생물 Ⅱ 교과서 광합성 단원의 오류 분석 및 생물 교사의 오류 인지 조사
Analysis of Mistakes in Photosynthesis Unit in Biology Ⅱ Textbooks and Survey of Biology Teachers' Recognition on them
0
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
The purpose of this study was to know whether or not any wrongful description or simple errors were in photosynthesis unit of Biology Ⅱ textbook under 7th national curriculum and if so, to know whether or not high school teachers recognized and corrected properly the mistakes. The mistakes in photosynthesis unit of text books were determined by the comparison with several reference books and through examination by three plant physiologists in 8 different Biology Ⅱ textbooks. After the mistakes were analysed, the survey using contents of textbook containing the mistakes was conducted on high school teachers teaching Biology Ⅱ. As a result, 48 mistakes were determined in 13 subjects. As many as four mistakes were found even in one subject in a certain textbook and a same mistake was found repeatedly in several textbooks. The survey result showed that the teachers who pointed exactly the mistakes out corrected properly, however, the percentage of these ones out of 35 teachers replied to survey was less than 50%. The ratios of correction out of total number of responses were high in question #6 (43%), #4-3 (40%), and #1-2 (32%) which were containing a simple mistake in graph, a wrong word and a wrong picture, respectively. But, no one pointed out and made correction in question #5-1 and #5-2 which were containing Z scheme of light reaction without the legend of vertical axis that should be explained as electron energy or standard reduction potential. The result indicates the possibility that the mistakes in photosynthesis unit of Biology Ⅱ textbook can be corrected and teached properly by teachers may be low. In order to reduce the possibility that students may have misconceptions about photosynthesis, the list of print's errors should be provided to the teachers and/or the training program and/or workshop for in-service high school biology teachers was recommended.
Abstract
The purpose of this study was to know whether or not any wrongful description or simple errors were in photosynthesis unit of Biology Ⅱ textbook under 7th national curriculum and if so, to know whether or not high school teachers recognized and corrected properly the mistakes. The mistakes in photosynthesis unit of text books were determined by the comparison with several reference books and through examination by three plant physiologists in 8 different Biology Ⅱ textbooks. After the mistakes were analysed, the survey using contents of textbook containing the mistakes was conducted on high school teachers teaching Biology Ⅱ. As a result, 48 mistakes were determined in 13 subjects. As many as four mistakes were found even in one subject in a certain textbook and a same mistake was found repeatedly in several textbooks. The survey result showed that the teachers who pointed exactly the mistakes out corrected properly, however, the percentage of these ones out of 35 teachers replied to survey was less than 50%. The ratios of correction out of total number of responses were high in question #6 (43%), #4-3 (40%), and #1-2 (32%) which were containing a simple mistake in graph, a wrong word and a wrong picture, respectively. But, no one pointed out and made correction in question #5-1 and #5-2 which were containing Z scheme of light reaction without the legend of vertical axis that should be explained as electron energy or standard reduction potential. The result indicates the possibility that the mistakes in photosynthesis unit of Biology Ⅱ textbook can be corrected and teached properly by teachers may be low. In order to reduce the possibility that students may have misconceptions about photosynthesis, the list of print's errors should be provided to the teachers and/or the training program and/or workshop for in-service high school biology teachers was recommended.
참고문헌 (30)
- 곽세근, "고등학교 과학교과서 자극과 반응 단원의 내용 중 잘못 기술된 부분 분석", 석사, pp.2005
- 구창회, "고등학교 생물Ⅰ 교과서 물질대사 관련 단원 내용 중 잘못 기술된 부분 분석", 석사, pp.2005
- 국동식, "대기와 해양의 몇 개념들에 대한 중ㆍ고등학교 과학교사의 개념", 한국지구과학회지, 25(6), pp.402~408 (2004), 한국지구과학회
- 김수미, "항상성, 동?식물 분류, 식물의 양분생산에 대한 학생의 개념 조사와 오개념 형성 원인으로써 교사 요인 분석", 한국과학교육학회지, 17(3), pp.261~271 (1997)
- 나상현, "제 7차 교육과정에 따른 생물Ⅰ 교과서의 오류 조사 분석", 석사, pp.2005
- 박인국, "고등학교 생물 Ⅱ" (1997), 박영사
- 박재근, "제 7차 교육과정에 따른 고등학교 생물 Ⅱ 교과서에서 물질대사 단원에 대한 탐구 활동의 비교 분석", 한국생물교육학회지, 32(2), pp.124~134 (2004)
- 생명과학사전편찬위원회, "생명과학사전" (2003), 아카데미서적
- 신현철, "등학교 생물 교과서 내용 중 잘못 기술된 부분에 대하여-식물 분야를 중심으로-", 식물분류학회지, 25(2), pp.131~138 (1995)
- 유영한, "7차 초등학교 교과서의 생명영역에 나타난 생태분류학적ㆍ논리적 오류,오개념과 이의 정정 및 그 개선안", 생물교육, 30(4), pp.374~392 (2002), 한국생물교육학회
- 정화숙, "제7차 교육과정에 의한 중등 과학 교과서의 광합성 영역에 대한 용어와 탐구의 연계성 분석", 생물교육, 33(2), pp.196~208 (2005), 한국생물교육학회
- 조희형, "과학교육의 이론과 실제" (2006), 교육과학사
- 최영란, "제 6 차 교육과정에 의한 초등학교 자연 교과서의 내용 분석", 초등과학교육, 17(2), pp.55~65 (1998)
- 한국생물과학협회, "생물학사전" (1998), 아카데미서적
- Campbell, N. A., "생명과학: 이론과 현상의 이해" (2004), 라이프사이언스
- Eisen, Y., "Students' understanding of photosynthesis", The American Biology Teacher, 50(4), pp.208~212 (1988)
- Hopkins,W.G., "식물생리학" (2001), 을유문화사
- Marmaroti, P., "Pupil's understanding of photosynthesis: A questionnaire for the simultaneous assessment of all aspects", International Journal of Science Education, 28(4), pp.383~403 (2006)
- Mathews, C. K., "Biochemistry", pp.1996, Benjamin
- Moore, R., "Botany" (1998), McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc
- Nobel, P. S., "Physicochemical and environmental plant physiology" (2005), Burlington: Elsevier Academic Press
- Purves. W. K., "생명 생물의 과학" (2003), 교보문고
- Raven, P. H., "Biology of plants. 7th ed" (2005), H. Freeman & Company
- Ridge, I., "식물의 이해" (2006), 드사이언스
- Salisbury, F., "Plant physiology" (1992), Wadsworth Publishing Company
- Solomon, E. P., "생물과학" (2006), 월드사이언스
- Stern, K. R., "Introductory Plant Biology" (2003), McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc
- Taiz, L., "식물생리학" (2005), 라이프사이언스
- Waheed, T., "Understanding interrelated topics: Photosynthesis at age 14+", Journal of Biological Education, 26(3), pp.193~199 (1992)
- Wallace, R. A., "생물학 생명의 과학" (2004), 을유문화사