현재성 문제와 지금의 지표성
"The Present Problem and Indexicality of Now"
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
최근의 시간에 관한 철학적 논의에서 새로운 무시제 이론가들은 시제 문장들의 진리조건을 무시제 문장들을 통해 부여할 수 있다는 언어철학적 결과를 통해, 시제 사실들과 같은 것들을 받아들일 필요가 없다고 주장함으로써 A-이론을 비판해 왔다. 이 논문에서는 형이상학적 논변을 새롭게 제시함으로써, 언어철학적인 논변과 달리 B-이론은 유지될 수 없으며, 오히려 A-이론이 시간에 대한 올바른 이론임을 논증하게 된다. 그리고 이러한 논의가 이루어지는 가운데 존속과 변화에 관한 흥미로운 문제들이 다루어지며, 시간 철학에서의 몇몇 개념에 관한 명료화 작업이 이루어진다. 나아가 이를 바탕으로 A-이론과도 B-이론과도 다른 새로운 대안적인 시간 이론이 제시되고, 이 이론이 지니는 특징들과 장점들이 이야기된다.
Abstract
In recent decades, new tenseless theorists challenged A-theory in virtue of a consequence of philosophy of language, according to which truth-conditions of tensed sentences can be given by tenseless sentences, so tensed facts are not needed. In this article, I argue that A-theory is more plausible and sustainable than B-theory by newly presented metaphysical argument. In the course of this argument, I raise some problems of the philosophical debate on persistence and change, and explicate several concepts very crucial in the philosophy of time. Finally I give an alternative theory of time and investigate some features and advantages of it.
참고문헌 (20)
- Bennett, Jonathan, "A Philosophical Guide to Conditionals" (2003), Oxford University Press Inc
- Bourne, Craig, "When am I? A Tense Time for Some Tense Theorists?", Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 80(3), pp.359~371 (2002)
- Crisp, Thomas. M, "Presentism (The Oxford Handbook of Metaphysics)" (2003), Oxford University Press
- Haslanger, Sally, "Persistence through Time (The Oxford Handbook of Metaphysics)" (2003), Oxford University Press
- Hawley, Katherine, "How Things Persist" (2001), Oxford University Press Inc.
- Le Poidevin, "The Philosophy of Time" (1993), Oxford University Press
- Lewis, David K, "Tensed Quantifiers (Oxford Studies in Metaphysics, volume 1)" (2002), Oxford University Press
- Lewis, David. K, "Tensing the Copula", Mind, 111(441) (2002)
- Lewis, David. K, "On the Plurality of Worlds" (1986), Blackwell Publishing Company
- Lewis, David. K, "Philosophical Papers Volume II" (1986), Oxford University Press.
- Lewis, David. K, "The Paradoxes of Time Travel (in Philosophical Papers Volume II)", American Philosophical Quarterly, 13, pp.145~152 (1976), Oxford University Press
- Lewis, David. K, "Causation (in Philosophical Papers Volume II)", Journal of Philosophy, 70, pp.556~567 (1973), Oxford University Press
- Lewis, David. K, "Counterfactuals" (1973), Blackwell Publishers
- Loux, Michael. J, "The Oxford Handbook of Metaphysics" (2003), Oxford University Press.
- McTaggart, "Unreality of Time (The Philosophy of Time)" (1993), Oxford University Press
- Mellor, D. H, "Real Time" (1981), Cambridge University Press
- Mellor, D. G.(, "Real Time II" (1998), ambridge University Press.
- Oaklander, L. N, "The New Theory of Time" (1994), Yale University Press
- Smith, Quentin, "Problems with the New Tenseless Theory of Time (The New Theory of Time)", Philosophical Studies, 52, pp.371~392 (1987), Yale University Press
- Zimmerman, D. W, "Oxford Studies in Metaphysics, volume 1" (2004), Oxford University Press