanities, Seoul National University)|제53호|pp. 33-63

0

조회

0

다운로드

5

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

경제적 합리성합리성rationalityeconomic rationality경제행위기술적 합리성 개념규범적 합리성 개념economic behaviordescriptive concept of rationalitynormative concept of rationality
주제분류기타인문학

초록

Abstract

This paper examines the concept of economic rationality from a philosophical point of view. According to the mainstream economics, economic rationality is an instrumental rationality; it is the rationality par excellence to which all the other kinds of rationality could be reduced; it is only the individual, not the society that could be the bearer of rationality; economic rationality as an instrumental rationality could be the foundation of economics. Contrary to what mainstream economics presupposes, there are various kinds of rationality that cannot be reduced to economic rationality. It is not only the individual, but also the society that could be the bearer of rationality and one can talk about social rationality as well. The concept of economic rationality is ambiguous, since it could be interpreted as a descriptive one or as a normative one. Moreover, the concept of economic rationality as a descriptive one as well as a normative one has some difficulties. The concept of economic rationality as a descriptive one is problematic, since there are so many types of economic behavior that do not have the property of economic rationality. The concept of economic rationality does not enable us to describe properly all types of economic behavior. The concept of economic rationality as a normative one is also problematic, since it is not clear if an economic behavior or an economic society that incarnates economic rationality is really an ideal one. The concept of economic rationality as a normative one is not free from ideological implication.

참고문헌 (30)

  1. "고려대학교 철학연구소 철학연구", 21 (1998)
  2. "현상학과 해석학" (2004), 서울:서울대학교 출판부
  3. 이정전, "합리적인 개인, 비합리적인 사회?", 철학사상, (19), pp.33~81 (2004), 철학사상연구소
  4. 이정전, "경제적 합리성 비판", 철학사상, (20), pp.77~110 (2005), 철학사상연구소
  5. "경제학의 수리화에 대하여 현대학문의 성격 전통의 재편과 새로운 영역의 출현" (2000), 서울:민음사
  6. in, "Über einige Rationalitätskonzeptionen in den Sozialwissenschaften" (1984)
  7. "New Developments in Theories of Social Norms", 29(2) (2000)
  8. "Existence of an Equilibrium for a Competitive Economy", eco(metrica 22) (1954)
  9. "Rationality of Self and Others in an Economic System The Contrast between Economics and Psychology The University of Chicago Press" (1987)
  10. "The Economic Approach to Human Behavior The University of Chicago Press" (1976)
  11. "Economics, Values, and Organization", eco(mics) (1998), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
  12. "Fulda und R Vernunftbegriffe in der Moderne" (1994)
  13. "The Calculus of Consent Logical Foundations of Constitutional Democracy The University of Michigan Press" (1974)
  14. "Morals by Agreement" (1988), Clarendon Press
  15. "Rationality in Economics" (1989), Basil Blachwell Ltd
  16. "New Challenges to the Rationality Assumption" (2000), Kahneman Kahnemann and A Cambridge University Press
  17. "Foundations of Procedural Rationality", 16 (2000)
  18. "A New Foundation for Microeconomics" (1976), Harvard University Press
  19. "Unparteilichkeit und Zwang - Zum Rationalitätsdilemma moderner Gesellschaften Fulda und R Vernunftbegriffe in der Moderne" (1994)
  20. "Contractarian Liberal Ethics and the Theory of Rational Choice" (1992)
  21. "A Theory of Justice" (1971), Cambridge University Press
  22. "Politische Rationalität und Ziviltugend Fulda und R Vernunftbegriffe in der Moderne" (1994)
  23. "Models of Bounded Rationality" (1982), MIT Press
  24. "Rationality in Science A Critical Evaluation of Four Models of Rationality University of Notre Dame Press" (1995)
  25. "A Critique of Instrumental Rationality", eco(mics and philosophy 11) (1995)
  26. "Rational Choice and the Framing of Decisions The Contrast between Economics and Psychology The University of Chicago Press" (1987), Kahneman
  27. "Theory of Games and Economic Behavior" (1990), Princeton Princeton University Press
  28. "Types of Rationality and Economic Action", eco(mics and philosophy) (1985)
  29. "Elements of Pure Economy or The Theory of Social Wealth" (1954), George Allen and Unwin LTD
  30. "Rationality, Allocation, and Reproduction" (1996), Oxford: Clarendon Press

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (10건)

국제정책조정게임에서의 사회적 합리성김영한pp. 3-31정보와 신념, 그리고 경제적 합리성이정전pp. 65-101롤즈와 평등주의: 경제적 혜택의 분배에 관한 철학적 논의의 한 사례주동률pp. 103-145내파(內破)의 시학: 미국 청교도의 예형론과 알레고리강우성pp. 149-171＂한 떼의 적군이 내 성에 들어온들 이 만큼 놀랍겠느냐＂: 『바꿔친 신부』에 나타난 여성문제와 정치김희진pp. 173-197
원문 보기