본문 바로가기
KERD
논문KCI 등재

The Characteristics of Dance Criticisms in the 1990s in South Korea

김현정
대한무용학회|2013.06|대한무용학회 논문집 (Dance Research Journal of Korea)|제71권 제3호|pp. 169-188

0

조회

0

다운로드

1

인용

0

참고문헌

키워드

characteristiccriticismdancesocial problemintrinsic and extrinsic knowledge of dance
주제분류무용

초록

This paper aims to examine the characteristics of dance criticisms in the 1990s --especially from 1990 to 1994 -- thereby exploring causes and clues of social problems of dance criticism. I discuss the reasons and types of art criticism, drawing on the arguments of John Hospers and Jerome Stolnitz. I investigate considerations for dance criticism, and analyze the focuses and characteristics of dance criticisms written by 5critics. As some of their criticisms show subjective evaluations without sufficient evidences, I suggest that with both the intrinsic and extrinsic knowledge of dance, critics need to evaluate dance work.

Abstract

This paper aims to examine the characteristics of dance criticisms in the 1990s --especially from 1990 to 1994 -- thereby exploring causes and clues of social problems of dance criticism. I discuss the reasons and types of art criticism, drawing on the arguments of John Hospers and Jerome Stolnitz. I investigate considerations for dance criticism, and analyze the focuses and characteristics of dance criticisms written by 5critics. As some of their criticisms show subjective evaluations without sufficient evidences, I suggest that with both the intrinsic and extrinsic knowledge of dance, critics need to evaluate dance work.

참고문헌 (33)

  1. Beardsley, M., "The classification of critical reasons", Journal of Aesthetic Education, 2(3), pp.55~63 (1968)
  2. Bond, C. T., "An aesthetic framework for dance", Journal of Physical Education, Recreation and Dance, 58(3), pp.62~66 (1987)
  3. Chang, K. Y., "92 kongyôn yesulkye ch’ongkyôlsan - muyong", Kaeksôk, pp.132~134 (1992)
  4. Fancher, G., "Philosophical essays on dance, with responses from choreographers, critics and dancers" (1981), Dance Horizons
  5. Han, H. R., "Muyong p’yongron muôt i paramchik hanka", Muyong hanguk, (Fall & Winter), pp.125~127 (1990)
  6. Han, H. R., "Muyong - ttodarûn chjisôngkwa ûi mannam" (1993), Sangchi munhwasa
  7. Han, J. S., "Kyoch'edoen pallet chuyôk, sangsangryôk ûro p'ulôssûn kyongyônp’yông", Kaeksôk, pp.260~261 (1994)
  8. Hwang, I. J., "Muyong pip’yông ûi mihakjôk ûimie kwanhan yôngu", Muyong hakhoe nonmunjip, 26, pp.331~344 (1999)
  9. Hwang, I. J., "Muyong pip’yông ûi ponjil e kwanhan yôngu", Muyong hakhoe nonmunjip, 27, pp.363~378 (2000)
  10. Hwang, I. J., "Muyong pip’yông ûi yôngyôk kwa kyoyukjôk ûimie kwanhan yôngu", Muyong hakhoe nonmunjip, 31, pp.127~140 (2001)
  11. 황인주, "무용비평훈련을 위한 방법론 연구", 대한무용학회 논문집, 39(39호), pp.275~297 (2004), 대한무용학회
  12. Hospers, J., "Understanding the arts" (1982), Prentice-Hall
  13. Kim, K. A., "Tongch’am kwa panggwan" (1990), Yôlûmsa
  14. Kim, C. H., "Idal ûi chwadam: Isidae p’yôngron ûi kinûng ûn muôt inga?", Ch'um, pp.26~41 (1989)
  15. Kim, M. B., "Muyong pipyông e taehan yôngu", 석사, pp.1981
  16. Kim, M. B., "Muyong haenwi wa muyong pip’yong ûi chônmunhwa sigûp", Kaeksôk, pp.234~235 (1987)
  17. Kim, T. W., "Kim tae-won Ch'um munhwaron p’yongronjip" (1991), Hyôndae mihaksa
  18. Kim, T. W., "Hugi hyôndae ch'um ûi mihak kwa tonghyang" (1992), Hyôndae mihaksa
  19. Kim, Y. T., "Nunûi nara sat’ang pinudûl" (1993), Nunbit
  20. Lee, H. S., "Hangukjôk aksûp ûi p’ungt’o igôkmanûn kaesôntoeya handa", Muyong yesul, pp.44~46 (1994)
  21. Lee, S. I., "Muyong haengwi e sônhaenghanûn p’yongron haengwi ûi oman", Kaeksôk, pp.134~136 (1993)
  22. Mun, A. R., "92 kônt’emporôry muyongtan, In Pip’yôngjôk kwanjômesô pon muyongyesul", pp.189~191 (1992), Nunbit
  23. Nam, J. H., "Ajikto kipûn pulsin", Kaeksôk, pp.138~139 (1993)
  24. Smith, J. M., "Dance composition: a practical guide for teachers" (1976), Lepus
  25. Song, A. K., "Tûpjip: pip’yong kwa jônôlijûm ôttôn munjeka itna?", Kaeksôk, pp.63~82 (1987)
  26. Stolnitz, J., "Mihak kwa pip’yông ch’olhak" (1992), iron kwa silch’ôn
  27. Taplin, D. T., "New directions in dance" (1978), Pergamon Press
  28. "Ch'um (Dance), published from 1990 to 1994", ~ (1990)
  29. "Kaeksôk (Auditorium), published from 1990 to 1994", ~ (1990)
  30. "Yesul segye (Art World), published from 1990 to 1994", ~ (1990)
  31. "Munhwa yesul (Cultural Art), published from 1990 to 1994", ~ (1990)
  32. "Muyong hanguk (Dance Korea), published from 1990 to 1994", ~ (1990)
  33. "Muyong yesul (Dance Art), published from 1993 to 1994", ~ (1993)

이 간행물의 다른 논문 (8건)

무용교육자의 비언어적 커뮤니케이션 능력, 지도자 신뢰 및 무용몰입의 구조적 관계김지영, 주형철, 윤인애pp. 1-24발목 관절 근육 피로와 피로 유발 방법이 외발서기 자세제어에 미치는 영향신영화, 염창홍pp. 25-40문헌자료를 통해 본 진주기생의 활동양상양지선, 강인숙pp. 41-66국내·외 예술인복지제도 분석을 통한 바람직한 무용가 복지방향에 관한 연구유가원pp. 67-90고등학생들의 사회·정서 학습(SEL)을 위한 표현활동 무용수업 적용 및 개선 방안이정화, 이한주pp. 91-116
원문 보기