Conservative and Progressive Papers’ News Presentation of the U.S. Beef Imports Issue: Analysis of Sources in Korean Newspaper Articles
0
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This study explores the source usage of three conservative and two progressive newspapers in Korea over the issue of beef imports from the United States. The purpose of the study is to understand the tendency of newspapers on both sides, which induced much turmoil, including huge demonstrations against the government in the middle of 2008. The results of a quantitative content analysis show that progressive newspapers employed more sources and presented the issue more negatively than conservative newspapers. In particular, progressive papers used more negative Information, especially from experts, NGOs, and citizens, while the conservative papers used more positive information. In terms of information credibility and valence, the progressive papers effectively used NGO sources, which are situated in the middle of source credibility order, to present a negative tone. The order of credibility is as follows: experts (most credible), followed by judiciary, administration, parliament, NGOs, commercial businesses, and citizens (least credible).
Abstract
This study explores the source usage of three conservative and two progressive newspapers in Korea over the issue of beef imports from the United States. The purpose of the study is to understand the tendency of newspapers on both sides, which induced much turmoil, including huge demonstrations against the government in the middle of 2008. The results of a quantitative content analysis show that progressive newspapers employed more sources and presented the issue more negatively than conservative newspapers. In particular, progressive papers used more negative Information, especially from experts, NGOs, and citizens, while the conservative papers used more positive information. In terms of information credibility and valence, the progressive papers effectively used NGO sources, which are situated in the middle of source credibility order, to present a negative tone. The order of credibility is as follows: experts (most credible), followed by judiciary, administration, parliament, NGOs, commercial businesses, and citizens (least credible).
참고문헌 (65)
- Abel, John D., "Newspaper vs. TV Credibility for Local News", Journalism Quarterly, 54, pp.371~375 (1977)
- Ader, Christine R., "A Longitudinal Study of Agenda Setting for the Issue of Environmental Pollution", Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly, 72, pp.300~312 (1995)
- Berkowitz, Daniel A., "TV News Sources and News Channels: A Study in Agenda-Building", Journalism Quarterly, 64, pp.508~513 (1987)
- Berlo, David K., "Dimensions for Evaluating the Acceptability of Message Sources", Public Opinion Quarterly, 33, pp.563~576 (1980)
- Blood, Deborah J., "Economic Headline News on the Agenda: New Approaches to Understanding Causes and Effects in : Communication and Democracy", pp.97~114 (1997), Lawrence Erlbaum
- Brooks, Brian, "News Reporting and Writing", pp.2002, Bedford
- Brooks, Brian, "Telling the Story: The Convergence of Print, Broadcast and Online Media", pp.2004, Bedford
- Brown, Jane D., "Invisible Power: Newspaper News Sources and the Limits of Diversity", Journalism Quarterly, 64, pp.45~54 (1987)
- Colombetti, Giovanna, "Appraising Valence", Journal of Consciousness Studies, 12(8), pp.103~126 (2005)
- Detjen, Jim, "Changing Work Environment of Environmental Reporters", Newspaper Research Journal, 21(1), pp.2~12 (2000)
- Entman, Roberts, "Framing Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm", Journal of Communication, 43(4), pp.51~58 (1993)
- Fan, David P., "Predictions of Public Opinion from the Mass Media" (1988), Greenwood
- Fiske, Susan T., "Social Cognition" (1992), McGraw-Hill
- Gans, Herbert J., "Deciding What’s News: A Study of CBS Evening News, NBC Nightly News, Newsweek, and Times" (1979), Vintage Books
- Gantz, Walter, "The Influence of Researcher Methods on Television and Newspaper News Credibility Evaluations", Journal of Broadcasting, 25, pp.155~169 (1981)
- Gaziano, Cecile, "Measuring the Concept of Credibility", Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly, 63(3), pp.451~462 (1986)
- Ghanem, Salma, "Filling the Tapestry: The Second Level of Agenda-Setting in : Communication and Democracy", pp.3~14 (1997), Lawrence Erlbaum
- Greenberg, Bradley S., "Media Use and Believability: Some Multiple Correlates", Journalism Quarterly, 43, pp.665~670 (1966)
- Gunther, Albert C., "Biased Press or Biased Public? Attitudes Toward Media Coverage of Social Groups", Public Opinions Quarterly, 56(2), pp.147~167 (1992)
- Hansen, Kathleen A., "Source Diversity and Newspaper Enterprise Journalism", Journalism Quarterly, 68(3), pp.474~482 (1991)
- Hayes, Arthur, "Shifting Roles, Enduring Values: The Credible Journalist in a Digital Age", Journal of Mass Media Ethics, 22(4), pp.262~279 (2007)
- Hilmert, Clayton J., "Positive and Negative Opinion Modeling: The Influence of Another’s Similarity and Dissimilarity", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90(3), pp.440~452 (2006)
- Hovland, Carl I., "Communication and Persuasion" (1953), Yale University Press
- Hovland, Carl I., "The Influence of Source Credibility on Communication Effectiveness", Public Opinion Quarterly, 15(4), pp.635~650 (1951)
- Hwang, Chi-sung, "New Approaches to Conflicting Issue Reporting" (2008), Korean Press Foundation
- Johnson, Thomas J., "Cruising Is Believing? Comparing Internet and Traditional Sources on Media Credibility Measures", Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly, 75(2), pp.325~340 (1998)
- "Joo, Yong-jung, and Woo-sang Chung. 2008. “Miseo gwangubyeong balsaeng- hamyeon suip jungdan” (Will Suspend the Import if Mad Cow Disease Attacks in the United States). Chosun Ilbo, May 8", ~
- Kim, Sei-Hill, "Think about It This Way: Attribute Agenda-Setting Function of the Press and the Public’s Evaluation of a Local Issue", Journalism and Mass Commu-nication Quarterly, 79(1), pp.7~25 (2002)
- "Kim, Sung-hwan, and Hyun-chul Park. 2008. “Gukje aemneseuti, ‘hanguk gyeongchal gwadohan muryuk sayong’” (Amnesty International, “Korean Riot Police Abuses Power”). Hankyoreh, October 7", ~
- Kiousis, Spiro, "Candidate Image Attributes: Experiment on the Substantive Dimension of Second Level Agenda Setting", Communication Research, 26, pp.414~428 (1999)
- Klaidman, Stephen, "The Virtuous Journalists" (1987), Oxford University Press
- Kovach, Bill, "The Elements of Journalism: What News People Should Know and the Public Should Expect" (2001), Crown
- Lee, Gunho, "Agenda Setting Effects in the Digital Age: Uses and Effects of Online Media", 박사, pp.2005
- 이건호, "한국 인터넷 매체들의 상호 의제 설정 효과 : 8개 온라인 신문의 내용 분석을 중심으로", 한국언론학보, 50(4), pp.200~227 (2006), 한국언론학회
- 이건호, "취재원 활용을 통해 살펴본 한국 신문의 보도시각 고찰 : 미국 쇠고기 수입 관련 기사에 나타난 취재원 신뢰도와유인가(Valence) 분석을 중심으로", 한국언론학보, 53(3), pp.348~370 (2009), 한국언론학회
- 이건호, "한국과 미국 신문의 1면 기사 비교 : 취재 영역 및 보도 형태별 취재원 출현에 따른 심층성 분석", 한국언론학보, 52(4), pp.25~49 (2008), 한국언론학회
- Lacy, Stephen, "Comparative Case Study: Newspaper Source Use on the Environmental Beat", Newspaper Research Journal, 21(1), pp.13~25 (2000)
- Lippmann, Walter, "Public Opinion" (1922), Macmillan
- McCombs, Maxwell E., "Setting the Agenda: The Mass Media and Public Opinion" (2005), Polity Press
- McCombs, Maxwell E., "Setting the Agenda of Attributes in the 1996 Spanish General Election", Journal of Communication, 50(2), pp.77~92 (2005)
- McComas, Katherine A., "Source Credibility in Environmental Health-Risk Controversies: Application of Meyer’s Credi-bility Index", Risk Analysis, 21(3), pp.467~480 (2001)
- McManus, John H., "What Kind of Commodity Is News?", Communication Research, 19(6), pp.787~805 (1992)
- McNair, Brian, "The Sociology of Journalism" (1998), Arnold
- Meyer, Philip, "Defining and Measuring Credibility of Newspapers: Developing an Index", Journalism Quarterly, 65(3), pp.567~574 (1988)
- Perloff, Richard M., "Political Communication: Politics, Press, and Public in America" (1998), Lawrence Erlbaum
- Price, Vincent, "News Values and Public Opinion: A Theoretical Account of Media Priming and Framing in : Progress in Communication Sciences: Advances in Persuasion Vol. 13", pp.173~212 (1997), Ablex
- Priest, Susanna H., "Information Equity, Public Understanding of Science and the Biotechnology Debate", Journal of Communication, 45(1), pp.39~54 (1995)
- Rich, Carole, "Writing and Reporting News" (2002), Wadsworth
- Robinson, Michael J., "Believability and the Press", Public Opinion Quarterly, 52(2), pp.174~189 (1988)
- Shah, Dhavan V., "News Framing and Cueing of Issue Regimes: Explaining Clinton’s Public Approval in Spite of Scandal", Public Opinion Quarterly, 66(3), pp.339~370 (2008)
- Schudson, Michael, "Discovering the News: A Social History of American Newspapers" (1978), Basic Books
- Schudson, Michael, "The Power of News" (1995), Harvard University Press
- Shoemaker, Pamela J., "Mediating the Message: Theories of Influences on Mass Media Contents" (1996), Longman
- Sigal, Leon V., "Sources Make the News in : Reading the News", pp.9~37 (1986), Pantheon Books
- Suls, Jerry, "Three Kinds of Opinion Comparison: The Triadic Model", Personality and Social Psychology Review, 4(3), pp.219~237 (2000)
- Tuchman, Gaye, "Making News: A Study in the Construction of Reality" (1978), Free Press
- Wathen, C. Nadine, "Believe It or Not: Factors Conservative and Progressive Papers’ News Presentation of the U.S. Beef Imports Issue 55 Influencing Credibility on the Web", Journal of American Society for Information Science and Technology, 53(2), pp.134~144 (2002)
- Wilson, Elizabeth J., "Source Effects in Communication and Persuasion Research: A Meta-Analysis of Effect Size", Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 21(2), pp.101~112 (1993)
- Yi, Jin-Young, "Change of Market Structure and Variety of News Reporting", 박사, pp.2008
- 윤영철, "Media Management of International Conflict: A Comparative Analysis of News Coverage of Dokdo Island", Korea Journal, 42(4), pp.264~297 (2002), 유네스코한국위원회
- Yoon, Youngmin, "Examining Journalists’ Perceptions and New Coverage of Stem Cell and Cloning Organizations", Journalism and Mass Communication Quarterly, 82(2), pp.281~300 (2005)
- Zaller, John, "The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Influencing Credibility on the Web", Journal of American Society for Information Science and Technology, 53(2), pp.134~144 (1992)
- Wilson, Elizabeth J., "Source Effects in Communication and Persuasion Research: A Meta-Analysis of Effect Size", Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 21(2), pp.101~112 (1993)
- Yi, Jin-Young, "Change of Market Structure and Variety of News Reporting", 박사, pp.2008
- Zaller, John, "The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion" (1992), Cambridge University Press
