본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

이행청구권에 관한 비교법적 연구

A Comparative Study on the Right to Require Performance

이병문
한국사법학회 (The Korean Association of Private Law)|2007.09|비교사법 (The Journal of Comparative Private Law)|제14권 제3호|pp. 505-540|DOI 10.22922/jcpl.14.3.200709.505

0

조회

0

다운로드

9

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

채무불이행특정이행영미법PICCCommon Law이행청구권강제이행Specific PerformanceBreach of ContractRight to Require PerformanceEquity Law
주제분류법학

초록

Abstract

A Comparative Study on the Right to Require PerformanceByung-Mun LeeThis study primarily concerns the right to require performance which is known as a process whereby the obligee obtains as nearly as possible the actual subject-matter of his bargain, as opposed to compensation in money for failing to obtain it. It is recognized in the civil law as a right available in the event of the obligor’s breach of contract so that if the obligee applies for a judgement for performance, the court is bound to grant him a judgement forcing the seller to perform what the seller has undertaken under the contract. In contrast, granting specific performance under English law is a remedy which is not treated as a right of the obligee who is aggrieved by the obligor’s breach, but as an equitable remedy whose exercise is left to the discretion of the court. In general, English courts are very reluctant to decree specific performance of contracts because of the rivalry between the courts of common law and equity and the reluctance to use the process of contempt of court, and such performance is granted in very limited circumstances. Having recognized the differences, the study describes and analyzes the rules on the remedy of specific performance under English law in comparison to those under PICC and Korean law. It also attempts to evaluate them in light of the discipline of Law and Economics.

참고문헌 (42)

  1. "이행청구권에 대한 비교법적 검토", 2(14) (2003), 연세법학회
  2. "현대 계약법상의 이행청구권", 15(1) (2004), 충북대 법학연구소
  3. "유니드로와(UNIDROIT)국제상사계약원칙에 있어서 계약책임", 11(2) (1999), 한국해사법학회
  4. "민법주해 IX" (1996), 박영사
  5. "민법주해 IX" (1996), 박영사
  6. "Remedies for Breach of Contract" (1980)
  7. "Chitty on Contracts" (1999), Sweet and Maxwell
  8. "Cases, Materials and Text on Contract Law" (2002), Hart Publishing
  9. "A New Approach to International Commercial Contracts: the Unidroit Principles of International Commercial Contracts" (1999), Kluwer Law International
  10. "Consumer Sales and Associated Guarantees" (2003), Oxford University Press
  11. "The Sale of Goods" (1997), Oxford University Press
  12. "Law as Practical Reason" (1989)
  13. "The Relationship of Contractual Remedies to Political and Social Status" (1982)
  14. "Comparative Remedies for Breach of Contract" (2005), Hart Pub
  15. "Law and Economics" (1997), Addison-Wesley
  16. "The Case for Specific Performance as the Primary Remedy for Breach of Contract in New Zealand", 35, pp.657~ (2004)
  17. "Inducement of Breach of Contract as a Problem of Ostensible Ownership", pp.16~ (1987)
  18. "Remedies in Contract & Tort, 2nd ed" (2002), Butterworths
  19. "Essays on Bentham" (1982), Oxford University Press
  20. "Towards A European Civil Code, 3rd ed" (2004), Kluwer Law International
  21. "Specific Performance" (1996), LexisNexis UK
  22. "An Introduction to the Economic Analysis of Contract Remedies" (1986)
  23. "On the Amorality of Contract Remedies Efficiency", pp.81~ (1981)
  24. "The Inadequacy of Adequacy The Granting of Specific Performance", pp.38~ (1987)
  25. "Efficient Breach of Contract Circles in the Sky" (1982)
  26. "Economics and the Law: From Posner to Post-Modernism" (1997), Princeton University Press
  27. "Economics of the Law" (1997), Oxford University Press
  28. "Misreading Oliver Wendell Holmes on Efficient Breach and Tortious Interference", 68, pp.1085~ (2000)
  29. "The Economics of Justice" (1981), Harvard University Press
  30. "Economic Analysis of Law, 5th ed" (1998), Aspen Law and Business
  31. "Efficient Reliance and Damage Measures for Breach of Contract", 15, pp.39~ (1984)
  32. "Unidroit Principles and Harmonization of International Commercial Law Focus on Chapter seven", pp.441~ (1997)
  33. "The Case for Specific Performance" (1979)
  34. "Injunctions and Specific Performance, 3rd. ed" (2000), Canada Law Book Inc
  35. "The Design of Contracts and Remedies for Breach", 99, pp.121~ (1984)
  36. "Remedies for Breach of Contract" (1988), Clarendon Press
  37. "The Law of Contract" (1999), Sweet and Maxwell
  38. "Unidroit Principles of International Commercial Contracts" (2004)
  39. "The Efficiency of Specific Performance Toward a Unified Theory of Contract Remedies" (1998), Oxford University Press
  40. "For Specific Performance under the United Nations Sales Convention" (1991)
  41. "The Remedial Provisions in the Vienna Sales Convention" (1984)
  42. "translated by T. Weir, An Introduction to Comparative law, 3rd ed" (1998), Oxford University Press

관련 논문AI추천

국제물품매매계약에 관한 UN협약에서 특정이행청구권에 관한 연구신창섭한국경영법률학회 · 경영법률2006 · 제17권 제1호유럽契約法 原則 下에서 不履行과 法的 救濟에 관한 比較法的 考察심종석법무부 · 국제법무연구2005 · 제62호동시이행의 항변권에 관한 일고찰서순택법학연구원 · 성균관법학2009 · 제21권 제3호强制履行― 특히 間接强制의 補充性을 중심으로 ―김형석법학연구소 · 서울대학교 법학2005 · 제46권 제4호이득상환청구권의 예외성에 대한 검토안강현한국사법학회 · 비교사법2005 · 제12권 제2호계약해제의 요건 -비교법적 법원리를 중심으로-정진명한국재산법학회 · 재산법연구2005 · 제21권 제2호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (34건)

필수설비이론의 동향에 관한 비교법적 검토 - 미국의 주요 사건을 중심으로 -권재열pp. 1-32투자은행과 이해상충김화진pp. 33-92規制와 私的 責任原理의 組合에 關한 法經濟學的 分析: 證券去來 分野를 中心으로모병욱, 김진호, 김일중pp. 93-146유럽에서의 배아줄기세포발명에 대한 특허:법, 윤리성 및 규제간의 긴장관계의 해결Graeme Lauriepp. 147-160인터넷의 발달과 증권규제 - 내부자거래를 중심으로 -장근영pp. 161-198
원문 보기