A Policy Text Created from History: Choi Hyung Sup’s Theory of Scientific and Technological Development Applicable to Developing Countries
1
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Choi Hyung Sup’s Gaebaldosangguk-ui gwahak gisul gaebal jeollyak (Development Strategies for Science and Technology in Developing Countries) trilogy is a seminal work covering science and technology policy studies in Korea, though it is not often evaluated as such, instead usually being treated as a history. This paper will describe the background and intended meaning of his publication through an examination of the Choi Hyung Sup Archives at Jeonbuk National University and a review of the English-language version of Development Strategies. Based on Korean history of the 1960s and 1970s, Choi’s text reflects his experiences at KIST. Writing for an international audience, Choi does not mention any of the significant policy changes that occurred in the 1980s (when the work was published in English), such as the reorganization of Korea’s government-funded research institutes and the establishment of a national R&D program. I also examine how Choi’s ideas are distinct from those of contemporaneous non-Korean scholars who also wrote on the area. Finally, I discuss the present value of the framework Choi articulated in these volumes by tracing how the work is currently utilized in Korea’s official development assistance efforts.
Abstract
Choi Hyung Sup’s Gaebaldosangguk-ui gwahak gisul gaebal jeollyak (Development Strategies for Science and Technology in Developing Countries) trilogy is a seminal work covering science and technology policy studies in Korea, though it is not often evaluated as such, instead usually being treated as a history. This paper will describe the background and intended meaning of his publication through an examination of the Choi Hyung Sup Archives at Jeonbuk National University and a review of the English-language version of Development Strategies. Based on Korean history of the 1960s and 1970s, Choi’s text reflects his experiences at KIST. Writing for an international audience, Choi does not mention any of the significant policy changes that occurred in the 1980s (when the work was published in English), such as the reorganization of Korea’s government-funded research institutes and the establishment of a national R&D program. I also examine how Choi’s ideas are distinct from those of contemporaneous non-Korean scholars who also wrote on the area. Finally, I discuss the present value of the framework Choi articulated in these volumes by tracing how the work is currently utilized in Korea’s official development assistance efforts.
참고문헌 (38)
- Amir, Sulfika, "The Technological State in Indonesia : The Co-constitution of High Technology and Authoritarian Politics" (2013), Routledge
- Choi, Hyung Sup, "Views of Science, Technology and Development, edited by Eugene Rabinowitch and Victor Rabinowitch", pp.17~28 (1975), Elsevier Science & Technology
- Choi, Hyung Sup, "Gaebaldosangguk-ui gongeop yeongu(Industrial Research in the Less-Developed Countries)" (1976), Iljogak
- Choi, Hyung Sup, "Bases for Science and Technology Promotion in Developing Countries" (1983), Asian Productivity Organization
- Choi, Hyung Sup, "Technology Development in Developing Countries" (1986), Asian Productivity Organization
- Choi, Hyung Sup, "Springboard Measures for Becoming Highly Industrialized Society", pp.1989, APCTT
- Choi, Hyungsup, "Transnational Intermediaries: The Cold War Origins of the ‘Korean Model of Development’", Paper presented at East Asia Seminar, 16 (2022), Cambridge University
- "2004-nyeon Choe Hyeongseop, yeongwonhan ‘gwagicheo janggwan’-euro namda (In 2004, Choi Hyung Sup Remains the Eternal ‘Minister of Science and Technology’)" (2023)[URL]
- Choi, Seok Sik, "Gwahak gisul jeongchaengnon (Science and Technology Policy Theory)" (2011), Sigma Press
- Cirera, Xavier, "The Innovation Paradox: Developing-Country Capabilities and the Unrealized Promise of Technological Catch-Up" (2017), World Bank Publications
- de Hemptinne, Yvan, "The Science Policy of States in Course of Independent Development", Impact of Science on Society, 13(3), pp.233~247 (1963)
- "Choi, Hyung Sup(1920–2004) : A Metallurgist Who Founded Modern Korean Science and Technology", STI Policy Review, 1(2), pp.89~96 (2010)
- The Swedish Paradox, "Ejermo, Olof", CIRCLE (Center for Innovation Research), Lund University, ~ (2006)
- Goldstein, G. R, "Michael J. Moravcsik : A Biographical Sketch", Few-Body Systems, 9, pp.41~56 (1990)
- 임재윤, "최형섭과 ‘한국형 발전모델’의 기원", 역사비평, (118), pp.169~193 (2017), 역사문제연구소[DOI]
- 강미화, "최형섭의 과학기술정책론: 개발도상국의 과학기술개발 전략 분석", 한국과학사학회지, 28(2), pp.297~296 (2006), 한국과학사학회
- Kang, Shin-gwi, "Gyunhyeongireun gwahak haengjeong(Science Administration Out of Balance)", Kyunghyang Shinmun, ~ (1974)
- Kim, Dong-Won, "Winning Markets or Winning Nobel Prizes? KAIST and the Challenges of Late Industrialization", Osiris, 13, pp.154~185 (1998)
- 2021-nyeondo gukje gisul hyeoksin hyeomnyeok saeop (2021 K-Innovation ODA Program), "Kim, Ji Hyun", 1~306, pp.Jeongchaek yeongu 2021-38 (2021)
- 김준형, "한국의 고도성장기의 고위관료의 역할: 1960~70년대 중화학공업화 정책 추진과정에서의 리더십을 중심으로", 한국사회와 행정연구, 26(4), pp.287~310 (2016), 서울행정학회
- 김근배, "The Political Power-Mediated Expansion of Science and Technology under the Park Chung Hee Regime", Korea Journal, 58(4), pp.114~142 (2018), 한국학중앙연구원[DOI]
- Gwahak gisul hyeoksin jeongchaek-eul wihan heonbeop gaejeong nonui-wa gwaje” (Discussions on and Tasks of a Constitutional Amendment for Science and Technology Innovation Policy), "Lee, Jaehoon", KISTEP, 1~34, pp.KISTEP Issue Weekly 225 (2018)
- Gwahak gisul ODA yunghap peurogeuraem gihoek yeongu (Planning of ODA Partnership Program in STI), "Lee, Jungwon", Science and Technology Policy Institute (STEPI), ~ (2020)
- Ma, Hyoung Ryul, "Identification of R&D Paradox after the Global Financial Crisis: Korean Case Focusing on the Smart Convergence and Conventional Industries", Science, Technology and Society, 27(2), pp.1~20 (2022)
- Malecki, Ignacy, "Some Problems Concerning Organization of Scientific Research in the Developing Countries", Impact of Science on Society, 13(3), pp.181~199 (1963)
- Martin, Ben R., "The Evolution of Science Policy and Innovation Studies", Research Policy, 41(7), pp.1219~1239 (2012)
- Moravcsik, Michael J., "Science Development : Toward the Building of Science in Less Developed Countries" (1975), International Development Research Center
- Moravcsik, Michael J., "Two Perceptions of Science Development", Research Policy, 15(1), pp.1~11 (1986)
- O, Won-chol, "The Korea Story: President Park Jung-hee’s Leadership and the Korean Industrial Revolution" (2009), Wisdom Tree Publishing
- Rhyu, Sang Young, "Bak Jeonghui-wa Gim Daejung-ui daehwa : Urideul-ui jahwasang(The Conversation between Park Chung-hee and Kim Dae-jung : Our Self-portrait)" (2022), Nonhyeong
- THAI Vinh Tran, "Hybrid Origins of a Modern Vietnamese Science and Tech-nology System: An Introduction to Contemporary History of Science and Technology in Vietnam", 한국과학사학회지, 40(2), pp.305~325 (2018), 한국과학사학회[DOI]
- Science and Technology for Development: Report on the United Nations Conference on the Application of Science and Technology for the Benefit of the Less Developed Area, Volume VII. Science and Planning, "United Nations", United Nations, ~ (1963)
- Wade, Robert, "Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization" (2004), Princeton University Press
- Won, Tae-sang, "Gwahak gisul-ui eungyong” (Application of Science and Technology: Upon Returning from the UN Science and Technology General Assembly)", Dong-A Ilbo, ~ (1963)
- Yang, Kyu-Hyun, "Hanguk-hyeong gwahak gisul ODA-eseo KIST model-ui hwaryong: KIST model-ui deungjang-gwa jeonpa noryeok, geurigo VKIST seollip (Utilization of the KIST Model in Korean Science and Technology Official Development Assistance: With Focus on the Emergence and Export of the KIST Model and the Establishment of the VKIST)", Master, pp.2022
- 이찬구, "과학기술정책학의 패러다임 논의 : 학문적 정의와 연구범위를 중심으로", 기술혁신학회지, 21(1), pp.1~32 (2018), 한국기술혁신학회
- 이찬구, "국가 성장동력 정책의 변동 분석: 정책문제와 정책혁신 방향", 기술혁신학회지, 25(2), pp.193~226 (2022), 한국기술혁신학회[DOI]
- Yoo, Sangwoon, "Innovation in Practice : The ‘Technology Drive Policy’ and the 4Mb DRAM R&D Consortium in South Korea in the 1980s and 1990s", Technology and Culture, 61(2), pp.385~415 (2020)