본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

말초성 안면마비 후유증의 비수술적 치료에 관한 국내외 연구 동향

Research Trends on Non-surgical Treatment of Peripheral Facial Paralysis Sequelae

고우신|윤화정|이성은
대한한방안이비인후피부과학회 (The Korean Medicine Opthalmology&Otolaryngology&Dermatology Society)|2018.11|한방안이비인후피부과학회지 (The Journal of Korean Medicine Ophthalmology&Otorhinolaryngology&Dermatology)|제31권 제4호|pp. 42-64|DOI 10.6114/jkood.2018.31.4.042

1

조회

0

다운로드

8

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

acupunctureRamsay-Hunt syndromeBell’s palsyfacial palsysequelae
주제분류한의학

초록

Objectives : The purpose of this study was to investigate the non-surgical treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequelae such as bell’s palsy and Ramsay-hunt syndrome during last 10 years. Methods : We searched articles in the RISS, MEDLINE, CAJ from January, 2008 to June, 2018. Articles on the non-surgical treatment of bell’s palsy and Ramsay-hunt syndrome sequelae were included. We extracted data about treatments, characteristics of intervention, outcomes from the included studies and classified in to 4 categories such as case studies, RCTs, nRCTs, literature reviews. Results : 132 potentially relevant studies were identified, of which 60 studies met our inclusion criteria. Of 60 included studies, 30 were case reports, 22 were RCTs, 4 were nRCTs, and 4 were reviews. China (81.8%) were the most common by country, bell’s palsy(81.7%) by disease, and case reports(50%) by study type were the most common. Symptoms were lagophthalmos, asymmetry, contracture, spasm, dacryorrhea, synkinesis, paresthesia, crocodile tears mostly in the order of frequency, and these symptoms occurred at least one month after the onset of symptoms. The most common method of treatment was acupuncture, which was used in 49 studies. As the evaluation variables, the effective rate was the highest in 25, House-Brakmann grading system in 17, and Sunnybrook facial grading system in 7. In 95% of the studies, after-treatment was reported to be cured, but objectivity is low. Conclusions : This study suggests that Korean medicine such as acupuncture can play a valid role in the non-surgical treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequelae. In the future, a systematic and well-designed clinical study is needed for treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequelae.

Abstract

Objectives : The purpose of this study was to investigate the non-surgical treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequelae such as bell’s palsy and Ramsay-hunt syndrome during last 10 years. Methods : We searched articles in the RISS, MEDLINE, CAJ from January, 2008 to June, 2018. Articles on the non-surgical treatment of bell’s palsy and Ramsay-hunt syndrome sequelae were included. We extracted data about treatments, characteristics of intervention, outcomes from the included studies and classified in to 4 categories such as case studies, RCTs, nRCTs, literature reviews. Results : 132 potentially relevant studies were identified, of which 60 studies met our inclusion criteria. Of 60 included studies, 30 were case reports, 22 were RCTs, 4 were nRCTs, and 4 were reviews. China (81.8%) were the most common by country, bell’s palsy(81.7%) by disease, and case reports(50%) by study type were the most common. Symptoms were lagophthalmos, asymmetry, contracture, spasm, dacryorrhea, synkinesis, paresthesia, crocodile tears mostly in the order of frequency, and these symptoms occurred at least one month after the onset of symptoms. The most common method of treatment was acupuncture, which was used in 49 studies. As the evaluation variables, the effective rate was the highest in 25, House-Brakmann grading system in 17, and Sunnybrook facial grading system in 7. In 95% of the studies, after-treatment was reported to be cured, but objectivity is low. Conclusions : This study suggests that Korean medicine such as acupuncture can play a valid role in the non-surgical treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequelae. In the future, a systematic and well-designed clinical study is needed for treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequelae.

참고문헌 (79)

  1. Finsterer J, "Management of peripheral facial nerve palsy", Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol, 265(7), pp.743~752 (2008)
  2. KORL, "Otorhinolaryngology", pp.203~215 (2016), Ilchokak
  3. 허은선, "정안침요법 복합치료를 이용한 말초성 안면마비후유증 치료 5례", 한방안이비인후피부과학회지, 29(3), pp.217~230 (2016), 대한한방안이비인후피부과학회[DOI]
  4. Bhatti MT, "Neuro-ophthalmologic complications and manifestations of upper and lower motor neuron facial paresis", Curr Neurol Neurosci Rep, 10(6), pp.448~458 (2010)
  5. Thaera GM, "Are corticosteroid and antiviral treatments effective for bell's palsy? : a critically appraised topic", The Neurologist, 16(2), pp.138~140 (2010)
  6. Catarina M, "PERIPHERAL FACIAL PARALYSIS - The Role of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation", Acta Med Port, 24, pp.907~914 (2011)
  7. Berg T, "The Effect of Prednisolone on Sequelae in Bell’s Palsy", ARCH OTOLARYNGOL HEAD NECK SURG, 138(5), pp.445~449 (2012)
  8. Baugh RF, "Clinical practice guideline: Bell's Palsy executive summary", Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg, 149(5), pp.656~663 (2013)
  9. McCaul JA, "Evidence based management of Bell's palsy", Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg, 52(5), pp.387~391 (2014)
  10. Jowett N, "Contemporary management of Bell palsy", Facial Plast Surg, 31(2), pp.93~102 (2015)
  11. Madhok VB, "Corticosteroids for Bell's palsy (idiopathic facial paralysis)", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 7, pp.CD001942~ (2016)
  12. Monini S, "Role of Kabat rehabilitation in facial nerve palsy: a randomised study on severe cases of Bell's palsy", Acta Otorhinolaryngol Ital, 36(4), pp.282~288 (2016)
  13. Vakharia K, "Bell's Palsy", Facial Plast Surg Clin North Am, 24(1), pp.1~10 (2016)
  14. Alptekin DO, "Acupuncture and Kinesio Taping for the acute management of Bell's palsy: A case report", Complement Ther Med, 35, pp.1~5 (2017)
  15. Takushima A, "Availability of latissimus dorsi minigraft in smile reconstruction for incomplete facial paralysis: quantitative assessment based on the optical flow method", Plast Reconstr Surg, 123(4), pp.1198~1208 (2009)
  16. Bodenez C, "Facial nerve decompression for idiopathic Bell's palsy : report of 13 cases and literature review", J Laryngol Otol, 124(3), pp.272~278 (2010)
  17. Kim SH, "Delayed facial nerve decompression for Bell's palsy", Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol, 273(7), pp.1755~1760 (2016)
  18. Socolovsky M, "Bell’s palsy and partial hypoglossal to facial nerve transfer: Case presentation and literature review", Surg Neurol Int, 3, pp.46~52 (2012)
  19. Chen ML, "Clinical observation on 52 cases of facial paralysis with electroacupuncture, infrared and massage", China Medical Herald, 5(33), pp.62~63 (2008)
  20. 최철훈, "봉약침 복합치료가 초기 회복지연에 따른 말초성안면마비 후유증에 미치는 영향", Journal of Acupuncture Research, 26(4), pp.115~123 (2009), 대한침구의학회
  21. 추민규, "안면성형침을 이용한 안면신경마비 후유증의 치험례 보고", 한방재활의학과학회지, 19(4), pp.175~188 (2009), 한방재활의학과학회
  22. 원재선, "안면마비(Bell's palsy) 후유증 환자에 대한 임상 고찰 18례", 한방안이비인후피부과학회지, 22(3), pp.167~177 (2009), 대한한방안이비인후피부과학회
  23. Komori M, "Mouth Movement Disturbance as a Sequela of Bilateral Bell’s Palsy", Otology &Neurotology, 30, pp.847~850 (2009)
  24. Shao XP, "Treatment of 50 Cases of Peripheral Facial Paralysis by Giant Spur Method", Clinical Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 21(2), pp.149~ (2009)
  25. Navarrete Álvaro ML, "Botulinum toxin and facial palsy. Our experience", Acta Otorrinolaringologica (English Edition), 61(4), pp.277~281 (2010)
  26. Fu X, "100 cases of sequelae of facial paralysis treated with acupuncture", China Modern Medicine, 17(7), pp.84~ (2010)
  27. Cui YX, "Professor Cheng Weiping's Clinical Experience in Treating Facial Paralysis by Extraction and Penetration", Information on Traditional Chinese Medicine, 27(4), pp.25~26 (2010)
  28. 이창우, "안면마비 후유증에 대한 매선치료의 효과", Journal of Acupuncture Research, 28(4), pp.93~103 (2011), 대한침구의학회
  29. Wiener A, "A Novel Long-term Therapy of Facial Synkinesis with Botulinum Neurotoxins Type A and Fillers", J Clin Aesthet Dermatol, 4(3), pp.45~49 (2011)
  30. Ai BW, "Professor Wu Xu's experience in treating facial paralysis", Chinese Medicine modern distance education of China, 9(14), pp.19~29 (2011)
  31. 이두희, "말초성 안면마비 후유증과 재발을 겸한 환자 3례에 대한 임상적 고찰", 한방안이비인후피부과학회지, 25(4), pp.57~69 (2012), 대한한방안이비인후피부과학회
  32. Wang W, "Curative Effect Analysis of 120 Cases of Facial Paralysis Caused by Acupuncture and Treatment of Traditional Chinese Medicine", Hebei Medicine, 18(1), pp.116~117 (2012)
  33. Wang W, "Curative effect observation of 120 cases of sequelae of peripheral facial paralysis treated with cutting", Hebei Medicine, 18(8), pp.1176~ (2012)
  34. Lu QM, "Wu Xu's experience in treating facial paralysis", Jiangxi Jounal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 359(11), pp.23~24 (2012)
  35. Li HF, "Summarization of Professor LI Kai＇s Treating Experience of Combination of Contralateral Acupuncture and Acupoint Injection for Facial Paralysis Sequelae", Journal of Practical Traditional Chinese Internal Medicine, 26(5), pp.22~23 (2012)
  36. Sun FF, "Discussion on the treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequela by fire therapy", Shanxi Traditional Chinese Medicine, 33(6), pp.732~733 (2012)
  37. Zhao JR, "Treatment of 48 cases of peripheral facial paralysis sequela with fire acupuncture", Journal of Hebei TCM and Pharmacology, 27(1), pp.39~ (2012)
  38. Ni WP, "Acupuncture and Tuina Comprehensive Treatment of 23 Cases of Peripheral Facial Paralysis", Chinese Traditional Medicine Technology, 19(1), pp.89~90 (2012)
  39. 조은, "말초성 안면마비 후유증에 대한 정안침요법 증례 보고", Journal of Acupuncture Research, 30(3), pp.155~163 (2013), 대한침구의학회[DOI]
  40. Han LB, "Treatment of 45 cases of peripheral facial paralysis sequela by penetrating and electroacupuncture", Zhejiang Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 48(1), pp.57~ (2013)
  41. Zhao JK, "Comprehensive treatment of 176 cases of peripheral facial paralysis sequela", Yunnan Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 34(8), pp.88~ (2013)
  42. Su ML, "Clinical Observation on 47 Cases of Facial Paralysis Caused by Facial Method of "Jing" in Yangbai Point", Chinese journal of ethnomedicine and ethnopharmacy, (1), pp.74~75 (2014)
  43. Pang Y, "Treatment of 80 cases of peripheral facial paralysis sequelae by three-needle penetration", Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion, 35(12), pp.1249~1259 (2015)
  44. Wang HG, "Treatment of 43 cases of tears after facial paralysis by plum blossom needle acupuncture", Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion, 35(1), pp.65~ (2015)
  45. 이은지, "안면신경마비 후유증 정안침 증례보고", 동의생리병리학회지, 29(4), pp.347~351 (2015), 한의병리학회[DOI]
  46. Wang JN, "Clinical effect of needle acupuncture combined with TDP lamp in the treatment of peripheral sequelae of peripheral facial paralysis", Medical Equipment, 31(7), pp.97~99 (2018)
  47. Wang W, "Preliminary study on 26cases of deafness syndrome treated by Chinese medicine Zhidan-Yangxue-Rongji decoction", Journal of Chengde Medical College, 25(4), pp.390~391 (2008)
  48. Fang D, "Professor Chen Yiguo's clinical experience in treating sequelae of facial paralysis", JCAM, 28(3), pp.59~60 (2012)
  49. Guo F, "Therapeutic effect of acupuncture combined with drugs on the sequela of peripheral facial paralysis and its effect on plasma endothelin", Zhejiang Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 45(11), pp.791~792 (2010)
  50. Hong YF, "Clinical observation of acupuncture combining with internal and external application of traditional Chinese medicine for the treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequela", World Clinical Drugs, 32(5), pp.287~289 (2011)
  51. Huang ZQ, "Warm Needling with Different Acupuncture Tool for Treating Sequelae of Facial Paralysis", Shanghai J Acu-mox, 30(7), pp.458~459 (2011)
  52. Wang XX, "Therapeutic effect of acupoint embedding therapy on facial sequelae", Xinjiang Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 30(5), pp.22~23 (2012)
  53. Jia HY, "Experience in treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequelae", Seek Medical And Ask The Medicine, 10(1), pp.79~ (2012)
  54. Liu LX, "Clinical observation of the treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequela with wrist-needle and bilateral oblique puncture", JETCM, 21(2), pp.296~297 (2012)
  55. Wu GH, "Therapeutic effect of 40 cases of muscle contracture after facial paralysis treated with reversed needle acupuncture and needle acupuncture", Asia-Pacific Traditional Medicine, 9(7), pp.93~94 (2013)
  56. Ding P, "Treatment of 74 cases of peripheral facial paralysis sequela with giant thorn method and electroacupuncture", Primary Medical Forum, 17(17), pp.2268~2269 (2013)
  57. Li WG, "Efficacy analysis of treating peripheral facial paralysis sequela by scalp acupuncture", CJCM, 6(5), pp.65~66 (2014)
  58. Li HH, "Clinical Observation of the Effect of Acupuncturing “Suihui Xuezu”on Sequelae of Facial Paralysis", JCAM, 30(8), pp.12~14 (2014)
  59. Dong YH, "Cut Acupuncture Treatment Sequelae of 40Cases of Facial Paralysis Efficacy", Cardiovascular Disease Journal of integrated traditional Chinese and Western Medicine, 2(7), pp.27~28 (2014)
  60. Kwon HJ, "Acupuncture for the sequelae of Bell's palsy: a randomized controlled trial", Trials, 16, pp.246~ (2015)
  61. Pourmomeny AA, "Management of Facial Synkinesis with a Combination of BTX-A and Biofeedback: A Randomized Trial", Iranian Journal of Otorhinolaryngology, 27(6), pp.409~415 (2015)
  62. Guo CC, "Treatment of 60 Cases of Peripheral Facial Paralysis by Acupoint Thread Embedding and Ginger Moxibustion", Heilongjiang Traditional Chinese Medicine, (1), pp.44~45 (2015)
  63. Sun LY, "Observation of the effect of the electro acupuncture in the treatment of the sequelae of facial paralysis", Shanghai Pharmaceutical, 36(24), pp.34~35 (2015)
  64. Li CY, "Therapeutic effect of moxibustion cans on the treatment of refractory facial paralysis", Shanxi Traditional Chinese Medicine, 36(12), pp.1665~1666 (2015)
  65. Cao J, "Clinical observation of effect of acupuncture combined with Chaihu Shugan and Qianzheng powders on sequelae of facial paralysis", Shanxi J of TCM, 32(8), pp.40~41 (2016)
  66. Song ZY, "Clinical observation on the treatment of sequelae of peripheral facial paralysis by tugof-war", Asia-Pacific Traditional Medicine, 12(22), pp.103~106 (2016)
  67. Chen YL, "A study on treating sequelae of facial paralysis by moxibustion at Yifeng point", Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine, 9(34), pp.36~38 (2017)
  68. Li X, "Clinical Observation on the Treatment of Hunter's Facial Paralysis with Plum Needle and Bloodletting Combined with Giant Needle Acupuncture", Lishizhen Medicine and Materia Medica Research, 28(5), pp.1139~1140 (2017)
  69. Zeng W, "To explore the clinical effect of acupuncture combined with medicine in treating sequelae of facial paralysis", Cardiovascular Disease Journal of integrated traditional Chinese and Western Medicine, 6(8), pp.75~ (2018)
  70. Zhang JN, "Observation on the therapeutic effect of acupoint injection combined with acupuncture on sequelae of peripheral facial paralysis", Asia-Pacific Traditional Medicine, 14(6), pp.169~170 (2018)
  71. Liu HY, "Acupuncture treatment of 48 cases of facial paralysis and facial paralysis", The world's latest medical information abstracts, (28), pp.160~161 (2015)
  72. Wan M, "Clinical Observation on the Treatment of Facial Paralysis by Tibetan Medicine Steam Bath and Moxibustion", Journal of Clinical Medical, 4(35), pp.6808~6810 (2017)
  73. Chen YH, "Treatment of peripheral facial paralysis sequela with Buqi-Yangxue-Rongji Decoction", Journal of Hebei TCM and Pharmacology, 24(2), pp.27~ (2009)
  74. Guo F, "Clinical progress of acupuncture treatment in peripheral sequelae", CJGM CM, 24(4), pp.776~778 (2009)
  75. Liu YY, "Recent developments in acupuncture treatment of facial paralysis sequelae", Journal of Liaoning University of TCM, 11(1), pp.54~55 (2009)
  76. Teixeira LJ, "Physical therapy for Bell's palsy (idiopathic facial paralysis)", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, (12), pp.CD006283~ (2011)
  77. Pourmomeny AA, "Management of Synkinesis and Asymmetry in Facial Nerve Palsy: A Review Article", Iranian Journal of Otorhinolaryngology, 26(4), pp.251~256 (2014)
  78. 이정우, "안면마비 후유증 및 평가 방법에 대한 고찰", Journal of Acupuncture Research, 28(2), pp.75~87 (2011), 대한침구의학회
  79. 석경환, "안면마비 후유증 평가법에 대한 고찰 및 제언", Journal of Acupuncture Research, 31(4), pp.99~108 (2014), 대한침구의학회

관련 논문AI추천

말초성 안면마비 후유증에 대한 한방 치료를 위한 후향적 차트리뷰 연구고우신, 배효빈, 윤화정대한한방안이비인후피부과학회 · 한방안이비인후피부과학회지2019 · 제32권 제1호안면신경마비의 치료와 관련된 한의학 보고들에 대한 고찰심성용대한한방안이비인후피부과학회 · 한방안이비인후피부과학회지2015 · 제28권 제4호정안침요법 복합치료를 이용한 말초성 안면마비후유증 치료 5례노현민, 박인해, 허은선, 황충연대한한방안이비인후피부과학회 · 한방안이비인후피부과학회지2016 · 제29권 제3호Bell's palsy 후유증 중 facial synkinesis에 관한 최근 논문 경향 분석 - Pubmed 중심으로 -권강, 서형식, 이동진, 황보민대한한방안이비인후피부과학회 · 한방안이비인후피부과학회지2012 · 제25권 제4호말초성 안면신경마비에 대한 매선요법 복합치료 효과김경수, 김경옥, 김지수, 박수연, 양승정, 위통순, 최창원대한한방안이비인후피부과학회 · 한방안이비인후피부과학회지2015 · 제28권 제2호한방병원에 입원한 말초성 안면신경마비 환자에 대한 한방복합치료 1례구강모, 김나영, 김준우, 손자연, 양석규, 이동환, 임유라대한한방내과학회 · 대한한방내과학회지2024 · 제45권 제5호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (11건)

창출금련탕(蒼朮芩連湯) 추출물의 항산화 및 항염증 활성에 미치는 영향박혜수, 김이화, 김용민, 원혜련pp. 1-12한방병원에서 입원치료를 시행한 중증 아토피피부염 환자의 예후지표 탐색김민희, 최인화, 박소영, 곽재영, 강민서pp. 13-21만성 저등급 염증이론을 바탕으로 한 건선의 한약치료에 대한 문헌고찰정창운, 조희근, 전선우pp. 22-30다빈도 피부질환에 대한 국내외 한의학 논문에서 평가도구 사용현황에 대한 고찰김민희, 박소영, 곽재영, 강민서, 최인화pp. 31-41국내 한약 치험례 분석을 통한 한의학적 여드름 치료법에 대한 고찰김규석, 조은채pp. 65-82
원문 보기