Quality of biosafety guidelines for dental clinical practice throughout the world in the early COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic review
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
OBJECTIVES: To conduct a systematic review of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)-related biosafety guidelines for dental clinical practice in the early stage of the pandemic, focusing on quality assessment. METHODS: Electronic (via PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Latin American and Caribbean Health Sciences Literature database, Brazilian Library in Dentistry, and Cochrane Library) and gray literature searches were performed for documents published up to May 12, 2020. Guidelines updated until April 17, 2021 were identified. Documents were included as guidelines if they (1) consisted of a set of statements, directions, or principles presenting current or future rules or policy; (2) were developed by government agencies, institutions, organizations, or expert panels; and (3) were related to the general conduct of health care activities rather a particular condition. Two researchers, using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research & Evaluation II, independently extracted the recommendations and evaluated the quality of the guidelines. RESULTS: Twenty-seven documents from 19 countries were included in the review. These documents presented 122 recommendations related to (1) professional biosafety; (2) patients’/companions’ safety; (3) the organization and biosafety of the physical dental facility environment; and (4) the work process in dental care. Overall, the scientific quality of the guidelines was considered low. Some recommendations presented in these guidelines would require further research to establish their effectiveness. CONCLUSIONS: We found a wide variety of biosafety guidelines for dental practice regarding COVID-19
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To conduct a systematic review of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)-related biosafety guidelines for dental clinical practice in the early stage of the pandemic, focusing on quality assessment. METHODS: Electronic (via PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Latin American and Caribbean Health Sciences Literature database, Brazilian Library in Dentistry, and Cochrane Library) and gray literature searches were performed for documents published up to May 12, 2020. Guidelines updated until April 17, 2021 were identified. Documents were included as guidelines if they (1) consisted of a set of statements, directions, or principles presenting current or future rules or policy; (2) were developed by government agencies, institutions, organizations, or expert panels; and (3) were related to the general conduct of health care activities rather a particular condition. Two researchers, using the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research & Evaluation II, independently extracted the recommendations and evaluated the quality of the guidelines. RESULTS: Twenty-seven documents from 19 countries were included in the review. These documents presented 122 recommendations related to (1) professional biosafety; (2) patients’/companions’ safety; (3) the organization and biosafety of the physical dental facility environment; and (4) the work process in dental care. Overall, the scientific quality of the guidelines was considered low. Some recommendations presented in these guidelines would require further research to establish their effectiveness. CONCLUSIONS: We found a wide variety of biosafety guidelines for dental practice regarding COVID-19
참고문헌 (74)
- Cucinotta D, "WHO declares COVID-19 a pandemic", Acta Biomed, 91, pp.157~160 (2020)
- Mahase E, "China coronavirus : WHO declares international emergency as death toll exceeds 200", BMJ, 368, pp.m408~ (2020)
- Meng L, "Coronavirus disease 2019(COVID-19) : emerging and future challenges for dental and oral medicine", J Dent Res, 99, pp.481~487 (2020)
- "Virtual press conference on COVID19" (2020)[URL]
- Struyf T, "Signs and symptoms to determine if a patient presenting in primary care or hospital outpatient settings has COVID-19disease", Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 7, pp.CD013665~ (2020)
- Kua J, "Healthcare COVID : a national cross-sectional observational study identifying risk factors for developing suspected or confirmed COVID-19 in UK healthcare workers", Peer J, 9, pp.e10891~ (2021)
- Bai Y, "Presumed asymptomatic carrier transmission of COVID-19", JAMA, 323, pp.1406~1407 (2020)
- Lai CC, "Asymptomatic carrier state, acute respiratory disease, and pneumonia due to severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2(SARS-CoV-2) : facts and myths", J Microbiol Immunol Infect, 53, pp.404~412 (2020)
- Rothe C, "Transmission of 2019-nCoV infection from an asymptomatic contact in Germany", N Engl J Med, 382, pp.970~971 (2020)
- Chen J, "Pathogenicity and transmissibility of 2019-nCoV-A quick overview and comparison with other emerging viruses", Microbes Infect, 22, pp.69~71 (2020)
- Kampf G, "Persistence of coronaviruses on inanimate surfaces and their inactivation with biocidal agents", J Hosp Infect, 104, pp.246~251 (2020)
- "Transmission of SARS-CoV-2: implications for infection prevention precautions: scientific brief" (2020)[URL]
- Huang N, "SARS-CoV-2 infection of the oral cavity and saliva", Nat Med, 27, pp.892~903 (2021)
- Wax RS, "Practical recommendations for critical care and anesthesiology teams caring for novel coronavirus(2019-nCoV)patients", Can J Anaesth, 67, pp.568~576 (2020)
- van Doremalen N, "Aerosol and surface stability of SARS-CoV-2 as compared with SARS-CoV-1", N Engl J Med, 382, pp.1564~1567 (2020)
- Li ZY, "The prevention and control of a new coronavirus infection in department of stomatology", Zhonghua Kou Qiang Yi Xue Za Zhi, 55, pp.E001~ (2020)
- Peng X, "Transmission routes of 2019-nCoV and controls in dental practice", Int J Oral Sci, 12, pp.9~ (2020)
- Backer JA, "Incubation period of 2019novel coronavirus(2019-nCoV)infections among travellers from Wuhan, China, 20-28 January 2020", Euro Surveill, 25, pp.2000062~ (2020)
- "Aerosol generating procedures and their mitigation in international dental guidance documents-a rapid review" (2020)[URL]
- "CDC recommendation: postpone non-urgent dental procedures, surgeries, and visits"[URL]
- "American Dental Association (ADA) coronavirus frequently asked questions"[URL]
- Dagens A, "Scope, quality, and inclusivity of clinical guidelines produced early in the covid-19 pandemic: rapid review", BMJ, 369, pp.m1936~ (2020)
- Marcenes W, "The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on dentistry", Community Dent Health, 37, pp.239~241 (2020)
- Shamseer L, "Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols (PRISMA-P) 2015: elaboration and explanation", BMJ, 350, pp.g7647~ (2015)
- Brouwers MC, "The AGREE reporting checklist: a tool to improve reporting of clinical practice guidelines", BMJ, 352, pp.i1152~ (2016)
- Khan GS, "Cross-cultural adaptation of the instrument Appraisal of Guidelines For Research & Evaluation II(AGREE II)for assessment of clinical guidelines", Cad Saude Publica, 30, pp.1111~1114 (2014)
- Xie Z, "Reformulation and generalisation of the Cohen and Fleiss Kappas", Int J Health Life Sci, 3, pp.1~15 (2017)
- Brouwers MC, "Development of the AGREE II, part 1 : performance, usefulness and areas for improvement", CMAJ, 182, pp.1045~1052 (2010)
- Brouwers MC, "Development of the AGREE II, part 2 : assessment of validity of items and tools to support application", CMAJ, 182, pp.E472~E478 (2010)
- "Clinical protocol in response to COVID-19 pandemic 2020"[URL]
- "Standard procedures for dental offices during coronavirus pandemic"[URL]
- "Care route for pediatric dentistry procedures during the confinement or quarantine stage of the COVID-19 pandemic"[URL]
- "New Normal in Dental Practice"[URL]
- "Argentine Ministry of Health- Covid -19 Initial Programmed Dental Attendance- Recommendations"[URL]
- "Protocol COVID-19 pour les soins dentaires in phase of Redemmarage" (2020)[URL]
- "AMIB/CFO Recommendations for coping with COVID-19 in dentistry"[URL]
- "Guidelines for health services: prevention and control measures that should be taken during the assistance to suspected or confirmed cases of infection with the new coronavirus (SARS-Cov-2)"[URL]
- "Manual of good practices in biosafety for dental environments"[URL]
- "Transitional protocol for the application of preventive measures and use of personal protection equipment for the provision of dental services in Colombia in El Marco de la Pandemia COVID-19"[URL]
- "Emergency call for alterations to oral health, during the pandemic period by SARS-COV2 (COVID-19)"[URL]
- "Recommendations for the exclusive care of emergencies and dental emergencies during the COVID-19 pandemic" (2020)[URL]
- "Technical guidelines for the prevention and containment of COVID-19 for dentists and auxiliary personnel of Costa Rica" (2020)[URL]
- "Recommendations for dental care in front of pandemic by COVID -19 / SARS CoV -2"[URL]
- "Guidelines for dental care in phase IV COVID-19"[URL]
- "Strategic action plan for the COVID-19 de-escalation period" (2020)[URL]
- "Prevention of transmission of COVID - 19 in the dental clinic" (2020)[URL]
- "ADA interim guidance for minimizing risk of COVID-19 transmission"[URL]
- "Protocol for dental care in dental emergencies and emergencies during the health emergency due to COVID-19" (2020)[URL]
- "Society of Stomatology Guatemala- Dental Biosafety Protocol COVID-19"[URL]
- "Protocol COVID-19"[URL]
- "SARS-coronavírus-2: guide for the control of Infections in the dental office"[URL]
- "Guidelines for oral health services at COVID-19 alert level 2" (2020)[URL]
- "Protocol for gradual return dental care" (2020)[URL]
- "Dental care during the SARS-Cov-2 pandemic in the republic of Paraguay" (2020)[URL]
- "COVID-19: procedures in clinics, consultations or serviços de saúde oral dos care de saúde primary. social and private sector" (2020)[URL]
- "Guidelines for the control and prevention of dental infections in the situation of COVID-19" (2020)[URL]
- Levit M, "Infection risk of COVID-19 in dentistry remains unknown: a preliminary systematic review", Infect Dis Clin Pract(Baltim Md), 29, pp.e70~e77 (2021)
- Hartshorne J, "COVID-19 risk management in dental practice. Part 3: are dental healthcare workers at greater risk of COVID-19 than other health professionals or general population?", Int Dent, 11, pp.24~39 (2021)
- Bidra AS, "rapid in-vitro inactivation of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2(SARS-CoV-2)using povidone-iodine oral antiseptic rinse", J Prosthodont, 29, pp.529~533 (2020)
- Hassandarvish P, "Povidone iodine gargle and mouthwash", Br Dent J, 228, pp.900~ (2020)
- Lee GY, "Pediatric clinical practice guidelines for acute procedural pain : a systematic review", Pediatrics, 133, pp.500~515 (2014)
- Irani S, "Evaluating clinical practice guidelines developed for the management of thyroid nodules and thyroid cancers and assessing the reliability and validity of the AGREE instrument", J Eval Clin Pract, 17, pp.729~736 (2011)
- Polus S, "Appraisal of WHO guidelines in maternal health using the AGREE II assessment tool", PLoS One, 7, pp.e38891~ (2012)
- Holmer HK, "Quality of clinical practice guidelines for glycemic control in type 2 diabetes mellitus", PLoS One, 8, pp.e58625~ (2013)
- Belser JA, "Ocular tropism of respiratory viruses", Microbiol Mol Biol Rev, 77, pp.144~156 (2013)
- Sabharwal S, "High methodologic quality but poor applicability : assessment of the AAOS guidelines using the AGREE II instrument", Clin Orthop Relat Res, 472, pp.1982~1988 (2014)
- Brosseau L, "A systematic critical appraisal for non-pharmacological management of osteoarthritis using the appraisal of guidelines research and evaluation II instrument", PLoS One, 9, pp.e82986~ (2014)
- Marciano NJ, "To what extent are current guidelines for cutaneous melanoma follow up based on scientific evidence?", Int J Clin Pract, 68, pp.761~770 (2014)
- White PE, "Independent appraiser assessment of the quality, methodological rigour and transparency of the development of the 2008 international consensus statement on concussion in sport", Br J Sports Med, 48, pp.130~134 (2014)
- Lytras T, "Occupational asthma guidelines : a systematic quality appraisal using the AGREE II instrument", Occup Environ Med, 71, pp.81~86 (2014)
- MacDermid JC, "Reliability and validity of the AGREE instrument used by physical therapists in assessment of clinical practice guidelines", BMC Health Serv Res, 5, pp.18~ (2005)
- Cabrera-Tasayco FDP, "Biosafety measures at the dental office after the appearance of COVID-19 : a systematic review", Disaster Med Public Health Prep, pp.1~5 (2020)
- Reis VP, "The new normal of dentistry: review of recommendations for the resumption of dental care during the COVID-19 pandemic", Braz J Dent, 77, pp.e1853~ (2020)
- Banakar M, "COVID-19 transmission risk and protective protocols in dentistry : a systematic review", BMC Oral Health, 20, pp.275~ (2020)
