Clinical Efficacy of Endoscopic Treatment for Benign Colorectal Stricture: Balloon Dilatation versus Stenting
1
조회
0
다운로드
3
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Background/Aims: There has been a lack of research comparing balloon dilatation and self-expandable metal stent (SEMS) placement to determine which is better for long-term clinical outcomes in patients with benign colorectal strictures. We aimed to compare the clinical efficacy and complication rates of balloon dilatation and SEMS placement for benign colorectal strictures from a variety of causes. Methods: Between January 1999 and January 2012, a total of 43 consecutive patients who underwent endoscopic treatment for benign colorectal stricture (balloon only in 29 patients, SEMS only in seven patients, and both procedures in seven patients) were retrospectively reviewed. Results: Thirty-six patients underwent endoscopic balloon dilatation, representing 65 individual sessions, and 14 patients received a total of 17 SEMS placements. The initial clinical success rates were similar in both groups (balloon vs SEMS, 89.1% vs 87.5%). Although the reobstruction rates were similar in both groups (balloon vs SEMS, 54.4% vs. 57.1%), the duration of patency was significantly longer in the balloon dilatation group compared with the SEMS group (65.5±13.3 months vs. 2.0±0.6 months, p=0.031). Conclusions: Endoscopic balloon dilatation is safe and effective as an initial treatment for benign colorectal stricture and as an alternative treatment for recurrent strictures.
Abstract
Background/Aims: There has been a lack of research comparing balloon dilatation and self-expandable metal stent (SEMS) placement to determine which is better for long-term clinical outcomes in patients with benign colorectal strictures. We aimed to compare the clinical efficacy and complication rates of balloon dilatation and SEMS placement for benign colorectal strictures from a variety of causes. Methods: Between January 1999 and January 2012, a total of 43 consecutive patients who underwent endoscopic treatment for benign colorectal stricture (balloon only in 29 patients, SEMS only in seven patients, and both procedures in seven patients) were retrospectively reviewed. Results: Thirty-six patients underwent endoscopic balloon dilatation, representing 65 individual sessions, and 14 patients received a total of 17 SEMS placements. The initial clinical success rates were similar in both groups (balloon vs SEMS, 89.1% vs 87.5%). Although the reobstruction rates were similar in both groups (balloon vs SEMS, 54.4% vs. 57.1%), the duration of patency was significantly longer in the balloon dilatation group compared with the SEMS group (65.5±13.3 months vs. 2.0±0.6 months, p=0.031). Conclusions: Endoscopic balloon dilatation is safe and effective as an initial treatment for benign colorectal stricture and as an alternative treatment for recurrent strictures.
참고문헌 (26)
- Baron TH, "Expandable metal stent placement for malignant colorectal obstruction", Endoscopy, 34, pp.823~830 (2002)
- Feo L, "Colonic stents: the modern treatment of colonic obstruction", Adv Ther, 28, pp.73~86 (2011)
- Saida Y, "Outcome of 141 cases of self-expandable metallic stent placements for malignant and benign colorectal strictures in a single center", Surg Endosc, 25, pp.1748~1752 (2011)
- Rayhanabad J, "Long-term outcome of endoscopic colorectal stenting for malignant and benign disease", Am Surg, 75, pp.897~900 (2009)
- Small AJ, "Expandable metal stent placement for benign colorectal obstruction: outcomes for 23 cases", Surg Endosc, 22, pp.454~462 (2008)
- Keranen I, "Outcome of patients after endoluminal stent placement for benign colorectal obstruction", Scand J Gastroenterol, 45, pp.725~731 (2010)
- Forshaw MJ, "Self-expanding metallic stents in the treatment of benign colorectal disease:indications and outcomes", Colorectal Dis, 8, pp.102~111 (2006)
- Araujo SE, "Efficacy and safety of endoscopic balloon dilation of benign anastomotic strictures after oncologic anterior rectal resection: report on 24 cases", Surg Laparosc Endosc Percutan Tech, 18, pp.565~568 (2008)
- Di ZH, "Colorectal anastomotic strictures:treatment by fluoroscopic double balloon dilation", J Vasc Interv Radiol, 16, pp.75~80 (2005)
- Di Giorgio P, "Endoscopic dilation of benign colorectal anastomotic stricture after low anterior resection: a prospective comparison study of two balloon types", Gastrointest Endosc, 60, pp.347~350 (2004)
- Suchan KL, "Endoscopic treatment of postoperative colorectal anastomotic strictures", Surg Endosc, 17, pp.1110~1113 (2003)
- Luck A, "Endoscopic laser stricturotomy and balloon dilatation for benign colorectal strictures", ANZ J Surg, 71, pp.594~597 (2001)
- Dai Y, "Treatment of benign colorectal strictures by temporary stenting with self-expanding stents", Int J Colorectal Dis, 25, pp.1475~1479 (2010)
- Brower RA, "Balloon catheter dilation of a rectal stricture", Gastrointest Endosc, 30, pp.95~97 (1984)
- 이현직, "Endoscopy-Guided Balloon Dilation of Benign Anastomotic Strictures after Radical Gastrectomy for Gastric Cancer", Gut and Liver, 8(4), pp.394~399 (2014), 거트앤리버 발행위원회
- Thienpont C, "Long-term outcome of endoscopic dilatation in patients with Crohn’s disease is not affected by disease activity or medical therapy", Gut, 59, pp.320~324 (2010)
- Lee KM, "Comparison of uncovered stent with covered stent for treatment of malignant colorectal obstruction", Gastrointest Endosc, 66, pp.931~936 (2007)
- Raijman I, "Use of an expandable Ultraflex stent in the treatment of malignant rectal stricture", Endoscopy, 27, pp.273~276 (1995)
- Tominaga K, "Expandable metal stent placement in the treatment of a malignant anastomotic stricture of the transverse colon", Gastrointest Endosc, 53, pp.524~527 (2001)
- Baron TH, "Expandable metal stents for the treatment of colonic obstruction: techniques and outcomes", Gastrointest Endosc, 47, pp.277~286 (1998)
- 최원재, "Effects of the Temporary Placement of a Self-Expandable Metallic Stent in Benign Pyloric Stenosis", Gut and Liver, 7(4), pp.417~422 (2013), 거트앤리버 발행위원회
- de Lange EE, "Rectal strictures: treatment with fluoroscopically guided balloon dilation", Radiology, 178, pp.475~479 (1991)
- Hood K, "Dilator for high rectal strictures", Br J Surg, 73, pp.633~ (1986)
- Odurny A, "Colonic anastomotic stenoses and Memotherm stent fracture: a report of three cases", Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol, 24, pp.336~339 (2001)
- Pommergaard HC, "A clinical evaluation of endoscopically placed self-expanding metallic stents in patients with acute large bowel obstruction", Scand J Surg, 98, pp.143~147 (2009)
- Attar A, "Safety and efficacy of extractible self-expandable metal stents in the treatment of Crohn’s disease intestinal strictures: a prospective pilot study", Inflamm Bowel Dis, 18, pp.1849~1854 (2012)