본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

After Cancún:G21, WTO, and Multilateralism

Imtiaz Hussain
국제학연구소 (The Keimyung Institute for International Studies)|2004.12|Journal of International and Area Studies|제11권 제2호|pp. 1-16|DOI 10.23071/jias.2004.11.2.1

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

주제분류정치외교학

초록

Abstract

Why did the Cancún WTO meeting collapse? What is expected next? A content analysis finds G21 at the interface of 1) less developed countries (LDCs) protesting the uneven playing field; 2) long-standing substantive fissures; 3) increasing unilateralism by developed countries (DCs); and 4) farm protection haunting multilateralism. US competitive liberalization emerges most coherently from the WTO wreckage (Feinberg 2003). Based on discrimination and asymmetrical reciprocity, it aggressively targets the European Union (EU), seeks LDC bandwagoning, discourages regime reconstruction (Krasner 1982), defies neorealist/neoliberalist/constructivist tendencies (Waltz 1979; Keohane 1989; Hopf 1998), and predicts future trade turbulence (Rosenau 1997).

참고문헌 (136)

  1. Richard, "？Bilateral trade arrangements in the Asia-Pacific University of California", tion and implications (2003), ？ Berkeley APEC Study Center
  2. Hirschman, "National Power and the Structure of Foreign Trade University of California" (1981)
  3. Feinberg, "Bilateral trade arrangements in the Asia-Pacific University of California National Power and the Structure of Foreign Trade University of California The promise of constructivism in international relations theory Direction of Trade Statistics Yearbook Essays in international relations theory American trade laws after the Uruguay Round Exploring Governance in a Turbulent World Theory of International Politics The emerging structure of international politics The prenegotiation phase of the Uruguay Round", tion and implications, pp.171 158 44 384 280~200 79 79 96 302, Berkeley APEC Study Center Cornell University Press Cambridge University Press
  4. Feinberg, "？Bilateral trade arrangements in the Asia-Pacific University of California", tion and implications (2003), ？ Berkeley APEC Study Center
  5. Feinberg, "？Bilateral trade arrangements in the Asia-Pacific University of California", tion and implications (2003), ？ Berkeley APEC Study Center
  6. Hopf, "？The promise of constructivism in international relations theory", pp.171~200 (1998)
  7. Hirschman, "National Power and the Structure of Foreign Trade University of California" (1981)
  8. Hirschman, "National Power and the Structure of Foreign Trade University of California" (1981)
  9. Hopf, "？The promise of constructivism in international relations theory", pp.171~200 (1998)
  10. Hopf, "？The promise of constructivism in international relations theory", pp.171~200 (1998)
  11. 2000 Washington, "Direction of Trade Statistics Yearbook" (2000)
  12. 2000 Washington, "Direction of Trade Statistics Yearbook" (2000)
  13. Keohane, "Essays in international relations theory", pp.158~79 (1989)
  14. 2000 Washington, "Direction of Trade Statistics Yearbook" (2000)
  15. from, "Textile workers？ tales of woe Cairns Group meeting to kickstart trade talks State of affairs CII happy with India？s stand at trade talks Mexican trade minister？s decision to halt deliberations baffled developing countries India to push for fresh WTO talks India urged to be flexible on farm tariff cuts USTR touts APEC overlaps with WTO Doha Poor nations join forces against the rich Europe and US say they are ready to compromise", pp.~9 15 1 16 025 20 9 21 11 15 (2003)
  16. Keohane, "Essays in international relations theory", pp.158~79 (1989)
  17. Keohane, "Essays in international relations theory", pp.158~79 (1989)
  18. Mastel, "American trade laws after the Uruguay Round" (1996)
  19. Mastel, "American trade laws after the Uruguay Round" (1996)
  20. Mastel, Greg, "American trade laws after the Uruguay Round" (1996)
  21. Rosenau, "Exploring Governance in a Turbulent World" (1997), Cambridge University Press
  22. Rosenau, "Exploring Governance in a Turbulent World" (1997), Cambridge University Press
  23. Waltz, "Theory of International Politics ？The emerging structure of international politics", pp.44~79
  24. Rosenau, "Exploring Governance in a Turbulent World" (1997), Cambridge University Press
  25. Waltz, "Theory of International Politics ？The emerging structure of international politics", pp.44~79
  26. Waltz, "Theory of International Politics ？The emerging structure of international politics", pp.44~79
  27. Winham, "？The prenegotiation phase of the Uruguay Round", pp.280~302 (1989)
  28. Winham, "？The prenegotiation phase of the Uruguay Round", pp.280~302 (1989)
  29. Winham, "？The prenegotiation phase of the Uruguay Round", pp.280~302 (1989)
  30. Beshai, Adel, "fiesta or failure?？ Al-Ahram Weekly Online", pp.~15 (2003)
  31. Abdel-Razek, "FTA inches forward" (2003), ？FTA inches forward
  32. ？ Dawn, "？Cracks begin appearing in G-22 bloc", 2003, pp.11 (2003), 03[DOI]
  33. Adel, "fiesta or failure?？ Al-Ahram Weekly Online", print, pp.2003 (2003), 659[DOI]
  34. Bussey, "？Bilateral pacts also goal for US the United States announces a flurry of new planned negotiations" (2003)
  35. Beshai, Adel, "Cancun:fiesta or failure", pp.~15 (2003)
  36. July 22, "？EU？s sugar subsidies in a jam", socecon, pp.ffd (2003), 2003[DOI]
  37. Bokhari, Ashfak, "Cracks begin appearing in G-22 bloc" (2003)
  38. ？ Dawn, "？Cracks begin appearing in G-22 bloc", 2003, pp.11 (2003), 03[DOI]
  39. Bussey, Jane, "Bilateral pacts also goal for US: the United States announces a flurry of new planned negotiations" (2003)
  40. Bussey, "？Bilateral pacts also goal for US the United States announces a flurry of new planned negotiations" (2003)
  41. Clarke, "？WTO collapse in Canc？n", pp.~22 (2003)
  42. Cox, "？Can US beat the heat at trade talks in Miami", money, pp.economy (2003), trade[DOI]
  43. July 22, "？EU？s sugar subsidies in a jam", socecon, pp.ffd (2003), 2003[DOI]
  44. Capdevila, Gustavo, "EU？s sugar subsidies in a jam" (2003), ？ Inter Press Service
  45. Clarke, Tony, "WTO collapse in Canc？n", pp.~22 (2003)
  46. ？ Al-Ahram Weekly Online, "？One last tango in Cancun", print, pp.2003 (2003), 657[DOI]
  47. Clarke, "？WTO collapse in Canc？n", pp.~22 (2003)
  48. Hesse, Stephen, "WTO conference: poor farmers pay price for subsidies" (2003)
  49. Cox, "？Can US beat the heat at trade talks in Miami", money, pp.economy (2003), trade[DOI]
  50. Cox, "？Can US beat the heat at trade talks in Miami", money, pp.economy (2003), trade[DOI]
  51. ？ Al-Ahram Weekly Online, "？One last tango in Cancun", print, pp.2003 (2003), 657[DOI]
  52. ？ Al-Ahram Weekly Online, "？One last tango in Cancun", print, pp.2003 (2003), 657[DOI]
  53. Martin, "？New Singapore issues still part of ？single undertaking？ ？New post-Cancun talks resume at WTO with an ？almost non-event？", pp.~16 (2003)
  54. Hesse, "poor farmers pay price for subsidies" (2003)
  55. Hesse, "poor farmers pay price for subsidies" (2003)
  56. Mathiason, "？Poor rattle doors of WTO club ？Rich-nation greed prompting poor nations to club together", pp.~14 19
  57. Martin, "？New Singapore issues still part of ？single undertaking？ ？New post-Cancun talks resume at WTO with an ？almost non-event？", pp.~16 (2003)
  58. Martin, "？New Singapore issues still part of ？single undertaking？ ？New post-Cancun talks resume at WTO with an ？almost non-event？", pp.~16 (2003)
  59. "The worst of times", pp.~5 (2003)
  60. Moreno, "？US adds 6 players to lean on Brazil American giant puts up Resistance" (2003)
  61. Mathiason, "？Poor rattle doors of WTO club ？Rich-nation greed prompting poor nations to club together", pp.~14 19
  62. Mathiason, Nick, "Poor rattle doors of WTO club ？Rich-nation greed prompting poor nations to club together", pp.~14 19 (2003)
  63. ？ The Guardian, "？The worst of times", pp.~5 (2003)
  64. Morton, "？Canada clashes with US on trade deals ？outrage？ over watered-down pacts" (2003)
  65. "The worst of times", pp.~5 (2003)
  66. Pierri, "？South America up in arms over US farm bill", socecon, pp.bwi-wto (2002), wto[DOI]
  67. Moreno, "？US adds 6 players to lean on Brazil American giant puts up Resistance" (2003)
  68. Moreno, Jenalia, "US adds 6 players to lean on Brazil: S. American giant puts up Resistance" (2003)
  69. Palmer, "Andean countries to negotiate trade pact" (2003)
  70. Morton, Peter, "Canada clashes with US on trade deals: ？outrage" (2003)
  71. Morton, "？Canada clashes with US on trade deals ？outrage？ over watered-down pacts" (2003)
  72. Pierri, "？South America up in arms over US farm bill", socecon, pp.bwi-wto (2002), wto[DOI]
  73. Pierri, Ra？l, "South America up in arms over US farm bill" (2002), ？ Inter Press Services
  74. Palmer, Doug, "Andean countries to negotiate trade pact" (2003)
  75. Palmer, "Andean countries to negotiate trade pact" (2003)
  76. June 30, "？WTO ignores calls for democratic inclusive processes for Canc？n", socecon, pp.bwi-wto (2003), wto[DOI]
  77. Rajagopalan, T.N.C, "Cancun failure is a big blow for India", pp.~16 0903 (2003)
  78. ？ Business Standard, "？Run-up to Canc？n WTO？s Singapore issues caught in a sling trade talks in tatters developing nations force fresh talks in Geneva in December", socecon, pp.bwi-wto (2003), wto[DOI]
  79. June 30, "？WTO ignores calls for democratic inclusive processes for Canc？n", socecon, pp.bwi-wto (2003), wto[DOI]
  80. Raghavan, Chakravarthi, "WTO ignores calls for democratic, inclusive processes for Canc？n" (2003)
  81. ？ Business Standard, "？Cancun failure is a big blow for India", pp.~16 0903 (2003)
  82. ？ Business Standard, "？EU adamant on Singapore issues", pp.~11 (2003)
  83. Rajagopalan, T.N.C, "Cancun failure is a big blow for India", pp.~16 0903 (2003)
  84. ？ Business Standard, "？Run-up to Canc？n WTO？s Singapore issues caught in a sling trade talks in tatters developing nations force fresh talks in Geneva in December", socecon, pp.bwi-wto (2003), wto[DOI]
  85. Singh, Mamata, "？India not to budge on investment", pp.~9 (2003)
  86. ？ Business Standard, "？Run-up to Canc？n WTO？s Singapore issues caught in a sling trade talks in tatters developing nations force fresh talks in Geneva in December", socecon, pp.bwi-wto (2003), wto[DOI]
  87. ？ Business Standard, "？EU adamant on Singapore issues", pp.~11 (2003)
  88. Wahish, Niveen, "Tightrope walk to Cancun", pp.~17 (2003)
  89. ？ Business Standard, "？EU adamant on Singapore issues", pp.~11 (2003)
  90. Singh, "？India not to budge on investment", pp.~9 (2003)
  91. Singh, Mamata, "India not to budge on investment", pp.~9 (2003)
  92. Peter, "citrus industries at odds with Bush over free trade" (2003)
  93. ？ Al-Ahram Weekly Online, "？Tightrope walk to Cancun", print, pp.2003 (2003), 655[DOI]
  94. Wahish, Niveen, "Tightrope walk to Cancun", pp.~17 (2003)
  95. Weisman, "？EU trade negotiator unyielding on subsidies" (2003)
  96. Walker, Andrew, "WTO kickstarts trade talks", pp.~15 (2003)
  97. Peter, "citrus industries at odds with Bush over free trade" (2003)
  98. Wallsten, Peter, "Sugar, citrus industries at odds with Bush over free trade" (2003)
  99. Weisman, "？EU trade negotiator unyielding on subsidies" (2003)
  100. March 25-27, "London School of Economics forum on ？Global dimensions", federal trust, ？2003, ~
  101. Weisman, Jonathan, "EU trade negotiator unyielding on subsidies" (2003)
  102. ？ from, "？Textile workers？ tales of woe", pp.~9 (2003)
  103. Woolcock, Stephen, "International competition policy and world trade" (2003)
  104. March 25-27, "London School of Economics forum on ？Global dimensions", federal trust, ？2003, ~
  105. "London School of Economics forum on"
  106. ？ from, "？Textile workers？ tales of woe", pp.~9 (2003)
  107. ？ from, "？Textile workers？ tales of woe", pp.~9 (2003)
  108. BusinessDay, "Cairns Group meeting to kickstart trade talks" (2003)
  109. Business Standard, "？State of affairs", pp.~1 (2003)
  110. BBC News, "World trade talks collapse", pp.~15 (2003)
  111. November 14, "？Cairns Group meeting to kickstart trade talks" (2003)
  112. Business Standard, "？CII happy with India？s stand at trade talks", pp.~16 025 (2003)
  113. BusinessDay, "Cairns Group meeting to kickstart trade talks" (2003)
  114. Business Standard, "？State of affairs", pp.~1 (2003)
  115. Business Standard, "？State of affairs", pp.~1 (2003)
  116. Business Standard, "Why Cancun did not succeed: Mexican trade minister", pp.~20 (2003)
  117. Business Standard, "？CII happy with India？s stand at trade talks", pp.~16 025 (2003)
  118. Business Standard, "？India to push for fresh WTO talks", pp.~9 (2003)
  119. Business Standard, "CII happy with India？s stand at trade talks", pp.~16 025 (2003)
  120. Business Standard, "Mexican trade minister？s decision to halt deliberations baffled developing countries", pp.~20 (2003)
  121. Business Standard, "Mexican trade minister？s decision to halt deliberations baffled developing countries", pp.~20 (2003)
  122. Business Standard, "India urged to be flexible on farm tariff cuts" (2003)
  123. ？ from, "？USTR touts APEC overlaps with WTO Doha", pp.~21 (2003)
  124. Business Standard, "？India to push for fresh WTO talks", pp.~9 (2003)
  125. Business Standard, "India to push for fresh WTO talks", pp.~9 (2003)
  126. Business Standard, "？India urged to be flexible on farm tariff cuts" (2003)
  127. Business Standard, "India urged to be flexible on farm tariff cuts" (2003)
  128. Taipei Times, "？Poor nations join forces against the rich", pp.~11 (2003)
  129. ？ from, "？USTR touts APEC overlaps with WTO Doha", pp.~21 (2003)
  130. ？ from, "？USTR touts APEC overlaps with WTO Doha", pp.~21 (2003)
  131. Taipei Times, "？Europe and US say they are ready to compromise", pp.~15 (2003)
  132. Taipei Times, "？Poor nations join forces against the rich", pp.~11 (2003)
  133. Taipei Times, "？Poor nations join forces against the rich", pp.~11 (2003)
  134. Taipei Times, "？Europe and US say they are ready to compromise", pp.~15 (2003)
  135. Taipei Times, "？Europe and US say they are ready to compromise", pp.~15 (2003)
  136. Taipei Times, "？Europe and US say they are ready to compromise", pp.~15 (2003)

관련 논문AI추천

Trade Liberalization under New RealitiesSajid Anwar, S.Zahid Ali경제연구소 · Journal of Economic Development2006 · 제31권 제1호The Evolving Role of Trade Diplomacy in Multilateral Trade Negotiations: Experience of Agricultural Trade LiberalisationTissaRajapakse,RamanieSamaratunge국제학연구소 · Journal of International and Area Studies2002 · 제9권 제2호침체기에 빠진 WTO, 제12차 각료회의 성과를 통해 부활할 수 있을까?안홍상법무부 · 국제법무연구2021 · 제4호WTO에서의 多者間投資協定 締結論議와 展望김인숙법무부 · 국제법무연구2003 · 제53호ASEM Cooperation in the DDA NegotiationKeuk-JeSung한국유럽학회 · 유럽연구2002 · 제15권 The multilateral Agreement on Investment: Implications and Policy Recommendations김관호대외경제정책연구원 · East Asian Economic Review1997 · 제1권 제1호

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (5건)

Commercial Presence in the Hospital Sector under GATS: A Case Study of IndiaIndrani Gupta, Bishwanath Goldarpp. 17-43Success and Failure of Business Negotiations for South KoreansClaudia L. Hale, Nagesh Rao, Yong-Jin Songpp. 45-65Analysis of the Changing Trends in Attitudes and Values by Chinese: The Case of Shanghai’s Young & EducatedLe Lu, Ilan Alonpp. 67-88Constraints on Environmental News Production in the U. S.:Interviews with American Journalists양정혜pp. 89-105The French Road to European Community:From the ECSC to the EEC (1945-1957)이재성pp. 107-123
원문 보기