Effect of Education on Discriminability of Montreal Cognitive Assessment Compared to Mini-Mental State Examination
2
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Background and Purpose: The Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) has been known as a screening test for detecting mild cognitive impairment (MCI) better than Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE). However, in previous domestic studies, no significant difference was found in the discriminability between MoCA and MMSE. Researchers have suggested that this might be because older Koreans are less educated than older Westerners. This study was conducted to examine the effect of education on the discriminability of MoCA compared to the MMSE. Methods: Participants were 123 cognitively normal elderly, 118 with vascular MCI, 108 with amnestic MCI, 121 with vascular dementia, and 113 with dementia of the Alzheimer’s type. The Korean-MoCA (K-MoCA) and Korean-MMSE (K-MMSE) were administered. Multiple regression analyses and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analyses were performed. Results: In all participants, education significantly affected both K-MoCA and K-MMSE scores along with age. The effect of education was re-examined by subgroup analysis after dividing subjects according to the level of education. Effect of education on K-MoCA and K-MMSE was only shown in the group with <9 years of education. ROC curve analyses revealed that the discriminability of K-MoCA to differentiate between vascular MCI and normal elderly was significantly higher than that of K-MMSE. When re-examining subgroups divided by education level, however, this higher discriminability of K-MoCA disappeared in the group with <9 years of education. Conclusions: These results indicate no difference in discriminating cognitive deficits between K-MoCA and K-MMSE in Korean elderly with <9 years of education.
Abstract
Background and Purpose: The Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) has been known as a screening test for detecting mild cognitive impairment (MCI) better than Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE). However, in previous domestic studies, no significant difference was found in the discriminability between MoCA and MMSE. Researchers have suggested that this might be because older Koreans are less educated than older Westerners. This study was conducted to examine the effect of education on the discriminability of MoCA compared to the MMSE. Methods: Participants were 123 cognitively normal elderly, 118 with vascular MCI, 108 with amnestic MCI, 121 with vascular dementia, and 113 with dementia of the Alzheimer’s type. The Korean-MoCA (K-MoCA) and Korean-MMSE (K-MMSE) were administered. Multiple regression analyses and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analyses were performed. Results: In all participants, education significantly affected both K-MoCA and K-MMSE scores along with age. The effect of education was re-examined by subgroup analysis after dividing subjects according to the level of education. Effect of education on K-MoCA and K-MMSE was only shown in the group with <9 years of education. ROC curve analyses revealed that the discriminability of K-MoCA to differentiate between vascular MCI and normal elderly was significantly higher than that of K-MMSE. When re-examining subgroups divided by education level, however, this higher discriminability of K-MoCA disappeared in the group with <9 years of education. Conclusions: These results indicate no difference in discriminating cognitive deficits between K-MoCA and K-MMSE in Korean elderly with <9 years of education.
참고문헌 (42)
- Nasreddine ZS, "The Montreal Cognitive Assessment, MoCA : a brief screening tool for mild cognitive impairment", J Am Geriatr Soc, 53, pp.695~699 (2005)
- Petersen RC, "Mild cognitive impairment as a diagnostic entity", J Intern Med, 256, pp.183~194 (2004)
- Folstein MF, ""Mini-mental state". A practical method for grading the cognitive state of patients for the clinician", J Psychiatr Res, 12, pp.189~198 (1975)
- Folstein MF, "MMSE-2 User’s Manual" (2010), Psychological Assessment Resources
- Ciesielska N, "Is the Montreal Cognitive Assessment(MoCA)test better suited than the Mini-Mental State Examination(MMSE)in mild cognitive impairment(MCI)detection among people aged over 60? Meta-analysis", Psychiatr Pol, 50, pp.1039~1052 (2016)
- Fujiwara Y, "Brief screening tool for mild cognitive impairment in older Japanese : validation of the Japanese version of the Montreal Cognitive Assessment", Geriatr Gerontol Int, 10, pp.225~232 (2010)
- Lu J, "Montreal cognitive assessment in detecting cognitive impairment in Chinese elderly individuals : a population-based study", J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol, 24, pp.184~190 (2011)
- Pinto TC, "Is the Montreal Cognitive Assessment(MoCA)screening superior to the Mini-Mental State Examination(MMSE)in the detection of mild cognitive impairment(MCI)and Alzheimer’s Disease(AD)in the elderly?", Int Psychogeriatr, 31, pp.491~504 (2019)
- Roalf DR, "Comparative accuracies of two common screening instruments for classification of Alzheimer’s disease, mild cognitive impairment, and healthy aging", Alzheimers Dement, 9, pp.529~537 (2013)
- Pendlebury ST, "Underestimation of cognitive impairment by Mini-Mental State Examination versus the Montreal Cognitive Assessment in patients with transient ischemic attack and stroke : a population-based study", Stroke, 41, pp.1290~1293 (2010)
- Wu Y, "The effects of educational background on Montreal Cognitive Assessment screening for vascular cognitive impairment, no dementia, caused by ischemic stroke", J Clin Neurosci, 20, pp.1406~1410 (2013)
- Lee JY, "Brief screening for mild cognitive impairment in elderly outpatient clinic : validation of the Korean version of the Montreal Cognitive Assessment", J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol, 21, pp.104~110 (2008)
- 강연욱, "혈관성 인지장애 선별검사로서 Korean-Montreal Cognitive Assessment(K-MoCA)의 신뢰도, 타당도 및 규준 연구", Korean Journal of Clinical Psychology, 28(2), pp.549~562 (2009), 한국임상심리학회[DOI]
- Horton DK, "An abbreviated Montreal cognitive assessment(MoCA)for dementia screening", Clin Neuropsychol, 29, pp.413~425 (2015)
- Malek-Ahmadi M, "Age-and education-adjusted normative data for the Montreal Cognitive Assessment(MoCA)in older adults age 70-99", Neuropsychol Dev Cogn B Aging Neuropsychol Cogn, 22, pp.755~761 (2015)
- 김지인, "The MMSE and MoCA for Screening Cognitive Impairment in Less Educated Patients with Parkinson’s Disease", Journal Of Movement Disorders, 9(3), pp.152~159 (2016), 대한파킨슨병및이상운동질환학회
- Kim Haeyoon, "Validity of the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) Index Scores: a Comparison with the Cognitive Domain Scores of the Seoul Neuropsychological Screening Battery (SNSB)", Dementia and Neurocognitive Disorders(대한치매학회지), 20(3), pp.28~37 (2021), 대한치매학회[DOI]
- 곽호성, "경도인지장애 선별검사로서 Montreal Cognitive Asessment-Korea(MoCA-K)의 규준 연구", 대한통합의학회지, 9(3), pp.37~45 (2021), 대한통합의학회
- "The Korean elderly survey" (2020)[URL]
- Christensen KJ, "A cognitive battery for dementia : development and measurement characteristics", Psychol Assess, 3, pp.168~174 (1991)
- Gorelick PB, "Vascular contributions to cognitive impairment and dementia : a statement for healthcare professionals from the American Heart Association", American Stroke Association, 2011, pp.42, 2672~2713
- McKhann GM, "The diagnosis of dementia due to Alzheimer’s disease : recommendations from the National Institute on Aging-Alzheimer’s Association workgroups on diagnostic guidelines for Alzheimer’s disease", Alzheimers Dement, 7, pp.263~269 (2011)
- Morris JC, "The Clinical Dementia Rating(CDR) : current version and scoring rules", Neurology, 43, pp.2412~2414 (1993)
- 강연욱, "K-MMSE(Korean-Mini Mental State Examination)의 노인 규준 연구", 한국심리학회지:일반, 25(2), pp.1~12 (2006), 한국심리학회
- Kang Y, "Second Edition (SNSB-II): Professional Manual" (2012), Human Brain Research and Consulting
- Cho MJ, "Validation of Geriatric Depression Scale, Korean Version(GDS)in the assessment of DSM-III-R major depression", J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc, 38, pp.48~63 (1999)
- 진주희, "Re-standardization of the Korean-Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (K-IADL): Clinical Usefulness for Various Neurogenerative Diseases", Dementia and Neurocognitive Disorders(대한치매학회지), 17(1), pp.11~22 (2018), 대한치매학회[DOI]
- Hanley JA, "A method of comparing the areas under receiver operating characteristic curves derived from the same cases", Radiology, 148, pp.839~843 (1983)
- Gorunescu F, "Data Mining : Concepts, Models and Techniques", pp.319~328 (2011), Springer Science & Business Media
- Freitas S, "Montreal Cognitive Assessment(MoCA) : validation study for vascular dementia", J Int Neuropsychol Soc, 18, pp.1031~1040 (2012)
- Matallana D, "The relationship between education level and mini-mental state examination domains among older Mexican Americans", J Geriatr Psychiatry Neurol, 24, pp.9~18 (2011)
- Wong A, "The validity, reliability and clinical utility of the Hong Kong Montreal Cognitive Assessment(HK-MoCA)in patients with cerebral small vessel disease", Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord, 28, pp.81~87 (2009)
- Nazem S, "Montreal cognitive assessment performance in patients with Parkinson’s disease with"normal"global cognition according to mini-mental state examination score", J Am Geriatr Soc, 57, pp.304~308 (2009)
- Ye BS, "Effects of education on the progression of early-versus late-stage mild cognitive impairment", Int Psychogeriatr, 25, pp.597~606 (2013)
- Wachholz TB, "The interpretation of proverbs by elderly with high, medium and low educational level : abstract reasoning as an aspect of executive functions", Dement Neuropsychol, 5, pp.31~37 (2011)
- Campanholo KR, "Impact of sociodemographic variables on executive functions", Dement Neuropsychol, 11, pp.62~68 (2017)
- Cortés Pascual A, "The relationship between executive functions and academic performance in primary education : review and meta-analysis", Front Psychol, 10, pp.1582~ (2019)
- De Jager CA, "Sensitivity and specificity of neuropsychological tests for mild cognitive impairment, vascular cognitive impairment and Alzheimer’s disease", Psychol Med, 33, pp.1039~1050 (2003)
- Sachdev P, "Diagnostic criteria for vascular cognitive disorders : a VASCOG statement", Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord, 28, pp.206~218 (2014)
- Sudo FK, "A continuum of executive function deficits in early subcortical vascular cognitive impairment : a systematic review and meta-analysis", Dement Neuropsychol, 11, pp.371~380 (2017)
- Julayanont P, "The Montreal Cognitive Assessment-Basic : a screening tool for mild cognitive impairment in illiterate and low-educated elderly adults", J Am Geriatr Soc, 63, pp.2550~2554 (2015)
- Luis CA, "Cross validation of the Montreal Cognitive Assessment in community dwelling older adults residing in the Southeastern US", Int J Geriatr Psychiatry, 24, pp.197~201 (2009)