Korean Semiotics of the Face Mask: Meanings of the Mask, Meanings of Everyday Life during the COVID-19 Pandemic
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Surgical face masks have become commonplace during the COVID-19 pandemic, producing debates on mask practices. This paper explains the semiotic practices of the face mask among Koreans, who accepted the mask early and have simultaneously remained uneasy about it until late 2020. It aims to explain this paradox by discovering various meanings Koreans ascribe to the mask. A content analysis of reader responses to news articles finds that Koreans signify what the mask means for life in various voices (i.e., instrumental meanings) in which they concurrently reveal multiple and contradictory meanings of everyday life (i.e., existential meanings) during the pandemic. Eight themes—beneficence, futility, nuisance, routine, privacy, dominance, collective commitment, and intricacy—constitute what the mask and everyday life mean. This study also finds that contradictions among these meanings are resolved either incidentally by their being simultaneously harbored in one piece of the mask that stays and holds tight in most circumstances or semiotically by certain integrative meanings embracing multiple meanings at once. The study argues that the meanings of the mask reflect meanings of life that are often contradictory and yet held together during the pandemic. It demonstrates that mask sociology serves as a promising humanistic inquiry on how the Maussian totality of everyday life is concretely experienced in the context of the pandemic.
Abstract
Surgical face masks have become commonplace during the COVID-19 pandemic, producing debates on mask practices. This paper explains the semiotic practices of the face mask among Koreans, who accepted the mask early and have simultaneously remained uneasy about it until late 2020. It aims to explain this paradox by discovering various meanings Koreans ascribe to the mask. A content analysis of reader responses to news articles finds that Koreans signify what the mask means for life in various voices (i.e., instrumental meanings) in which they concurrently reveal multiple and contradictory meanings of everyday life (i.e., existential meanings) during the pandemic. Eight themes—beneficence, futility, nuisance, routine, privacy, dominance, collective commitment, and intricacy—constitute what the mask and everyday life mean. This study also finds that contradictions among these meanings are resolved either incidentally by their being simultaneously harbored in one piece of the mask that stays and holds tight in most circumstances or semiotically by certain integrative meanings embracing multiple meanings at once. The study argues that the meanings of the mask reflect meanings of life that are often contradictory and yet held together during the pandemic. It demonstrates that mask sociology serves as a promising humanistic inquiry on how the Maussian totality of everyday life is concretely experienced in the context of the pandemic.
참고문헌 (54)
- Asenbaum, Hans, "Anonymity and Democracy: Absence as Presence in the Public Sphere", American Political Science Review, 112(3), pp.459~472 (2018)
- Baehr, Peter, "Networked Disease: Emerging Infections in the Global City", pp.138~151 (2009), Blackwell Publishing
- Berger, L. Peter, "The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge" (1991), Penguin Books
- Bhasin, Tavishi, "Does Karen Wear a Mask? The Gendering of COVID-19Masking Rhetoric", International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 40(9-10), pp.929~937 (2020)
- Caulfield, Timothy, "Let’s Do Better: Public Representations of COVID-19 Science", FACETS, 6(1), pp.403~423 (2021)
- Cha, Su-Joung, "“Q bangbeomnon-eul sayonghan korona19 sidae hangugin-ui maseukeu insik yuhyeong” (Mask Cognition Types of Korean in the COVID-19Era Using the Q Methodology)", Hanguk keompyuteo jeongbohakhoe nonmunji (Journal of the Korea Society of Computer and Information), 27(9), pp.157~167 (2022)
- Chang, Hawon, "“Korona19 sidae-ui maseukeu-deul:Bogeonyong maseukeu-wa maseukeu saengtaegye” (Masks in the Era of COVID-19: Medical Masks and the Ecosystem of Masks)", Bigyo hangukhak (Comparative Korean Studies), 30(1), pp.43~69 (2022)
- Choi, Hee An, "To Mask or To Unmask, That Is the Question: Facemasks and Anti-Asian Violence During COVID-19", Journal of Human Rights and Social Work, 6(3), pp.237~245 (2021)
- Eikenberry, E. Steffen, "To Mask or Not to Mask: Modeling the Potential for Face Mask Use by the General Public to Curtail the COVID-19 Pandemic", Infectious Disease Modelling, 5, pp.293~308 (2020)
- Emirbayer, Mustafa, "What Is Agency?", American Journal of Sociology, 103(4), pp.962~1023 (1998)
- Goffman, Erving, "On Face-Work : An Analysis of Ritual Elements in Social Interaction", Psychiatry, 18(3), pp.213~231 (1955)
- Goffman, Erving, "The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life" (1956), University of Edinburgh Social Sciences Research Centre
- Green, Jon, "Elusive Consensus: Polarization in Elite Communication on the COVID-19 Pandemic", Science Advances, 6(28), pp.eabc2717~ (2020)
- Heimstädt, Maximilian, "A Pandemic of Prediction: On the Circulation of Contagion Models between Public Health and Public Safety", Sociologica, 14(3), pp.1~24 (2020)
- Hong, Sungwook, "Maseukeu panorama (Mask Panorama)", pp.42~63 (2022), Munhak-gwa jiseongsa (Moonji Publishing)
- Hyun, Jaehwan, "“Iljegangjeomgi wisaeng maseukeu-ui deungjang-gwa jeongchak” (Emergence and Development of Hygienic Masks in Colonial Korea)", Uisahak (Korean Journal of Medical History), 31(1), pp.181~220 (2022)
- Hyun, Jaehwan, "Maseukeu panorama (Mask Panorama)" (2022), Munhak-gwa jiseongsa (Moonji Publishing)
- Jung, Joon Young, "“Korona sidae maseukeu chagyong-ui jeongchihak:Paendemik chogi gungmyeon-ui yeoksahwa” (Politics of Mask-Wearing in the COVID-19 Era: Historizing the Early Stage of the Pandemic)", Yeoksa bipyeong (Critical Review of History), 137(Winter), pp.139~174 (2021)
- Kahn, Kimberly Barsamian, "(Un)masking Threat:Racial Minorities Experience Race-based Social Identity Threat Wearing Face Masks during COVID-19", Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 25(4), pp.871~891 (2021)
- Kang, Min Hye, "“Korona 19-wa maseukeu: Hanguk-gwa miguk-eul jungsim-euro bon maseukeu chagyong-eseo-ui dongseoyang munhwa chai”(COVID-19 and Face Masks: East-West Cultural Differences in Wearing Face Masks in Public)", Hanguk simni hakhoeji: Sahoe mit seonggyeok (Korean Journal of Social and Personality Psychology), 35(4), pp.77~103 (2021)
- Kim, Heewon, "Maseukeu panorama (Mask Panorama)", pp.42~63 (2022), Munhak-gwa jiseongsa (Moonji Publishing)
- Korean General Social Survey 2003–2021, "Kim, Jibum", Inter University Consortium for Political and Social Research, ~ (2022)
- Kim, Sangmin, "“Paendemik sidae gyeonggyesang-ui samul, maseukeu-ui munhwa jeongchi” (Cultural Politics of the Mask: A Boundary Object during the Pandemic)", Munhwa gwahak (Cultural Science), 103, pp.150~166 (2020)
- Kim, Yunna, "“Korona19 ihu yuadeul-ui yuchiwon ilsang sok maseukeu sseugi-e daehan hyeonsanghakjeok yeongu” (A Phenomenological Study on Young Children’s Face Mask Wearing in a Kindergarten during the COVID-19Pandemic)", Yua gyoyuk yeongu (Korean Journal of Early Childhood Education), 41(6), pp.107~131 (2021)
- "“Maseukeu chakyong-ui sahoe simnihak: Saram-deul-i maseukeu-reul chakyonghaneun iyu” (Social Psychology of Face Mask Use:Why People Wear the Face Mask)" (2020)[URL]
- Leone, Massimo, "The Semiotics of the Medical Face Mask: East and West", Signs and Media, 1(1), pp.40~70 (2020)
- Lévi-Strauss, Claude, "The Way of the Masks" (1988), University of Washington Press
- Li, Hongyan, "“Paendemik yeonghyang ha-ui paesyeon maseukeu dijain gyeonghyang mit uimi bunseok” (Analysis of Trends and Meanings of Fashion Masks under the Pandemic Influence)", Boksik munhwa yeongu (Research Journal of Costume Culture), 29(3), pp.406~421 (2021)
- Lim, S., "Face Masks and Containment of COVID-19: Experience from South Korea", Journal of Hospital Infection, 106(1), pp.206~207 (2020)
- Ma, Yingyi, "To Mask or Not to Mask amid the COVID-19Pandemic: How Chinese Students in America Experience and Cope with Stigma", Chinese Sociological Review, 54(1), pp.1~26 (2022)
- Makovicky, N, "The National(ist) Necropolitics of Masks", Social Anthropology, 28(2), pp.314~315 (2020)
- Martinelli, Lucia, "Face Masks During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Simple Protection Tool With Many Meanings", Frontiers in Public Health, 8, pp.606~635 (2021)
- Mauss, Marcel, "Techniques of the Body", Economy and Society, 2, pp.70~88 (1973)
- Mauss, Marcel, "The Category of the Person: Anthropology, Philosophy, History", pp.1~25 (1985), Cambridge University Press
- Mauss, Marcel., "The Gift: The Form and Reason for Exchange in Archaic Societies" (1990), Routledge
- Mead, George Herbert, "Mind, Self and Society" (1972), University of Chicago Press
- Mervosh, Sarah, "Mask Rules Expand across US as Clashes over the Mandates Intensify", New York Times. August 3, ~ (2020)
- Moulson, Geir., "Thousands Protest in Berlin Against Coronavirus Restrictions" (2020), AP (The Associated Press)
- Mueller, Benjamin, "After Months of Debate, England Requires Face Masks for Shoppers", New York Times. July 14, ~ (2020)
- "“Gyeongchal, maseukeu chagyong sibi pokaeng yeokak josa banghae deung korona19 bangyeok suchik wiban haengwi-e omjeong daeeung bangchim” (Press Release: Police Take Strict Action against ‘Violations of Corona-19 Quarantine Rules,’ such as Assaults over Mask Mandates and Testing)"[URL]
- Park, Robert E., "Race and Culture", pp.244~255 (1950), Free Press
- Park, Sang-Hyun, ""Maseukeu munhwa-e gwanhan bigyo yeongu : Ilbon-gwa miguk-eul jungsim-euro"(Comparative Study on Mask Culture : Focusing on Japan and America)", Ilbon munhwa yeongu (Japanese Cultural Studies), 76, pp.107~126 (2020)
- Peretti-Watel, Patrick, "A Future Vaccination Campaign against COVID-19 at Risk of Vaccine Hesitancy and Politicisation", Lancet Infectious Diseases, 20(7), pp.769~770 (2020)
- Pollock, Donald, "Masks and the Semiotics of Identity", Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 1(3), pp.581~597 (1995)
- Ren, Jingqiu, "Face Mask Symbolism in Anti-Asian Hate Crimes", Ethnic and Racial Studies, 44(5), pp.746~758 (2021)
- Ruiz, Pollyanna, "Revealing Power: Masked Protest and the Blank Figure", Cultural Politics, 9(3), pp.263~279 (2013)
- Santayana, George, "Soliloquies in England and Later Soliloquies" (1922), Charles Scribner’s Sons
- Schreier, Margrit, "Qualitative Content Analysis in Practice" (2012), Sage Publications
- Shim, Jae-Mahn, "Mask Sociology as a Way of Action Theory: Voices of the Face Mask among Social Individuals in the Covid-19 Masquerade in South Korea", PLoS One, 18(11), pp.e0293758~ (2023)
- ), "Paper Presented at the 2020 Annual Conference of the Korean Sociological Association", 2020, ~, pp.Sungkyunkwan University and Online
- Tateo, Luca, "Face Masks as Layers of Meaning in Times of COVID-19", Culture & Psychology, 27(1), pp.131~151 (2020)
- Tonkin, Elizabeth, "Masks and Powers", Man, 14(2), pp.237~248 (1979)
- Tseëlon, Efrat, "Is the Presented Self Sincere? Goffman, Impression Management and the Postmodern Self", Theory, Culture & Society, 9(2), pp.115~128 (1992)
- Ward, K. Jeremy, "The French Public’s Attitudes to a Future COVID-19Vaccine: The Politicization of a Public Health Issue", Social Science & Medicine, 265, pp.113414~ (2020)