본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

Democratic Peace and Covert War: A Case Study of the U.S. Covert War in Chile

김재천
국제학연구소 (The Keimyung Institute for International Studies)|2005.06|Journal of International and Area Studies|제12권 제1호|pp. 25-47|DOI 10.23071/jias.2005.12.1.25

0

조회

0

다운로드

0

인용

0

참고문헌

주제분류정치외교학

초록

Abstract

A body of scholarly work organized around “Democratic Peace” demonstrates that democracies rarely if ever wage war against other democracies, although occasionally they may do so against non-democracies. The United States (U.S.), however, has engaged in covert wars against other democratically-elected governments. Do the so-called Democratic Peace findings carry over to the somewhat murkier realm of covert war? By analyzing the U.S. covert war against Chile in the early 1970s, this paper looks for implications of covert wars waged between democracies for Democratic Peace scholarship. Arguably, there are two strands of causal logic to Democratic Peace. One attributes the absence of war among democracies to democratic institutional constraints: the restraining effects of public opinions or those of the checks and balances embedded in a democratic state’s domestic political institutions (institutional/structural explanation). Other theories posit that democratic norms and culture  peaceful conflict resolution norms and culture shared by elites  account for the absence of war between democratic states (normative/cultural explanations). If the nonviolent norms of elites in democracies were sufficient, the U.S. should not have resorted to covert war as well as overt war to resolve conflict with democratic Chile. The paper demonstrates that the findings on the U.S. covert war against Chile undermine the cultural/normative explanation of Democratic Peace.

참고문헌 (47)

  1. "The Case of Chile" (1978), The Free Press
  2. Benoit, Kenneth, "Democracies really are More Pacific(in General", 40, pp.636~657 (1996)
  3. "Allendes Chile" (1977), International Publishers
  4. "An Institutional Explanation of the Democratic Peace" (1999)
  5. Carpenter,Ted G, "The United States and Third World Dictatorships:A Case for Benign Detachment", pp.36~50 (1985)
  6. "In Search of Democratic Peace:Problems and Promise", 41, pp.59~91 (1997)
  7. Davis,Nathaniel, "The Last Two Years of Salvador Allende" (1985), Cornell University Press
  8. "Democracy and the Management of International Conflict", pp.42~68 (1993)
  9. "Democracy and the Peaceful Settlement of International Conflict", pp.14~32 (1994)
  10. "Dyads, Disputes, and the Democratic Peace", pp.126~130 (1998), Kluwer
  11. "Case Study and Theory in Political Science Handbook of Political Science" (1975)
  12. "Journal of Peace Research 29", pp.385~395 (1992)
  13. "The Political System of Chile" (1966), Houghton Mifflin
  14. Hersch, "The Price of Power Kissinger in the Nixon White House" (1983)
  15. "The Years of Upheaval" (1982), Brown and Company
  16. "Years of Renewal" (1999), Simon & Schuster
  17. Knott, Stephen F, "Secret and Sanctioned: Covert Operations and the American Presidency," (1996), Oxford University Press
  18. "An Interpretation of American Expansion", Cornell University Press
  19. "The United States in Central America", tions (1993)
  20. Layne,Christopher, "Kant or Cant:The Myth of the Democratic Peace", pp.5~49 (1994)
  21. Linz, "The Failure of Presidential Democracy" (1994), Johns Hopkins University Press
  22. "Normative and Structural Causes of Democratic Peace" (1993), 624-638
  23. "University of South Carolina Press" (1989)
  24. Nixon, "The Memoirs of Richard Nixon" (1979)
  25. ONeal, John R, "Triangulating Peace: Democracy, Interdependence, and International Organizations" (2001), Norton.
  26. "How Liberalism Produces Democratic Peace", pp.87~129 (1994)
  27. "American Politics and International Security" (1997), Cornell University Press
  28. Prados, John, "Presidents Secret Wars: CIA and Pentagon Covert Operations from World War II through the Persian Gulf" (1996), Ivan R. Dee.
  29. "Democracy and International Conflict" (1995), University of South Carolina Press
  30. Richelson, Jeffrey, "The U.S. Intelligence Community" (1999), Westview Press
  31. "Democratic Peace Warlike Democracies? A Social Constructivist Interpretation of the Liberal Argument", 1, pp.491~517 (1995)
  32. "Power Kills:Democracy as a Method of Non-Violence" (1997), Transaction.
  33. "Principles for Post-Cold War" (1993), Princeton Princeton University Press
  34. Russett, Bruce, "From Democratic Peace to Kantian Peace: Democracy and Conflict in the International System" (2000), University of Michigan Press
  35. "The United States and Democracy in Chile" (1993), Johns Hopkins University Press
  36. Sorenson,George, "Kant and Processes of Democratization:Consequences of Neorealist Thought", pp.405~33 (1992)
  37. "The Limits of Intervention in the Postwar World" (1987), Basic Books
  38. "The Emergence of Democracy A Comparative Study of 119 States Finnish Society of Sciences and Letters"
  39. "The Process of Democratization A Comparative Study of 147 States"
  40. "The Case Against Intervention", pp.72~80 (1990)
  41. November 6, "Briefing by Richard Helms for the National Security Council" (1970)
  42. "Memorandum of Conversation of Meeting with Henry Kissinger", pp.~15 (1970)
  43. "Operating Guidance Cable on Coup Plotting", pp.~16 (1970)
  44. "Report of CIA Chilean Task Force Activities" (1970)
  45. "Department of Defense", pp.~1 (1973)
  46. "Department of State" (1973)
  47. "Report to Chilean Military on Detainee" (1975)

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (6건)

Power Transition and U.S.-China Relations:Is War Inevitable?Zhiqun Zhupp. 1-24Economic Crisis, Poverty, and the Emergence of Populism in Thailand최정욱pp. 49-59The End of Britain?:Challenges from Devolution, European Integration, and Multiculturalism김남국pp. 61-80Endangered Korean Minority Society in China:Recent Socio-demographic Changes in the Yanbian Korean Autonomous Prefecture김두섭, 김정민pp. 81-98Foreign Direct Investment and Location Advantages:Japanese Perceptions of India Compared to China and ASEANN. S. Siddharthan, M.L. Lakherapp. 99-110
원문 보기