Alterations of the Past and Future : History, Interests, and Politics in the Contemporary Korea Japan Relations
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
In this work, I attempt to draw a broad picture of Korea-Japan relations over the last 5 decades on the basis of inductive reasoning. By reviewing the history of their bilateral interactions since the normalization of diplomatic relationship in terms of cooperation and conflict, I sort out three cases of qualitatively advanced cooperation and four cases of serious diplomatic confrontations. By analyzing these cases of cooperation and conflict, I detect the common variablesthat affected most the aspects and results. Based on such empirical analyses, I put forth three arguments. The first is that the essential formula of cooperation and conflict in Korea-Japan relations can be articulated as the interactions between economic incentives as the cooperative factor and historical perception gaps as the cause of provocation. The second argument is that the economic motivations and history issues are affected, in turn, by variables such as international political system, economic developments and domestic political changes in each country.The third argument is that from the 1990s on, the factors that affect the basic formula of Korea-Japan relations have changed in ways that decrease the economic incentives while increasing the saliency of history issues.
Abstract
In this work, I attempt to draw a broad picture of Korea-Japan relations over the last 5 decades on the basis of inductive reasoning. By reviewing the history of their bilateral interactions since the normalization of diplomatic relationship in terms of cooperation and conflict, I sort out three cases of qualitatively advanced cooperation and four cases of serious diplomatic confrontations. By analyzing these cases of cooperation and conflict, I detect the common variablesthat affected most the aspects and results. Based on such empirical analyses, I put forth three arguments. The first is that the essential formula of cooperation and conflict in Korea-Japan relations can be articulated as the interactions between economic incentives as the cooperative factor and historical perception gaps as the cause of provocation. The second argument is that the economic motivations and history issues are affected, in turn, by variables such as international political system, economic developments and domestic political changes in each country.The third argument is that from the 1990s on, the factors that affect the basic formula of Korea-Japan relations have changed in ways that decrease the economic incentives while increasing the saliency of history issues.
참고문헌 (48)
- Abramowitz, Morton, "Adjusting to the New Asia", Foreign Affairs, 82(4) (2003)
- Ahn,Byung‐Joon, "The Rise of China and the Future of East Asian Integration", Asia‐Pacific Review, 11(2) (2004)
- Austin, Michael R., "Japan and South Korea: The New East Asian Core", Orbis, (Summer) (2005)
- Berger, Thomas., "The Construction of Antagonism: The History Problem in Japan’s Foreign Relations, Reinventing the Alliance: U.S.‐Japan Security Partnership in an Era of Change" (2003), Palgrave
- Bridges, Brian., "Japan and Korea in the 1990s: From Antagonism to Adjustment" (1993), Cambridge University Press
- Calder,Kent., "The New Face of Northeast Asia", Foreign Affairs, 80(1) (2001)
- Cha, Victor D., "Alignment Despite Antagonism: The U.S.–Korea‐Japan Security Triangle" (1999), Stanford University Press
- Cha,Victor D, "Abandonment,Entrapment,and Neoclassical Realism in Asia:The United States,Japan and Korea", International Studies Quarterly, 44 (2000)
- Choi, Hee‐Gap., "Korea‐Japan FTA and the Changes in Financial Industry" (2004), Samsung Institute for Economic Research
- Chung, Sung‐Chun, "The Characteristics and the Directions for Cooperation in Korea‐Japan Economic Relations" (2005), Segyegyungje (World Economics)
- Colbert, Evelyn., "Japan and the Republic of Korea: Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow", Asian Survey, 26(3) (1986)
- 동북아의 평화를 위한 바른 역사 정립 기획단, "Changes in the Korea‐Japan Relations Since the Kim Young‐Sam Government", Council for the Establishment of Correct History toward Northeast Asian Peace, ~ (2005)
- Crone, Donald., "Does Hegemony Matter? The Reorganization of the Pacific Political Economy", World Politics, 45(4) (1993)
- Curtis, Gerald C., "Japan's Foreign Policy after the Cold War: Coping With Change" (1993), Sharpe
- Duck, Isa., "Status Power: Japanese Foreign Policy Making Toward Korea" (2002), Routledge
- Fukuyama,Francis, "Re‐Envisioning Asia", Foreign Affairs, 84(1) (2005)
- Green, Michael., "Japan's Reluctant Realism: Foreign Policy Changes in an Era of Uncertain Power" (2001), St. Martin's Press
- Hahn Bae‐ho., "Korea‐Japan Relations in the 1970s", Asian Survey, 20(11) (1980)
- Han, Bae Ho, "The Korean Peninsula and the Major Powers" (1998), Sejong Institute
- Han, Bae Ho., "Policy Toward Japan, The Foreign Policy of the Republic of Korea" (1985), Columbia University Press
- Harbor, Deborah., "The Death of Hegemony: Why Pax Nipponica Is Impossible", Asian Survey, 30 (1990)
- Ikenberry, John., "International Relations Theory and the Asia‐Pacific" (2003), Columbia University Press
- Inoguchi, Takashi., "Distant Neighbors? Japan and Asia", Current History, 94(595) (1995)
- Kim, Do‐Hyung., "The Reconsideration of Korea‐Japan Relations and the New Industrial Cooperation", Journal of Korea‐Japan Economic Cooperation, 12 (1996)
- Kim,Ho‐Sup, "Korea‐Japan Relations in the Period of Democratization", Gukjejeongchinonchong (Korean International Political Science Review, 28(2) (1987)
- Kim, Ho‐Sup, "The Evaluation and Prospects of Roh Mu‐Hyun Governments’ Policies Toward Japan, The Prospects and Tasks for the Formation of Northeast Asia in the 21st Century" (2006), Hanul
- Kim, Hong N., "Japanese‐South Korean Relations in the Post‐Vietnam Era", Asian Survey, 16(10) (1976)
- Kim, Hong N., "Japanese‐Korean Relations in the 1980s", Asian Survey, 27(5) (1987)
- Krauss, Ellis S., "Beyond Bilateralism: U.S.‐Japan Relations in the New Asia‐Pacific" (2004), Stanford University Press
- Kristof, Nicholas D., "Problem of Memory", Foreign Affairs, 77(6) (1998)
- Lee, Chae Jin., "Japan and Korea: The Political Dimension" (1985), Hoover Institution Press
- Lee, Hong‐Bae., "The Changes in Japanese Foreign Policy and Their Implications for Korea", Segyegyungje (World Economics) (1999)
- Lee,Won‐Duk., "The Basic Nature and Problems of ’1965 System’:Implications for the Normalization of North Korea‐Japan Diplomatic Relations", GukjeㆍJiyok Yongu (Journal of International and Area Studies), 9(4) (2000)
- Lee, Won‐Duk., "An Analysis of the Changes and Major Issues of the Korea‐Japan Relations", Ilbonyongunonchong (Journal of Japanese Studies), 11 (2002)
- Mathews, Eugene A., "Japan’s New Nationalism", Foreign Affairs, 82(6) (2003)
- Okonogi, Masao., "The Development of Japan‐Korea Relations" (2005), Keio University Press
- Park, Seon‐Won., "International Politics of Korea‐Japan Relations during the Cold War Period", Gukjejeongchinonchong (Korean International Political Science Review), 42(3) (2002)
- Ravenhill, John. A., "Three World Bloc? The New East Asian Regionalism", International Relations of Asia‐Pacific, 2
- Rozman,Gilbert., "Japan and Korea:Should the US be Worried about Their New Spat in 2001", The Pacific Review, 15(1) (2002)
- Rozman, Gilbert., "Japan’s North Korea Initiative and U.S.‐Japanese Relations", Orbis, (Summer) (2003)
- Seo, Jung‐Suk., "Park Government’s Stance Toward Japan and Crippled Korea‐Japan Relations", Yoksabipyung(Critical History), 1 (1995)
- Tamamoto, Masaru., "A Land Without Patriots: The Yasukuni Controversy and Japanese Nationalism", World Policy Journal, (Fall) (2001)
- Taniguchi, Tomohiko., "A Cold Peace: The Changing Security Equation in Northeast Asia", Orbis, (Summer) (2005)
- Task Force for Foreign Relations., "Strategy for Japanese Diplomacy in the 21st Century: New Era, New Vision, and New Diplomacy", ~ (2002)
- Togo,Kazuhiko, "Greater Self‐Assertion and Nationalism in Japan", The Copenhagen Journal of Asian Studies, (21) (2005)
- Townsend, James., "Chinese Nationalism", The Australian Journal of Chinese Affairs, (27) (1992)
- Woo, Seung‐Ji., "The Puzzle of Korea‐Japan Relations during the Cold War Period: The Hypotheses of Non‐Interference vs. Interference‐Coalition Politics", Hangukjeoungchihakhoebo (Korean Political Science Review), 37(2) (2002)
- Yang, Ki‐Ung., "Korea‐Japan Relations under Foreign Pressures and Domestic Politics: The New Fishing Negotiations and Korean Politics", 한림일본학 (구 한림일본학연구), 22 (2005), 일본학연구소